Digitizing art as NFTs backfires among big-name artists

Digitizing art as NFTs backfires among big-name artists

Performance artist Lee Kun-yong’s “The Method of Drawing (Angels)” (1997) / Courtesy of MMCA

By Park Han-sol

The latest hyped phenomenon, the “NFT (non-fungible token),” has been declared Collins Dictionary’s word of the year for 2021. The term burst onto the digital market scene as a unique certificate that represents the ownership of any digital asset, including a work of art, as it is registered in a shared ledger, better known as a blockchain.

But as much as the concept has generated excitement in Korea’s fine art market, a number of big-name artists and their families have continued to raise the issue of copyright infringement, with some denying the legitimacy of NFT-based works of art altogether.

On Dec. 2, Pica Project, the operator of an “art co-ownership” platform through NFT-based trading, announced that it will tokenize one video and two photos featuring the works of experimental art master Lee Kun-yong at the Asan Gallery in South Chungcheong Province.

Lee, who belongs to the first generation of Korea’s avant-garde artists, is best known for letting the movement of his entire body take over the canvas. He often paints in an unconventional way, as he faces away from his painting, with his back against the canvas, and moves his arm to create different figures.

Just a day after the announcement, the 79-year-old artist voiced heavy criticism, citing that the company did not seek his consent for turning his work into a digital asset.

“The fact that they are creating something that is ‘non-fungible’ but is not seeking the artist’s participation or consent in any way makes this no different from a shameless scam,” he wrote in his latest Instagram post.

“If this is happening to a relatively known artist like me, I can’t even imagine what the situation would be like for younger creators… Such an act that snatches away artists’ creative passion should be immediately put to a stop.”

But according to Pica Project, the video and two photos featuring the artist’s works to be tokenized were filmed by the Asan Gallery. Because they are not the artist’s pieces themselves, the copyright should lie with the gallery, not Lee, the company argued.

Nevertheless, the project to tokenize these assets has been tentatively put on hold.

Digitizing art as NFTs backfires among big-name artists

Artist Park Seo-bo speaks during an interview with The Korea Times at his studio-cum-residence, Gizi, in Seodaemun District, Seoul, in this May 14, 2019, photo. Korea Times photo by Choi Won-suk

Lee is not the only established artist who has expressed skepticism about the recent NFT fad.

Dansaekhwa master Park Seo-bo ― a recipient of the country’s highest cultural honor, the Geumgwan Order of Cultural Merit, known for his “Ecriture” series, spanning decades ― stated last month that he would forbid any attempt to trade his works of art in the form of NFTs.

“It is impossible for digital images created by taking pictures to be sold at soaring prices under the name of being ‘irreplaceable,’ while my paintings exist here in the real world. My painting itself is irreplaceable,” he wrote on a Nov. 11 Facebook post.

“I am a person of the physical world. I belong to the age of materials. My works also are outcomes of this time and horizon. Paints, brushes and canvases are the media of my artistic world,” he continued. “I have no intentions of going beyond these times that I do not know.”

Last June, an auction organized by Wannabe International to sell NFT-based artworks of modern masters ― Lee Jung-seob, Kim Whanki and Park Soo-keun ― was called off after the artists’ families and relevant foundations raised questions about copyright infringement. They claimed that no consent was given to turn the artworks into NFTs, later prompting an apology from the company.

With the market surrounding NFTs still in its infancy, similar questions about copyright infringement and the virtual, nonmaterial nature of digital assets will likely continue to be raised moving forward.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Korean stocks plunge on US rate hike, Omicron fears

A signboard at Hana Bank shows the KOSPI closing at 2,614.49, Thursday, down 3.5 percent from the previous day’s close, after the U.S. Federal Reserve stated it would hike its ... Read more »

KDB chief slams EU for being 'selfish' in declining HHI-DSME merger

Korea Development Bank (KDB) Chairman Lee Dong-gull speaks during a press conference in this file photo take in 2018. Yonhap By Yi Whan-woo Korea Development Bank (KDB) Chairman Lee Dong-gull ... Read more »

Youn Yuh-jung, Lee Min-ho's 'Pachinko' set for global release in March

Actors Lee Min-ho, right, and Kim Min-ha in a scene from Apple TV+ series “Pachinko”/ Courtesy of Apple TV+ By Kwak Yeon-soo The much-anticipated Apple TV+ series “Pachinko” will be ... Read more »

POSCO's restructuring plan angers Pohang residents

Politicians from Pohang, North Gyeongsang Province, speak during a press conference at the National Assembly in Seoul, Thursday, to protest POSCO’s plan to set up a holding company in Seoul. ... Read more »

ICT minister hints at delay of 5G spectrum license auction

Science and ICT Minister Lim Hye-sook speaks during a press conference at the Sejong Government Complex, Thursday. Yonhap By Lee Kyung-min An auction for 5G spectrum licenses in the 20MHz ... Read more »

Netmarble looking for cash cow in metaverse, blockchain

By Baek Byung-yeul Bang Jun-hyuk, chairman of Netmarble, speaks during a press conference at the company’s headquarters in Seoul, Thursday. Courtesy of Netmarble Netmarble is actively seeking new business opportunities ... Read more »

Experts call for easing age limit for antiviral pills, aggressive testing to flatten COVID curve

People stand in line to receive a COVID-19 test at a testing center near Seoul Station, Thursday. Yonhap By Lee Hyo-jin Korea is grappling with its worst COVID-19 crisis yet, ... Read more »

Samsung to readjust investment plans due to global supply chain disruption

Tech giant posts record sales of 279 tril. won in 2021 By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics will readjust its 2022 investment plans in accordance with the rapidly changing business environment ... Read more »

Korea's plan to win MSCI developed market status faces difficulties

Finance Minister Hong Nam-ki speaks during a ministerial meeting at Government Complex in Seoul, Thursday. Yonhap Korea seeks inclusion in watch list for MSCI developed markets index By Lee Min-hyung ... Read more »

Lotte takes big leap forward with future-oriented investments

Lotte Chemical inks a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Indonesian government officials for the LINE project on January 7, 2022. The project aims to construct a $3.9 billion petrochemical complex ... Read more »

EcoProBM under investigation on suspicion of insider trading

EcoPro Chairman Lee Dong-chae, left, speaks during a memorandum of understanding signing ceremony at Pohang City Hall in North Gyeongsang Province in this September 2021 file photo. Yonhap By Park ... Read more »

'Concrete Utopia' sequel underway with star-studded cast

From left, actors Lee Jun-young, Ma Dong-seok and Roh Jeong-eui / Korea Times file By Kwak Yeon-soo “The Wilderness” (working title), which is known to be the sequel to the ... Read more »

[Election 101] TV debates, where the ‘real battle' takes place

From left: Ruling Democratic Party of Korea candidate Lee Jae-myung; People Power Party candidate Yoon Suk-yeol; Justice Party candidate Sim Sang-jung; People Party leader Ahn Cheol-soo (Yonhap)The main opposition People ... Read more »

More than 10 K-pop stars test positive for COVID-19 in one week

Donghan of K-pop act WEi / Courtesy of OUI Entertainment By Dong Sun-hwa The K-pop scene is on high alert after more than 10 singers have tested positive for COVID-19 ... Read more »

Yoon pledges to overhaul presidential office, working methods

Presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol (Yonhap)Presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol vowed Thursday to build a new presidential office at the Seoul Government Complex in Gwanghwamun and return the existing Cheong Wa Dae ... Read more »

Top court confirms 2-yr prison term for ex-environment minister in power abuse case

Former Environment Minister Kim Eun-kyung (C) arrives at the Seoul Central District Court on Feb. 9, 2021, to attend a sentencing hearing over alleged abuse of power. The court sentenced ... Read more »

N. Korea to assume rotational presidency of UN disarmament conference

This photo, captured from North Korea’s Central TV last Tuesday, shows one of two tactical guided missiles that the North test-fired from a transporter erector launcher toward an island target ... Read more »

PPP proposes Yoon-Lee debate on top of TV debate

In this file photo, Yoon Suk-yeol (L), the presidential candidate of the main opposition People Power Party, and Lee Jae-myung, the candidate of the ruling Democratic Party, attend an event ... Read more »

Andaz Seoul Gangnam launches 'Love Yourself' package for MZ generation

Andaz Seoul Gangnam presents a “Love Yourself” package, in which guests can have a body profile photo session during their stay, in limited quantity from Jan. 24 to Apr. 30. ... Read more »

JW Marriott Hotel Seoul presents Yut-Nori with Black Tiger package

JW Marriott Hotel Seoul presents a Yut-Nori with Black Tiger package from this Friday to Feb. 6 to celebrate the Lunar New Year. Courtesy of JW Marriott Hotel Seoul By ... Read more »

Hyundai Motor, Kia appoint new chief safety officers

The headquarters of Hyundai Motor and Kia in southern Seoul / Courtesy of Hyundai Motor Group By Anna J. Park In a move to respond proactively to the country’s strengthened ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution debuts after $13 trillion frenzy in Korea's biggest IPO

The logo of LG Energy Solution is pictured at its office building in Seoul, Nov. 23, 2021. Reuters-Yonhap Shares of battery maker LG Energy Solution Ltd (LGES) debut on Thursday ... Read more »

Seoul monitoring situation after N. Korea hit by suspected cyber attack

(123rf)The Seoul government is keeping tabs on North Korea following reports it was hit by a suspected cyber attack the previous day, an official said Thursday. On Wednesday, Reuters said ... Read more »

Korea's daily COVID-19 cases surpass 14,000 amid rapid Omicron spread

Health workers wearing protective gears stand to help visitors at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus near the Seoul City Hall in Seoul, Jan. 26. AP-Yonhap Korea’s daily COVID-19 ... Read more »

N.Korea fires two suspected short-range ballistic missiles toward the East Sea: JCS

(File Photo – Yonhap)North Korea on Thursday fired two suspected short-range ballistic missiles from South Hamgyong Province toward its east coast, South Korea’s Joint Chiefs of Staff said. The South ... Read more »

Samsung Electronics' operating profit up by 53.3% in Q4

Samsung Electronics building in Seocho-dong, southern Seoul / Yonhap Samsung Electronics’ operating profit was up by 53.3 percent in the fourth quarter of 2021 driven by record annual sales, the ... Read more »

N. Korea fires unidentified projectile toward East Sea: S. Korean military

This photo, captured from North Korea`s Central TV on Jan. 18, 2022, shows one of two tactical guided missiles that the North test-fired from a transporter erector launcher toward an ... Read more »

Many 'promising things' can happen if N. Korea comes to dialogue table: Lambert

Mark Lambert, deputy assistant secretary of state for Korea and Japan, is seen speaking in a webinar hosted by the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies think tank on ... Read more »

PEFs eyeing Osstem Implant

The headquarters of Osstem Implant in Seoul / Courtesy of Osstem Implant By Anna J. Park Despite the ongoing risks surrounding Osstem Implant stemming from an employee’s embezzlement of some ... Read more »

KCCI chairman to conduct first major reshuffle

The front of the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry building (KCCI) / Korea Times file By Kim Hyun-bin The Korea Chamber of Commerce & Industries (KCCI) Chairman Chey Tae-won ... Read more »

30 Year of the Tiger sneakers: from Nike and Adidas to Dior and Gucci, the best buys to look out

The Year of the Tiger kicks off on February 1, and one way to ensure you put your best foot forward is a new pair of kicks. As has become ... Read more »

Aldi Is Selling A Heated Dressing Gown But They're Going Fast

Aldi‘s heated dressing gown, sold out online, but in stores now. (Photo: Aldi) We hope you love the products we recommend! All of them were independently selected by our editors. ... Read more »

Kate Middleton steps out in leopard print midi dress for first solo appearance of 2022

Photo credit: WPA Pool – Getty Images The Duchess of Cambridge stepped out for her first solo royal engagement of the year on Wednesday (26 January) morning, as she paid ... Read more »

Senior diplomats of S. Korea, Russia hold phone talks over N. Korea

This photo, captured from North Korea`s Central TV on Jan. 18, 2022, shows one of two tactical guided missiles that the North test-fired from a transporter erector launcher toward an ... Read more »

Lotte Department Store CEO working to change company culture

Lotte Department Store in Gangnam, Seoul / Courtesy of Lotte Shopping By Kim Jae-heun Lotte Department Store’s new CEO Jung Jun-ho is striving to change the authoritarian leadership style that ... Read more »

CJ Logistics delivery workers' strike spreads to Lotte, Hanjin

Union representatives from the Lotte, Hanjin, Korea Post and Logen logistics firms hold a press conference in front of CJ Logistics’ building in Seoul, Dec. 30, 2021. Yonhap By Kim ... Read more »

Woowa Brothers pressed to earn more for Delivery Hero

From left, Woowa Brothers founder Kim Bong-jin and Delivery Hero CEO Niklas Oestberg / Korea Times file By Kim Jae-heun Woowa Brothers, the operator of the country’s No. 1 food ... Read more »

SAE-A Trading workers ordered to wear company brand clothes only

SAE-A Trading CEO James Ha / Courtesy of SAE-A Trading By Kim Jae-heun The head of a major apparel maker has been in the hot seat for sending emails to ... Read more »

##Seoul in conundrum over NK preemptive strike option

#Seoul faces conundrum over NK preemptive strike optionKicker — N. Korea’s mounting threats increase necessity of preemptive plan By Ji Da-gyum If South Korea faces an imminent attack from nuclear-armed ... Read more »

Lunar New Year drawings warding off evil spirits adorn Gwanghwamun

A set of “munbaedo,” or traditional drawings to ward off evil spirits, is hung on Gwanghwamun, the main gate to Gyeongbokgung Palace in central Seoul, Wednesday. Yonhap By Park Han-sol ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic