Diet or Exercise: Which Is Better For Weight Loss?

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photo credit: DjordjeDjurdjevic – Getty Images

Got a question for the Women's Health Collective? Send us a DM @womenshealthcollectiveuk and we'll call on our experts. We're getting your questions answered.

Amy from Woking asks:

'What’s more effective for weight loss: diet or exercise?'

Expert: Kathryn Stewart, sports dietitian

We know that you know that the key to healthy, sustainable weight loss lies in both the foods you choose to fuel your body with and the movement that makes up your workout week. But is one more significant than the other?

Before we get into it, it's important to say that while losing weight to reach a healthy weight range is a legitimate health goal, it isn't appropriate for everyone. If you're already at a healthy weight for your height and age – or there's another reason weight loss may not be a suitable goal for you – speak to your GP for more advice.

As for your question, despite what the slew of January gym discounts might suggest, working up a sweat isn’t actually the most efficient way to shed excess fat.

Why? Well, weight loss happens when your body requires more energy and calories than you’re putting in and so is forced to break down the molecules in your fat cells for fuel.

‘Start by writing down what you’re eating during a regular day,’ suggests sports dietitian Kathryn Stewart (@edible_evience), adding that you could try using a calorie counting app like My Fitness Pal if that works for you.

‘If that amount is keeping your weight stable, then reducing it by about 10% to 15% will help create a calorie deficit,’ adds Stewart. ‘That might be one fewer snack per day or just slightly smaller portions of your three daily meals.’

But it’s advice that comes with a caveat. Stewart notes that any diet that presents itself as a 'quick fix' or requires you to cut out whole food groups should be given a wide berth, for the sake of both your body and your mind.

As for exercise, it can help you reach this deficit, as well as delivering ample benefits beyond fat burn.

Stewart recommends incorporating strength training to build lean muscle which, in turn, will increase your basal metabolic rate. This will support you with your weight-loss endeavours without the need for excessive dietary restriction.

As well as your scheduled workout, Stewart advises boosting your non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT) – essentially any movement that isn’t part of your structured training plan, such as walking to the shops, cleaning your house or running around after your dependants.

Still got questions about calories deficits, strength training or NEAT? For more on how to lose weight in a healthy, sustainable way, see this guide.

    Internet Explorer Channel Network
    Asia's Tech News Daily
    News Related


    Prince Andrew: How Prince Charles plotted to get his royal titles removed

    Prince Charles played a big part in Andrew’s axed royal duties, sources claim. Charles and William both made it clear to the Queen that Andrew must relinquish his royal titles ... Read more »

    What is sleep hygiene (and why is it important)?

    Photo: Unsplash Do you often have trouble falling asleep? Maybe it’s your sleep hygiene. It’s worth investigating further before reaching for the sleep aids. Sleep hygiene is a method of ... Read more »

    Doctor warns against parents fat shaming their children

    Welcome to Ask Doctor Zac, a weekly column from This week, Dr Zac Turner provides his take on parents fat-shaming their children. Question: Hi Dr Zac, I’ve inherited something ... Read more »

    The ultimate chocolate and extra virgin olive oil mousse

    Eatwell Vegan recipe collection 31 Oct, 2021 09:15 PMQuick Read A collection of delicious and healthy vegan dishes. Eatwell Taco collection 22 Oct, 2021 01:34 AMQuick Read Pulled pork, chicken, ... Read more »

    Deborah Mele's olive oil cake

    Eatwell Vegan recipe collection 31 Oct, 2021 09:15 PMQuick Read A collection of delicious and healthy vegan dishes. Eatwell Taco collection 22 Oct, 2021 01:34 AMQuick Read Pulled pork, chicken, ... Read more »

    Woman in China forced to lock down at house of blind date

    When it comes to bad dating stories, I pretty much have them all. Yet, even I’m feeling sorry for a woman in China who went to her blind date’s house ... Read more »

    Ancient olive salad recipe

    Eatwell Vegan recipe collection 31 Oct, 2021 09:15 PMQuick Read A collection of delicious and healthy vegan dishes. Eatwell Taco collection 22 Oct, 2021 01:34 AMQuick Read Pulled pork, chicken, ... Read more »

    Syrian savoury olive cake

    Eatwell Vegan recipe collection 31 Oct, 2021 09:15 PMQuick Read A collection of delicious and healthy vegan dishes. Eatwell Taco collection 22 Oct, 2021 01:34 AMQuick Read Pulled pork, chicken, ... Read more »

    Cooking with olive oil: Extra virgin honey recipe

    Eatwell Vegan recipe collection 31 Oct, 2021 09:15 PMQuick Read A collection of delicious and healthy vegan dishes. Eatwell Taco collection 22 Oct, 2021 01:34 AMQuick Read Pulled pork, chicken, ... Read more »

    Relationship Rehab: Wife's 'hurt' after discovering X-rated secret

    They’ve been married for years, but after a growing problem in the bedroom, the wife has uncovered a shocking sex truth about her husband. Sexologist Isiah McKimmie hears about a ... Read more »

    In my kitchen ... with Carmel Davidovitch of Carmel Israeli Street Food

    Carmel Davidovitch and partner Tomer are on a mission to bring authentic Israeli street food to New Zealand. Kiwi-born Carmel grew up in Israel and returned here with Tomer to ... Read more »

    German corona app under fire after illegal use by police

    (Image: AP) In Germany, a corona app has been discredited after the police used it to track down people who were near a crime. It concerns the Luca app, which ... Read more »

    Gustav Leonhardts hartstocht voor Bach gloeit nog altijd na

    Er gaat een onweerstaan ​​bare pioniersgeest uit van de opnamen die het label Warner verzamelde op de vrijdag verschenen New Gustav Leonhardt Edition. De 35cd-box telt vooral albums uit die ... Read more »

    Lululemon shoppers are obsessed with this 'versatile and flattering' sweater

    This Lululemon Cashlu Sweater wrap is a must-have for cold weather. Yahoo Lifestyle Canada is committed to finding you the best products at the best prices. We may receive a ... Read more »

    Emilia Fox opens up about 'unsustainable' health 'obsession' at the start of the pandemic

    Emilia Fox has opened up about embarking on a health kick shortly after COVID-19 was discovered. (Getty Images) The arrival of COVID-19 led many of us to consider ways to ... Read more »

    How to get started with open water swimming

    Swimming is a great activity if you’re looking to get in shape and stay that way. Hitting the local pool on a regular basis is perfect for burning calories, keeping ... Read more »

    Holly Willoughby responds to people constantly 'commenting' on her stylish outfits

    Holly Willoughby is often praised for her stylish outfits. (Getty Images) She has won a huge number of fans for her fashionable looks – but Holly Willoughby has said she ... Read more »

    Waterfront family home in Cornwall now up for sale

    Photo credit: Knight Frank A picture-perfect waterfront home in Cornwall has just been put up for sale for £2,250,000. Foreshore is a family home that lies on the Helford Estuary, ... Read more »

    Tips by health experts on embracing motherhood in your 20s, 30s, 40s

    While a pregnancy in the twenties has many positives, anxious women can relax as no bells will ring on her 30th birthday and announce the end of her fertility. As ... Read more »

    Positive Parenting: Shape Your Kid's Mind with These Important Lessons

    © Provided by News18 Positive Parenting: Shape Your Kid’s Mind with These Important Lessons Every parent wants their kid to be happy and flourishing. They want their kids to achieve ... Read more »

    Oikeus linjasi: Novak Djokovic karkotetaan Australiasta

    © Diego Fedele Novak Djokovic ei puolusta mestaruuttaan Australian avointen tennisturnauksessa. Tennispelaaja Novak Djokovic karkotetaan oikeuden päätökselle Australiasta, jonne hän saapui puolitoista viikkoa sitten pelatakseen huomenna alkavissa Australian avoimissa. Djokovicin ... Read more »

    Made New Year weight loss resolutions? Know what you can realistically achieve

    © Provided by The Indian Express After festive eating during New Year celebrations comes weight loss resolutions. People give in to weight loss fads, crash diets, detoxes and more to ... Read more »

    Dutch dictionary announces that future editions will include gender

    To adapt to the changing world and the growing popularity of gender-neutral terms, the world’s leading Dutch dictionary will be available in future editions. m With men v Gender neutral ... Read more »

    Four-legged toilet terrorist shocks a couple in Amsterdam

    A couple in Amsterdam was shocked by an unexpected visitor earlier this month when a four-legged “toilet terrorist” was revealed on a night trip to the bathroom. Rodents terrorize Amsterdam ... Read more »

    Prince Harry threatens British government with legal action over security

    Prince Harry is taking legal action against the British government after a decision was made to remove his security. The Mail on Sunday has revealed lawyers acting for Harry have ... Read more »

    Nino Cerruti (91) dead: innovator in men's clothing, popular in Hollywood

    “I wanted men to be freer in their elegance and more elegant in their freedom,” Cerruti himself summed up his contribution to a fashion that was more casual but still ... Read more »

    Nyt Elisa Viihde Viaplayssä: Hyytävä mysteerileffa – ”yksi lähivuosien kylmimpiä psykologisia trillereitä”

    Neljän tähden jännäri. Elisa Viihde Viaplayn valikoimaan on lisätty Nainen junassa (The Girl on the Train, 2016). Paula Hawkinsin samannimiseen romaaniin perustuva mysteeritrilleri kertoo avioerosta toipuvasta ja alkoholisoituneesta Rachelista, joka ... Read more »

    Woman catches best friend messaging her boyfriend in bed

    A woman has taken to TikTok to share the moment she found her best friend messaging her own boyfriend. Emmy was spending time with her best friend when she noticed ... Read more »

    Prince Andrew and accuser name witnesses in sex abuse lawsuit

    Lawyers for Prince Andrew and Virginia Giuffre have filed their initial requests for witnesses in her lawsuit accusing the British royal of sexually abusing her at age 17. Recently released ... Read more »

    Why Queen's Platinum Jubilee choice will devastate Prince Harry

    Opinion: Of all the trappings and frippery of palace life, of all of the symbolic totems of royalty, there is none more universally known, like the Coke logo or the ... Read more »

    Are fresh vegetables healthier than frozen vegetables?

    Are fresh vegetables, as above, healthier than frozen vegetables? Photo: Pexels In the section Nutrition under the microscope we share a scientific view of nutrition and health. The internet is ... Read more »

    Tulips for Amsterdam: Growers hand out free flowers

    On Location: January 14, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press AMSTERDAM — As stores in Amsterdam and across the Netherlands cautiously reopened after weeks of ... Read more »

    Climate change's adverse effects on health starts in the womb, studies find

    Undated file photo of a mother holding the feet of a new baby (Dominic Lipinski/PA) (PA Wire) Rising temperatures around the world as a result of climate change are having ... Read more »

    Novak Djokovic pidätettiin Australiassa

    © Toimittanut Sport Content Tenniksen maailmanlistan ykköspelaaja Novak Djokovic on pidetty uudelleen Australiassa. Djokovic on pidätettynä Melbournessa niin kauan, kun hänen karkottamistaan käsitellään. Australian maahanmuuttoministeri Alex Hawke perui rokottamattoman Djokovicin ... Read more »

    What is a Dutch angle? Why is it really German?

    The word “Dutch” is used many times in various expressions to describe several different behaviors. Whether you’re splitting the bill after eating out with your friends or splitting the bill ... Read more »

    Avoid these parenting mistakes to give your baby a healthy environment

    © Provided by News18 Avoid these parenting mistakes to give your baby a healthy environment In modern times, planning a family is a task. With the changing world, parents are ... Read more »

    KLM tickets can be up to € 12 higher thanks to new sustainable fuels

    With this week’s policy changes, tickets for KLM flights could be up to € 12 higher after Dutch airlines use more environmentally friendly fuel on flights from Amsterdam. Dutch airlines ... Read more »

    Senior fit-izens: Inside the boomer gym revolution

    OPINION: Just before the pandemic, I joined a gym because I didn’t like what midlife was doing to my middle. “Yeah, my mum has that, too,” announced the young personal ... Read more »

    Daniela Elser: Kate Middleton left to clean up Prince Andrew mess

    OPINION Who would want to be Queen? That’s a question I think about a lot. Sure, the perks are pretty impressive: the vast, draughty castles at your disposal, getting to ... Read more »

    Prince Andrew's accuser Virginia Roberts Giuffre responds after the royal family abandoned him

    Prince Andrew’s rape accuser Virginia Roberts Giuffre has spoken out after the news that Prince Andrew has been stripped of his royal titles. Giuffre took to social media to also ... Read more »
    On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic