Did astronomers find the first planet outside of the Milky Way? It's complicated

Asia's Tech News Daily

The Whirlpool Galaxy, some 28 million light-years from Earth, looks to our telescopes like a cosmic hurricane littered with sparkling gemstones. Huge, lean arms spiral out from the centre of Whirlpool, also known as M51. Cradled within them are young stars flaring to life and old stars expanding, expiring and exploding. 

Did astronomers find the first planet outside of the Milky Way? It's complicated
© NASA/CXC/A.Jubett

Astronomers aren’t convinced a dip in X-rays in a distant galaxy signify the first extroplanet

In 2012 NASA’s Chandra Observatory, which sees the sky in X-rays, spotted a curious flicker coming from the galaxy. An X-ray source in one of Whirlpool’s arms switched off for about 2 hours, before suddenly flaring back to life. This isn’t particularly unusual for X-ray sources in the cosmos. Some flare, others periodically dim. 

This particular source emanated from an “X-ray binary,” known as M51-ULS-1, which is actually two objects: Cosmic dance partners who have been two-stepping around each other for potentially billions of years. One of these objects is either a black hole or a neutron star and the other may be a large, very bright type of star known as a “blue supergiant.”

As astronomers looked a little more closely at the X-ray signal from the pair, they began to suspect the cause for the dimming may have been something we’ve never seen before: A world outside of the Milky Way, had briefly prevented X-rays from reaching our telescopes. The team have dubbed it an “extroplanet.”

A research team led by astronomer Rosanne Di Stefano, of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, published details of their hypothesis in the journal Nature Astronomy on Oct. 25. Their study lays out evidence that the X-ray wink detected by Chandra was potentially caused by a planet, about the size of Saturn, passing in front of M51-ULS-1.

The extroplanet candidate currently goes by the name “M51-1” and is believed to orbit its host binary at about the same distance Uranus orbits our sun.

While many news sources have championed the detection as the “first planet discovered outside of the Milky Way,” there’s no way of confirming the find. At least, not for another few decades, when the proposed planet is supposed to make another transit of the binary. Di Stefano says the team modeled other objects that could potentially produce the dip in X-rays but came up short. Still, she stresses this is not a confirmed detection.

“We cannot claim that this is definitely a planet,” says Di Stefano, “but we do claim that the only model that fits all of the data … is the planet candidate model.”

While other astronomers are excited by the use of X-rays as a way of discovering distant worlds, they aren’t as convinced Di Stefano’s team has been able to rule out other objects such as large, failed stars known as brown dwarfs or smaller, cooler M stars. 

“Either this is a completely unexpected exoplanet discovered almost immediately in a small amount of data or it’s something quite common or garden variety,” says Benjamin Pope, an astrophysicist studying exoplanets at the University of Queensland in Australia.

Hunting for hidden worlds

Astronomers have been probing the skies for decades, searching for planets outside of our solar system. The first confirmed detection of an exoplanet came in 1992 when two or more bodies were detected around the rapidly spinning neutron star PSR1257+12. 

Prior to these first detections, humans had mostly imagined planets very similar to those we become familiar with in preschool. Rocky planets like the Earth and Mars, gas giants like Jupiter and smaller worlds, like Pluto, far from the sun. Since 1992, our ideas have proven to be extremely unimaginative. 

Exoplanets are truly alien worlds with extremely strange features. There’s the planet where it rains iron, the mega Jupiter that orbits its home star in an egg-shaped orbit, a “naked” planet in the Neptune desert and a ton of super-Earths that seem to resemble home, just a little engorged. Dozens of strange, new worlds continue to be found by powerful planet-hunting telescopes each year. 

But all of these worlds have, so far, been located within the Milky Way. 

Did astronomers find the first planet outside of the Milky Way? It's complicated
© Provided by CNET The Whirlpool Galaxy, M51, in X-ray and optical light. NASA/CXC/SAO/R. DiStefano, et al.

It’s very likely (in fact, it’s practically certain) that planets exist outside of our galaxy — we just haven’t been able to detect them yet. Our closest galactic neighbour, Andromeda, is approximately 2.5 million light-years away. The farthest exoplanet we’ve found resides at just 28,000 light-years from Earth, according to the NASA Exoplanet Catalog

Finding planets outside the solar system is not easy because less and less light makes its way across the universe to our telescopes. Astronomers rarely “see” an exoplanet directly. This is because the bright light from a star in nearby planetary systems usually obscures any planets that might orbit around it. 

To “see” them, astronomers have to block out a star’s rays. Less than 2% of the exoplanets in NASA’s 4,538-strong catalog have been found by this method, known as “direct imaging.” 

But one highly successful method, accounting for over 3,000 exoplanet detections, is known as the “transit” method. Astronomers point their telescopes at stars and then wait for periodic dips in their brightness. If these dips come with a regular cadence they can represent a planet, moving around the star and, from our view on Earth, periodically eclipsing its fiery host. It’s the same idea as a solar eclipse, when the moon passes directly in front of our sun and darkness descends over the Earth.

It’s this method that was critical to the discovery of M51-1. However, instead of detecting dips in visible light (a form of electromagnetic radiation), the team saw a dip in the X-rays (a different form of electromagnetic radiation). Because those X-rays were emanating from a relatively small region, Di Stefano says, a passing planet seems like it could block most or all of them.

M51-1

If M51-1 is a planet, Di Stefano’s team believe it may have had a tumultuous life. 

It’s gravitationally bound to the X-ray binary, M51-ULS-1, which Di Stefano’s team posits consists of a black hole or neutron star orbiting a supergiant star. In the eons-old dance between the pair, the black hole or neutron star has been siphoning off mass from the supergiant. This mass, made of hot dust and gas, is constantly in motion around the black hole/neutron star in what’s known as an accretion disk. This hot disk gives off the X-rays detected by Chandra.

Regions of space around X-ray binaries are violent places and this disk doesn’t give off X-rays in a stable manner. Sometimes, the X-rays seem to switch off for hours, but pinning down the reason why is hard. “Within the very wide range of kinds of behaviors of these dynamic systems, it’s possible that some variation in the accretion rate or something like that could give rise to events like this,” says Duncan Galloway, an astrophysicist at Monash University studying neutron star binaries.

Did astronomers find the first planet outside of the Milky Way? It's complicated
© Provided by CNET The dip in X-ray brightness is apparent on this graph, just prior to 45 hours — but was it caused by a planet? NASA/CXC/SAO/R. DiStefano, et al.

One belief is the dimming could result from some of the hot gas and dust in the system obscuring the signal. Di Stefano says this is not the case, because gas and dust would provide a different signal. “As they pass in front of the x-ray source, some of the light from the source begins to interact with the outer regions of the cloud and this gives a distinctive spectral signature,” she notes.

Another possibility is the X-ray dimming was caused by different types of stars obscuring our view. One type, known as a brown dwarf, arises when a star fails to properly ignite. Another, an M dwarf, is a common type of star sometimes dubbed a “red dwarf.” But due to the age of the M51-ULS-1 system, Di Stefano’s team believe these objects would be much larger than the object they’ve detected.

Di Stefano’s team ran a load of models exploring various different scenarios for why the X-ray source switched off. In the end, she says, it was a Saturn-sized planet that seemed to fit what they were seeing best.

“The planet candidate model was the last one standing, so to speak,” says Di Stefano.

Pope is less convinced. “Personally, I wouldn’t bet that this is a planet,” he says. “In my view this is probably a stellar companion or something exotic happening in the disk.” 

Trust The Process

This isn’t the first time NASA’s Chandra observatory has been swept up in a potential “extroplanet” find. Studying how radiation from distant stars is “bent” by gravity, a technique known as microlensing, astronomers at the University of Oklahoma believed they detected thousands of extragalactic planets back in 2018. Earlier studies have claimed to find evidence of extragalactic planets in the Andromeda galaxy.

Other astronomers were skeptical about these detections, too. The same skepticism has played out in the case of M51-1. And, importantly, that’s perfectly normal. 

This is the scientific process in action. Di Stefano’s team have argued their case: M51-1 is an extragalactic planet. Now, there’s more work to do. Confirmation that M51-1 is planetary won’t be possible until it makes another transit of the X-ray binary in many decades time, but there are other ways for astronomers to vet their results. 

Pope notes that if we found analogous systems in the Milky Way, we’d be able to follow up with optical telescopes and get a better understanding of what might be happening at these types of systems. 

We know there must be planets outside of the Milky Way and so, eventually, humans will discover them. For Galloway, the study is exciting not because of what caused the X-ray binary to dip in brightness, but what happens next. 

“The really exciting thing is there might be additional events in other data, so now we have a motivation where we can go and look for them,” he says.

Di Stefano feels the same way, hoping the publication will bring others into this type of research. She says the team is working hard, studying the skies for other X-ray binaries which may exhibit similar dimming.

“Ultimately,” she notes, “the best verification will be the discovery of more planets.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Go: I quit for Duterte's sake

SEN. Christopher Lawrence “Bong” Go appealed to his supporters for understanding following his decision to withdraw from the presidential race, saying his decision was in the best interest of President ... Read more »

Typhoon to bring rain but will not enter PAR

© PAGASA Typhoon to bring rain but will not enter PAR MANILA, Philippines — A typhoon with international name Nyatoh is expected to further intensify but will no longer enter ... Read more »

Selecta launches 12 Ways of Christmas

As Christmas is the season for giving, Selecta aims to spread the spirit of Happinas all over the country once again through 12 Ways of Christmas. Together with local retailers, ... Read more »

Fire razes textile building in Divisoria

© Miguel De Guzman Fire razes textile building in Divisoria MANILA, Philippines — At least P5 million worth of property was destroyed after a fire struck a commercial building in ... Read more »

Duterte: Go's decision to pull out of presidential race 'made a lot of people sad'

THE decision of Senator Christopher Lawrence “Bong” Go to withdraw his presidential bid in the May 2022 polls has “made a lot of people sad”, President Rodrigo Duterte said Thursday. ... Read more »

China-Laos train opens Fri

© The Manila Times The Lane Xang EMU train arrives at the northern Laos’ border town of Boten, after passing by the China-Laos borderline, Oct. 15, 2021. The streamlined The ... Read more »

A 'snake,' chicharon bulaklak, and earning one's keep in ‘After Six' conversations with JAZA and Lance Gokongwei

Based from his juicy scoops as of late, it seems that JAZA as a newshound of sorts is also as good as JAZA the newsmaker that many has been accustomed ... Read more »

Philippines bares new quarantine protocols for travelers from countries not on red list

A passenger tries to find a flight as several airlines have stopped flying out of South Africa, amidst the spread of the new SARS-CoV-2 variant Omicron, at O.R. Tambo International ... Read more »

Embark on Magical Adventures with Adorable Baby Bear Brothers in Original New Series, We Baby Bears, Premiering January 8 on Cartoon Network

Pinoys can travel up, up, and away to faraway places with the 2-episode premiere of the original animated comedy, We Baby Bears, Saturday, January 8 at 10:30am on Cartoon Network ... Read more »

India announces first two cases of Omicron variant

NEW DELHI: India announced its first two cases of the highly infectious Omicron Covid variant on Thursday, months after a devastating wave of the virus killed more than 200,000 people ... Read more »

Anthony Taberna pens emotional "2nd birthday" message for daughter Zoey

© Provided by PEP.ph A sentimental message was shared by broadcaster Anthony Taberna on his Facebook account this Thursday, December 2. Tungkol ito sa pagkakadiskubreng mayroong leukemia ng anak na ... Read more »

Why Nueva Ecija is worth the drive

AS over 30 percent of the Philippine population becomes fully vaccinated, more provinces in Northern Luzon are reopening their doors to visitors. One of them is Nueva Ecija, a landlocked ... Read more »

Which booster should I get? What to know about mixing vaccines and the omicron variant

© Provided by CNET Sarah Tew/CNET As of Thursday, three cases of COVID-19 caused by the omicron variant have been detected in the US, detected in people in California, Minnesota ... Read more »

China's aviation regulator expects 737 MAX to resume flights around year-end

By Stella Qiu and Jamie Freed © Reuters/Karen Ducey A Boeing 737 MAX airplane lands after a test flight at Boeing Field in Seattle BEIJING/SYDNEY (Reuters) -China’s aviation regulator expects ... Read more »

Norris scores late, Senators beat Canes for NHL-low 5th win

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — Alex Formenton scored twice and Josh Norris broke a tie 19 seconds after the Ottawa Senators lost the lead in their 3-2 win over the Carolina ... Read more »

Makar, Avalanche bounce back, beat Canadiens 4-1

MONTREAL (AP) — Cale Makar scored to put Colorado ahead to stay late in the second period, Valeri Nichushkin had a goal and an assist, and the Avalanche beat the ... Read more »

Balance helps No. 25 Florida State women top Illini 67-58

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. (AP) — Morgan Jones scored 12 points with 10 rebounds and a pair of freshmen scored 12 points off the bench and No. 25 Florida State turned back ... Read more »

Grizzlies throttle Thunder by NBA-record 73-point margin

MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) — The Memphis Grizzlies broke the NBA record for margin of victory on Thursday night, beating the Oklahoma City Thunder 152-79. The 73-point margin easily topped the ... Read more »

Lampley carries Sam Houston St. over Schreiner 106-46

HUNTSVILLE, Texas (AP) — Demarkus Lampley had 21 points as Sam Houston rolled past Division III Schreiner 106-46 on Thursday night. Lampley hit 7 of 10 3-pointers. Donte Powers had ... Read more »

Best of NFL Week 13

New Orleans Saints tight end Nick Vannett (81) catches a pass against the Dallas Cowboys. Dallas Cowboys tight end Dalton Schultz catches the ball as the New Orleans Saints’ Malcolm ... Read more »

Minus Giannis, Bucks lose to Toronto, ending win streak at 8

TORONTO (AP) — Fred VanVleet scored 29 points, Pascal Siakam had 20 and the Toronto Raptors took advantage of Giannis Antetokounmpo’s absence to beat Milwaukee 97-93 Thursday night, ending the ... Read more »

DeRozan, LaVine help Bulls hang on to beat Knicks 119-115

NEW YORK (AP) — DeMar DeRozan scored 34 points, Zach LaVine and Nikola Vucevic each added 27, and the Chicago Bulls held on for a 119-115 victory over the New ... Read more »

Butler lifts Drexel over Fairleigh Dickinson 86-65

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — James Butler had 25 points plus 14 rebounds as Drexel romped past Fairleigh Dickinson 86-65 on Thursday night. Melik Martin added 20 points for the Dragons. Camren ... Read more »

TCU beats back Oral Roberts in 71-63 win

FORT WORTH, Texas (AP) — Damion Baugh and Mike Miles scored 13 points apiece and TCU fought off Oral Roberts for 71-63 win on Thursday night. The Horned Frogs (6-1) ... Read more »

Kami tak akan leka selepas menang di Melaka, kata Naib Presiden Umno

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menurut Mohamed Khaled Nordin, Umno sebenarnya menjadi ‘lebih berhati-hati’ dan akan menggunakan semua data yang ada untuk menilai ‘mood’ rakyat. PETALING JAYA: Naib Presiden ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Details How the Gun Went Off in Fatal 'Rust' Shooting, Says He Is Not Responsible

© Jim Spellman/Getty Images Alec Baldwin is opening up for the first time about the fatal shooting on the set of Rust. In his first sit-down interview since the incident back in October, ... Read more »

Jennifer Lopez Drops 'On My Way' Music Video for Single From Her Upcoming Film 'Marry Me'

© John Parra/GC Images Jennifer Lopez is tugging at the heart strings again, this time with her “On My Way” music video. Lopez on Thursday night dropped the video to ... Read more »

Covid risk remains higher for some ethnic groups

© Getty Images The risk of catching and becoming very sick from Covid remains higher for people belonging to certain ethnic groups, a major review has found. The Covid-disparities report, ... Read more »

Jets' Denzel Mims expected to get another extended look

Injury and illness have created a need for the Jets at wide receiver, and Denzel Mims looks like he will get a chance to fill that void. With the status ... Read more »

The One Claim From Alec Baldwin's Rust Interview That Has Twitter Fuming

Tinseltown/Shutterstock The tragic death of cinematographer Halyna Hutchins occurred on October 21, 2021, when she was fatally struck by a live round fired from a prop gun used by Alec ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Makes A Bold Claim About His Future In Hollywood

Jim Bennett/Getty Images October 21, 2021, will forever stand as one of the darkest days in Hollywood history. What started out as just another day of filming on the set ... Read more »

China celebrity crackdown: producer questions blacklists before legal system has its say

Li Xuezheng is most famous for the hit political drama In the Name of the People He questioned whether a powerful industry association has the legal authority to blacklist artists ... Read more »

Global stocks wobble as Didi delisting revives U.S.-China worries

© Reuters/ISSEI KATO Passersby wearing protective face masks walk past an electronic board displaying world stock indexes in Tokyo By Tom Westbrook SYDNEY (Reuters) – Stocks fell on Friday after ... Read more »

Juventus probe shines a light on Italy's alleged transfer trickery

© Isabella BONOTTO Juventus Vice-president Pavel Nedved (2ndL) and president Andrea Agnelli (3rdL) look on prior to the Serie A game against Fiorentina last month Transfer dealings in Italy have ... Read more »

Dutch Covid surge fuelled by liberal ways, say experts

© Ramon van Flymen Masks often remain unworn and Covid passes unchecked as the government shies away from enforcing its guidelines Even before it became a hotspot for Omicron variant ... Read more »

Baldwin says does not feel guilt over 'Rust' shooting death

© Angela Weiss Alec Baldwin says he does not feel guilty over the death of Halyna Hutchins because he was not responsible Alec Baldwin said he does not feel guilty ... Read more »

Ghostface is back for another scare fest in new ‘Scream'

© Provided by Interaksyon Did you miss Ghostface? Paramount Pictures recently released a featurette and a trailer that revealed the famous “Scream” character Ghostface would make a return in the ... Read more »

Tom Udall, Biden's cowboy boot-wearing friend, makes debut as ambassador to New Zealand

Clad in the cowboy boots and turquoise gemstone bolo tie of his home state, Tom Udall, Joe Biden’s longtime friend and pick as US ambassador, made a distinctly American impression ... Read more »

Toronto Public Health declares COVID-19 outbreak at Toronto East Detention Centre

(Reuters) – Toronto Public Health on Thursday announced a COVID-19 outbreak at the provincially run Toronto East Detention Centre with one suspected case of the Omicron variant. The Durham Region ... Read more »

This Mom Who Has An OnlyFans Account Was Banned From Volunteering At Her Kids' School Because Of What She Does For A Living

About a month ago, Victoria Triece — who goes by Victoria Snooks online — was told that she couldn't volunteer at her kids' school because she has an OnlyFans account. ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic