Despite gains, Europe's indigenous people still struggle for recognition

Asia's Tech News Daily

Elisabeth Roy Trudel, The University of Western Australia, Leena Heinämäki, University of Lapland, Philipp Kastner, won a court case, boarding schools, this diversity is decreasing, Nordic Saami Council, protests against the construction, Finnmark Act, Initiatives to address injustices, without adequately consulting, Saami Convention, this series of articles, The Conversation, original article

The authors of this article are Elisabeth Roy Trudel, Ph.D. Candidate in Humanities, Concordia University; Honorary Fellow, UWA Faculty of Law, The University of Western Australia; Leena Heinämäki, Senior Researcher, University of Lapland, and Philipp Kastner, Assistant Professor in International Law, The University of Western Australia.

The Saami (previously known in English as Laplanders) are the only recognized indigenous people of Europe. But they rarely make international headlines.

Unlike most indigenous peoples in the post-colonial world, Saami people don’t live in extreme poverty and aren’t exposed to high levels of violence. But they too have a history of colonization and discrimination, and tend not to have easy relationships with the four modern states they inhabit.

Although the Saami have made political and legal gains in the past decades, progress is precarious. And recognition of their rights by the governments of Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Russia cannot be taken for granted.

As recently as February 2016, for instance, a small Saami village in Sweden won a court case against the state after a decades-long battle over hunting and fishing rights, which had been restricted by the national parliament in 1993.

See also: “The music chose me”: A talk with Sámi artist Mari Boine

Difficult relationship

The Saami established themselves as a distinct ethnic group in Scandinavia around 2,000 years ago. While they’re mostly known as semi-nomadic reindeer herders today, traditionally their livelihood also included hunting, fishing, trapping, and farming.

From the Middle Ages onwards, Saami people were pushed further and further north because of migration into the areas they’d occupied. This led to a progressive loss of land as well as access to natural resources.

Attempts were made to convert them to Christianity, and assimilationist policies were adopted in the late 19th century, especially in Norway and Sweden. Saami languages and cultural activities were suppressed and, until the 1960s, many children were placed in boarding schools, where they were forbidden from speaking their native tongue.

Current population estimates vary greatly: there may be between 50,000 and 65,000 Saami in Norway; up to 20,000 in Sweden; around 8,000 in Finland; and 2,000 on the Kola Peninsula in Russia. They encompass nine language groups, but this diversity is decreasing.

Today, it’s mostly mining and logging, oil and gas, as well as wind power development projects promoted by the state and private companies that threaten Saami people’s traditional lifestyle, cultural identity, and spiritual values – because all are closely connected to the natural environment. Many Saami have also left their homelands to find work in the cities further south.

Inadequate constitutional protection

Saami people started to organize themselves politically in the early 20th century. And the first tangible regional initiative to represent their populations in Nordic countries resulted in the creation of the Nordic Saami Council in 1956.

This, along with the influence of international law and the mobilization of indigenous peoples worldwide, led to important forms of legal recognition in the second half of the 20th century. Still, although the Saami are considered one people, the degree of their recognition varies greatly in the four countries where they live.

In Norway, it was only in the aftermath of attention-grabbing protests against the construction of a major hydroelectric dam on the Alta River that the national constitution was amended (in 1988) to protect Saami culture. But the change didn’t explicitly recognize the Saami as a people, as the constitution of Finland has done since 1995 and the constitution of Sweden since 2010.

Norway added legal protection by ratifying the 1989 Indigenous and Tribal Peoples Convention of the International Labour Organisation and by adopting the Finnmark Act in 2005. The latter recognizes that the Saami have – collectively and individually – acquired rights to land in the northeastern part of the country.

Still, some of the constitutional protections given to the Saami lack implementing legislation, and there are no comprehensive guarantees regarding cultural self-determination. The provision in the Swedish constitution is considered to be particularly weak. And the Russian constitution says nothing about the Saami at all.

See also: The Sámi: A people often forced to live between two worlds

Largely symbolic progress

So-called Saami parliaments have been established in Finland (1973), Norway (1989), and Sweden (1993). These are a positive step towards self-governance, and play an important advisory role for governments. But problems remain: the parliaments have few decision-making powers, and many Saami don’t participate in elections.

Initiatives to address injustices stemming from assimilationist policies include an apology by the Norwegian king in 1997 and the prime minister a couple of years later. Norway has also established a compensation fund.

Overall, constitutional recognition by the Nordic states of their Indigenous people has gone further than in other countries such as Australia. But, in practice, the legal protection of Saami people is far from satisfactory. The Saami don’t have any real self-determination, and they still lack adequate protection of their culture and lifestyle.

Even though there’s specific legislation to protect Saami languages, as in Finland and Norway, laws are limited or not fully implemented. Access to public education in the Saami language, for instance, is restricted to designated areas. But more than half of the Saami live outside these areas, which means that many children don’t have access to education in their first language.

And while participation by and consultation of the Saami are often legally required for development and exploitation projects that impact the environment, these obligations are not always honored. All this despite international law increasingly putting forward the importance of free, prior, and informed consent by indigenous peoples.

As recently as December 2015, the Finnish government introduced a bill that would radically change the way forests are managed in the country, without adequately consulting the Saami.

On the positive side, recent mining legislation in Finland requires consultation with the Saami and sets an obligation to conduct a cultural impact assessment before any mining activities can take place in the Saami homeland.

Stalled move

To strengthen and harmonize legal protections given to the Saami in the Nordic countries, efforts have been made in recent years to adopt a Saami Convention.

This could become the first regional treaty concerning indigenous peoples and would enshrine various rights, including the right to self-determination, Saami language and culture, and land and water, endorsing the principle of free, prior, and informed consent.

The convention mirrors the essence of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, but it would create even stronger legal obligations for the Nordic states. Unfortunately, negotiations have stalled, and it’s not clear whether the 2005 draft convention will be adopted anytime soon.

A certain degree of recognition of the Saami and reconciliation has arguably been achieved in the Nordic countries, and this could inspire other Indigenous peoples and states in the world.

But Saami people still face significant threats. Clearly, these should be dealt with by listening to the voices of the Saami, and by considering them with respect and as full and equal partners. And by respecting their rights as an indigenous people under international law.

Drawing on attempts at reconciliation, this series of articles from The Conversation explores different ways of addressing unfinished business between modern nations and indigenous peoples.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Source: The Conversation / #NorwayTodayTravel

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Norway is providing 10 billion kroner in guarantees and loans to offshore wind projects

The Norwegian state is providing a loan guarantee of NOK 1.5 billion for a third transformer platform on the giant offshore wind project Doggerbank. Export Finance Norway (Eksfin) is providing ... Read more »

FSB nabs two Ukrainian spies for collecting data on strategic sites in Russia

The detainees confessed that they had been recruited by a current employee of the Ukrainian Security Service Read more »

FSB apprehends Ukraine's operative for preparing terrorist attack in Russia

He was to detonate two self-made explosive devices Read more »

Communist lawmaker faces illegal hunting charges, says Russia's top investigator

Valery Rashkin faces up to five years in prison Read more »

Murals take shots at presidential candidates in ‘Art Battle'

Graffiti artist Ninbolt stands in front of the wall of a secondhand book store on which he has depicted political scandals of Yoon Seok-youl, the presidential candidate of the main ... Read more »

Norway's Karsten Warholm named World Athlete of the Year

Norway’s Karsten Warholm has been named the athlete of the year by the International Athletics Federation (WA). He is the first-ever Norwegian to receive the award. The prize was awarded at ... Read more »

Feast and be merry: 10 UK winter villages for Christmas food and drink

The Winter Village, York The new winter village at York Minster is a good spot for shopping as well as socialising, with wooden cabins selling local food, drinks and gifts. ... Read more »

Youn Yuh-jung, BTS and aespa named visionaries of Korean entertainment

Youn Yuh-jung wins at the 2021 Visionary Awards at the CJ ENM Center in Mapo-gu, western Seoul, Wednesday. (CJ ENM)South Korean cultural icons including Oscar-winning actor Youn Yuh-jung, top comedian ... Read more »

Western Australia, a state almost no one can visit, to pitch itself to tourists as ‘safest place in the world'

Photograph: Chameleons Eye/REX/Shutterstock WA premier says the state will loosen Covid-19 border restrictions in ‘a couple of months’, but those trying to get home are unimpressed Get our free news ... Read more »

Soldier charged with careless handling of weapons after a shooting accident in Færder Municipality

A soldier was charged with careless handling of weapons after a shooting accident at Mågerøy in Færder Municipality on Tuesday. The Southeastern Police District states that a young female conscript ... Read more »

Health Directorate chief Bjørn Guldvog: A fourth corona vaccine dose might be necessary this spring

Three doses of the corona vaccine may not be enough. Health director Bjørn Guldvog says a fourth dose may be necessary this spring. The government’s goal is for the entire ... Read more »

First group of Afghan students studying at Russian universities arrives in Russia

The Russian Ministry of Education and Science stated, that the task is to give students a possibility to receive high-quality higher education in comfortable conditions and safe environment Read more »

Second evacuation plane from Afghanistan touches down at Chkalovsky airfield near Moscow

One more military-transport plane is expected Read more »

Cold and dry weather expected this weekend – especially in the north of Norway

In Northern Norway, temperatures could drop to as low as -30 degrees this weekend. For Southern Norway, the forecasts are more uncertain. A high-pressure area from the Barents Sea will ... Read more »

No evidence that HIV is linked to emergence of Omicron coronavirus variant, says expert

The reason why this variant was associated with HIV is because it emerged in South Africa, where a lot of people are infected with HIV, Vadim Pokrovsky said Read more »

Vedum confirms that the government will cover part of the costs for the dissolution of Viken

Minister of Finance Trygve Slagsvold Vedum (SP) promises that the government will pay if there is a dissolution of the large county of Viken. But he does not want to ... Read more »

Critically endangered spoon-billed sandpipers spotted on Hainan beach for the first time

These birds nest in northeastern Russia and winter in the Southeast Asian region Read more »

Northern Ireland art group Array Collective wins 2021 Turner prize

A group of artists from across the sectarian divide in Northern Ireland has won the 2021 Turner prize, the highlight of the contemporary art calendar. The Array Collective is a ... Read more »

Leaders of three major monotheistic religions receive “Bridge Builder” awards in Oslo

The Bridge Builder Award 2021 has been awarded at the Opera House in Oslo. Demonstrations were expected when leaders of the three monotheistic religions received the award. This year’s Bridge ... Read more »

Omicron infection confirmed at a concert in Denmark

The Danish health authorities stated that a corona-infected person who was in the audience at a large concert in the Danish city of Aalborg this weekend had been diagnosed with ... Read more »

The Hockey News Fantasy Podcast: Cash Out on Nazem Kadri?

Is it time to sell high on Kadri? Who are the best buy-low targets? And more. © Provided by Hockey News on Sports Illustrated Nazem Kadri (Jeff Curry-USA TODAY Sports) ... Read more »

WHO: Travel bans will not prevent the spread of the omicron variant

The World Health Organization (WHO) believes that general travel bans aimed at preventing the spread of the omicron variant of the coronavirus will not be effective. Several countries have introduced ... Read more »

At least 23 countries reported Omicron variant — WHO

It was also reported that several WHO advisory groups have met in the last few days to "evaluate the emerging evidence and prioritize the studies needed to answer these questions" Read more »

Russian citizen Grichishkin sentenced to 60 months in US for cybercrimes

Alexander Grichishkin was accused of organizing a hacker group Read more »

WHO: Omicron could become more transmissible than Delta

On November 26, the WHO designated the new COVID-19 strain, which was detected in southern Africa, as Omicron Read more »

How to avoid overtourism and uncover the real Atacama

Chile Copiapo, Altiplano Lagoon – Pura Adventure With light twinkling through its empty eye sockets, even a dead cow looks ethereal on the Altiplano’s high plateau. Polished brilliant white by ... Read more »

NATO chief Stoltenberg warns Russia: “A high price will be paid for any aggression against Ukraine”

NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg says Russia has to pay a high price for any aggression against Ukraine.  “It would have serious political and economic consequences and a high price to ... Read more »

The countries banning all travellers over the 'mild' omicron variant

Japan flight cancellation omicron variant travel ban – Getty Britain has added 10 African countries to its travel red list, and beefed up its testing requirements for overseas arrivals, a ... Read more »

Bomb found near the US ambassadorial residence in Reykjavik

A homemade bomb has been found in a rubbish bin near the residence of the US ambassador in Reykjavik, Icelandic media reports. Three people were arrested when the special forces ... Read more »

Over 400 migrants to be able to leave Belarus on Thursday — Minsk airport

The Iraqi authorities organized an evacuation flight for the migrants Read more »

Eleven people detained in Belarus for insulting comments on death of Russian paratroopers

Two Russian soldiers died on November 12, when the domes of their parachutes intertwined during a landing on a shooting range in the west of Belarus Read more »

Around 400 Seadrill Norway Crew employees could lose their jobs soon

Around 40% of the employees in Seadrill Norway Crew could lose their jobs when two rigs complete their assignments in the new year. Seadrill has 1,050 employees in Norway through ... Read more »

10 underrated Caribbean islands the jet set are flocking to

Anguilla, West Indies – Getty There are 31 islands and territories in the Caribbean, yet most British travellers only visit a few select favourites, in some cases year after year. ... Read more »

Court sentences participant in 1999 attack on Dagestan to 25 years in jail

The court found Umakhanov guilty of participation in an armed gang, armed rebellion and an attempt on the life of law enforcers Read more »

Wolves in Norwegian forests are of Finnish descent, new report claims

The wolves that live in Norwegian forests are of Finnish descent. There is no trace of the original Norwegian-Swedish wolf population, a new research report states. The report, which is ... Read more »

Airbnb allegedly hosts Xinjiang rentals on land owned by sanctioned group

Photograph: Mark Schiefelbein/AP Carrying properties owned by XPCC, which has been linked to human rights abuses, risks breaching US regulations Airbnb has reportedly listed more than a dozen properties on ... Read more »

Bolshoi Theatre to hold world premiere of The Master and Margarita ballet

The world premiere of The Master and Margarita ballet was supposed to take place last season, but was postponed due to the pandemic Read more »

Veslefrikk oil field to close after 32 years of operations

Equinor will end production on the Veslefrikk oil field in February next year after 32 years.  “We plan to close production already in February next year. That will be the ... Read more »

FHI: Two new omikron cases confirmed in Norway – the infected people are travelers from South Africa

The omicron variant of the coronavirus has been confirmed in two people who have flown to Gardermoen from South Africa, the National Institute of Public Health (FHI) announced on Wednesday.  ... Read more »

Why you should consider Scotland instead of the Alps for a ski holiday this winter

Glencoe view There are many common misconceptions about skiing in Scotland. “It’s not worth the long journey,” and “There’s no snow” were just some of the comments I received when ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic