DeSantis Says Requiring Students Quarantine After COVID Exposure 'Draconian'

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis announced a new policy to allow parents of children who have been exposed to COVID-19 to opt their children out of mandatory quarantine on Wednesday.

© Joe Raedle/Getty Florida Governor Ron DeSantis announced a new policy that allows parents to opt out their children from following quarantine after a known exposure to COVID-19. DeSantis is pictured gesturing during a roundtable discussion on Cuba in Miami, Florida on July 13, 2021.

The Republican governor touted the new Florida Department of Health policy, Emergency Rule 64DER21-15, as a victory for parental rights that would prevent “the unnecessary exclusion of healthy students” who have been exposed to the highly contagious disease from in-person classrooms.

“Parents have the right to have their healthy kids in school,” DeSantis said during a news briefing. “Quarantining healthy students is incredibly damaging for their educational advancement. It’s also incredibly disruptive for families all throughout the state of Florida.”

“You haven’t seen a lot of data or studies to justify those types of draconian actions,” he added. “And the places that have done a symptoms-based approach have had very similar outcomes to places that have done more draconian quarantines.”

Under the new rule, parents can choose which protocol to implement after their student comes into direct contact with an infected person: either allow their asymptomatic child to return to school “without restrictions or disparate treatment,” or put the student into voluntary quarantine for a period “not to exceed seven days” from the point of exposure.

The rule, which goes into effect immediately, also allows students that have COVID-19 and are experiencing symptoms to go back to classrooms even before their symptoms clear or they test negative, as long as they have received “written permission to return to school” from a licensed doctor or registered nurse practitioner.

Dr. Joseph Ladapo, Florida’s new surgeon general, said in a statement that he and DeSantis “share a similar vision of weighing the costs and benefits of public health policies” and argued there was not “a single high-quality study that shows that any child has ever benefited from forced quarantining policies, but we have seen demonstrable and considerable harm to children.”

The rule was the first Florida Department of Health change made under Ladapo, who was appointed by DeSantis on Tuesday. The previous Surgeon General, Dr. Scott Rivkees, left the job on Monday. His departure followed a long period of few public appearances, preceded by a joint appearance with DeSantis at an April 2020 press briefing he abruptly departed after advocating for social distancing amid the pandemic.

DeSantis’ decision to appoint Ladapo quickly came under heavy criticism due to controversial statements the doctor has made regarding COVID-19. Last year, Ladapo promoted the unproven and ineffective drug hydroxychloroquine as a COVID-19 treatment, while on Tuesday he downplayed the proven effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines as “nothing special.”

Newsweek reached out to the Florida Education Association for comment.

Related Articles

  • Ron DeSantis’ New Surgeon General Appeared in ‘Demon Sperm’ Doctor’s COVID Conspiracy Video
  • Ron DeSantis Says Monoclonal Antibody Brought Florida COVID ER Visits Down 70 Percent
  • MSNBC Host Brian Williams Accuses DeSantis, Abbott of ‘Ghoulish’ COVID-19 ‘Denialism’

Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Former Theranos product manager Daniel Edlin testifies in criminal trial of Elizabeth Holmes

To many people a decade or so ago, Elizabeth Holmes was the founder of high-flying blood-testing startup Theranos. To Daniel Edlin, she was the sister of his Duke University college ... Read more »

AAC set to expand, Nick Rolovich out at Wazzu, drunkest counties

Subscribe to The College Football Enquirer Apple Podcasts • Stitcher • Google Podcasts • Spotify Dan Wetzel is back and ready to rib Pat Forde about him stirring it up with Knoxville radio hosts. The guys ... Read more »

Photo exhibit highlights Princess Diana's life in never-before-seen images

For fans of the late Diana, Princess of Wales, the coming weeks offer a bounty of never-before-seen images thanks to the British royals’ longest-serving official photographer and his two sons. ... Read more »

Lawsuit Alleging YouTube Violated Constitution by Taking Down QAnon Videos Dismissed

A lawsuit alleging that YouTube violated the Constitution’s First Amendment by removing videos promoting the QAnon conspiracy theory has been thrown out by a federal judge. © LIONEL BONAVENTURE/AFP/Getty A ... Read more »

21 officers placed on 'no pay' status amid Chicago vaccine standoff

Twenty-one Chicago police officers have been placed on “no pay” status for refusing to comply with the city’s order to disclose their COVID-19 vaccination status amid a standoff between officials ... Read more »

NHL player Jimmy Hayes' death highlights spike in fentanyl-related drug overdose deaths

Family members of a former NHL player who had cocaine and fentanyl in his system when he died are now speaking out to warn people about the risks of fentanyl, ... Read more »

COVID-19 updates: Homeland Security secretary tests positive for virus

The United States has been facing a COVID-19 surge as the more contagious delta variant continues to spread. More than 727,000 Americans have died from COVID-19 while over 4.9 million ... Read more »

Where to find Ariana Grande in Fortnite Chapter 2 Season 8

Music icon Ariana Grande has once again arrived into the world of Fortnite. This time around, she will be aiding in the search for the Caretaker — a beast that ... Read more »

Freeform's '31 Nights of Halloween' 2021 Schedule Looks Fang-tastic With 14 "Hocus Pocus" Screenings

Freeform’s “31 Nights of Halloween” starts Friday, October 1. The 2021 schedule includes fan favorites like Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas, Hocus Pocus, The Addams Family, and more. The ... Read more »

Amazon Is Already Offering Major Black Friday Discounts — Shop the Best Ones Now

© Amazon Toshiba 65-inch 4K UHD Smart Fire TV, best amazon black friday deals We’re all trying to get a head start on shopping this year. There’s a lot of ... Read more »

Supreme Court won't block vaccine mandate for Maine's health care workers

PORTLAND, Maine — The U.S. Supreme Court declined Tuesday to block a vaccine requirement imposed on Maine health care workers, the latest defeat for opponents of vaccine mandates. © Robert ... Read more »

Orionid meteor shower: How to see bits of Halley's Comet burn up this week

Get up early enough this week and you might be rewarded with a dazzling fireball in the sky courtesy of the annual Orionid meteor shower. The Orionids are set to ... Read more »

NHTSA is investigating Ram diesel high-pressure fuel pumps

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is working with Stellantis to investigate potential high-pressure fuel pump failures in its 2018-2020 Ram trucks with the 6.7-liter Cummins diesel engine. According to ... Read more »

Klopp delighted to escape Atletico Madrid with 'three dirty points'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp took great satisfaction in ‘three dirty points’ after a wild 3-2 Champions League win over 10-man Atletico Madrid in ... Read more »

Dune movie: First 10 minutes left me with a dropped jaw, high expectations

When the theatrical and HBO Max release of Denis Villeneuve’s new sci-fi epic Dune were still three months away, a handful of Imax theaters across the US hosted a special two-day ... Read more »

Lil Nas X films 'thank you video' on Hollywood tour bus

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Lil Nas X filmed a scene on top of a tour bus in Hollywood to thank people for raising his song, Industry Baby, ... Read more »

Rapper Rick Ross Keynote Speaker at ‘Black Men Talk Tech' Conference

Another technology conference is coming to South Florida. The “Black Men Talk Tech” Unicorn Ambition Conference is a two-day meeting that focuses on helping up-and-coming tech entrepreneurs with their businesses. ... Read more »

Blue Ivy Carter Looks So Much Like Dad Jay-Z in This Peek at Her Crashing Beyoncé's Tiffany & Co. Video

© AP Photo/David J. Phillip. Blue Ivy Carter is stealing the show from mom and dad as she makes the most adorable cameo in Beyoncé and Jay-Z’s new Tiffany & ... Read more »

Gas leaks, rodents, asbestos: 10 military families in Texas sued their landlord over unsafe living conditions in base housing

© Provided by Business Insider Vacant homes dot the landscape in the Medina Annex at the Lackland Air Force base in San Antonio, where some families say they still wait ... Read more »

Alyssa Milano arrested during voting rights protest outside of the White House

Alyssa Milano was arrested on Tuesday while protesting outside of the White House.  The 48-year-old was advocating for voting rights.  Videos showed Milano standing outside of the White House. “I ... Read more »

Ryan Tannehill breaks down Week 6's top fantasy football bad beat

Did you suffer a crushing loss in Week 6, by way of a last-second defeat or a blowout? Well, we here at Yahoo Fantasy are here for you, yet again, ... Read more »

Sergio Perez heads to the US, Mexican F1 GPs with a hometown advantage

After a one-year hiatus because of the COVID-19 pandemic, F1 returned to the United States with fanfare provided by Red Bull Racing and Sergio Perez. © Provided by NBC Sports ... Read more »

Jayapal says tuition-free community college 'probably won't' be in spending plan

Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) expressed doubt on Tuesday that the tuition-free community college proposal previously floated by Democrats to be included in the sweeping social spending plan the party is ... Read more »

Aspen Ladd's coach wasn't wrong for UFC Vegas 40 cornering

Jim West handled the Aspen Ladd situation perfectly during her UFC Vegas 40 main event. © Provided by Fansided Aspen Ladd suffered a unanimous decision loss to Norma Dumont in ... Read more »

Inaugural Indy Autonomous Challenge to Bring 'Shock and Awe' to Brickyard

© Indy Autonomous Challenge No drivers, no problem for driverless cars on the famed Indianapolis Motor Speedway. On October 23 and for the first time in Indianapolis 500 history, cars ... Read more »

Russell, Abdul-Jabbar, Durant highlight first 25 of NBA's 75 greatest players

© Provided by NBC Sports When all of the NBA’s 75 greatest players list is out there, arguments will inevitably follow about the snubs. Defenders of the 76th and 77th ... Read more »

Habs vs. Sharks: Game thread

Montreal Canadiens vs. San Jose Sharks How to watch Start time: 7:00 PM EDT / 4:00 PM PDT In the Canadiens region: TSN2 (English), RDS (French) In the Sharks region: ... Read more »

San Francisco police have 'evidence' Phish concert attendee 'leapt' before deadly fall

The man who fell to his death during a Phish concert on Sunday night at San Francisco‘s Chase Center has been identified, and police say they “have evidence to believe ... Read more »

Biden admin backs down on tracking bank accounts with over $600 annual transactions

The Biden administration on Tuesday backed down on a controversial proposal to direct the IRS to collect additional data on every bank account that sees more than $600 in annual ... Read more »

12 Beauty Products from Small Businesses That InStyle Editors Are Gifting Themselves This Year

‘Tis the season to start ordering those holiday gifts — and don’t forget to add yourself to that shopping list. While buying gifts for family and friends may be at ... Read more »

Heather Rae Young Shares Sweet Video of Tarek El Moussa Moments Before His Proposal: 'Makes Me Tear Up'

© Provided by People Tarek El Moussa/instagram Tarek El Moussa is clearly head-over-heels in love with fiancée Heather Rae Young! Ahead of the pair’s upcoming nuptials, Young, 34, shared a ... Read more »

Steve Bannon not cooperating suggests Trump may have been 'personally involved in the planning and execution' of the January 6 insurrection, Liz Cheney says

© Getty Getty The Select Committee investigating January 6 met Tuesday night to discuss Steve Bannon. The former White House advisor has refused to comply with a subpoena to testify. ... Read more »

Boy is cancer-free 2 years after viral photo

After two years of birthdays, holidays and chemotherapy treatments, Beckett Burge was able to celebrate the biggest milestone of all — being officially cancer-free. Beckett was only 4 years old ... Read more »

Trump bungles history while fuming at Jefferson statue's removal from City Hall

Perhaps Trump can bond with the Thomas Jefferson statue over being removed from a government building. The country’s 45th president was predictably upset with Monday’s decision to evict the Jefferson ... Read more »

Puerto Rico leads US states, territories in COVID-19 vaccination

Puerto Rico leads U.S. states and territories with the highest vaccination rate against the coronavirus. © Getty Images Puerto Rico leads US states, territories in COVID-19 vaccination The island has ... Read more »

MacOS Monterey: Apple's new software upgrade drops next week. Here's how to download it

MacOS Monterey, Apple’s new operating system for Macs, will be here on Monday, Oct. 25. The release date for Apple’s new software (also known as MacOS 12) was announced on Monday, ... Read more »

Coronavirus crisis: Australian hits first jab milestone with 70 per cent double vaxxed

Australia is set to become one of the most vaccinated countries in the world, as the first major milestone in the national reopening plan of 70 per cent of the ... Read more »

Colts promote Antwaun Woods to active roster

© Provided by NBC Sports The Colts elevated defensive tackle Antwaun Woods to the 53-player roster from the practice squad Tuesday, the team announced. Woods has spent time on Indianapolis’ ... Read more »

A 10-year-old Black girl was arrested at school in Hawaii after allegedly drawing a photo of her bully, ACLU says

© Google Maps Honowai Elementary School in Waipahu, Hawaii Google Maps A 10-year-old Black girl was arrested after drawing a picture that allegedly left a parent “very upset,” HawaiiNewsNow reported. ... Read more »

Democrats raise proposed IRS bank reporting threshold to $10,000 from $600

By David Lawder © Reuters/ANDREW KELLY FILE PHOTO: The word “taxes” is seen engraved at the headquarters of the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in Washington, D.C. WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Senior Democrats ... Read more »