Derek Jarman: Protest! review – ‘Coherence is overrated'

Manchester Art Gallery
From confrontational paintings about his Aids treatment to the sublime beauty of his film Blue, the late artist, writer gay activist and gardener is revealed in his multifarious, contradictory talents

A film of nothing but a static blue, haunted by voices and a tale of a man going blind, and thinking of buying shoes he will never get a chance to wear – his own will see him through. Self-portraits of a young man, anxious but done with the lightness of Matisse, and another, sullen and glowering, seeing himself as Wyndham Lewis. While you look, Pet Shop Boys are singing It’s a Sin, staged for a decadent pop video over the wall, vying with the industrial electronic noise of Throbbing Gristle leaking from another room.

Creativity is not a fashionable word. But you can’t think about Derek Jarman, painter, sometime theatre designer, film-maker, gay activist, writer and gardener, without recognising his multifarious and sometimes contradictory talents. He was both the most public and outspoken of artists, a hedonist and city dweller, and an introspective observer of nature, of birdsong and sunsets.

Jarman’s enthusiasm and energy, his outspokenness and curiosity saw him through to the end. He died at 52 from an Aids-related illness, in 1994. After his diagnosis as HIV-positive in 1986 Jarman made the decision to be open about his illness which, at that time, was invariably fatal. He had and would continue to lose many friends to Aids, and there is a thread of commemoration running through his later work. Jarman counted the losses.

In life, Jarman achieved a secular sainthood, canonised by the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, a group of gay male nuns. Since his death, he has become more than an artist of his time. A quarter of a century on, a blue plaque now commemorates what was once his studio on the Thames, and the Art Fund has purchased his black-tarred cottage, with its canary yellow windows, perched on the shingle of the Dungeness headland, for the nation. Jarman’s seaside garden drifts into the no-man’s land of the surrounding landscape. It has no discernible boundaries. Neither did its maker.

Currently, there is a show of Jarman’s work in Paris, for the city’s Festival d’Automne, and a large overview exhibition has just opened at Manchester Art Gallery, travelling from the Irish Museum of Modern Art in Dublin. A season of Jarman’s feature films and shorts at Manchester’s Home opens at the end of January, and another, smaller exhibition is now at the John Hansard Gallery in Southampton.

Exhibitions that attempt an overview of Jarman’s life and work face the difficulty of his creativity. He did so much, in so many different ways, always going his own way. The variety of his approaches, and the shuttle between introspection and outrage, and the radical shifts in his tempo and method over the 40 or so years of his career don’t make life easy either for his curators or viewers. There’s too much to take in, so many different ways you have to look.

Derek Jarman: Protest! at Manchester Art Gallery dramatises these difficulties, which are in effect the difficulties of the artist himself. Curator Jon Savage has met Jarman’s complexity head-on in a theatrical installation in which paintings from the 1950s to the early 90s collide with photography and film, theatre design and pictures of the set he devised for Ken Russell’s movie The Devils. Here’s Margaret Thatcher’s Lunch, the place-setting stuck in black paint, the cutlery oozing red, and there’s the prize he won at the Alternative Miss World competition in 1979, a shapely leg covered in shards of broken mirror. Wall-sized blow-ups of Prospect Cottage and small driftwood and stone sculptures vie with songs by the Smiths.

This exhibition, like its lavish accompanying publication, and despite interesting essays, makes Jarman hard to read coherently. Coherence is probably overrated, and in any case, lives aren’t lived that way. Jarman was, I think, a reactive rather than programmatic artist, responding to the things and situations around him and the opportunities and challenges they presented – whether it was a sense of space in a painting or a landscape, an attractive personality, the larky, party atmosphere of his film sets or the flare of the gorse flowering near Dungeness’s nuclear power station.

Everywhere, there were miracles – human, botanical, literary, meteorological – and matters of geology, theology or poetry or sex. An atheist, Jarman had an almost gnostic sense of the spiritual. He could find it anywhere, especially perhaps in the profane, the transient, in the vitality of a dancing body or in the tenacity of plant life growing in the unlikely and hostile conditions of the shingle he tended.

Words, sometimes scrawled in thick paint, sometimes rendered in his distinctive, highly tuned calligraphy, were as important for Jarman as the mise-en-scène, the spectacle and the tableau. His writing is wonderful, and I keep returning to Modern Nature, his day-by-day journal of 1989 and 1990. It keeps me grounded. His later, small agglutinative paintings and assemblages have a similar brevity to his journal entries, with their daily reflections on weather, local incidents, politics, things found and seen and discovered on the foreshore. Always alert to the things around him, the world adheres to them, they rail against darkness.

His Super 8 shorts often capture the same fleeting world, of people and moments and light. They are all a kind of bricolage. With their broken glass and their morbid black surfaces, their confected agglomerations of spent bullets and seeds, unrolled condoms decaying under glass, a scatter of pills mired in paint, nasty, black tarry canvasses with medical bags and tubes, toy skeletons, rosary beads and crosses, and a grim, symmetrical arrangement of pharmaceutical bottles and packages called One Day’s Medications, these all become reliquaries of a life lived. Upping the scale, he also made two series of seething, bitter, large-scale abstractions, the paint spattered and smeared across their clotted, coagulated surfaces. They heave and drag, shout and repulse, without a moment of respite. Queer, they say. Blood. Infection. Disease. Weak and half-blind, Jarman was as much director as painter of these images, and couldn’t make them alone. They were deliberately confrontational.

Jarman the painter takes centre stage in Manchester, though he is constantly interrupted, not least by himself. His earlier paintings are filled with the ghosts of other painters, including Paul Nash, perhaps inevitably, and David Hockney. The mix is eclectic. The suave quasi-minimalism of his 70s landscape paintings are a kind of premonition of Dungeness, that great flat expanse poking into the English Channel. Jarman’s landscape paintings have a receding flatness and emptiness. You can imagine the lighthouse foghorn and the ominous klaxon from the power station filling these empty painted spaces with sound.

Related: Saintmaking: the canonisation of Derek Jarman by queer ‘nuns’ – video

For me, Jarman’s best works are his books, his garden and his last film, Blue, a work that, broaching the sublime, is simplicity itself, a screen on which nothing happens, but the static blueness. Your ears do all the visualising, and all the projecting is your own. The blue is filled with voices, memories and tart, wistful and mordant observations. Whatever the difficulties and inconsistencies, it is good to return to Jarman, an exemplary artist and man, and a model of the creative life.

    News Related

    OTHER NEWS

    39 feared missing as boat capsizes off Florida

    This handout image, provided by the US Coast Guard on January 25, 2022, shows a capsized vessel approximately 45 miles east of Fort Pierce inlet, Florida. – The US Coast ... Read more »

    Khaman seller from Surat gets PETA award for saving birds from kite string

    A khaman (snack) seller from Gujarat’s Surat has been given an award by PETA India for his initiative to dissuade people from using manja or nylon string thus saving the ... Read more »

    Teacher charged with animal cruelty over video of horse being punched and kicked

    A primary school teacher has been charged with animal cruelty after a video appeared to show her punching and kicking a horse. © Other The woman was filmed hitting and ... Read more »

    Mangsa banjir di Pahang diberi 3 bulan pengecualian bayaran bil air

    © Provided by Free Malaysia Today Wan Rosdy Wan Ismail berkata, pengecualian itu dibuat kerana kerajaan negeri memahami keadaan mangsa banjir terutama ketika dalam fasa pemulihan akibat bencana itu. (Gambar ... Read more »

    WHO weist auf geringeres Wachstum der Corona-Zahlen hin

    © Bereitgestellt von Keystone-SDA Die Weltgesundheitsorganisation (WHO) schätzt das Risiko durch die hochansteckende Omikron-Variante des Coronavirus nach wie als sehr hoch ein. In ihrem wöchentlichen Bericht erklärte die WHO am ... Read more »

    Harry und Meghan wollen das Showbiz aufmischen

    Prinz Harry und seine Ehefrau Meghan haben einen kostenspieligen Lebensstil. Nach ihrem Umzug in die USA muss der Royal sich nun einen Job suchen und scheint nach diversen TV-Interviews Gefallen ... Read more »

    Duterte ally wrests control of TV signals used by ABS-CBN

    A billionaire businessman and political fundraiser linked to Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte has wrested control of the broadcast frequencies used by the country’s largest television network ABS-CBN before the government ... Read more »

    Soccer-Rashford, Lingard condemn anti-Semitism after picture with UK rapper

    © Reuters/IAN WALTON Premier League – Brentford v Manchester United (Reuters) – Manchester United’s Marcus Rashford and Jesse Lingard have said they do not condone any form of discrimination after ... Read more »

    Sherrie Hewson teases Corrie comeback saying she is 'waiting for that phone call'

    Sherrie Hewson has hinted she could one day return to the cobbles of Coronation Street. The actress, 71, starred as the lovable Maureen Holdsworth on the long-running soap. However, she’s ... Read more »

    Asian stocks cautiously higher as investors await Fed policy update

    © Provided by Business Today Asian stocks cautiously higher as investors await Fed policy update Asian share markets got off to a cautious start on Wednesday, after another volatile Wall ... Read more »

    IPO-bound LIC posts Rs 1,437 crore net profit during April-September

    © Provided by Zee News Mumbai: IPO-bound Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) on Tuesday reported a profit after tax of Rs 1,437 crore for the first half of the ... Read more »

    Edinburgh's council elections 2022: residents urged to make sure they are registered to vote

    © The deadline for registering to vote is midnight on April 18. Let us know what you think and join the conversation at the bottom of this article. The elections ... Read more »

    Gary Lineker mocks Watford after confirming Roy Hodgson as new manager

    Gary Lineker has mocked Watford after they unveiled Roy Hodgson as their new manager for the rest of the season. Claudio Ranieri was given the boot over the weekend after ... Read more »

    6 shot dead in Milwaukee home, victims' families 'don't know why'

    Six people were found dead in one Milwaukee home Sunday, Jan. 23, and police are trying to figure out what led to the massacre. Family members of the homicide victims ... Read more »

    Tilawah Amal Maya: Covid-19 tidak halang anak istimewa/autisme buktikan keupayaan luar biasa

    Mendidik dan membesarkan anak istimewa dan autisme bukan satu perkara mudah kerana ia memerlukan pengorbanan masa dan tenaga. Namun begitu, melalui bimbingan dan perhatian yang tepat, anak istimewa dan autisme ... Read more »

    China restricts activists' social media ahead of Olympics

    Human rights activists and some academics in China have had their WeChat messaging app accounts restricted in recent weeks, multiple people affected have told AFP, as Beijing cracks down on ... Read more »

    Arsenal transfer gossip: New Dusan Vlahovic alternative and Aubameyang's exit plan

    It’s been a difficult few weeks for Arsenal and their manager Mikel Arteta. The Gunners’ hopes of winning a trophy this season are over after losing in the FA Cup ... Read more »

    Melania Trump's crypto-only hat auction has become collateral damage in the cryptocurrency crash

    © Alex Wong/Getty Images Former First Lady Melania Trump put the Hervé Pierre hat up for auction. However, the bitcoin bids on the hat are far less than expected, due ... Read more »

    Analysis: How the Omicron variant ignited new battles and changed pandemic politics

    The Omicron variant may be showing the first hopeful signs of passing its peak. But the angry politics of Covid-19 are only getting more intense, and given their future electoral ... Read more »

    In this Texas school district, parents step up to fill teacher shortage

    As Jan Stone stirred a large pot of grits with sausage for her six adopted children on Friday, she was juggling a little more than usual during the family’s predawn ... Read more »

    PM Modi Wears Cap from U'khand, Dons Flower Used During Kedarnath Pooja | Details on His R-Day Attire

    © Provided by News18 PM Modi Wears Cap from U’khand, Dons Flower Used During Kedarnath Pooja | Details on His R-Day Attire Prime Minister Narendra Modi continued the tradition of ... Read more »

    West Bengal Lottery Result 2022: Dear Bangabhumi Raidak Results For January 26 at 4 PM; Here's How You Can Check

    © Provided by News18 West Bengal Lottery Result 2022: Dear Bangabhumi Raidak Results For January 26 at 4 PM; Here’s How You Can Check West Bengal Lottery Result 2022: Today ... Read more »

    India reports 2,85,914 new Covid-19 cases, daily positivity rate at 16.16%

    © Provided by Zee News New Delhi: India logged 2,85,914 new coronavirus infections taking the total tally of COVID-19 cases to 4,00,85,116, according to the Union Health Ministry data updated ... Read more »

    Off-centre | The epic voyage that brought Subhas Chandra Bose onto centrestage of history

    © Provided by Firstpost Off-centre | The epic voyage that brought Subhas Chandra Bose onto centrestage of history As we celebrate our 73rd Republic Day, we would do well to remember ... Read more »

    Yemen's ragtag rebels became a threat to world economy, showed military power has its limits

    © Provided by The Print From the beginning of 1904, under Yemen’s gentle winter sun, the largest army ever seen on its soil slowly flowered. Five brigades—26,000 men in all, ... Read more »

    Ironic that Congress doesn't need his services: Kapil Sibal on Padma award to Ghulam Nabi Azad

    Ironic that Congress doesn’t need his services: Kapil Sibal on on Padma award to Ghulam Nabi Azad Senior leader and member of the group of 23 who wanted organisational reforms ... Read more »

    Andhra Pradesh approves creation of 13 new districts

    © Provided by The Statesman Andhra Pradesh approves creation of 13 new districts On the eve of Republic Day, the Andhra Pradesh government has issued a new official gazette notification ... Read more »

    "I Am A Woman Abuser"- Mbuso Mandela

    Never has a day gone by without Mzansi witnessing yet another incident or story of gender based violence. And when such a heinous act is committed by those we look ... Read more »

    Azpilicueta future still not decided, despite claims from Spain — report

    © Photo by Darren Walsh/Chelsea FC via Getty Images The rumor-mongers down in Spain — and there are more than I’d ever care to count, to be sure — spun ... Read more »

    IPL 2022: 'Warner's goodwill has taken a hit', says ex-India opener; 'Don't think Chennai will even think about him'

    © Provided by Hindustan Times File photo of David Warner. (AP) The mega auction for the 2022 Indian Premier League will take place on February 12-13 and over a thousand ... Read more »

    Mexico: Journalists protest killings of colleagues

    © Provided by DW So far in 2022 in Mexico three journalists have been murdered Mexican journalists began nationwide protests Tuesday following the killings of three journalists in the space ... Read more »

    All in a day: Things to do around the city on your Republic Day break

    © Provided by Mid-Day Listen Talking it out Mahatma Gandhi The Asiatic Society of Mumbai is hosting two talks centred on Republic Day. The first one is by Kurush Dalal, ... Read more »

    Republic Day 2022: Lata Mangeshkar's Aye Mere Watan Ke Logon to B Praak's Teri Mitti, songs to celebrate India

    © Provided by Pinkvilla The Republic Day Of India is celebrated every year on January 26 and it is the day on which, back in 1950, our Constitution came into ... Read more »

    China's Communist Party expels former boss of Hangzhou for graft

    SHANGHAI (Reuters) -China’s anti-corruption watchdog said on Wednesday it had expelled a former Communist Party secretary of the technology hub of Hangzhou from the party, five months after announcing he ... Read more »

    Dr Chandraprakash Dwivedi 'deeply humbled' on being honoured with Padma Shri Award

    © Provided by Pinkvilla On Republic Day 2022 eve, the government of India announced the list of winners of the prestigious Padma Awards. The list included several celebs from the ... Read more »

    Mandy Moore watches A Walk to Remember after a decade to celebrate the film's 20th anniversary

    © Provided by Pinkvilla Mandy Moore is celebrating the 20th anniversary of one of Hollywood’s most iconic romantic dramas, A Walk to Remember. The film showcased an emotional love story ... Read more »

    This one-way smoke on Mirage by NaVi is a game-changer

    Professional Counter-Strike: Global Offensive players are using this one-way smoke on Mirage, and it’s pretty easy to learn.  Mirage is one of the most balanced CSGO maps. While one side ... Read more »

    Here's what we know about CSGO majors in 2022

    Many Counter-Strike: Global Offensive tournaments for 2021 were scratched due to health concerns, but the new year looks bright. The prospects of a CSGO major are strong for 2022, though ... Read more »

    Samridh: Important for the world`s largest democracy to have a just constitution

    © Provided by Mid-Day As India celebrates its 73rd Republic Day today, Samridh Bawa who plays Jigar in Balika Vadhu 2 on Colors joins mid-day.com for a special conversation.  What ... Read more »

    Salman Khan gets mobbed outside Mumbai restaurant. His reaction is epic

    Salman Khan gets mobbed in Mumbai. Salman Khan has a huge fan following, which has been growing every day. Fans eagerly wait to see a glimpse of Bhaijaan. Salman was ... Read more »
    On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic