Democrats face growing storm over IRS reporting provision

Asia's Tech News Daily

Democrats are facing a firestorm of criticism over a proposal to increase the amount of bank account information reported to the IRS, posing a challenge as they craft their wide-ranging social spending bill.

© Greg Nash Internal Revenue Service headquarters in Washington, D.C.

The proposal is a top priority of the Biden administration, which argues it will help the IRS go after wealthy tax cheats.

But it has come under a barrage of attacks from banks and Republicans, who say it raises significant privacy concerns. Financial institutions have been mobilizing their customers to speak out against the proposal to lawmakers.

Congressional Democrats are expected to make changes to the administration’s initial proposal, but are generally supportive of the idea. The increasing attacks on the proposal has prompted lawmakers and administration officials to go on the defensive.

“Ultimately, the President’s proposal seeks to pare back tax evasion by shedding some light on opaque sources of income that accrue disproportionately to the top 1 percent of earners,” Natasha Sarin, deputy assistant secretary for economic policy at the Treasury Department, wrote Thursday in a post on the department’s website.

“As such, it is unsurprising that substantial resources are being deployed to defeat these efforts, because many tax cheats stand to lose from a fairer tax system,” Sarin added.

The Biden administration earlier this year released a proposal that would require banks and other financial institutions to report on existing annual IRS forms the total amount of money that came into an account during a year and the total amount of money that came out of it.

The president’s budget request proposed imposing the reporting requirement for accounts with flows of at least $600. Congressional Democrats have discussed raising that threshold to $10,000 and exempting payments from payroll processors.

The proposal could be a way to raise revenue that could be used to offset the cost of spending in Democrats’ social safety net package in areas such as child care, education and climate. Treasury estimated that the administration’s proposal would raise about $460 billion over 10 years, and has said that a narrower proposal could raise $200 billion to $250 billion over a decade.

The administration said the proposed reporting requirement would help the IRS better target audits and close the “tax gap” between the amount of taxes paid and amount owed, which Treasury has estimated to be about $7 trillion over the next decade.

“If somebody reports an income of $10,000 and they had $3 million go out of their checking account, that tells the IRS that’s an individual you might audit,” Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said in an interview with CBS News this week.

The administration said that it plans to focus enforcement efforts on high-income taxpayers, and that audit rates wouldn’t increase for taxpayers with actual income of under $400,000.

But banking groups and Republicans argue that the proposal would lead to the IRS receiving additional financial information about a large swath of taxpayers. They’ve expressed concerns about the IRS’s ability to keep the information secure, pointing to past instances where the agency was hacked and where there were unauthorized disclosures of tax information.

“The implications of this reporting and data collection scheme are serious and far-reaching,” said Sam Whitfield, senior vice president of congressional affairs at the Consumer Bankers Association.

Financial groups said that many non-wealthy Americans would still have their accounts subject to the proposed reporting requirement if the threshold was raised from $600 to $10,000. And they said it would be complicated for them to implement exemptions for wage payments.

“We think this is a flawed proposal at any threshold,” said Ryan Donovan, chief advocacy officer and executive vice president at the Credit Union National Association (CUNA).

Banks and credit unions have been alerting their customers to the IRS proposal and have been urging their members to contact their members of Congress. Donovan said his group is aware of more than 500,000 emails and other communications from credit union members to Capitol Hill.

“We’re going to keep it up,” he said.

Republican lawmakers, who have a long history of disliking the IRS, have also frequently been criticizing the IRS bank-reporting proposal in congressional hearings, speeches and op-eds.

GOP lawmakers on the tax-writing House Ways and Means Committee this week introduced a bill to bar Treasury from implementing a proposal along the lines of the administration’s plan.

“We should not allow the IRS to invade the privacy of Americans by snooping into their bank accounts,” Rep. Drew Ferguson (R-Ga.), lead sponsor of the bill, said in a statement. “The Biden Administration and Congressional Democrats have clearly demonstrated their intent to instate a broad financial surveillance regime using Americans’ private financial information.”

Congressional Democrats are still working on the details of any IRS bank-reporting provision for their spending bill. A provision on the topic was not included in the bill the Ways and Means Committee approved in September, with panel Chairman Richard Neal (D-Mass.) saying at the time that he was still discussing the issue with the administration.

Still, Democrats have been pushing back against criticisms of the proposal. Provisions to get taxpayers to pay the taxes they already owe could be appealing to Democrats if they face pushback within their caucus on proposals to raise taxes.

Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said during a press conference Tuesday that a version of the IRS proposal would be included in the spending package.

“Yes, there are concerns that some people have, but if people are breaking the law and not paying their taxes, one way to track them is through the banking measure,” she said.

Democratic lawmakers and administration officials have been emphasizing that the proposal would not direct banks to give the IRS details about specific transactions, after some Republicans have inaccurately suggested that the IRS would receive this type of information.

“I think this proposal has been seriously mischaracterized,” Yellen told CBS News.

Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) said in a statement that “the reason Republicans have latched on to this issue as the one to lie about every day is because they know their tax agenda is a political loser.”

Supporters of the proposal are optimistic that a version of it is included in a final social spending package that gets enacted into law.

Seth Hanlon, senior fellow at the left-leaning Center for American Progress, said “there is strong support and a strong understanding of how important it is” among key congressional Democrats.

Hanlon added that lawmakers and the administration “have more work to do countering the false claims” about the proposal.

But those who have been critical of the proposed bank-reporting requirement are predicting that a proposal resembling the administration’s plan will not be included in the spending bill.

Steve Rosenthal, a senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, whose former director now works in the Biden administration, said the proposal is too expansive and thinks bank lobbyists “have touched a raw nerve” with their customers who are concerned about privacy.

“I think at the end of the day, this bank proposal will fail,” he said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


It's raining jobs for freshers at banks

Mumbai: Banks and NBFCs are expected to add more than 70,000 freshers to their payrolls in the next three years as they expand their footprint and add feet on the ... Read more »

Despite pandemic, famed Italian theater opens season

MILAN (AP) — While many European theaters remain closed due to the pandemic, the famed Teatro alla Scala on Tuesday opened its new season with the gala premiere of Verdi’s ... Read more »

UAE moves its weekend to Saturday-Sunday

The United Arab Emirates is moving its weekend. People there will now get Saturday and Sunday off, instead of Friday and Saturday. The change will take effect from the start ... Read more »

Kes SRC International Najib Razak: Mahkamah Rayuan sampaikan keputusan dinanti-nanti hari ini

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Panel tiga hakim Mahkamah Rayuan, dipengerusikan Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil, telah menangguhkan keputusannya selepas mendengar hujahan daripada peguam sepanjang enam bulan lalu. (Gambar Bernama) ... Read more »

All multiplayer medals in Halo Infinite

© Provided by GamePur When you do something good in Halo infinite multiplayer, you will receive a medal on the side of your screen. This is the game’s way of ... Read more »

On brink of first Giants start, Jake Fromm won't let himself be the underdog

Jake Fromm spent his final 30 minutes of free time in a hotel lobby eagerly awaiting the start of his Giants career. Told to be ready by 5:15 a.m. last ... Read more »

Man City boss Pep Guardiola says Kyle Walker deserved to be sent off

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Pep Guardiola criticised Kyle Walker after the full-back was shown a potentially costly red card in Manchester City‘s Champions League defeat at RB ... Read more »

Passenger in 2019 pot plane crash gets time served, probation

Dec. 7—A man who walked away from a 2019 plane crash in east Medford will not serve any additional prison time for the illicit marijuana found after the crash. Zachary ... Read more »

PM in for grilling as leaked video heaps fresh pressure over No 10 party claims

Boris Johnson is expected to face questions over whether he has told the truth about an alleged lockdown-busting Christmas party in No 10 after leaked footage showed his aides joking ... Read more »

GSK: Antibody treatment has potential to work against omicron

GlaxoSmithKline on Tuesday said that its COVID-19 antibody treatment had positive results in lab tests that show it has the potential to be effective against the new omicron variant. GSK, ... Read more »

Hesperia teen shot to death in Rancho Cucamonga. Detectives looking for clues

Rancho Cucamonga Sheriff’s officials report the death of an 18-year-old Hesperia man whose body was found near a business center. Sheriff’s officials are investigating the shooting death of an 18-year-old ... Read more »

Mother of murdered sisters Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman: ‘We've been to hell and back again'

The mother of two murdered sisters whose dead bodies were photographed and shared by police officers said her family had been “to hell and back again”. Pc Deniz Jaffer and ... Read more »

‘A real big eff you' to Eric Adams: insider on De Blasio's 11th-hour vax mandate

Mayor Bill de Blasio’s sudden private sector COVID-19 vaccine mandate is a giant middle finger to Mayor-elect Eric Adams — who will have to figure out how, or if, to ... Read more »

Russian military capacity on Ukraine's border is on a 'more lethal scale' than 2014 Crimea invasion, US official says

Russian President Vladimir Putin has built military capacity on the border of Ukraine that is “much larger and on a much more lethal scale” than preceded Russia’s 2014 invasion of ... Read more »

The One James Bond Director Producers Want To Bring Back

Universal Pictures/YouTube Cary Joji Fukunaga’s work on “No Time To Die” has received rave reviews ever since the film was released in October 2021 (via Rotten Tomatoes). Throughout the course ... Read more »

Man arrested in Thanksgiving shooting

Dec. 7—TRINITY — A man who was wanted in connection with a shooting last month in Trinity was arrested this past weekend in Guilford County.. Derek William Stockwell, 42, of ... Read more »

Australia suffered great trauma during the Covid pandemic – and fixing mental health should be our first priority

Photograph: Tolga Akmen/AFP/Getty Images We’ve come a long way since the days when mental illness was treated like a shameful secret. But there is still a long way to go. ... Read more »

This Small Town in the Midwest Has Surprisingly Great Seafood

© Provided by Fodor’s Mike Valley could smoke seven days a week and never catch up with demand. The owner of Valley Fish & Cheese smokes catfish, walleye, bullheads, sturgeons, ... Read more »

James Cameron calls his Spider-Man ‘the greatest movie I never made' after failing to secure the film's rights

James Cameron has called his Spider-Man “the greatest movie I never made” after he failed to secure rights to the superhero franchise. As reported by Indiewire, the Avatar filmmaker opened ... Read more »

Covid PCR testing is a ‘rip-off jungle'

© Getty Images PCR tests for travel are a “rip-off jungle”, former Chairman of the Competition and Markets Authority, Lord Tyrie has told the BBC. The government website has recently ... Read more »

Strong earnings forecasts, miners lift FTSE 100 to 3-week highs

FILE PHOTO: Pedestrians leave and enter the London Stock Exchange in London By Bansari Mayur Kamdar (Reuters) -UK's FTSE 100 rose to a three-week highs on Tuesday, boosted by mining ... Read more »

TikTok gets into shopping

© Getty Images The social media platform TikTok is making a big push into shopping. The video sharing app is famous for its short lip sync videos, dance routines and ... Read more »

Woman suffers gunshot wound

Dec. 7—KERNERSVILLE — Police are investigating the circumstances of a woman being shot Saturday evening. Kernersville Police Department officers went about 7:20 p.m. to the Kernersville Medical Center, where a ... Read more »

Court to rule on ex-Malaysia PM's appeal against 1MDB conviction

© Provided by Al Jazeera A court in Kuala Lumpur will rule on Wednesday in former Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak’s appeal against his conviction for corruption [File: Lim Huey ... Read more »

Defense rests at Jussie Smollett's Chicago trial

Associated Press reporter Don Babwin has been in the courtroom throughout the Jussie Smollett trial where lawyers for the former “Empire” actor rested their case today. Smollett is charged with ... Read more »

Federal wildlife officials approve 'unprecedented' plan to feed Florida's starving manatees

Federal wildlife officials are taking “unprecedented” action to slow Florida’s record manatee die-off: They’re going to feed the threatened species in a limited trial to help them survive the winter ... Read more »

CA governor writes children's book about dyslexia

California Gov. Gavin Newsom has written a semi-autobiographical children’s book about dyslexia. The book is titled “Ben & Emma’s big Hit” and comes out on Tuesday. It tells the story ... Read more »

UK trade negotiators must not be ‘stretched too thin' to get benefits from deals

© PA Wire Boris Johnson meets Scott Morrison Government trade negotiators must not be “stretched too thin” to ensure the country gets the best out of post-Brexit agreements, it has ... Read more »

Brexit delays to cross-Channel trade still worsening as 79% of firms report hold-ups

Delays to cross-Channel trade are still worsening almost a year after Brexit checks came in, says a study also highlighting rising costs and key staff shunning the UK. © AP ... Read more »

'Don't Look Up' review: Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Lawrence headline a scathing climate-change satire that occasionally veers off course

In a grand science fiction tradition, “Don’t Look Up” uses a disaster-movie framework as a metaphor for a reality-based crisis, with a huge comet hurtling toward Earth as a surrogate ... Read more »

Jennifer Garner, 49, Wants to ‘Normalize Looking Normal'—Plus, Her Tips for Combatting Self-Criticism

Jennifer Garner says she keeps her daily beauty routine “low-key” on purpose. “I want to look normal and I want to normalize looking normal,” the 13 Going on 30 star ... Read more »

Video shows NYPD officers save driver from burning car

When seconds matter, NYPD officers are here for New Yorkers — at any cost. We’re fortunate that the driver of a vehicle engulfed in flames wasn’t seriously injured and grateful ... Read more »

Netflix movie review: Don't Look Up – Leonardo DiCaprio, Jennifer Lawrence try to save the world in star-studded tragicomic satire

Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Lawrence discover that a comet is coming for Earth – but the gravity of the situation is lost on a celebrity-obsessed world Adam McKay’s Netflix film ... Read more »

PM urged to stand firm in the face of calls for tougher Covid curbs

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Cabinet ministers last night urged Boris Johnson to hold his nerve and resist tighter Covid restrictions this Christmas. The Prime Minister yesterday warned ... Read more »

SDLP unveils plan to tackle rising energy costs

The SDLP has launched a plan the party says will address the rising energy costs hitting households across Northern Ireland. © PA Wire A view of an electricity pylon (Peter ... Read more »

Prince Andrew ‘orders legal team to cancel Christmas plans' to focus on sex assault court case

PRINCE Andrew has ordered his legal team to cancel their Christmas plans so they can focus on his sexual assault case, royal sources have claimed. The Duke of York has ... Read more »

One woman's six-year ordeal shows we must reform civil forfeiture laws

Malinda Harris’ case shows how easy it is for the government to seize innocent people’s property. Goldwater Institute After police in Berkshire County, Mass., took her car, Malinda Harris did ... Read more »

AIUDF MLA claims Aurangzeb donated lands for Kamakhya temple in Guwahati

A controversy has erupted in Assam after an AIUDF MLA claimed that Mughal emperor Aurangzeb had donated lands for the famed Shaktipeeth Maa Kamakhya temple in Guwahati. Aminul Islam, AIUDF ... Read more »

M3: ONIC Philippines top Group B, secure upper bracket berth

Mobile Legends: Bang Bang Pro League (MPL) Philippines Season 8 runners-up ONIC Philippines have secured an upper bracket berth in the M3 World Championship Playoffs after a 2-1 run in ... Read more »

Merryl Tisch intervened to save SUNY boss Malatras' job

Merryl Tisch, the head of SUNY’s board of trustees, reportedly stepped in to prevent SUNY Chancellor James Malatras from getting fired. Natan Dvir Critics demanding SUNY Chancellor James Malatras’ ouster ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic