Delving into presidential hopefuls' N. Korea policy: What's in the box?

Delving into presidential hopefuls’ N. Korea policy: What’s in the box?
Main opposition People Power Party presidential candidate Yoon Seok-youl (L) and ruling Democratic Party presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung (R). (Yonhap)North Korea policy is one of the main dividers between progressives and conservatives in South Korean politics, and the two leading presidential candidates — Lee Jae-myung and Yoon Seok-youl — are poles apart on how to secure stability and peace on the Korean Peninsula. They also disagree on the fundamental causes of the current strained inter-Korean relations.

But Yoon and Lee both dismiss the redeployment of tactical nuclear weapons as an impractical option and endorse the idea of providing humanitarian aid to the people of North Korea irrespective of the political situation. So what are their visions for North Korea policy? What are the differences and similarities? 

1. Denuclearization: How to achieve it 
Lee and Yoon both favor a “step-by-step” approach toward denuclearization based on reciprocal commitments. But the two diverge on their approach to reciprocity — on how and when to reward Pyongyang for any potential denuclearization steps.

Yoon: Substantial steps a precondition for sanctions relief
Yoon’s presidential campaign announced in November that it would “present a predictable step-by-step road map for denuclearization” and take the initiative in international cooperation to achieve that goal.

Yoon believes nuclear negotiations can proceed primarily within the trilateral framework of the two Koreas and the US, rather than a four or six-party format, which requires prior arrangements for meetings. To that end, Yoon proposes to establish a liaison office either in Panmunjom or Washington to run trilateral communication channels.

The essence of Yoon’s denuclearization approach is to ask for “verifiable” and “substantial” denuclearization measures first, and then reciprocate with economic support and other rewards, an official with Yoon’s campaign who wished to remain anonymous told the Korea Herald.

When asked if the camp takes a “denuclearization first, rewards later” approach, the official said Seoul could take reciprocal measures in the process of achieving complete, verifiable, irreversible denuclearization.

But “economic support can be provided if North Korea makes substantial progress in denuclearization, such as a verifiable freeze on nuclear programs,” the official added.

The official said Yoon’s strategy is to reward Pyongyang for substantial denuclearization measures, and that it cannot be defined as either a “big deal” or “small deal” approach.

On sanctions, Yoon’s stance is in line with the Biden administration’s approach.

“I think it is desirable to entice North Korea to voluntarily move toward denuclearization, making it realize that the possession of nuclear weapons is rather detrimental to its security and economy,” Yoon said in an interview with Monthly Chosun Magazine earlier this month, adding that the international community should “thoroughly implement sanctions” while pushing for nuclear negotiations.

Delving into presidential hopefuls’ N. Korea policy: What’s in the box?
Lee Jae-myung, the presidential candidate of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea,speaks during a meeting with foreign correspondents at the Press Center in Seoul on Nov. 25.(Yonhap)Lee: Small deal, simultaneous actions, sanctions relief 
Lee supports the pursuit of a small deal and an “action for action, simultaneous” approach to denuclearization, which is also favored by China, North Korea and Russia.

Lee’s campaign underscores that corresponding measures should be taken incrementally and in a synchronized manner in exchange for denuclearization steps from North Korea, as part of a process of building trust.

Notably, the Lee camp proposes easing the economic sanctions against North Korea with a “snapback” provision.

In a recent conference with the Seoul Foreign Correspondents’ Club, Lee said he would come up with a meticulous plan and lead efforts to narrow the gap on the sequencing of denuclearization measures and rewards.

Lee also said an appeasement policy is currently more effective than a hard-line, sanctions-oriented policy. He cast doubt on whether the hard-line policy of sanctions and pressure has been as effective as Western countries had hoped, and said the Kim Dae-jung government’s Sunshine Policy brought about stability on the peninsula.

Lee, however, dismisses the Trump administration’s all-or-nothing approach and its “grand bargain” scenario as unfeasible, while endorsing Trump’s top-down approach. Lee said he would seek to resolve nuclear issues by directly engaging in leader-level dialogue with US President Joe Biden and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un. 

2. Peace-building: How to achieve peace and stability
Lee and Yoon advocate different paths toward securing peace and stability on the peninsula. Lee proposes economic cooperation as the key to creating a virtuous cycle of peace and economic development, and he hopes to establish a “peace economy.”

Yoon, in contrast, prioritizes steps to strengthen the US’ extended nuclear deterrence, South Korea’s indigenous missile defense capabilities, and trilateral military cooperation among South Korea, the US and Japan.

Yoon: Reinforce nuclear deterrence, normalize inter-Korean relations
Yoon emphasizes that enhancing deterrence against North Korea’s nuclear and missile threats is the “starting point” of pushing Pyongyang toward denuclearization.

The kernel is to reinforce the US’ “extended deterrence” within the South Korea-US alliance. Yoon’s camp plans to establish procedures for Seoul and Washington to consult on the deployment of US nuclear weapons on the peninsula in case of contingencies and to enhance the credibility of the US nuclear umbrella by holding a regular military exercise.

In addition, Yoon proposes strengthening Seoul’s missile defense capabilities as a way to “neutralize” North Korea’s missile and nuclear threats, along with the expeditious deployment of a missile shield system similar to Israel’s Iron Dome and the development of indigenous tactical weapons. In this context, Yoon believes Seoul can decide whether to upgrade the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense system.

Yoon also underscores the significance of enhancing the trilateral cooperation among Seoul, Washington and Tokyo on intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance.

The emphasis on reinforcing deterrence options is part of Yoon’s efforts to normalize inter-Korean relations. He has described the relationship between Pyongyang and Seoul as one between a superior and a subordinate, with Seoul being the latter.

Delving into presidential hopefuls’ N. Korea policy: What’s in the box?
Yoon Seok-youl, the presidential candidate of the main opposition People Power Party, speaks during a meeting with foreign correspondents at the Press Center in Seoul on Nov. 12. (Yonhap)Lee: Pursue pragmatic inter-Korean relations, establish peace economy
In contrast, Lee’s election campaign highlights the importance of inter-Korean economic cooperation as a means to establish peace on the peninsula and develop a mutually beneficial relationship.

Lee’s camp says it will pursue “pragmatic coexistence between the two Koreas by establishing a peace economy system on the Korean Peninsula,” the legacy of the Moon Jae-in government’s peace process initiative.

The Lee camp pledges to create a “virtuous cycle of peace and economy,” which means peace would lead to economic development and economic cooperation would solidify peace.

Seoul and Pyongyang should build up “pragmatic relations” that bring about economic development and improve people’s lives, the Lee camp says, adding that “ideological and systemic competitions no longer have a practical benefit.”

Lee’s pragmatic approach to inter-Korean relations is also reflected in his views on unification. In a meeting with young people earlier this month, Lee said, “It is too late to pursue unification.” He prefers “de facto unification” status and a “pragmatic” approach to unification, he explained, rather than increasing hostility toward each other.

Lee last week emphasized that it is “more pressing and realistic” to seek ways for the two Koreas to prosper together through exchanges and cooperation rather than setting reunification as a short-term goal, in a separate news briefing after his meeting with foreign correspondents.

But the Yoon camp sees upfront denuclearization as a precondition to resuming inter-Korean economic cooperation, and would push for “inter-Korean joint economic development to prepare for the post-denuclearization era.”

3. Points in common: Opposition to redeployment of tactical nuclear weapons
Lee and Yoon both view the redeployment of tactical nuclear weapons on the peninsula as impractical, explaining that Pyongyang could use it as justification for possessing nuclear weapons.

Lee in late August also said it would “lead to strong opposition from neighboring countries and cause serious diplomatic friction.” Yoon has dismissed the redeployment of tactical nuclear weapons and NATO’s nuclear-sharing mechanism as breaches of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

The two camps also share the view that South Korea should provide humanitarian aid to the North Korean people irrespective of progress on denuclearization and the political situation, and that both sides should expand inter-Korean cultural and people-to-people exchanges. But the Yoon camp underlines the importance of providing aid that substantially helps the North Korean people and seeks to implement policy to open and reform Pyongyang in coordination with the international community.

Lee said he would take the initiative in providing humanitarian aid and implementing health and medical cooperation, and other cooperative projects that would lead to economic growth and development for the two Koreas.

By Ji Da-gyum (dagyumji@heraldcorp.com)

News Related

OTHER NEWS

MS-Blizzard deal prompts Korean game firms to seek more metaverse M&As

By Baek Byung-yeul Nexon, NCSOFT, Netmarble and other Korean game companies are expected to seek more mergers and acquisitions (M&As) in metaverse- and non-fungible token (NFT)-related businesses, sparked by Microsoft’s ... Read more »

Storytelling baristas appointed as Starbucks ambassadors

2022 Starbucks Korea ambassadors Yang Jung-eun, left, and Seo U-ram hold cups of coffee at a Starbucks coffee shop in Seoul, on Tuesday. Courtesy of Starbucks Korea By Kim Jae-heun ... Read more »

Korea remains No. 2 most popular content provider on Netflix in last quarter of 2021

A version of the Netflix series “Squid Game” is played on a mobile phone in this picture taken Sept. 30, 2021. Reuters-Yonhap Korea remained the No. 2 supplier of popular ... Read more »

More people place hopes on lottery tickets as pandemic drags on

By Lee Kyung-min Kim Sun-jin, 20, has been buying a lottery ticket each month, ever since she was let go from her part-time job at an eatery in Seoul in ... Read more »

Kyochon F&B hit for frequent discounts after price hikes

Kyochon F&B CEO and Chairman So Jin-se speaks during an online press conference held on Oct. 22, 2020. Courtesy of Kyochon F&B By Kim Jae-heun Kyochon F&B, Korea’s largest fried ... Read more »

S-Oil to collaborate with Saudi Aramco on low-carbon energy development

S-Oil CEO Hussain A. Al-Qahtani, left, and Saudi Aramco’s Vice President of Chemicals and Hydrogen Olivier Thorel pose after signing MOUs at “Saudi Arabia ― Korea Investment Forum for Smart ... Read more »

Yoon calls for more investment, exchanges between S. Korea, Russia

Yoon Suk-yeol (R), the presidential candidate of the main opposition People Power Party, poses for a photo with Russian Ambassador to South Korea Andrey Kulik during their meeting at the ... Read more »

A battle of lion, tiger and turtle? Art of face reading offers peculiar take on presidential race

Between various scandals, the leaking of private conversations and talks of possible unified candidacies, support for the three major candidates in Korea’s ongoing presidential race has fluctuated unpredictably throughout. But ... Read more »

Woori Financial marks sharp rise in market cap after successful privatization

Woori Financial Group, headquartered in central Seoul, is enjoying the sharpest rise among the country’s major banking groups this year in terms of market capitalization, after fully privatizing on Dec. ... Read more »

Kakao Bank CEO's huge stake sale extends debate on betrayal of shareholders' trust

Yoon Ho-young, fourth from left, then co-CEO of Kakao Bank, poses with other dignitaries during a ceremony to mark the company’s launch at the Floating Island Convention Center in southern ... Read more »

Lee Seo-jin takes stab at comedy with 'Dr. Park's Clinic'

Actors Ra Mi-ran, left, and Lee Seo-jin pose during the online press conference for Tving’s new comedy series, “Dr. Park’s Clinic,” Tuesday. Courtesy of Tving By Lee Gyu-lee Actor Lee ... Read more »

KENTECH criticized for 'ill-prepared' commendation award

The construction site of Korea Institute of Energy Technology (KENTECH) in Naju, South Jeolla Province. Yonhap KEPCO CEO Cheong Seung-il By Lee Kyung-min Criticism is mounting over the government’s plan ... Read more »

[Contribution] Korea's growth prospects optimistic, despite inflation, rising debt

Florencia T. Castro-Leal By Florencia T. Castro-Leal Korea’s handling of the pandemic and policy response have been one of the best in the world. The effective measures have both minimized ... Read more »

Samsung battling TSMC, Intel to be global leader in foundry business

By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics is facing growing competition with its rivals in the foundry business, as TSMC and Intel are expanding their investments in the rapidly growing, contracted semiconductor ... Read more »

SillaJen investors likely to take legal action

SillaJen shareholders call for the trading of the biotech company’s stocks to be resumed in front of the Korea Exchange’s building on Yeouido, Seoul, Tuesday. Yonhap Final decision for biotech ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution sets historically high bids in IPO subscription

Customers visit a sales office of Shinhan Investment in Seoul, Tuesday, to place bids for LG Energy Solution shares ahead of its initial public offering. Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung The ... Read more »

Labor issue potential risk to SK ecoplant's IPO

SK ecoplant CEO Park Kyoung-il presides over an extraordinary meeting of shareholders at the company headquarters building in Seoul in this December 2021 file photo. Courtesy of SK ecoplant By ... Read more »

FTC fines feared to prompt foreign regulators to sanction local shippers

A Hyundai Merchant Marine containership using eco-friendly bio heavy oil is seen in this file photo. Courtesy of HMM Taiwanese, Singaporean firms consider filing lawsuits By Park Jae-hyuk A decision ... Read more »

Defense minister stresses military's 'will, efforts' for OPCON transfer assessment

Defense Minister Suh Wook (C) attends a meeting with top commanders to discuss progress in South Korea’s efforts to retake wartime operational control from the United States at the defense ... Read more »

BTS-inspired webtoon '7FATES: CHAKHO' is making waves, but what is 'chakho'?

The BTS-inspired webtoon, “7FATES: CHAKHO” / Courtesy of Naver Webtoon By Dong Sun-hwa As many people had expected, the BTS-inspired webtoon, “7FATES: CHAKHO,” turned out to be an instant hit, ... Read more »

Omicron set to become dominant strain this week

People wait in line to get swabbed for the coronavirus at a testing center near Seoul City Hall, Wednesday. Newsis New infections soar to over 5,000 for first time in ... Read more »

Korean currency's value falls sharply against US dollars

gettyimagesbank South Korea’s currency has depreciated against the U.S. dollar more steeply than other currencies due to soaring prices of raw materials, the country’s heavy dependence on the Chinese economy ... Read more »

Monday's launches ‘tactical guided missiles' under production

The photo, released by North Korea`s official Korean Central News Agency on Jan. 18, 2022, shows what the North claims to be a tactical guided missile being launched the previous ... Read more »

Govt. to finalize extra budget plan this week

SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — The government will convene an extra Cabinet meeting this week to finalize a supplementary budget plan aimed at helping small businesses hit by the pandemic, ... Read more »

US envoy urges NK to cease ‘unlawful' activities, engage in dialogue

South Korean citizens watch a TV news report on North Korea`s launch of a ballistic missile at Seoul Station in central Seoul on Monday. (Yonhap)The US envoy for North Korea ... Read more »

Fed rate hikes not entirely dampers on stock market: AllianceBerstein

David Wong, senior investment strategist at AllianceBerstein, speaks during an online press conference held in Seoul, Tuesday. Courtesy of AllianceBerstein By Lee Min-hyung The U.S. Fed’s planned rate hikes will ... Read more »

Hyundai Engineering IPO raises concerns over value of Hyundai E&C

Hyundai E&C CEO Yoon Young-joon, left, and Hyundai Engineering CEO Kim Chang-hag / Courtesy of each company By Park Jae-hyuk Hyundai Engineering’s planned listing on the benchmark KOSPI market next ... Read more »

Lee pledges to create over 3m jobs through digital, energy transformation

Ruling party presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung (C) announces his job growth vision during a campaign event at the Democratic Party headquarters in Seoul on Tuesday. (Yonhap)Ruling party presidential candidate Lee ... Read more »

LG Chem advances into plastic waste recycling, eyeing replacing fossil fuels

LG Chem’s complex in South Chungcheong Province / Courtesy of LG Chem By Baek Byung-yeul LG Chem is venturing into the chemical recycling of plastic waste as part of its ... Read more »

Shaman in the house? Yoon Suk-yeol says no

Rep. Kwon Young-se, head of the presidential election campaign committee for main opposition People Power Party’s presidential nominee Yoon Suk-yeol, announces the decision to disband a networking subcommittee during a press conference ... Read more »

Gov't to offer up to 5 million won in medical fee assistance to students with post-vaccine symptoms

A health worker wearing protective gear prepares for visitors in the sub-zero temperatures at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, Jan. 14. AP-Yonhap The government plans to ... Read more »

Lee, Yoon to have first one-on-one TV debate next week

Democratic Party candidate Lee Jae-myung (left) and People Power Party presidential candidate Yoon Suk-youl (Yonhap)The presidential candidates of the ruling and main opposition parties will have their first one-on-one TV ... Read more »

Military reports 24 more COVID-19 cases

Ministry of National Defense (Yonhap)South Korea’s military on Tuesday reported 24 additional COVID-19 cases, including 23 breakthrough infections, raising the total caseload among its personnel to 3,657. Of the new ... Read more »

[Graphic News] South Korean artists' activities nearly halved in 2021

South Korean artists released an average 3.8 artistic works to the public in 2021, a sharp drop from 7.8 pieces in 2018, attributable to the COVID-19 pandemic, a government survey ... Read more »

Daily cases back above 4,000 amid Omicron woes

A medical worker wearing protective gear in a booth prepares to take samples in the sub-zero temperatures at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, Jan. 14. AP-Yonhap ... Read more »

Moon holds phone talks with Abu Dhabi crown prince, voices condolences over attack victims

President Moon Jae-in delivers a keynote speech during the opening ceremony of the Abu Dhabi Sustainability Week (ADSW) 2022 at an exhibition center in Dubai on Monday. ADSW is a ... Read more »

Korean banks remain conservative toward cryptocurrency industry

Seen above is a real-time trading price of bitcoin at an office of Bithumb in Seoul on Jan. 10. Yonhap By Lee Min-hyung Korean banks are taking a cautious attitude ... Read more »

N. Korea says it confirmed accuracy of tactical guided missiles in test-firing

This photo, released by North Korea’s official Korean Central News Agency on Tuesday, shows a tactical guided missile being launched the previous day. (KNCA-Yonhap)North Korea said Tuesday that it conducted ... Read more »

Seoul rebuts Japanese Dokdo claims

Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Yonhap)Seoul on Monday strongly protested against Japanese Foreign Minister Yoshimasa Hayashi’s remarks that renewed territorial claims over South Korea’s easternmost islets of Dokdo, demanding an immediate ... Read more »

Yoon-related stocks spike after clearing 'Kim phone call risk'

The main opposition People Power Party’s presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol is seen with his wife Kim Keon-hee on MBC’s program airing contents of phone calls between Kim and a YouTuber, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic