Debunked: No, you can't give someone medical power of attorney with a 'Notice of Standing and Fact'

VIDEOS AND DOCUMENTS shared on social media falsely claim that a patient can sign “medical power of attorney” over to someone else using a “Notice of Standing And Fact” form.

The letter is being shared on platforms including Facebook and Telegram by people who are sceptical about Covid-19.

Various claims are being made about the form, including that it gives anyone who signs it the right to discharge another person from hospital if that person also signs it.

At least two discharges or attempted discharges against medical advice have occurred at Irish hospitals in recent days.

Coronavirus sceptics are encouraging people to carry the document on their person in case they need it at short notice to sign their medical power of attorney over to someone else or to assume it from another person.

The claims are entirely false. Power of attorney over health matters cannot be created in this way.

In Irish law, two different types of power of attorney are allowed under the Powers of Attorney Act, 1996, but neither of them cover healthcare decisions.

The first allows the attorney to take actions on the person’s behalf in relation to property, business and financial affairs. 

This form of power of attorney is created when signed by the person in the presence of a witness. It is no longer valid if the person becomes mentally incapacitated.

The second, enduring power of attorney (EPA) only comes into effect if the person becomes mentally incapacitated. However, several conditions have to be met in order to create this.

Statements from the person creating the EPA and the person being given power of attorney are required along with statements from a doctor and a solicitor.

These statements have to verify that the person has the mental capacity to create the EPA, that they understand the effect of creating it and that they are not under undue influence.

The EPA also has to be created before the person becomes incapacitated. While EPAs do not cover healthcare decisions they can include “personal care decisions”.

The distinction between personal care decisions and healthcare decisions is not always clear. However, the form being shared on social media fails to meet several of the criteria required to create an EPA. 

‘Bizarre’

“You can’t make decisions on behalf of someone who has capacity,” explained Dr Adam McAuley, a law lecturer in Dublin City University’s School of Law and Government.

“If a person has capacity and they want to discharge themselves from hospital, even if it’s contrary to medical advice, they can do that themselves. Nobody else can do that on their behalf. If they don’t have capacity, nobody can make that decision. 

You can’t just rock up to a hospital with a piece of paper that says you’re there to discharge somebody. If the person has capacity then it’s that person’s decision.

Dr McAuley said that a doctor could simply ignore the document that’s circulating as it has no legal basis. A patient is entitled to leave hospital if they wish, even if it’s contrary to medical advice.

The person who signed the document being circulated is entitled to assist the patient in leaving the hospital (as they would be without the document) but they have no right or entitlement to intervene on their behalf.

The medical law expert also gave a withering assessment of the so-called ”Notice of Standing And Fact”. 

“I don’t know why anybody would draft a document like that. It’s bizarre, the way it’s written. If a first year law student drafted that I’d be very upset by it. It doesn’t make any sense,” Dr McAuley said.

Dr Eileen Culloty of DCU’s Institute for Future Media and Journalism said that conspiracy theorists have targeted hospitals throughout the coronavirus pandemic, fuelled by the “FilmNearHospitals” hashtag on social media.

At earlier stages of the public health crisis, this hashtag saw Covid deniers filming empty hospital wards and claiming it was evidence that the virus wasn’t real. In reality, this was simply because normal hospital operations had been cancelled.

More recently in the United States, people have visited hospitals to demand that patients be treated with the drug ivermectin, which is unproven as a treatment for Covid-19.

In Ireland and the UK people have tried to remove patients from hospital care, often against their doctor’s advice.

“‘Film near hospital’ activities were started by leaders in the anti-lockdown movement, but it’s really sustained by ordinary citizens who’ve fallen into these rabbit hole conspiracy theories,” Dr Culloty said.

Throughout Covid there has also been a tendency to share these legalistic documents in order to make claims about people’s legal rights or their position under the Constitution; the basis of it is often pretty dubious. 

Coat of Arms

An eye-catching element of the document being circulated by Covid sceptics is the grand looking coat of arms at the head of the page.

The symbol features a medieval looking knights’ helmet, a maple tree, a crest with four stars and a stag and a doe.

A trawl of heraldic histories has revealed that this antique-appearing symbol was actually created in the year 2000, when it was granted to Barbara Uteck by the Canadian Heraldic Authority.

Uteck, who once served as Secretary to the Governor General of Canada, featured the colours of the flag of Ukraine in the crest as a nod to her maternal family, while the deer were suggested by her husband to honour his Scottish roots.

The Journal contacted Ottawa Art Gallery, where Barbara Uteck now serves as Secretary, to try and determine if there was a particular reason the crest was chosen to head the document, or if it was simply selected because the creator of the form thought it was an appealing symbol.

This article will be updated if any light can be shed on the matter. 

The Journal’s FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network’s Code of Principles. You can read it here. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader’s Guide here. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks here.

Have you gotten a message on WhatsApp or Facebook or Twitter that you’re not sure about and want us to check it out? Message or mail us and we’ll look into debunking it. WhatsApp: 085 221 4696 or Email: answers@thejournal.ie

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Bears activate Damien Williams from COVID-19 reserve

© Provided by NBC Sports The Bears’ first-string running back is still out, but they’re their second-string running back will return on Sunday against the Buccaneers. Chicago announced that running ... Read more »

How did Sophie Reyes hold onto her career amid the pandemic, ABS-CBN shutdown?

Despite the circumstances, Kapamilya young star Sophie Reyes never doubted the power of ABS-CBN. She held onto the promise of the said Network. © Provided by LionhearTV She said in ... Read more »

Trump has 'still not forgiven' Kevin McCarthy for suggesting his censure after the January 6 riot, report says

© Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images President Donald Trump and House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) step off Air Force One at Joint Base Andrews, Md., after returning from Cape ... Read more »

‘Wrong on So Many Levels': Colorado Daycare Owner Sentenced for Hiding 26 Toddlers in Basement Behind ‘False Wall'

© Provided by Law & Crime Carla Marie Faith in court Carla Marie Faith in court. A judge in Colorado sentenced a former day care owner to six years in ... Read more »

Bill Walton Delivers Delightful Picks in 'College Gameday' Appearance

Walton delivered a picks segment for the ages during an appearance on ESPN’s flagship Saturday morning program. © Provided by Sports Illustrated Bill Walton’s time at ESPN as a college ... Read more »

Oregon beef producer faces $2.7M lawsuit after E. coli outbreak

An Oregon beef producer is facing a $2.7 million lawsuit after a supermarket chain alleged that it received meat contaminated with E. coli. © Getty Oregon beef producer faces $2.7M ... Read more »

Hardik Pandya doubtful for India vs Pakistan clash? All-rounder skips training ahead of T20 World Cup opener

© Provided by Zee News Team India all-rounder Hardik Pandya skipped an optional training session called on the eve of the high-voltage clash against Pakistan in the T20 World Cup ... Read more »

Sovereign Gold Bond scheme announced: Check subscription dates, issue price

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Reserve Bank of India is all set to put the seventh tranche of Sovereign Gold Bonds up for subscriptions starting from October ... Read more »

T20 World Cup 2021 Points Table, Highest Run Scorer, Highest Wicket Taker Update After Eng vs WI Match: England Top Group 'A' With Resounding Win

© Provided by News18 T20 World Cup 2021 Points Table, Highest Run Scorer, Highest Wicket Taker Update After Eng vs WI Match: England Top Group ‘A’ With Resounding Win T20 ... Read more »

Myntra CEO Amar Nagaram steps down

© Provided by Zee Business Amar Nagaram, the chief executive officer of Myntra, has put in his papers after three years of leading the fashion e-commerce platform, and will pursue ... Read more »

For Namibia, it's a chance to throw their chips on the table and let it ride

© AFP/Getty Images JJ Smit is pumped after hitting the winning runs in the game against Ireland © AFP/Getty Images Big picture If making their first appearance in a T20 ... Read more »

Palestinian NGOs designated ‘terrorists' call for support

© Provided by Al Jazeera The designated groups had been calling for a UN inquiry into human rights violations in the occupied Palestinian territories [File: Jamal Aruri/AFP] Palestinian human rights ... Read more »

Over 2,000 migrants march out of southern city in Mexico

TAPACHULA, Mexico (AP) — Over 2,000 migrants, mainly Central Americans, began walking out of a city in southern Mexico on Saturday where they have essentially been trapped. © Provided by ... Read more »

Buffalo's India Walton won the Democratic primary for mayor. Now she has to defeat incumbent Byron Brown -- again

On paper, India Walton is a shoo-in to become Buffalo’s next mayor. The Democratic nominee, who defeated incumbent Mayor Byron Brown in a June primary, is the only name on ... Read more »

Midwest weather: Severe storms in Kansas, Missouri and Iowa will move to Midwest, then Mid-Atlantic

A potent system in the central US is stirring up severe weather this weekend that will move eastward early next week, impacting more than 50 million people. © CNN Weather ... Read more »

Poacher likely killed by elephant in South Africa then ‘left behind by his accomplices': park officials

A poacher was likely killed by an elephant in northeastern South Africa earlier this week and his body was “left behind by his accomplices,” park officials said. In a statement ... Read more »

Probe into Border Patrol agents drags on over a month, despite Mayorkas claim it would take 'days'

An ongoing investigation into Border Patrol agents pictured on horseback turning away Haitian migrants – and who were the subject of false claims that they “whipped” migrants – is still ... Read more »

Model Cindy Crawford Loves This Sonic Facial Cleansing Brush & It's 40% Off on Amazon Right Now

© Courtesy of Adobe Stock. After decades of modeling and filming commercials, Cindy Crawford has mastered the art of the early call-time. The 55-year-old supermodel needs to get her face ... Read more »

Tory MP: BBC ‘should hire a Brexiteer as its next political editor'

A senior Conservative MP has said that if Laura Kuenssberg steps down as the BBC’s political editor, the corporation should consider replacing her with somebody “much more pro-Brexit”. © David ... Read more »

Fears over Squid Game-inspired video game kids are using parents' credit cards to play

Parents are being warned about a computer game based on the ultra-violent Netflix show Squid Game. Children are not only accessing the game – hosted on web platform Roblox – ... Read more »

When can Brits return to the USA? FCDO latest travel advice ahead of border reopening

In March 2020, then-President Donal Trump shut the US borders, locking out Britons who did not have a legal reason to enter the country. However, the nation is set to ... Read more »

Bihar Cong leaders hail break-up with RJD, others feel it's temporary

© Provided by Hindustan Times Congress in charge for Bihar Bhakta Charan Das (HT FIle) A day after Congress in-charge for Bihar Bhakta Charan Das formally announced the break up ... Read more »

Bihar Vidhan Sabha centenary year celebration: PM, V-P, LS Speaker likely to attend

© Provided by Hindustan Times The assembly building beautifully illuminated ahead of the CPA meet, in Patna. (HT Photo) The ongoing centenary celebrations of the Bihar Legislative Assembly building will ... Read more »

Kejriwal says Capital nearly winning the battle against dengue

© Provided by Hindustan Times Kejriwal urged residents to take part in the Delhi government’s “10 Hafte, 10 Baje, 10 Minute” campaign to combat vector borne diseases. (HT) New Delhi: ... Read more »

UP and Meghalaya Next, Says Mamata's Nephew Abhishek, Sets Tone for TMC's Expansion in 5 States

© Provided by News18 UP and Meghalaya Next, Says Mamata’s Nephew Abhishek, Sets Tone for TMC’s Expansion in 5 States The Trinamool Congress is aiming to spread its wings to ... Read more »

One held for creating fake parliament entry pass

© Provided by Hindustan Times A view of Parliament house in New Delhi. (HT PHOTO) The crime branch of Delhi police raided Gopalganj’s Purani Chowk locality on Saturday and arrested ... Read more »

Tension in Dhanarua after firing, probe ordered

© Provided by Hindustan Times Patna DM Chandrasekhar Singh has ordered magisterial inquiry into the incident and asked the Masaurhi SDO and SDPO to submit joint reports within 24 hours. ... Read more »

Indiana governor asks state Supreme Court to review law giving legislators greater emergency powers

Indiana Gov. Eric Holcomb (R) is asking the state’s Supreme Court to review a state law that gives lawmakers in the Hoosier State greater emergency powers. © Getty Images Indiana ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin's Rust stunt double accidentally fired two rounds before fatal shooting

© Copyright 2021 Santa Fe New Mexican Prop Firearm Movie Set – Copyright 2021 Santa Fe New Mexican A stunt double on the set of Rust reportedly fired two rounds ... Read more »

Saturday Deal Alert: Peak season fares to Puerto Rico

© Provided by The Points Guy MSN has partnered with The Points Guy for our coverage of credit card products. MSN and The Points Guy may receive a commission from ... Read more »

Watch: Leeds starlet Gelhardt does brilliantly to win injury-time pen

© PA Images Joe Gelhardt Leeds United Leeds United had to battle to draw 1-1 at home to Wolverhampton Wanderers, but academy starlet Joe Gelhardt used his short cameo to ... Read more »

Greek striker nets first Celtic goal in Premiership win over St Johnstone

© PA Georgios Giakoumakis celebrating his goal. GEORGIOS GIAKOUMAKIS’ FIRST Celtic goal in his first start helped the Hoops to a comfortable 2-0 Premiership win over St Johnstone at Parkhead. ... Read more »

The Best Cat Leashes On Amazon

© Amazon We independently pick all the products we recommend because we love them and think you will too. If you buy a product from a link on our site, ... Read more »

Soccer-Watford reacted well after Liverpool thrashing to stun Everton - Ranieri

© Reuters/MOLLY DARLINGTON Premier League – Everton v Watford LIVERPOOL, England (Reuters) – Watford manager Claudio Ranieri took heart in how his team bounced back from a 5-0 hammering by ... Read more »

New trade deals ‘are unfair on farmers and won't help emissions'

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Dorset Media Service/Alamy The chairman of the government’s climate change advisory board has condemned trade deals with Australia and New Zealand as “totally offensive” ... Read more »

Possession lost 18x: Sunderland dud with 25% dribble success had a 'mare vs Charlton - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Sunderland’s Aiden McGeady looks dejected Sunderland dropped down to fourth in the League One table after a disappointing 1-0 home defeat to Charlton on Saturday. ... Read more »

Man charged with murder of woman found dead in Kettering

© PA Marta Chmielecka death A man has been charged with the murder of a woman found dead in a house in Kettering. Pawel Chmielecki, 38, is accused of killing ... Read more »

‘Duke of Edinburgh would want Queen to prioritise health'

© Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Queen Elizabeth II Angela Levin told TalkRadio: “I think if Prince Philip was still around, he would exercise a bit of control and say: ‘Look, stop it, ... Read more »

The Skyfall Casting Rumor The Producers Say They Never Considered

© Provided by CinemaBlend Daniel Craig and Dame Judi Dench stand together in the countryside in Skyfall. The James Bond series has had its fair share of whispers hinting at ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic