Dear CEO's, you're getting ripped off by legal AI scams

Data Science, artificial intelligence, Follow @neural

What if I told you I was selling a set of computer programs that could automagically solve all of your hiring, diversity, and management problems overnight? You’d be stupid not to at least listen to the rest of the offer, right?

Of course no such system exists. The vast majority of AI products purported to predict social outcomes are blatant scams. The fact that most of them are legal doesn’t stop them from being snake oil.

Typically, the following AI systems fall under the “legal snake oil” category:

  • AI that predicts recidivism
  • AI that predicts job success
  • Predictive policing
  • AI that predicts whether an individual will become a criminal or terrorist
  • AI that predicts outcomes for children

The reason for this is simple: AI cannot do anything a human (given enough time and resources) could not themselves do. Artificial intelligence is not psychic and it cannot predict social outcomes.

As associate professor of computer science at Princeton University Arvind Narayanan said in on snake oil AI:

These problems are hard because we can’t predict the future. That should be common sense. But we seem to have decided to suspend common sense when AI is involved.

Think about it, have you ever heard of a big business that’s never made a single hiring mistake? 

These systems work on the same principle as the magic beans from Jack and the Beanstalk. You have to install the systems, pay for them, and then use them for an extended period of time before you can evaluate their effectiveness.

That means you’re being sold on statistics up front. And, when it comes to , you may as well be measuring how much mana it takes to cast a fireball spell or counting how many angels can dance on the head of a pin: there’s no science to be done.

Take HireVue, one of the most popular AI-hiring system vendors in the world. Its platform can everything from “leadership potential” to “personality” and “work style” from a combination of video interviews and games.

That sounds pretty fancy, and HireVue’s all seem quite impressive. But the bottom line is that AI can’t do any of those things.

The AI doesn’t measure candidate quality, it measures a candidate’s adherence to an arbitrary set of rules decided on by the platform’s developers.

Here’s a snippet from by the Financial Times’ Sarah O’Connor that explains how silly the video interview process really is:

While it’s hard to communicate naturally in such an unnatural situation, the platforms simultaneously urge jobseekers to “be authentic” to have the best chance of success. “Get excited and share your energy with the camera, letting your personality shine,” HireVue advises.

Unless you’re being hired to be a TV news anchorperson, this is ridiculous.

Energy” and “personality” are subjective ideas that can’t possibly be measured, as is “authenticity” when it comes to humans.

HireVue’s systems, like all AI purported to predict social outcomes, are nothing more than arbitrary discriminators. 

If the only “good” candidates are those who smile, maintain eye contact, and exhibit the right “authenticity” and “energy,” then candidates with muscular, neurological, or nervous system disorders who can’t do those things are instantly excluded. Candidates who don’t present as neurotypical on camera are excluded. And candidates who are culturally diverse from the creators of the software are excluded. 

So why do CEOs and HR leaders still insist on using AI-powered hiring solutions? There are two simple reasons:

  1. They’re gullible enough to believe the vendor’s claims
  2. They recognize the value in being able to blame the algorithm

Here are some other scientific and (well-sourced) journalistic resources explaining why AI purported to predict social outcomes is almost always a scam:

  • (University of Sussex)
  • (ProPublica)
  • (Princeton University)
  • (Toward Data Science)
  • (UC Berkeley)
  • (Wired)
  • (MIT Technology Review)
  • (Princeton University)
  • AI can’t tell if you’re lying – anyone who says otherwise is selling something (Neural)
  • (Harvard Business Review)
  • (Georgetown Public Policy Review)
  • Predictive policing is a scam that perpetuates systemic bias (Neural)

News Related

OTHER NEWS

37 cute and fun Valentine's Day gifts kids will love

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Valentine’s Day isn’t just for romantic love! It’s also the best ... Read more »

Get a pair of Madewell jeans for less than $24 during this blowout sale

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re looking to overhaul your winter wardrobe, now is the ... Read more »

Save up to 65% off Cuisinart, Samsonite and Pyrex at Macy's massive home sale

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Are you looking for a new luggage set for the upcoming ... Read more »

Google stops serving ads on Fox News host Dan Bongino's website

Following YouTube's ban of Dan Bongino over its Covid-19 misinformation policy, Google stopped serving ads on Bongino's website. Read more »

What Is Level 2 Healthcare Software, and How Can We Use It for Maximum Advantage?

In healthcare, many patients are moving through a variety of clinical workflows. Their information is being created or collected every hour of every day, and many professionals need to consider ... Read more »

Best Biotech Stocks to Invest in Now

Biotechnology firms have attracted billions in capital due to the belief that biotech can transform health care. More flexible than traditional big pharma, biotech drives past basic and applied science ... Read more »

Huge subscription fraud campaign hits over 100 million Android users

A widespread Android subscription fraud campaign has been discovered actively stealing from users money. Uncovered by cybersecurity researchers from Zimperium zLabs, the “Dark Herring” campaign consists of some 470 apps, ... Read more »

Can you avoid COVID-19 if a household member has it? Here's how to decrease your risk

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Many of us have received that dreaded phone call or text ... Read more »

PGA Tour golf on ESPN Plus: what can I watch and how much does it cost?

Armchair golf fans in the US have never had it so good, with more live action available from the fairways online than ever before thanks to the all-new PGA Tour ... Read more »

Love Wordle? A new archive website has every daily puzzle you missed

If you’re new to Wordle or just can’t get enough, your experience doesn’t have to stop at one puzzle a day. A Duke University student has created a website archiving ... Read more »

Steam Lunar Sale has Back 4 Blood, Sekiro and Valheim at cheapest ever prices

Steam’s New Year Lunar Sale has kicked off ahead of the start of the Year of the Tiger, and it runs from now until February 3. That means you have ... Read more »

Montana weighs wolf hunt limits; 23 from Yellowstone killed

The Associated PressThis Jan. 24, 2018, photo released by the National Park Service shows a wolf from the Wapiti Lake pack silhouetted by a nearby hot spring in Yellowstone National ... Read more »

Sadiq Khan poll blow: London Mayor's approval rating firmly negative for first time

(PA Wire) Sadiq Khan’s approval ratings have fallen firmly into negative territory for the first time since he became mayor in 2016, a new poll has revealed. A survey by ... Read more »

NordLayer review

NordLayer (the service formerly known as NordVPN Teams) is a capable VPN-based network access security solution for all levels of business, from startups with small teams to big corporations with ... Read more »

Blizzard warnings issued for millions as East Coast braces for ‘bomb cyclone'

Millions of Americans are in the path of a powerful winter storm that could bring dangerous heavy snow, ice and winds with hurricane-like force threatening to flood coastal areas, knock ... Read more »

1000-Lb. Sisters' Tammy Slaton Drinks 8 Bottles of Liquor a Week, 'Putting Herself in Grave Danger'

Between Tammy Slaton's eating habits, lack of exercise and her worrisome new interest in drinking excessively, her doctor is concerned she's “putting herself in grave danger.” On the season finale ... Read more »

200k call for release of teens arrested for ‘beating and killing' stepfather who ‘inappropriately touched' their 9-year-old sister

Alejandro Trevino, Christian Trevino and Juan Melendez (Hidalgo County Jail) More than 200,000 people have signed a petition calling for the release two Texas brothers and their friend, after they ... Read more »

Revealed: Nearly two-thirds of bar staff aren't fully vaccinated

Nearly two-thirds of bar and waiting staff haven’t had three COVID vaccine doses. (Getty Images) Nearly two-thirds of bar staff and waiters in England are not fully vaccinated against COVID, ... Read more »

How Queen Elizabeth's Uncle Helped Her Father Have an Affair with a Married Woman

FREDA DUDLEY WARD, Edward VIII, George VI Pictorial Press Ltd / Alamy Stock Photo Prince Albert, Freda Dudley Ward and Edward, Prince of Wales around 1925 A 103-year-old letter that's ... Read more »

Woman, 20, charged after tractor gets stuck at rail bridge

Emergency services on the scene at the collision with a rail bridge in Inverkeithing. Pic: Fife Jammer Locations. A WOMAN has been charged after an incident in Inverkeithing this morning ... Read more »

European consumer watchdog forces Microsoft to fairly charge Xbox gamers

London, An investigation by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) in Europe has forced Microsoft to provide more transparent, upfront information to help customers understand their Xbox gaming console membership ... Read more »

IIT Jodhpur team develops Covid diagnosis technique using chest X-Ray

Jodhpur, Researchers at the Indian Institutes of Technology Jodhpur (IIT-J) have developed an Artificial Intelligence (AI) based chest X-Ray technique for Covid-19A screening.The team proposed a deep learning-based algorithm called ... Read more »

Data Bill waivers sought by govt worry Indian IT firms

New Delhi: The information technology sector will petition the government over concerns that the broad exemptions sought by lawmakers in the proposed Data Protection Bill will adversely impact the fortunes ... Read more »

Meta partners FICCI to support 5 lakh women-led SMBs in India

Social media giant Meta on Friday said it has, under its #SheMeansBusiness programme, partnered with industry body FICCI to support five lakh women-led small businesses across India. The announcement was ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22+ and Galaxy S22 Ultra will reportedly come with 45W fast charging support

Samsung is expected to announce the next-generation Galaxy S series flagship smartphones on February 9. Ahead of the official launch, the rumour mill has been abuzz with the leaks and ... Read more »

Elden Ring director says It Takes Two was the last game to stick with him

Elden Ring director Hidetaka Miyazaki has said the last game to leave an impression on him was co-operative platformer It Takes Two. Speaking about Elden Ring on the official PlayStation ... Read more »

Sea of Thieves is becoming more story-driven in 2022 - and I can't wait

I’ve always found there are two types of Sea of Thieves players: the ones who take it seriously and the ones who simply want to drink grog and aimlessly sail ... Read more »

The Microsoft Teams empire is about to expand even further

Microsoft has launched a new initiative designed to attract even more customers to its collaboration platform, Teams. As described in a Microsoft blog post, the company is kickstarting a device ... Read more »

FAA clears Verizon and AT&T to turn on more 5G cell towers

Federal safety regulators say they have cleared the way for Verizon and AT&T to power up more towers for new 5G service without causing radio interference with airplanes. The Federal ... Read more »

8 of the best Kate Spade bags you can buy right now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. You know a Kate Spade bag when you see one: equal ... Read more »

This Brooklyn Bedding mattress sale is too good to miss—save 20% now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’ve been thinking about updating your sleep setup, today’s the ... Read more »

6 types of Windows malware to watch out for - and how to remove them

Windows is the most prevalent desktop operating system in the world, and therefore PCs running Microsoft’s OS are most often targeted by cybercriminals and their various strains of malware. While ... Read more »

Epic Super Bowl TV deal: Samsung's 75-inch QLED TV drops to record-low price

Super Bowl TV deals have landed at Samsung, and we’ve just spotted a massive discount on this stunning QLED TV. For a limited time, you can get Samsung’s 75-inch Neo ... Read more »

Burkina Faso vs Tunisia live stream: watch AFCON online from anywhere

Tunisia have a chance of moving one step closer to glory with this intriguing AFCON quarter-final clash with Burkina Faso. Having pulled off the major giant-killing shock of knocking out ... Read more »

TikTok and Instagram pull ads by mental health company that linked ADHD to obesity

Meta and TikTok removed advertisements from a mental health care startup after the ads promoted harmful and misleading health information, NBC News reported. Cerebral, a mental health company that hired ... Read more »

UCI Cyclo-cross World Championships 2022 free live stream: how to watch cycling online from anywhere

The 2022 UCI Cyclo-cross World Championships sees the competition take place outside Europe for only the second time in the event’s 72-year history. Prepare for some mud-spattered action as the ... Read more »

7 new movies and TV shows on Netflix, Prime Video, HBO Max and more this weekend

It’s been a busy old month for television. In the last few weeks alone, we’ve seen the likes of Peacemaker, The Book of Boba Fett, Euphoria season 2 and Ozark ... Read more »

Nokia breaks Standalone 5G record using 'world first' technique

Nokia, China Mobile (CMCC) and MediaTek have achieved a record 5G Standalone (5G SA) speed of 3Gbps thanks to the world’s first test of three component carrier aggregation technology. Nearly ... Read more »

Bye-bye Spotify? How to delete your Spotify account, and where to go next to stream music

Are you ready to keep on rockin’ in the free world without Spotify? On Wednesday, Spotify agreed to pull rock icon Neil Young’s music from the streaming service after he ... Read more »

Chilling CCTV captures rapist carrying victim along street before attack

Watch: Rapist caught on camera carrying victim through streets before attack This chilling CCTV footage captures the moment a rapist carries his victim through a city centre in the early ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic