De Blasio has still set up NYC kids for needless school closures

 									Coronavirus								,  									schools

New York Mayor Bill de Blasio does not feel the urgency of keeping kids in school. AP Photo/Richard Drew

Imagine a small grease fire flares up on your stove. Do you grab the fire extinguisher from under the sink — or call the fire department and have firefighters bombard the place with water, causing hundreds of thousands of dollars in damage? Seems like a no-brainer. And yet when it comes to COVID in our city schools, Mayor Bill de Blasio chose the second option.

As we begin a third pandemic-impacted year, here is what we know. International and local data showed that schools could be reopened safely even before vaccines were available. School staff have been eligible for the vaccine since January and are required to have their first shot in almost all cases by Sept. 27.

Most important, we know that school closures were profoundly detrimental to kids, particularly the most vulnerable. Childhood obesity and diabetes increased during the pandemic, and the learning of already-marginalized students suffered greatly. Students attending predominantly black and Hispanic schools were six months behind where they would normally be in math; students attending schools where the average household income was less than $25,000 annually were seven months behind.

At the public charter school I cofounded, you can see every day what it means for students to be back in person. You can see it as they chat with their friends or playfully tease their teachers. There is a newfound appreciation for what it means to interact face-to-face — or at least mask-to-mask.

Fortunately, New York City belatedly took steps Monday to align its quarantine policy with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidance, backing off its initial position, which was to shut down entire classrooms in the event of one positive case. Under the old mandate, all unvaccinated students — which, obviously, includes all elementary schoolers — would have to quarantine for 10 days in the event of a positive case. Now, those students can remain in school as long as the masking, distance and ventilation required by Gotham authorities are in place.

 									Coronavirus								,  									schools

A girl arrives for the first day of class at Brooklyn’s PS 245 elementary school, Monday, Sept. 13, 2021.

AP Photo/Mark Lennihan

This is progress but insufficient.

Many Big Apple schools are too crowded to maintain meaningful social distancing. And healthy kids can still be forced, unnecessarily, into remote learning.

In the most galling example, PS 79 in East Harlem was closed for 10 days because 19 staff members tested positive for COVID. It is unclear how many of those staff were vaccinated, though it would be a helluva coincidence if they were all breakthrough cases. But what’s clear is that 250 young people in a school that serves “students with autism, intellectual disabilities or multiple challenges” will now be denied needed in-person learning for a fortnight.

In crowded schools or in cases like PS 79, lots of healthy young children will be stuck at home, isolated from friends, teachers and normalcy. Their parents will either have to arrange childcare or stay home from work. The burden will fall disproportionately on women and on lower-income parents who don’t have flexible working conditions. Maybe it’s just me, but this seems like the sort of thing a mayor who professes to be “equity”-focused would want to avoid.

 									Coronavirus								,  									schools

Students wear face masks for the third week of classes at Roosevelt Elementary School in Hawthorne, NJ on September 15, 2021.

Christopher Sadowski

A better alternative exists. In Massachusetts and Utah, localities are adopting a policy called test-to-stay. Dr. Michael Mina of the Harvard School of Public Health explained this process thusly: “Instead of having everyone quarantine, you use a simple, at-home, rapid test before school, and you do that each day they would otherwise be quarantining.” Those who test positive stay home; negatives can come to class; spread is contained; healthy kids keep learning.

Yet while districts have been exploring test-to-stay possibilities for months, de Blasio seemed to indicate during his weekly interview with Brian Lehrer on Sept. 17 that he was hearing of it for the first time. It’s pretty remarkable that the man with control over the nation’s largest school system has just heard of this proposal, but maybe he was too busy planning out his quixotic gubernatorial bid and crushing dirt bikes. Priorities, people.

De Blasio may not feel the urgency of keeping kids in school, but parents and other education leaders do. There is no reason to keep healthy kids at home. They have been out of school for far too long. Let’s implement test-to-stay and get them back in, pronto.

Arthur Samuels is the cofounder and co-executive director of MESA Charter High School in Brooklyn.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


People 'should use their own judgment on wearing masks', says health minister

Boris Johnson wears a face mask during the Battle of Britain 81st Anniversary Service of Thanksgiving and Rededication at Westminster Abbey last month. (Getty) With COVID cases in the UK ... Read more »

Plan B: What are the Covid measures NHS chiefs want imposed this winter?

NHS chiefs have called on the government to take urgent action to halt the spread of coronavirus in order to avoid a winter crisis. The NHS Confederation, a membership body ... Read more »

Children sick with COVID and other bugs flooded hospitals in the fall. Doctors worry what winter will bring.

Nurse Kristen Brown cares for 6-year-old Jaxon Philiph, of Cedar Rapids. Jaxon was in the PICU after contracting COVID-19. IOWA CITY, Iowa – It feels like winter came five months ... Read more »

Gujarat vaccinates 90% of eligible population with first dose of COVID-19 vaccine

Gujarat has vaccinated 90 per cent of its eligible population with the first dose of COVID-19 vaccine, while 47 per cent beneficiaries are completely vaccinated against the deadly disease, state ... Read more »

Covid news – live: Ministers accused of negligence over ‘plan B' as Javid warns winter restrictions may return

Doctors have accused the government of “wilful negligence” for refusing to implement immediately its coronavirus “plan B” for winter. The British Medical Association warned Covid-19 deaths were as high as ... Read more »

Airports set to increase revenue after Tata Group takes over Air India

Air India | Representative image The aviation industry is abuzz with what Air India’s privatisation means for the sector. For starters, industry experts said that with the Tatas getting Air India, ... Read more »

Covid: What could a ‘Plan C' involve?

© Getty Images The government is facing calls for its ‘Plan B’ to be implemented – Getty Images Ministers are reportedly considering additional Covid measures that could amount to a ... Read more »

COVID effect: When the weakest quarter becomes the strongest for airlines

Representational image. Traditionally, Indian aviation has been divided into two ‘good’ and two ‘not good’ quarters. More often than not, this is also reflected in airline results. The April-May-June quarter ... Read more »

India crosses 100-crore-vaccination mark | The Everest is yet to be conquered

Despite the hostile terrain, the northern state of Himachal Pradesh, where Malana is located, earlier this month became the first in India to administer at least one COVID-19 vaccine dose ... Read more »

Zahl der Menschen mit einfachem Impfschutz in Deutschland steigt auf rund 57,4 Millionen

Düsseldorf. Die Impfungen gegen das Coronavirus laufen. Bislang wurden in Deutschland rund 110 Millionen Dosen verimpft, im Vergleich zur letzten Meldung stieg die Zahl um 191.737 weitere Impfungen. Hier finden ... Read more »

Housing prices across cities largely stable in third quarter, may inch up as demand outgrows supply

An accelerating COVID-19 vaccination drive, robust hiring in the financial services, information technology (IT) and IT-enabled services (ITes) sectors, coupled with record-low home loan interest rates, helped housing sales double ... Read more »

India now as a 'protective' shield' of 100 crore vaccine doses: PM Modi

India now has a strong “protective shield” of 100 crore vaccine doses to combat Covid-19, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Thursday, as the country passed this important milestone in ... Read more »

Zahl der vollständig Geimpften in Deutschland steigt um 77.278 auf 66 Prozent

Düsseldorf. Die Impfungen gegen das Coronavirus laufen. Bislang wurden in Deutschland rund 110 Millionen Dosen verimpft, im Vergleich zur letzten Meldung stieg die Zahl um 191.737 weitere Impfungen. Hier finden ... Read more »

100 heritage monuments to be lit in colours of Indian flag to mark 100 crore COVID vaccination feat

The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) will light up 100 of its heritage monuments in colours of the national flag to mark 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses being administered in ... Read more »

Ministers ‘wilfully negligent' by not reimposing Covid restrictions, says doctors union

© REUTERS London Underground passengers, some wearing masks, travel amidst the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in London Doctors have accused ministers of being “wilfully negligent” after the ... Read more »

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker: India achieves 100-crore-vaccinations milestone on October 21

Representative image. India has achieved the milestone of 100 crore (one billion) vaccinations on October 21. India accounts for about 15 percent of the total vaccine doses administered worldwide as ... Read more »

India crosses record one billion jabs

India has crossed the milestone of administering one billion Covid-19 vaccines, nine months after the second most populous country in the world initiated this mammoth movement. On social media platforms, ... Read more »

India has hit the 100-crore vaccination mark

FIle image: AP Read more »

'Wilfully negligent': Govt attacked for refusing to move to Plan B, as doctors warn action needed now

The government is being “wilfully negligent” by refusing to enforce its Plan B strategy for tackling rising COVID infections, doctors have claimed. © Reuters During a Downing Street news conference ... Read more »

India all set to cross the milestone of 1 billion jabs today

India is set to cross the milestone of administering one billion Covid-19 vaccine doses today, just over nine months after the government initiated the mammoth immunisation drive in the second ... Read more »

Making kids wear masks in school is torture, not safety

There is no need to continue to make children wear masks in schools. Matthew McDermott How long will we continue to torture kids? And let’s be clear: Forcing them to ... Read more »

Biden's endless list of broken promises and other commentary

On Sept. 9, President Joe Biden announced a vaccine-or-testing mandate. NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP via Getty Images Conservative: Biden’s Broken Promises On Sept. 9, President Biden announced a vaccine-or-testing mandate but his ... Read more »

Colorado school district investigates after parents say teachers taped masks to students' faces

A Colorado school district is investigating allegations that teachers taped masks to students’ faces at one of its schools. The school district in Colorado Springs opened its investigation after a ... Read more »

Backstreet Boys fará show em São Paulo em janeiro de 2023

Quer se manter informado, ter acesso a mais de 60 colunistas e reportagens exclusivas?Assine o Estadão aqui! Após a paralisação dos eventos há mais de um ano e meio por ... Read more »

Why Team Biden is purposely scaring folks about kids and COVID

Dr. Anthony Fauci has said he favors COVID-19 vaccination mandates in schools. Jim Lo Scalzo/Pool Photo via AP, File The papers and newscasts on Wednesday morning were filled with stories ... Read more »

Parents in Michigan sue to stop AG Garland going after them over protests

Attorney General Merrick Garland issued a memo saying the FBI would get involved in reports of violent acts against school personnel. REUTERS/Ken Cedeno/File Photo A group of parents from a ... Read more »

New York's Orthodox neighborhoods lagging in COVID shots, records show

Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods have seen low COVID-19 vaccination rates. Gregory P. Mango The Big Apple’s major ultra-Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods are now among the biggest laggards in the city’s coronavirus vaccination ... Read more »

Duchess Meghan passionately argues for paid parental leave in open letter to U.S. Congress

Duchess Meghan has written an open letter to members of the United States Congress to voice her support for a comprehensive paid leave program for new parents. The Duchess of ... Read more »

Letters to the Editor — Oct. 21, 2021

Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg has come under fire for taking paternity leave as the nation’s supply-chain woes worsened. Getty Images The Issue: Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg taking three months of ... Read more »

Front-line health care worker shortage due to COVID-19 vaccine mandates, burnout

Hospitals have seen shortages in health care workers due to disputes over COVID-19 vaccine mandates and burnout. AP Photo/Jae C. Hong Hospital staffing shortages due to COVID-19 vaccination disputes have ... Read more »

School safety agents seize 3 guns from students at NYC schools

A student at Adlai Stevenson High School in the Bronx was busted with a loaded .32-caliber weapon and a bag of marijuana on Oct. 20, 2021. Three guns were confiscated ... Read more »

Covid restrictions could return unless public ‘do their bit', Sajid Javid warns

© Reuters Britain’s Health Secretary Sajid Javid speaks during a press conference held in Downing Street, London Health secretary Sajid Javid has warned that coronavirus restrictions could return in England ... Read more »

Gobiernos de Latinoamérica que bajaron salarios de funcionarios en pandemia

© José Jácome / EFE El presidente de Colombia, Iván Duque, y el expresidente de Ecuador, Lenín Moreno. Redujeron el sueldo ante la crisis económica que dejó la emergencia sanitaria ... Read more »

CDC says schools should keep mask mandates as kids get vaccinated

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Wednesday it will continue to recommend schools implement mask mandates for students and staff even after young children are allowed to be ... Read more »

Watchdog sues North Carolina town over scholarship intended for black students

Efforts like Asheville, North Carolina’s are generally defended as ways to either rectify historic injustices or assist underrepresented communities. Asheville is currently pursuing a reparations program. Getty Images/iStockphoto The city ... Read more »

De Blasio ‘troubled' by video of maskless cops shoving man out of subway station

Mayor Bill de Blasio said Wednesday he was “troubled” by a video of two maskless cops shoving a man out of a Manhattan subway station on Tuesday after the straphanger ... Read more »

Cost to replace Washington State Patrol troopers lost to vaccine mandate tops $12.4M

Washington State Patrol’s (WSP) decision to terminate the employment of 127 people Tuesday for refusing to comply with Gov. Jay Inslee’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate will end up costing the state ... Read more »

Adrian Barich: How I'm preparing for Leavers Week as a parent

Having successfully negotiated grand final week in Perth and then done our bit for Telethon at the weekend, I was thinking it was clear air all the way to Christmas. ... Read more »

Sajid Javid urges public to wear face masks - hours after Tories refuse to in Commons

Sajid Javid has said the public should wear a face mask to “think about others around them” in some enclosed settings just hours after Tory MPs packed into the House ... Read more »

Wissenschaft setzt Hoffnung in diese Corona-Medikamente

© APA/dpa Medikamente Arzneien Weltweit forschen Pharmaunternehmen an Medikamenten gegen eine Covid-19. Bisher ist nur eines offiziell zugelassen. Weitere acht warten noch darauf. Neben den nachweislich sehr wirksamen Impfstoffen arbeiten ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic