Data storage, mining and wind: oceans seen as growth area but at what cost?

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photograph: Olivier Morin/AFP/Getty Images

In September 2017, a giant, floating fish farm capable of raising 1.5 million salmon was installed in central Norway. Besides its vast size – the circular structure is roughly the equivalent of two baseball fields – what set SalMar’s Ocean Farm 1 apart was its location three miles off the coast. It was hailed as the world’s first offshore salmon farm.

Four years later, there have been two production cycles with better growth and survival of salmon compared with inshore farms, according to the company, hence less food waste and a lower carbon footprint. Energy demand was also reduced compared with traditional inshore farms because seawater naturally flows through the nets, oxygenating salmon with no need for the pumps used on traditional inshore farms.

But the facility now lies empty, awaiting the development of new nets after farmed salmon escaped through a tear. Tougher nets will be vital for SalMar’s next-generation Smart Fish Farm that’s slated to be four times bigger and will operate even farther from the coast.

Plans to place fish cages offshore are part of a wider trend among industries that are gazing out to sea in an effort to find more space, more cold, clean water and more wind. Many are chasing an ambition of greater sustainability. These initiatives are mostly at an early proof-of-concept stage, but they offer a glimpse of what the future of the ocean could look like, as well as some of the risks.

SalMar’s Ocean Farm 1, three miles off the coast of Norway. Photograph: SalMar ASA/PA

“It’s not the first time we’ve had a kind of offshoring initiative,” said Klaus Dodds, professor of geopolitics at Royal Holloway, University of London. Popular culture in the 1960s and 70s portrayed the ocean as offering a brighter, shinier future with new opportunities to advance humanity, from seabed mining to living underwater. “I have a suspicion that the ocean yet again will become either a place for technical scientific fixes or for capitalism to constantly reinvent itself with clever new solutions,” says Dodds.

Part of the new wave of industrial interest in offshore waters comes from tech companies. Microsoft has tried sinking data centres to see how well the sea can cool the systems and save power. After two years underwater a mile off Orkney in Scotland, a storage device was brought up encrusted in sea life. It performed well in its time underwater, according to the company, with fewer failures than land-based systems, and its energy efficiency is being analyzed.

Related: Race to the bottom: the disastrous, blindfolded rush to mine the deep sea

A number of problems could arise if seabed data storage takes off. “Where does all the heat go for oceans and seas that we’re already worried about in terms of warming?” Dodds said. It’s also unclear whether operators would carefully remove units at the end of their lifespans, possibly raising equivalent problems as encountered with decommissioning oil rigs in the North Sea. “I want to see some more careful research that really reassures me that overall, given the scaling-up implications, that it really is better to be offshore as opposed to on land,” Dodds said.

He has seen a lot of interest from companies in data storage in the cold climate of Arctic regions but little research into the implications for ocean biodiversity. “There’s this presumption that just because we can’t see something or just because the ocean is so enormous, we can probably crack on.”

As well as new ideas for using the ocean, old ones are coming back. After a decades-long hiatus, mining companies are once again planning to exploit metallic deposits on the deep seabed. This latest rush to mine the deep is facing growing opposition. Civil society, governments, scientists and corporations are calling for a moratorium on seabed mining due to the likely impacts on biodiversity and climate.

The International Seabed Authority (ISA), the global regulator, is holding an in-person meeting in December at its headquarters in Jamaica, despite requests from states and observers to postpone – pandemic-related travel restrictions mean the meeting is not likely to be well-attended. In a letter to the ISA in October, the Deep-Sea Conservation Coalition criticised the plan as “out of step with the growing calls for more inclusion in global decision-making”. Critics are concerned the ISA may take the opportunity in December to give the deep-seabed mining industry the go-ahead to commence in 2023.

Deep-sea mining robot Patania II was trialled in the Pacific Ocean in April 2021. Photograph: GSR/Reuters

The race for the ocean has caused conflicts to unfold between different offshore users. While offshore aquaculture companies are keen to emphasise the sustainable credentials of their operations, they face opposition.

The Don’t Cage Our Ocean Coalition, a group of environmentalists, consumer advocacy organisations and fishing organisations, liken these offshore operations to land-based industrial feedlots. Their concerns include escaped fish mingling with wild populations and adding nutrients and pollutants to waters that in many places are already struggling. “It’s all going somewhere, even if we don’t see it,” says founding member Marianne Cufone. The organisation is campaigning against US federal waters being opened to large-scale fin fish farming, such as salmon and tuna.

At present, there’s no aquaculture in US federal waters but that could change if plans go ahead to streamline the permitting process. Other regions, Cufone says, are stepping away from fish farms both inshore and offshore, including a Danish moratorium on new fish farms and Canadian plans to phase out ocean fish farms in waters off British Columbia. “We should learn from what comes before us and move on to smart, progressive, thoughtful, sustainable approaches if we want to increase domestic seafood production without harming our fishing communities and others who care about and want to use the waters,” she said.

The wind energy sector is also looking to move further offshore and meeting resistance from environmentalists and fishing industries. Earlier this year, the Biden administration committed to building 30 gigawatts of offshore wind capacity by 2030. Many fishers feel they are being forgotten in the race to tackle the climate crisis. They are worried about losing access to fishing grounds and that windfarm installations could disrupt ocean currents and fish populations.

Offshore wind developers have held meetings with fishermen to plan windfarms more collaboratively. After talking with fishers, Empire Wind, a proposed offshore windfarm south of Long Island, changed its plans to include an area open to fishing.

A lack of inclusive planning risks causing problems in UK waters, where the government has pledged to install 40 gigawatts of offshore wind by 2030. Nature conservation groups are worried the current planning regime is not fit for purpose. “At the moment, the industry is very project-led,” says Joan Edwards, director of marine conservation at The Wildlife Trusts.

Windfarm developers in the UK can pick an area and approach the crown estate, which owns most of the seabed around the UK out to 12 nautical miles, for a lease. A better approach, Edwards says, would be to identify places nationally where offshore wind will not affect important parts of the marine environment, via noise pollution and digging up the seabed for cabling. “We need to work out just how best to develop this industry so that it gives us renewable energy but doesn’t create more of a problem for nature,” she says.

With industries rushing offshore, the ocean is on a course to become more crowded. To avoid a messy and damaging scramble for marine real estate, a coordinated approach is needed. “We’re really going to have to be very confident these things are being regulated, monitored and evaluated holistically, and over the long term as well,” says Klaus Dodds. “There’s a real danger that we think the oceans are this kind of frontier space, that we can just do things and worry about the implications later. That’s patently not true.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Garmin Fenix 7 vs Garmin Fenix 6: which watch should you choose?

In January 2022, Garmin unveiled the Fenix 7 range – its latest lineup of top-tier sports watches. The nine watches in the range all offer lots of new fitness training ... Read more »

Mum who died in car crash 'may have been distracted watching 'Love Island' on her phone'

More than 40 bunches of flowers and messages have been left inn Charlotte Buesden memory. (SWNS) A mum may have been distracted by watching Love Island on her phone when ... Read more »

Get your small business connected with Aruba Instant On

As the pandemic moved workers out of the office to work wherever they were able to, the need to stay connected and online has never been more important. We’ve all ... Read more »

The Best Buy 4-day sale is ending soon - deals on TVs, laptops, AirPods and more

The Best Buy 4-day sale is happening right now with epic deals on 4K TVs, laptops, AirPods, kitchen appliances, tablets, and more. We’ve scoured through the sale to bring you ... Read more »

The Book of Boba Fett episode 4 recap: the weakest chapter so far

About this episode – Episode 4 (of 7), ‘Chapter 4: The Gathering Storm’ – Written by Jon Favreau – Directed by Kevin Tancharoen ★★ Spoilers for The Book of Boba ... Read more »

Christian Wakeford: Moment Labour MPs cheer after Tory MP defeats in protest at Boris Johnson leadership

This is the moment Christian Wakeford ‘crossed the floor’ in the House of Commons after defecting from the Tory party in protest at Boris Johnson’s leadership.Wakeford was cheered by Labour ... Read more »

Godiva just released chocolate diamonds—here's how to get the jewelry for Valentine's Day

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. When you think of the best Valentine’s Day gifts, chocolate and ... Read more »

Tech giants face online safety inquiry

Some of the world's biggest tech companies will have their say on proposed laws that would hold them accountable for online harassment and abuse on their platforms. The proposed laws ... Read more »

SpaceX Rocket Streaks Through Florida Sky

SpaceX launched 49 Starlink satellites from the Kennedy Space Center in Florida on January 18, the company said. This hyperlapse footage was published by the Port St Lucie Police Department. ... Read more »

Gmail is getting a new 'inbox zero' icon - but you'll probably never see it

For those of us who really dominate the email game, a new Gmail update has promised a reward in the form of an all-new congratulatory “inbox zero” icon. The refreshed ... Read more »

Make dinnertime easier with Home Chef meal kits—save $90 now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Looking to streamline dinnertime? Meal kit delivery services can take the ... Read more »

Saturday Kitchen star Matt Tebbutt undergoes emergency surgery: details

Matt Tebbutt hasn't had the best start to the year! The Saturday Kitchen star has revealed he had to undergo emergency surgery this week, sharing an update from his hospital ... Read more »

How to watch Ivory Coast vs Algeria: live stream AFCON online from anywhere

Read more »

Computer Scientists Eliminate Pesky Quantum Computations

For years, intermediate measurements made it hard to quantify the complexity of quantum algorithms. New work establishes that those measurements aren’t necessary after all. Read more »

EXPLAINER: Microsoft's Activision buy could shake up gaming

Microsoft stunned the gaming industry when it announced this week it would buy game publisher Activision Blizzard for $68.7 billion, a deal that would immediately make it a larger video-game ... Read more »

The new normal is now just the normal

We’ve been talking about the new normal for some time, but when will it just become the norm? I think it already has, and businesses need to start playing catch ... Read more »

Arsenal vs Liverpool live stream: how to watch the Carabao Cup semi-final online, second-leg

Something has got to give tomorrow night in the second leg semi-final of the Carabao Cup when Liverpool travel to North London to play Arsenal. After a 10-man Gunners scraped ... Read more »

Amazon's Lord of the Rings forges a title to rule us all

Amazon Studios has officially unveiled the title for its upcoming Lord of the Rings TV series – and, given its ties to Sauron, it sounds very ominous indeed. Revealed in ... Read more »

How Dune's production team brought the world of Arrakis to life

There’s a saying among Hollywood’s most revered directors that filmmaking shouldn’t be about serving the audience, but the filmmakers themselves. Denis Villeneuve’s Dune just so happens to do both. The ... Read more »

Sony stock drops $20 billion thanks to Microsoft/Activision Xbox deal

Stock in Sony plunged overnight by 13%, equating $20 billion lost in the company, in the wake of Microsoft’s announcement that it will be purchasing Activision Blizzard. According to Bloomberg ... Read more »

Activision Blizzard CEO reveals why it was the right time to do a deal with Microsoft

Activision Blizzard lawsuit Publisher Activision Blizzard, responsible for the game this article refers to, is currently embroiled in ongoing litigation in regards to claims reporting a workplace culture that allegedly ... Read more »

ProtonMail wants to stop you being tracked online via email

Privacy-oriented email provider ProtonMail has introduced a new feature that looks to prevent advertisers from tracking users reading their emails. The ‘enhanced tracking protection’ blocks tracking pixels commonly found in ... Read more »

HSN is hosting its annual Beauty Choice Awards—check out our beauty editor's top picks

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. HSN is home to tons of incredible products, from our favorite ... Read more »

Last chance - get up to $300 off Asus Zephyrus gaming laptop deals at Best Buy

Are you shopping for high-end gaming laptop deals? There are two excellent options at Best Buy right now that are worth checking out. Word of warning, however – they expire ... Read more »

Best green web hosting of 2022

Choosing the best web hosting company typically involves weighing up many factors, such as price, features, support, reputation and more. The environmental impact of a web host probably won’t rank ... Read more »

The inventor of the World Wide Web says his creation has been abused for too long

Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the inventor of the World Wide Web, has called for a stronger focus on addressing the imbalance of power on the web. Speaking to Fujitsu CTO Vivek ... Read more »

Brentford vs Manchester United live stream: how to watch Premier League from anywhere

Ralf Rangnick’s mission to get the Red Devils back on track could get a major boost this evening, with the interim boss knowing that a win in west London will ... Read more »

Madeleine McCann investigators find ‘shocking' new evidence about suspect

Madeleine McCann was three years old when she disappeared in 2007 (PA) A German TV channel has discovered “shocking” new evidence against a man suspected of kidnapping Madeleine McCann, reports ... Read more »

Man arrested and charged with murder after nine-year-old girl found dead in a barrel in Australia

Nine-year-old Charlise Mutten was found dead in a barrel near a river in Australia (Screengrab/ABC News Australia/YouTube ) The 31-year-old stepfather of nine-year-old girl Charlise Mutten has been arrested and ... Read more »

David Davis tells Boris Johnson ‘in the name of God, go' at chaotic PMQs

Tory grandee calls on Johnson to resign at PMQs featuring fierce exchanges between PM and Keir Starmer The Tory grandee David Davis told Boris Johnson: “In the name of God, ... Read more »

AMD's new Radeon PRO GPU is more sensible than sexy, but that's no bad thing

AMD has unveiled a new addition to its Radeon PRO W6000 GPU series that caters specifically to the needs of the typical knowledge worker. The new Radeon PRO W6400 sits ... Read more »

Microsoft acquires Activision Blizzard for $68.7 Billion: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

Martine McCutcheon reveals secret behind her stunning figure – and fans are inspired

Martine McCutcheon has taken to Instagram to reveal the one activity that has helped her mentally and physically – walking. MORE: Martine McCutcheon reveals jaw-dropping hair transformation Sharing a picture ... Read more »

Man pretended to be lawyer, doctor and council official to control girlfriend's life

Carwyn Roberts attempted to control his partner by telling her a string of lies. (North Wales Police) A controlling boyfriend who posed as a doctor to convince his girlfriend that ... Read more »

Boris Johnson scraps Plan B COVID rules and mandatory face masks from next week

Boris Johnson has confirmed that Plan B COVID measures will end next week. (PA) Boris Johnson has announced an easing of England’s Plan B coronavirus restrictions amid a battle to ... Read more »

Jennifer Lopez wears risqué leather bra top in striking new photo – fans react

Jennifer Lopez has taken to social media with a striking new look. The singer shared two snapshots on Instagram with fans – and they were blown away by her appearance. ... Read more »

Hogwarts Legacy will release this year says Warner Bros. in spite of delay rumors

Despite claims to the contrary, Hogwarts Legacy, the Harry Potter action-RPG, is apparently still on track to release at some point in 2022. The official Warner Bros. Brazil Twitter account ... Read more »

Starbucks to widen online reach in China through new alliance with Meituan, ending coffeehouse chain's partnership with Alibaba-backed

US coffeehouse chain Starbucks is gearing up to expand its online presence across China through a new alliance with on-demand local services giant Meituan, ending an exclusive partnership with Alibaba ... Read more »

Monopoly in jeopardy: The two US bills that have Big Tech worried

With increased scrutiny from regulators around the globe these days, legal departments at the world’s biggest tech companies are likely working overtime on a daily basis. This week, the focus ... Read more »

China's digital currency: e-CNY wallet nearly doubles user base in two months to 261 million ahead of Winter Olympics

China’s official digital yuan app, e-CNY, had 261 million unique users at the end of 2021, nearly twice what it had in October, even before it was released in app ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic