Data flow's decisive role on the global stage

New research by political science PhD candidate Meicen Sun illuminates the broad economic and political impacts of internet restrictions.

Technology and society, Politics, Internet, Students, Graduate, postdoctoral, Policy, Profile, China, Mobile devices, Political science, Digital humanities, Democracy, Data, Digital technology, Information Systems and Technology, Research, School of Humanities Arts and Social Sciences, Meicen Sun, Kenneth Oye, In Song Kim, Yasheng Huang,

During her undergraduate and graduate studies, which came to focus on China and its expanding global role, Meicen Sun became convinced that digital constraints initially intended to prevent the free flow of ideas were also having enormous and growing economic impacts. Photo: Maisie O'Brien

In 2016, Meicen Sun came to a profound realization: “The control of digital information will lie at the heart of all the big questions and big contentions in politics.” A graduate student in her final year of study who is specializing in international security and the political economy of technology, Sun vividly recalls the emergence of the internet “as a democratizing force, an opener, an equalizer,” helping give rise to the Arab Spring. But she was also profoundly struck when nations in the Middle East and elsewhere curbed internet access to throttle citizens’ efforts to speak and mobilize freely.

During her undergraduate and graduate studies, which came to focus on China and its expanding global role, Sun became convinced that digital constraints initially intended to prevent the free flow of ideas were also having enormous and growing economic impacts.

“With an exceptionally high mobile internet adoption rate and the explosion of indigenous digital apps, China’s digital economy was surging, helping to drive the nation’s broader economic growth and international competitiveness,” Sun says. “Yet at the same time, the country maintained the most tightly controlled internet ecosystem in the world.”

Sun set out to explore this apparent paradox in her dissertation. Her research to date has yielded both novel findings and troubling questions.  

“Through its control of the internet, China has in effect provided protectionist benefits to its own data-intensive domestic sectors,” she says. “If there is a benefit to imposing internet control, given the absence of effective international regulations, does this give authoritarian states an advantage in trade and national competitiveness?” Following this thread, Sun asks, “What might this mean for the future of democracy as the world grows increasingly dependent on digital technology?”

Protect or innovate

Early in her graduate program, classes in capitalism and technology and public policy, says Sun, “cemented for me the idea of data as a factor of production, and the importance of cross-border information flow in making a country innovative.” This central premise serves as a springboard for Sun’s doctoral studies.

In a series of interconnected research papers using China as her primary case, she is examining the double-edged nature of internet limits. “They accord protectionist benefits to domestic data-internet-intensive sectors, on the one hand, but on the other, act as a potential longer-term deterrent to the country’s capacity to innovate.”

To pursue her doctoral project, advised by professor of political science Kenneth Oye, Sun is extracting data from a multitude of sources, including a website that has been routinely testing web domain accessibility from within China since 2011. This allows her to pin down when and to what degree internet control occurs. She can then compare this information to publicly available records on the expansion or contraction of data-intensive industrial sectors, enabling her to correlate internet control to a sector’s performance.

Sun has also compiled datasets for firm-level revenue, scientific citations, and patents that permit her to measure aspects of China’s innovation culture. In analyzing her data she leverages both quantitative and qualitative methods, including one co-developed by her dissertation co-advisor, associate professor of political science In Song Kim. Her initial analysis suggests internet control prevents scholars from accessing knowledge available on foreign websites, and that if sustained, such control could take a toll on the Chinese economy over time.

Of particular concern is the possibility that the economic success that flows from strict internet controls, as exemplified by the Chinese model, may encourage the rise of similar practices among emerging states or those in political flux.

“The grim implication of my research is that without international regulation on information flow restrictions, democracies will be at a disadvantage against autocracies,” she says. “No matter how short-term or narrow these curbs are, they confer concrete benefits on certain economic sectors.”

Data, politics, and economy

Sun got a quick start as a student of China and its role in the world. She was born in Xiamen, a coastal Chinese city across from Taiwan, to academic parents who cultivated her interest in international politics. “My dad would constantly talk to me about global affairs, and he was passionate about foreign policy,” says Sun.

Eager for education and a broader view of the world, Sun took a scholarship at 15 to attend school in Singapore. “While this experience exposed me to a variety of new ideas and social customs, I felt the itch to travel even farther away, and to meet people with different backgrounds and viewpoints from mine,” than she says.

Sun attended Princeton University where, after two years sticking to her “comfort zone” — writing and directing plays and composing music for them — she underwent a process of intellectual transition. Political science classes opened a window onto a larger landscape to which she had long been connected: China’s behavior as a rising power and the shifting global landscape.

She completed her undergraduate degree in politics, and followed up with a master’s degree in international relations at the University of Pennsylvania, where she focused on China-U.S. relations and China’s participation in international institutions. She was on the path to completing a PhD at Penn when, Sun says, “I became confident in my perception that digital technology, and especially information sharing, were becoming critically important factors in international politics, and I felt a strong desire to devote my graduate studies, and even my career, to studying these topics,”

Certain that the questions she hoped to pursue could best be addressed through an interdisciplinary approach with those working on similar issues, Sun began her doctoral program anew at MIT.

“Doer mindset”

Sun is hopeful that her doctoral research will prove useful to governments, policymakers, and business leaders. “There are a lot of developing states actively shopping between data governance and development models for their own countries,” she says. “My findings around the pros and cons of information flow restrictions should be of interest to leaders in these places, and to trade negotiators and others dealing with the global governance of data and what a fair playing field for digital trade would be.”

Sun has engaged directly with policy and industry experts through her fellowships with the World Economic Forum and the Pacific Forum. And she has embraced questions that touch on policy outside of her immediate research: Sun is collaborating with her dissertation co-advisor, MIT Sloan Professor Yasheng Huang, on a study of the political economy of artificial intelligence in China for the MIT Task Force on the Work of the Future.

This year, as she writes her dissertation papers, Sun will be based at Georgetown University, where she has a Mortara Center Global Political Economy Project Predoctoral Fellowship. In Washington, she will continue her journey to becoming a “policy-minded scholar, a thinker with a doer mindset, whose findings have bearing on things that happen in the world.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Govt's foreign policy -- how to lose friends, influence nobody: Rahul Gandhi's dig at Centre

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi. File image. Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Friday took a dig at the Centre over Bhutan and China signing a pact on border talks, saying the government’s foreign policy is ... Read more »

Nasa's Lucy mission will seek out Solar System 'fossils'

Artwork: Lucy is just one in a series of Nasa missions to the Solar System‘s asteroids A spacecraft will launch in the coming hours on a mission to uncover “the ... Read more »

Australian PM says he will attend Cop26 climate summit, as doubts grow over China's Xi Jinping

Street artists paint a mural on a wall opposite the Cop26 climate summit venue in Glasgow (AFP via Getty Images) Australian prime minister Scott Morrison has finally confirmed he will ... Read more »

Apple reportedly just fired another employee who brought attention to issues at the company

Apple CEO Tim Cook. Yves Herman/Reuters Apple just fired a staffer who helped organize employees at the company, The Verge reported. Janneke Parrish was an Apple Maps program manager who ... Read more »

A Mysterious 'Ghost Particle' Probably Didn't Come From a Black Hole's Meal After All

© DESY, Science Communication Lab Animation of AT2019dsg. A high-energy neutrino traced back to a violent encounter between a black hole and a star needs a different origin story, new ... Read more »

UN extends Haiti political mission after US-China dispute

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The U.N. Security Council voted unanimously Friday evening to extend the U.N. political mission in Haiti after a dispute between China which has no diplomatic relations ... Read more »

Brawl breaks out at high school

Oct. 15—KERNERSVILLE — Four people were arrested after a fight involving adults and students at Glenn High School Friday afternoon. All students and staff are safe, but law enforcement did ... Read more »

Dogs can show human-like ADHD behaviors, study finds

Some dogs exhibit behaviors that closely resemble ADHD in humans, according to a study released this month in the journal Translational Psychiatry. The study, which tracked hyperactivity, impulsivity and inattention ... Read more »

De Blasio is a goner, but his toxic anti-meritocracy mentality is here to stay

Mayor de Blasio’s final term is coming to an end soon. Robert Miller As his two terms as mayor approach their end, Bill de Blasio has chimed in with one ... Read more »

Sally Carman made 'Coronation Street' co-star Joe Duttine repeat his proposal because 'it went too quick'

Sally Carman attends the National Television Awards 2021. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Coronation Street and Shameless actor Sally Carman says she made her fiancé Joe Duttine propose a second time, ... Read more »

Woman left terrified after finding seven inch arachnid in her house

The giant ‘harvestman‘ that was photographed in a house in Cambridge, October 14 2021 A woman was left terrified after finding a huge spider-like creature in her house. The creature, ... Read more »

William Shatner Responds To Prince William's Criticism Of Space Tourism

Recent rocket passengerWilliam Shatner responded to Prince William’s criticism of space tourism for the wealthy while the Earth continues to be plagued by environmental problems. Shatner, 90, became the oldest ... Read more »

How the mighty fell! Scientists determine that 75% of Rome's emperors died from violent deaths on the battlefield or palace plots

More than 75% of the 69 Roman emperors died from unnatural causes  This includes dying in battle or being murdered in palace plots The data also means that only one in four died from sickness or old age Read more »

Bird flu outbreak killed five swans, five seals and a FOX after the 'unusual' virus jumped to mammals at UK wildlife centre, report finds

Scientists report species infected by a bird flu strain during the outbreak in 2020The outbreak took place at an undisclosed wildlife rehabilitation centre in the UKThousands of animals were killed last winter to prevent the spread of bird flu Read more »

Hombre es sentenciado a muerte por prender fuego a su exesposa mientras ella transmitía en vivo

© Weibo Lhamo.jpg Un hombre en China fue condenado a muerte por matar a su exesposa prendiéndole fuego mientras estaba transmitiendo en vivo en las redes sociales. En un caso ... Read more »

Eric Adams would require COVID vax for students if FDA approves it

Eric Adams said in an interview with WCBS Newsradio 880 that he would require school kids to get the vaccine if the FDA approves it. Robert Miller Democratic mayoral candidate ... Read more »

Sorry former Pentagon expert, but China is nowhere near winning the AI race

Nicolas Chaillan, the Pentagon’s former Chief Software Officer, is on a whirlwind press tour to drum up as much fervor for his radical assertion that the US has already lost ... Read more »

Busta Rhymes has questions about NFTs, and he has NFTs for sale

© Photo by Johnny Nunez/WireImage You can’t always take Busta Rhymes literally, and sometimes you shouldn’t take his questions seriously at all, but a tweet from this morning about NFTs ... Read more »

‘Nightmare' Mom Accused in Drunken Teen Sex Parties Loved ‘Power'

Ada County Sheriff’s Office The California mom accused of encouraging sex abuse at booze-fueled parties she arranged for young teens has long been known as a “liar” who leaves a ... Read more »

Stacey Solomon introduces new daughter to Loose Women co-stars

Photo credit: ITV Stacey Solomon has introduced her newborn daughter to Loose Women co-stars Nadia Sawalha and Jane Moore. In a smiling snap Nadia posted to Instagram, the three presenters ... Read more »

William Shatner Calls Prince William's Criticism of Space Race 'Inane': 'I'm Surprised'

William Shatner, Prince William Santiago Felipe/Getty; Max Mumby/Indigo/Getty Prince William and William Shatner do not see eye to eye on the space race. After his return to Earth on Wednesday, ... Read more »

10 Key Health Appointments to Schedule Starting in Your 40s and 50s

© Provided by Real Simple Getty Images People have their individual reasons for avoiding the doctor’s office—from packed schedules to a fear of the unknown. But medical experts reiterate that ... Read more »

Unnamed Tottenham duo test positive for coronavirus before Newcastle clash

Tottenham’s plans for Sunday’s Premier League trip to Newcastle have been plunged into chaos after two players tested positive for coronavirus. Both men, who trained with the group on Thursday, ... Read more »

SkEye app review

© Provided by Space SkEye review: image shows SkEye planetarium Getting out in nature doesn’t have to involve a sweaty hike or an arduous road trip. Stepping outside at night ... Read more »

Virgin Galactic delays first commercial space flight

Virgin Galactic‘s VSS Unity spacecraft Shares in Virgin Galactic dived as much as 20% on Friday after the space tourism company said it was postponing its first commercial flight. The ... Read more »

Raise your TV-audio game with this 2.1-channel soundbar, now $30 off at Amazon

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. Built-in TV speakers make ears cry. Enjoy much-improved audio with a ... Read more »

‘Sensational': skeleton buried in Vesuvius eruption found at Herculaneum

Photograph: Sebastian Condrea/Getty Images The partially mutilated remains of a man buried by the AD79 eruption of Mount Vesuvius at Herculaneum, the ancient Roman town close to Pompeii, have been ... Read more »

Study shows fragile X treatment can incur resistance, suggests ways around it

While the brain acquires resistance to continuous treatment with mGluR5 inhibitor drugs, lasting effects may still arise if dosing occurs intermittently and during a developmental-critical period. Read more »

China launches second crew on six-month mission to space station

China on Saturday launched a three-person crew for a six-month mission aboard its space station that is planned at setting a new record for the length of time spent in ... Read more »

Putting artificial intelligence at the heart of health care — with help from MIT

Cardiologist Demilade Adedinsewo is using her MIT Professional Education experience to advance cardiovascular care at the Mayo Clinic. Read more »

Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz to plead guilty to murders of 14 students and three teachers

The shooter who claimed responsibility for the 2018 shooting in Parkland, Florida, that claimed 17 lives will plead guilty to all charges, his lawyers say. Nikolas Cruz, who said he ... Read more »

Russia shadows US Navy destroyer in dramatic video amid warnings to ‘turn back' from its territorial waters in Sea of Japan

© Russian Defence Ministry Russia releases video footage of encounter with USS Chafee – Russian Defence Ministry Russia accused the US Navy of attempting to enter its territorial waters during ... Read more »

Who knew you could buy a portable thermal printer for just $35?

We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. The PeriPage A6 printer is almost as adorable as the puppy ... Read more »

Industry bodies seek clarity on online gaming

IT industry associations Nasscom and IndiaTech.org have urged Karnataka to clarify several clauses in its recently notified Karnataka Police (Amendment) Act, 2021 that bans gaming through internet and mobile apps, ... Read more »

China crackdown on Apple store hits holy book apps, Audible

FILE – In this Sept. 28, 2021 file photo, people wearing face masks to help curb the spread of the coronavirus try out the latest iPhone 13 handsets at an ... Read more »

Will Russia seek leverage over Europe amid global energy squeeze?

© Alexander Nemenov, AFP Russia has been seeking in recent days to position itself at the centre of the debate surrounding Europe’s energy crisis. Although the geostrategic chess player Vladimir Putin may want to leverage Russia’s ... Read more »

Brain ‘Fingerprints' Could Unlock Alzheimer's Early Warning System

Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast / Photos Getty Every human brain is made up of seemingly countless connections that come together as a type of biological map of the ... Read more »

Accelerating the discovery of new materials for 3D printing

A new machine-learning system costs less, generates less waste, and can be more innovative than manual discovery methods. Read more »

Scientists find evidence the early solar system harbored a gap between its inner and outer regions

The cosmic boundary, perhaps caused by a young Jupiter or a wind from the solar system emerging, likely shaped the composition of infant planets. Read more »

Qualcomm is salty about Pixel's switch to Tensor but really shouldn't be

© Image: Google The Google Pixel 6 phones will ditch Snapdragon chips for an in-house design, and Qualcomm is clearly feeling a little hurt about it. Qualcomm couldn’t help but ... Read more »