DAs, retailers say California needs stronger shoplifting law

FILE - A security guard stands outside the Nordstrom store at The Grove retail and entertainment complex in Los Angeles, on Nov. 23, 2021. Prosecutors and retailers are pushing back on assertions by California’s governor and attorney general that the
Image Icon
The Associated PressFILE – A security guard stands outside the Nordstrom store at The Grove retail and entertainment complex in Los Angeles, on Nov. 23, 2021. Prosecutors and retailers are pushing back on assertions by California’s governor and attorney general that they have enough tools to combat shoplifting. California Retailers Association president Rachel Michelin says shoplifting has been a growing problem. (AP Photo/Eugene Garcia, File)

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Spurred by a recent run of large-scale smash-and-grab robberies, prosecutors and retailers are pushing back on assertions by California’s governor and attorney general that they have enough tools to combat retail theft in the wake of a voter-approved easing of related laws.

“We cannot function as a society where we have told people over and over again that there is no consequence for stealing other people’s property,” said Vern Pierson, immediate past president of the California District Attorneys Association and El Dorado County’s district attorney.

“We feel a little bit like we’re under assault,” California Retailers Association President and CEO Rachel Michelin said separately.

Shoplifting has been a growing problem, Michelin said, but recent large-scale thefts in California and elsewhere across the nation in which groups of individuals rush into stores and take goods in plain sight or smash and grab from display cases is ”raising it to a whole new level.”

California is hardly alone, with similar brazen incidents seen in Minnesota, Chicago’s North Michigan Avenue and North Rush Street and many other locations.

Authorities in Oak Brook, Illinois, for instance said 14 people entered a Louis Vuitton store in the Chicago suburb last month and filled large plastic bags with clothing and other items worth more than $120,000.

National retail groups last month estimated the annual losses to be in the tens of billions of dollars. Some states’ attorney generals are supporting a congressional bill that would require more prevention efforts by large online marketplaces, where experts say many of the stolen goods are fenced.

The thefts have become a political issue as well, particularly in California, where critics place blame on progressive policies like Proposition 47, a ballot measure approved by 60% of state voters in 2014 that reduced certain theft and drug possession offenses from felonies to misdemeanors.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom and Attorney General Rob Bonta separately argued Wednesday that police and prosecutors still have the legal tools to go after such perpetrators, and Newsom called out some local officials he said choose not to do so.

“It’s patently false to assert that we have enough laws on the books that are fixing this problem, because it’s obviously not going away and won’t be going away,” countered John Kabateck, director of the California chapter of the National Federation of Independent Businesses, which represents small and independent business owners.

Yet authorities in Los Angeles on Thursday announced 14 arrests in 11 recent smash-and-grab robberies where nearly $340,000 worth of merchandise was stolen.

San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin last week charged nine people with looting targets including Louis Vuitton and other Union Square retailers.

And Bonta planned a Friday announcement with San Mateo County law enforcement officials on a major organized retail theft case in the Silicon Valley.

Newsom has repeatedly said prosecutors can “stack” multiple misdemeanor thefts into a felony charge. But Pierson, the district attorney, said that “reveals a significant misunderstanding of the law in the wake of Prop. 47.”

Subsequent court decisions require that the repeated thefts involve the same victim and conduct eventually amounting to a loss exceeding $950, which Pierson said “is very difficult to prove.”

“The law here in California is very clear — we cannot simply stack petty thefts into a felony,” he said.

Will Matthews, a spokesman for Californians for Safety and Justice, which sponsored the ballot measure, cited penal code sections for receiving stolen property, organized retail theft, conspiracy, grand theft or aggregating crimes that he said provide “multiple avenues” for filing more serious charges.

“Unfortunately, too many of our law enforcement leaders … are choosing to play a blame game,” he said.

A law firm that has worked with the prosecutors’ association last week introduced a ballot measure that would allow up to a year in jail for anyone who previously was twice convicted of various thefts.

“Brazen retail theft, auto theft, porch piracy, and other similar crimes are out of control,” asserts the initiative proposed by attorney Thomas Hiltachk, who did not return a call seeking comment. “Anyone convicted two or more times for these types of theft crimes must be incarcerated for up to one year. No exceptions, no excuses.”

Pierson called the proposal “a significant step in the right direction” but said the association isn’t a sponsor.

But 62% of California voters last year rejected a broader effort to roll back portions of Proposition 47 and other recent laws easing criminal sentences.

“Californians have made clear multiple times that they want to see us prioritize our investments on crime prevention over continued investments in failed incarceration,” said Matthews.

Though Newsom and Bonta defended current law as adequate, the retail association’s Michelin praised the governor’s aides for reaching out to her last week to see if more should be done.

She thinks there may be common ground in restoring a “carrot and stick” approach that would let shoplifters enter diversion programs in lieu of jail.

“Many times they’re homeless, they have additional problems, but there’s no reason for them to go out and take advantage of services. They’ll just continue to shoplift,” she said.

Those lower-level thieves in turn are often recruited by retail theft organizers, experts say. And in another affront to brick-and-mortar stores already battling online sales, the stolen goods often are then sold online.

It’s a double-whammy particularly for small businesses that can’t afford increased security, said Kabateck: They are struggling this year with supply chain shortages only to see products they do receive stolen off the shelves.

Newsom said blaming Proposition 47 is too simplistic and pointed to consistently lower property crime rates since the measure took effect seven years ago.

That’s because few retailers report the crimes, Pierson and Michelin said separately.

“I know on the retail side they’re underreported because if someone’s coming and stealing under $950 — I’ve heard this multiple times — there’s no reason; law enforcement doesn’t have the resources to come out and do anything. And if they do they’re just going to write them a ticket,” Michelin said.

She’s proposing to work with her members and Newsom’s administration next year to better collect that data, because right now “even the stores don’t know because a lot of times they just let them go.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Blackburn Rovers transfer exit scrapped following injury setback

© Provided by Football League World Championship – Queens Park Rangers v Blackburn Rovers Blackburn Rovers manager Tony Mowbray has revealed that young striker Daniel Butterworth was set to go ... Read more »

Vishal's 'Veerame Vaagai Soodum' release postponed

© IANS Vishal’s Veerame Vaagai Soodum release postponed. Chennai, Jan 26 (IANS) The release of director Thu Pa Saravanan’s action entertainer ‘Veerame Vaagai Soodum’ featuring actors Vishal and Dimple Hayathi ... Read more »

DOH reports three more fatalities due to Omicron variant

© Philippines Daily Inquirer MANILA, Philippines — The country’s confirmed death toll due to the Omicron variant rose to five after the Department of Health (DOH) recorded the death of ... Read more »

Newcastle transfer rumours: Toon lead chase for Alli

© PA Newcastle are interested in signing Dele Alli this month All the latest Newcastle transfer news, rumours and gossip, as new manager Eddie Howe looks to improve his squad ... Read more »

These Two Self-Test Antigen Kit Brands Are Now FDA Certified

© Provided by reportr.world The Food and Drug Administration on Monday said it authorized the sale of two brands of self-test antigen kits, making available a reliable and accessible means ... Read more »

The 10 defenders with the most league goals in the 21st century - John Terry 4th

Sergio Ramos scored his first goal for Paris Saint-Germain last Sunday evening. The Spanish defender – who’s had a nightmare with injuries over the past 12 months or so – ... Read more »

IMF calls on El Salvador to stop using bitcoin as a means of payment

Photo: ANP El Salvador must end the use of the crypto currency bitcoin as legal tender. So says the International Monetary Fund (IMF). According to the IMF, there are too ... Read more »

Box Office: Hridayam has a strong Tuesday; Crosses 10 crores in Kerala and 20 crores worldwide

© Provided by Pinkvilla Hridayam had another strong day at the box office on Tuesday. The film grossed Rs. 2 crores Approx on its day five in India, with Rs. ... Read more »

Keith Urban takes over some of Adele's dates at Caesars Palace

© IANS Keith Urban takes over some of Adele’s dates at Caesars Palace. Los Angeles, Jan 26 (IANS) Country star Keith Urban has just been booked on some nights in ... Read more »

Sara Ali Khan shares a selfie with Vicky Kaushal as they head for a drive on Republic Day

© Provided by Pinkvilla Sara Ali Khan, who is quite active on social media, has a knack for making headlines with her posts on Instagram. She is often seen sharing ... Read more »

Kareena Kapoor Khan flaunts Taimur's healthy 'tricolour breakfast' on Republic Day; PIC

Republic Day is a special occasion for every Indian and our B-Town celebs too are making it special with their families. Speaking of which, Kareena Kapoor Khan gave fans a ... Read more »

Ältester männlicher Gorilla der Welt gestorben

Ozzie, das älteste Gorillamännchen der Welt, ist im Alter von 61 Jahren gestorben. Er hat aber bereits in den vergangenen Tagen an Appetitlosigkeit und Schwellungen im Gesicht gelitten. © Zoo ... Read more »

Auch dank Moderna-Impfstoff: Lonza wächst im Geschäftsjahr 2021 deutlich

Die «neue» Lonza ist deutlich profitabler ohne das mittlerweile verkaufte Chemiegeschäft. Altlasten drücken aber auf den ausgewiesenen Gewinn für das Geschäftsjahr 2021. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Lonza wächst im Geschäftsjahr ... Read more »

Schneechaos in Griechenland: Tausende Menschen mussten in ihren Autos übernachten

Wegen der starken Schneefälle in ganz Mittelgriechenland haben Tausende Autofahrer die Nacht auf Dienstag in ihren Autos auf Autobahnen verbracht. Auch in der Türkei sorgte heftiger Schneefall für Probleme. © ... Read more »

Tonga: COVID-hit Australian ship delivers disaster aid to virus-free island

© Provided by DW The HMS Adelaide’s entire crew is vaccinated and tested positive before departure, but several has since tested positive An Australian warship docked in Tonga on Wednesday ... Read more »

Kids must move! It's vital for learning – occupational therapist

Playing is learning. If you want your children to develop appropriately, all they need to do when they’re very small is play and move. It should be simple, but with ... Read more »

Omicron wave: Covid-19 took away two of our senses, one is smell. What is the other?

Patients have nearly lost their lives to Covid-19 from believing fake news and not getting timely medical help. (Photo by Andrea Piacquadio from Pexels) During the first wave, Covid-19 compromised ... Read more »

SIU: DoT flouted process in appointing PPE service provider for taxi sector

© @vm_africa/Twitter Taxis at a Gauteng taxi rank being disinfected as part of measures to protect public transport commuters from contracting COVID-19. JOHANNESBURG – The Special Investigating Unit (SIU) investigation ... Read more »

Greece: Explosion damages buildings in central Athens

© Provided by DW A loud explosion caused serious damage to a multi-story building in the Greek capital Athens on Wednesday morning. The blast happened some 200 meters (656 feet) ... Read more »

Joburg's development planning offices hit by burglaries, MMC smells foul play

© Provided by Times Live Member of the mayoral committee (MMC) for development planning, councillor Belinda Echeozonjoku, has expressed deep shock and disappointment about the burglaries.  She said building development ... Read more »

Soweto school still unfished 20 years since start of construction

© Provided by SowetanLive While the Gauteng department of education struggles to finish a school it began building 20 years ago, more than 500 pupils from Tholimfundo Primary School in ... Read more »

The signs someone else in your home has Omicron without realising

OMICRON is lurking around every corner and has likely infected at least one person you know. But some people may still be unaware of the nasty illness it inflicts, and ... Read more »

Britain's Pets At Home raises full-year profit outlook

© Reuters/Andrew Boyers FILE PHOTO: Outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Milton Keynes (Reuters) – Britain’s Pets At Home on Wednesday raised its profit outlook for fiscal 2022, as ... Read more »

CMC Markets says client money in third quarter close to record highs

© Reuters/Dylan Martinez FILE PHOTO: Dealers work at their desks whilst screens show market data at CMC Markets in London (Reuters) – Online trading platform CMC Markets Plc said on ... Read more »

M&G will take a minority stake in digital wealth manager Moneyfarm

© Reuters/DADO RUVIC Illustration shows a smartphone with displayed M&G plc logo LONDON (Reuters) – British money manager M&G said on Wednesday it has taken a minority stake in digital ... Read more »

Let's Learn How To Get Acrylic Paint Out Of Carpet In 7 DIY Steps

© homify / Rose Rigan Step 9: Final result You can now use your carpet again! Do you see, easy-peasy! There are other options you can use when you want ... Read more »

Sathyamangalam Tiger Reserve in TN wins TX2 Award for doubling tiger population

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: The Sathyamangalam Tiger Reserve in Tamil Nadu was Tuesday awarded the prestigious international TX2 Award for doubling its tiger population since 2010. Nepal’s ... Read more »

There's Something Left in Pujara But Rahane Out of my Plans If I Was a Selector: Manjrekar

© Provided by News18 There’s Something Left in Pujara But Rahane Out of my Plans If I Was a Selector: Manjrekar One of the biggest talking points in Indian cricket revolves ... Read more »

The uncapped England players eyeing a PSL launch pad

© Alex Davidson/Getty Images Tom Lammonby latches onto a pull © Alex Davidson/Getty Images The PSL has provided countless young players with opportunities to develop since its inception in 2015 ... Read more »

Celebrity birthdays for Jan. 26

Celebrity Birthdays for Jan. 26:   Cartoonist Jules Feiffer is 93.  ’50’s rock ‘n’ roller Huey (Piano) Smith is 88. Sports announcer-actor Bob Uecker is 88. Actor Scott Glenn is 83. Singer ... Read more »

Woman booked for escaping from Covid ward in Chandigarh

Woman booked for escaping from Covid ward in Chandigarh A 30-year-old woman, admitted to the Covid-19 ward, was booked for escaping from the Government Medical College and Hospital, Sector 32, ... Read more »

Ant McPartlin's ex Lisa Armstrong looks sun-kissed as she enjoys being in her ‘happy place' with boyfriend James

LISA Armstrong looked happier than ever as she cosied up to her boyfriend James Green for selfie during a sun-soaked breakaway. The make-up artist, who divorced TV host Ant McPartlin ... Read more »

Cannabis compound CBD stops coronavirus in test tube, but can it treat COVID?

© Provided by Interaksyon Early research suggesting that a popular non-psychoactive compound derived from marijuana might help prevent or treat COVID-19 warrants further investigation in rigorous clinical trials, researchers say. ... Read more »

Dozens missing after boat capsizes off Florida

© US COAST GUARD/AFP via Getty Images US-MIGRATION-MARITIME-ACCIDENT Rescue crews searched late into the night on Tuesday for 39 people reported missing in the Atlantic off Florida by a man ... Read more »

Two Senegalese soldiers killed, nine ‘missing' in The Gambia

© Provided by Al Jazeera The Senegalese army says nine of its soldiers serving in a multinational peacekeeping force in The Gambia have gone “missing” and likely taken hostage by ... Read more »

Second policeman dies as a result of shooting in New York's Harlem neighbourhood

A New York City police officer gravely wounded last week in a Harlem shooting that killed his partner has also died of his injuries, the city’s police commissioner said, adding ... Read more »

KPN lets new customers watch Formula 1 for free

Photo: ANP KPN is trying to bring in new customers by letting them watch Formula 1 for free in the coming year. Existing customers of the provider will continue to ... Read more »

‘Downing Street a crime scene'

A round-up of the headlines from the UK front pages The Sun said that 10 Downing Street is now a “crime scene” as it covered news that the Metropolitan Police ... Read more »

Avenatti trial - live: Stormy Daniels to be cross-examined by former lawyer as he ditches his own legal team

© AP PRI219445088.jpeg LIVE – Updated at 07:14 Michael Avenatti has been granted permission to represent himself at his own trial in Manhattan, setting the stage for him to directly ... Read more »

Human Rights Watch staff targeted using Israeli NSO spyware

© (photo credit: Wikimedia Commons) Human Rights Watch logo Lama Fakih, the US-Lebanese Director of Crisis and Conflict and head of the Beirut office at Human Rights Watch, was targeted ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic