'Crypto Bill Description on Banning Private Crypto Was a Mistake': Ex-Fin Secy who Drafted Bill

Asia's Tech News Daily

'Crypto Bill Description on Banning Private Crypto Was a Mistake': Ex-Fin Secy who Drafted Bill
© Provided by News18 ‘Crypto Bill Description on Banning Private Crypto Was a Mistake’: Ex-Fin Secy who Drafted Bill

With the winter session of the Parliament officially kick-starting, I sat down with Subhash Garg, the former finance secretary who drafted the Crypto Bill to understand what has changed from 2019 to now. The description of the listed bill – The Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill 2021 said that all private cryptocurrencies will be banned and that created a lot of panic among investors. What will be the future of cryotocurrencies in India, let’s find out

What does the government have a tough stance on cryptocurrencies? What are the concerns and do you see it being passed this session?

First of all, I am not so sure whether Crypto Bill is expected any day. The bill has still not been formulated. It has not been considered by the Cabinet and therefore I have even doubts whether this bill will get introduced. Though it’s a long session of four to five weeks, we need to wait for that bill to emerge. I hope it is not a big surprise because so far what we hear is that the government is probably dealing with only the currency aspect of it. The crypto economy and the services is a much larger business now, much larger economy now. And therefore we need to see if it can be confined to only one aspect of the currency.

So I think we need to wait and see what exactly is there.

You were the one who drafted the original crypto bill in 2019. What do you think has changed from since then?

That digital currency is an useful tool for the humanity, if I may say so. But there are certain issues we need to look at. Private players should not be allowed to issue currencies. If you allow one private entity to issue currencies, another can come up with more number of currencies or any other currency and it will create a problem.

This was the main issue with cryptocurrency and the Centre and the Reserve Bank of India are worried about this new phenomenon. And I would say rightly so.

You can not allow cryptocurrency as currency in India and 2019 draft bill largely focussed on that. The bill also proposed to introduce digital rupee or currency as an answer to the private digital currency.

However, the blockchain world of cryptocurrency is way bigger than currency today. Therefore, we need to take into account these aspects when we design the bill today rather than confining it only to currencies.

The description of Crypto Bill which will be introduced during the winter session in the Lok Sabha, said private cryptos to be banned. Any word on what will be banned and what will be left out?

I think this was perhaps a mistake. When you are not even ready with the bill, it is misleading to say that private cryptocurrencies will be banned and to intimate the government about the same. Ideally, the government should discuss with stakeholders and crypto investors and then formulate a bill.

This is a new emerging technologies, no one really fully understands it, whether in the government or in the private sector. Something like cryptocurrency and blockchain technology which has an an enormous future potential, needs to be discussed widely. Then, a decision can be taken keeping in mind India’s best interest.

Do we have a framework ready for RBI’s central bank digital currency?

That also is quite a complex question. There are two major experiments that are going around in the world with respect to the central bank digital currency. It must be noted that the central bank rupee is also central bank currency. The distinction is that this is physical rupee and that is going to be a digital currency.

Now, the retail digital currency would mean that the RBI and government is in the position to put this digital currency with 130 crore people in the country. They will be able to hold that digital currency in their digital wallets on their phones and they would be able to use their digital wallets to make payments.

It’s way more complex that it may sound. Everyone in India does not have a smartphone. How will you create digital wallet for those who use feature phones? A lot of issues need to be solved and discussed before bringing in RBI central bank digital currency.

The crypto industry body has been harping on the fact that each crypto has different use case just like websites and when you call all crypto as currency at large that’s problematic. Do you think that there is lack of understanding somewhere?

Lack of understanding is definitely there. The crypto blockchain world in my view, have three or four broad kind of things. There are further finer variations. One is of course which we have been discussing is the currency aspects. Even in the currency, there are three primary kinds of products.

One is Bitcoin kind of product of currency which is general currency. Now we have very large offerings of what we call stable coins. USDT which not many people in India know, is a stable coin which is now being internationally used and it has been equated with dollars. So one USTD is equal to one US Dollar. That is why this is called stable coins. It maintains in terms of that value. So anyone who thinks that the cryptocurrency is one uniform similar kind of phenomenon, and all these 8,000-9,000 currencies are similar, will be committing a big mistake. This is a very valid question. we must understand.

Is there a thinking about classifying cryptocurrency as an asset where it can be taxed like a commodity?

This is another big mistake. Cryptocurrency is crypto assets, crypto services and this is whole economy. You don’t classify the wheat that you produce, you don’t classify the clothes you produce, as assets. That is too much of oversimplification to treat this as an asset.

I think this is coming from exchanges who have limited interest. They are providing limited services. They’re not the crypto world.

Read all the Latest News, Breaking News and Coronavirus News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Telegram.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Brazil electoral court could ban Telegram app for not fighting fake news

© Reuters/Ilya Naymushin The Telegram logo is seen on a screen of a smartphone in this picture illustration BRASILIA (Reuters) – Brazil’s top electoral authority, the TSE, is considering whether ... Read more »

'Ozark' returns for its final season on January 21 — here's how to watch the critically acclaimed crime drama

Prices are accurate at the time of publication. When you buy through our links, Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more. © Provided by Business Insider Netflix The Netflix ... Read more »

Best of Treasures: Cut overlay vase has superb craftsmanship

© Handout/Handout/TNS This tall vase was probably once part of a pair. (Editor’s Note: This article was originally published June 24, 2019.) Dear Helaine and Joe: What can you tell ... Read more »

Correction: Music Review-The Lumineers story

In a music review published January 14, 2022, about the new Lumineers album, The Associated Press erroneously reported the last name of one of the band’s founding members. He is ... Read more »

'There are no minor incursions'

The U.S. faced a rare retort from an ally that has received millions of dollars in military assistance, the Jan. 6 committee seeks cooperation from Ivanka Trump, and tens of thousands of ... Read more »

What's unusual about this egg sandwich?

A foodie popular for posting healthy recipes has shared how to make an unconventional ‘egg’ sandwich that’s protein packed and vegan. Yumna, from Michigan, who goes by Feel Good Foodie, has ... Read more »

Q&A: Aguilera picks up Spanish full force with "LA FUERZA"

The Associated PressFILE – Christina Aguilera performs at the Latin Recording Academy Person of the Year gala honoring Ruben Blades in Las Vegas on Nov. 17, 2021. Aguilera’s Spanish-Language EP ... Read more »

Lara Trump puts pressure on DeSantis to back Trump in 2024: ‘Let’s give him another opportunity’

© Getty Lara Trump has pressured Ron DeSantis to support Donald Trump in 2024 – Getty Donald Trump’s daughter-in-law Lara Trump has put pressure on Florida Governor Ron DeSantis to ... Read more »

Bentley powers to an eco-friendly future with new Flying Spur Hybrid

Movie stars and moguls moseying through sunny Los Angeles this week may have spotted a new luxury Bentley Flying Spur in traditional British racing green. It’s just one colourful shade ... Read more »

Why some people invest in toys like Lego instead of stocks and commodities

© Provided by ABC News Rafal Skowron has been a Lego fan since the 1990s. (Supplied: Rafal Skowron) Liverpool-based Rafal Skowron has spent $80,000 on his childhood dream toy — Lego. The ... Read more »

The M&Ms are getting a new look to become more ‘inclusive'. People jokingly think they should be hotter.

A newly announced makeover for the beloved M&Ms characters has prompted many on social media to call for the return of the previous, more classic “hot” M&Ms. © Provided by ... Read more »

Covid-19: Which coronavirus rules are changing across the UK?

Wales and Northern Ireland have changed their coronavirus restrictions after England confirmed it would be dropping its Plan B measures from next week. It comes after all four nations have ... Read more »

West Virginia reporter gets hit by SUV, rebounds to finish the shot

Tori Yorgey can only be classified as a true professional. © Twitter Tori Yorgey was hit by an SUV while doing a live hit for her station. The 25-year-old reporter ... Read more »

Crowds will return to outdoor sports events in Wales as restrictions eased

Wales will continue on its roadmap back to coronavirus alert level zero later this month, the first minister has confirmed. © PA From Friday, Wales will move to alert level ... Read more »

HelloFresh's Family-Approved Recipes Will Make Getting Home-Cooked Meals on the Table a Total Breeze

Now that the holidays are firmly in the rearview mirror, parents might be feeling a little uninspired in the kitchen. It can be so tiring to figure out what to ... Read more »

CSX railroad's 4Q profit jumps 23% even though volume slips

The Associated PressFILE – A CSX freight train passes through Homestead, Pa. Feb. 12, 2018. CSX railroad’s fourth-quarter profit jumped 23% even though volume slipped amid the ongoing supply chain ... Read more »

Yellen says Fed, Biden administration will take steps to control inflation

© Reuters/JONATHAN ERNST U.S. Treasury Secretary Yellen addresses the U.S. Conference of Mayors in Washington WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said on Thursday she was confident the Federal ... Read more »

Tolentino backs DoTr 'No vaccination, no ride' policy

© The Manila Times Sen. Francis Tolentino. PHOTO BY ENRIQUE AGCAOILI SENATOR Francis Tolentino, who served as the former chairman of the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA), expressed support for ... Read more »

Jen Psaki admits midterm vote will be legitimate even without election reform bills

White House press secretary Jen Psaki finally acknowledged Thursday that the outcome of November’s midterm election would be on the up and up, even if sweeping election reform measures pushed ... Read more »

London worst hit by the Royal Mail delivery crisis

© Getty Images NHMountPleasantGettyImages-88574921.jpg London has been struck down by the Royal Mail delivery crisis – with one in three of the worst affected postcodes in the UK lying in ... Read more »

Intel CEO to speak on ‘manufacturing leadership' during webcast tomorrow

© Provided by Dot Esports In a last-minute announcement, Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger and SVP and general manager of manufacturing, supply chain, and operations Keyvan Esfarjani are set to lead ... Read more »

Wisconsin bans fan for anti-Asian gesture at Northwestern students

A Wisconsin fan has been banned from future athletic events for making an anti-Asian gesture at Northwestern students. The University of Wisconsin has banned a fan who made an anti-Asian ... Read more »

Mitch McConnell’s viral Black voter comments cause widespread furor

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA Comments by Senate minority leader Mitch McConnell regarding Black voters in the US have gone viral online and sparked widespread outrage. ... Read more »

Ghana: Many feared dead after lorry carrying mining explosives blows up

© Google Maps A screenshot showing an aerial view of Ghana’s western region. An explosion occurred today in Apiate, located between the towns Bogoso and Bawdie. – Google Maps Police ... Read more »

FIFA 22 Luis Figo Prime Icon SBC Leaked

New Icons should be arriving in FIFA 22 Icon SBCs in the coming days, and according to leaks, one of them will be Portuguese legend Luis Figo. Luis Figo’s Prime ... Read more »

Cloudy skies, scattered rains over Bicol, Calabarzon due to the shear line

rain thumbnail weather thumb raindrops rainfall rain in traffic The shear line will be affecting the eastern section of southern Luzon on Friday while the northeast monsoon or amihan will ... Read more »

4 found dead in blizzard in Canada near US border

© Provided by Associated Press Canada Manitoba Border Deaths WINNIPEG, Manitoba (AP) — The bodies of four people, including an infant and a teen, were found in the Canadian province ... Read more »

Does Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel have cross-saves?

© Provided by GamePur With platforms more willing to allow your progression to transfer between systems these days, cross-saves, or cross-progression, has easily become one of the more requested and ... Read more »

30 Non-Boring Valentine's Day Gifts For Your Guy

© Provided by Refinery29 Valentine’s Day can befuddle the best of us. On top of the whole holiday serving as a dedicated relationship reminder (aka whether we have one or ... Read more »

Pokémon Unite alters move stats for most of the game's Pokémon in latest patch

© Provided by GamePur After ten hours of server maintenance, Pokémon Unite re-launched not only with a new playable Defender, but with significant alterations to many of its Pokémon. The ... Read more »

Three men are arrested after man, 73, was killed when bridge collapsed

Police have arrested three man after a 73-year-old man died and two others were left needing hospital treatment when a bridge collapsed during a £900-a-head pheasant shoot. Brian Harwood, of Penrith, ... Read more »

Massive aid arrives in Tonga

© The Manila Times This handout photo taken and released on January 20, 2022 by the Royal Australian Air Force and the Australian Defence Force shows Air Movements Operator Leading ... Read more »

As Omicron fuels COVID fatigue, Canadians weigh the risks for themselves

As the news first spread that the Omicron variant of COVID-19 had entered Canada, Ottawa resident Saad Khan calculated his personal risk tolerance for a very important event — and he ... Read more »

Tennant Creek Mayor recounts moment an escaped prisoner jumped his fence

© Provided by ABC NEWS Richard Henwood, 37, Maximus Cutta, 20, and Ezra Austral, 23, were arrested in Tennant Creek on Thursday. (ABC RN: Stefan Fergueca) The mayor of an outback ... Read more »

Calgary patients treated in ER hallways as paramedics needed for 911 calls

© Oseremen Irete/CBC An ambulance delivers a patient to Foothills Medical Centre in Calgary on Tuesday. Calgary’s ambulance service and hospitals are so stressed that this week patients normally cared ... Read more »

These famous faces are the spitting image of Panini football sticker stars – how many did you have in your collection?

GOT any swaps? Or maybe they’re swappelgangers. This weekend The Sun is giving away FREE Premier League Panini stickers. We look at footie stickers from days gone by and found ... Read more »

Liverpool set up Chelsea showdown with Emirates victory as Arsenal end with 10 men

Even a weekend break was not enough to recharge Arsenal’s batteries. Liverpool won the Covid derby, settled arguments over sick notes once and for all and took Jurgen Klopp’s winning ... Read more »

Kyle Rittenhouse wants his gun back — to destroy it

Kyle Rittenhouse wants his rifle back and says he plans to destroy it. The Illinois teenager, who was acquitted on all charges in November after fatally shooting two people and ... Read more »

Australia news live update: NSW marks deadliest day with 46 Covid deaths; 20 deaths in Victoria; WA delays border reopening

LIVE – Updated at 22:12 Read more »

Channel 4 First Dates: The dating show's original narrator you may recognise from some iconic British comedies

Everyone has a soft spot for television dating shows, they’re sentimental, hopeful, and always entertaining, and Channel 4’s First Dates is no exception. Having been on air since 2013, the ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic