‘Critically flawed': Review of new Tesla sparks debate after writer claims problems with autopilot

‘Critically flawed’: Review of new Tesla sparks debate after writer claims problems with autopilot
© AP

A Tesla Model Y Long Range is displayed on Feb. 24, 2021, at the Tesla Gallery in Troy, Mich. Consumer Reports says electric SUVs generally are among the least reliable vehicles on the road, but it’s not because of the batteries or electric motors that power them. Compact and plug-in gas-electric hybrids were the most reliable category. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio, File)

– AP

A critical review of the Tesla Model Y has caused a stir on social media, where many are complaining that the car, in its current state, should never have been sent to market. Others – especially fans of Tesla and, more specifically, the company’s CEO, Elon Musk – have rushed to defend the car and, by proxy, the CEO.

The debate began when Tim Stevens, an automotive journalist, released a review of the Model Y on CNET’s Roadshow vertical. The review is titled “2021 Tesla Model Y review: Nearly great, critically flawed.”

Unlike other car reviews on the site, Roadshow actually entered into a two-year lease to give the car an extensive analysis over the course of a full lease period. Stevens intends to give the car multiple reviews over the lease period, accounting for changes that may be made to the Model Y over the course of two years.

“The Model Y is a phenomenal achievement in many ways, a great blend of range and practicality and even performance mixed with a suite of unique features that are as useful as they are distinct. But, as it stands, you absolutely should not buy one,” he wrote, before elaborating.

His criticisms included safety concerns – like having to take his eyes off the road to read certain information on the Model Y’s 15 inch central display, which stands in place of a traditional gauge cluster – to more aesthetic complaints, like the SUV’s white interior option. He also noted that the vehicle’s $10,000 premium to upgrade to a Full Self-Driving package was so steep the Roadshow writers would likely never have a chance to sample it for review.

Stevens praised the Tesla’s range and acceleration, but his primary gripe was with the car’s active safety systems.

The writer describes that on a near hourly basis, the 2021 Tesla Model Y would engage its autopilot emergency brake.

“Basically, the car often gets confused and thinks there’s an obstacle ahead and engages the automatic emergency braking system. You get an instant, unwanted and often strong application of the brakes. This is not a problem unique to Teslas,” he wrote. “I’ve experienced it on other cars, but very, very rarely. On our Model Y this happens constantly, at least once an hour and sometimes much more often than that. In a single hour of driving I caught five phantom braking incidents on camera, two hard enough to sound the automatic emergency braking chime.”

Stevens theorised that a decision to remove radar from the Tesla Models 3 and Y in preference of the Tesla Vision optical sensor was to blame for the phantom braking. He ultimately calls the car “unsafe” as a result.

On Twitter, Stevens said it was the “first time in my automotive career I’m outright recommending you do not buy a car.”

For the first time in my automotive career I’m outright recommending you do not buy a car. Our Model Y is flawed. For the why, I encourage you to read the full review. Then, before you attack me for being anti-Tesla, I encourage you to read this thread. https://t.co/bMwFpaY32R

— Tim Stevens (@Tim_Stevens) November 26, 2021

His review rankled some fans of Musk and Tesla, prompting one to accuse the journalist of taking money from Ford or Volkswagen in exchange for a bad review.

“@elonmusk, what’s your guess on how much @VW and @Ford paid Tim Stevens to do this review on the Model Y?” one Twitter user said, delving into conspiracy theories.

Another user with “SpaceX” in their name jumped in to defend the car, calling the author “Timmy” and suggested he turn off the autopilot feature of the $70,000 car whose primary selling point is its self-driving technology in order to avoid phantom braking incidents.

Mr Musk has not acknowledged or responded to the review.

Stevens anticipated blowback and shared his review alongside a tweet-thread explaining his many years writing about not only cars, but about Teslas, pointing out that he had given many of Mr Musk’s vehicles glowing reviews in the past.

“Anyhow, just wanted to throw some context in there so that if you choose to attack me for recommending against the Model Y you can know without doubt that it isn’t me who’s biased,” he wrote.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

News Related


Clubbers mark end of Plan B restrictions by hitting the dancefloor

Thousands of punters took to dance floors across England for a wild Friday night without needing to show Covid passes or use masks for the first time since Plan B ... Read more »

Drink-driver banned after ‘driving through' McDonald's restaurant

A drink-driver has been banned from the roads after crashing into a McDonald’s restaurant, causing extensive damage. Taylor Steel was disqualified from driving for two years after the crash at ... Read more »

Australian Open 2022, Women's Singles Final Live Score and Updates: Barty Breaks Back Twice to Stay Alive in 2nd Set

© Provided by News18 Australian Open 2022, Women’s Singles Final Live Score and Updates: Ashleigh Barty takes the first set 6-3 against Danielle Collins to give herself an important lead ... Read more »

Drew Barrymore surprises fans with ‘open relationship' revelation about Luke Wilson

Drew Barrymore shared details of her “young and wild” days in Hollywood on her talk show. Barrymore, 46, was a child star alongside Kate Hudson, who guested on The Drew ... Read more »

'He absolutely will do it': Why Putin seems poised to attack Ukraine - after one of surest signs yet

There is still no certainty that Vladimir Putin will opt for new military action but Britain, the United States and other NATO allies appear increasingly concerned that hostilities are more likely than a negotiated solution to the crisis. Read more »

Bigg Boss 15 finale: Shehnaaz Gill - Salman Khan cry as they remember Sidharth Shukla; SidNaaz fans say 'this made us numb' – read tweets

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com In the latest promo of Bigg Boss 15, we see Shehnaaz Gill gracing the stage of Bigg Boss 15. It was this platform that gave her ... Read more »

Smriti Khanna mourns her mother's loss. Arjun Bijlani to Kishwer Merchantt, celebs pour condolences

TV actress Smriti Khanna is mourning the loss of her mother, Neeta Khanna. She took to social media today, January 29, to announce the sad news with her fans. Many ... Read more »

Why Virginia governor's tip line is sparking new critical race theory concerns in schools

The Virginia government’s tip line – which encourages parents to report unease over “divisive” teaching and COVID-19 restrictions – has engaged conservatives and riled up liberals. But it’s unclear what ... Read more »

Allu Arjun returns home to a Pushpa themed party by his team; See Photos

© Provided by Pinkvilla Pushpa star Allu Arjun has returned after a 16-day trip to Dubai. Welcoming him, his team threw a small surprise for the actor. The celebration involved ... Read more »

Boris Johnson news - live: Redacted Sue Gray report ‘imminent' as Met Police denies delaying publication

© EPA PRI220404370.jpg LIVE – Updated at 09:24 Boris Johnson is expected to soon receive a copy of a report into the parties held at Downing Street during lockdown. The ... Read more »

Four exciting ways Liverpool could line up with Luis Diaz this season

Luis Diaz appears to be on the brink of a sensational move to Liverpool. Despite Tottenham Hotspur having sniffed around for the Colombian’s signature earlier in the transfer window, the ... Read more »

'Pavitra Rishta': Ankita Lokhande reveals Archana's quality she'd take back home

© IANS Pavitra Rishta Season 2 New Delhi, Jan 29 (IANS) Actress Ankita Lokhande shared that it’s the trait of patience that she would like to take from her ‘Pavitra ... Read more »

Keanu Reeves faces wrath of Chinese netizens over Tibet benefit concert

© Provided by Zee News Washington: Hollywood actor Keanu Reeves has incurred the wrath of “Chinese nationalists” after it emerged earlier this week that he will be performing at an ... Read more »

Ajay Devgn as a fierce cop in crime drama Rudra - The Edge of Darkness trailer looks gritty - Watch

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: OTT giant Disney+ Hotstar’s latest crime thriller, Rudra – The Edge of Darkness trailer has been dropped online. The series is headlined by ... Read more »

Ceesay-Ersatz Tosin verpasst Auftakt: Zürich droht ein Stürmer-Problem

Leader FCZ gehen vor dem Rückrundenstart gegen Servette die Stürmer aus. Aus verschiedenen Gründen. © freshfocus Zürich droht ein Stürmer-Problem Wenn Zürich zum Rückrundenstart auf Servette trifft, steht auch Topskorer ... Read more »

Soll die Schweiz Medien mit Millionen fördern?

Brauchen Schweizer Verlage Unterstützung, um die digitale Transformation zu schaffen? Oder wird an den Bedürfnissen der Bevölkerung vorbei investiert? Die Debatte zum neuen Gesetz läuft auch in unserer Redaktion. © ... Read more »

I'm a psychologist – here's the one thing you must ask the person you're dating about their ex-partners

WHEN in love, it's only natural that people tend to see past the flaws and red flags. But, according to a psychologist, this is might cause you a great deal ... Read more »

I had unusual Covid side-effect that lasted for three weeks after testing positive – my heart rate was through the roof

A WOMAN has revealed the bizarre symptom she still had three weeks after testing positive for Covid. Charlotte Mortlock suffers from an unusually high heart rate “all the time” after contracting ... Read more »

Piers Morgan shares flirty throwback of kiss from Pamela Anderson after her fifth marriage fails

PIERS Morgan has shared a flirty throwback of a kiss from Pamela Anderson after her fifth marriage failed. Broadcaster Piers posted the incredible throwback to his 1.8 million followers on ... Read more »

Snus warning for pregnant women gets approved in Norway

A health label aimed at warning pregnant women of the dangers of using snus whilst pregnant has been approved and will be in use from February 4. Important warning about ... Read more »

Brick homes and rural holidays make poorer children resilient, study finds

© Provided by Times Live According to the research by the University of California and Stellenbosch University, in the Cape Town communities of Khayelitsha, Gugulethu and Mfuleni, living in formal ... Read more »

NATO's on notice in Ukraine crisis: What's next?

© Provided by DW UK troops provide enhanced defense for Estonia under NATO command Romania has long wanted a NATO battlegroup on its territory, similar to those mustered for Estonia, ... Read more »

‘You're not alone' — Linda Mtoba tells moms dealing with identity crisis after birth

© Provided by Times Live Mom to two-year-old Bean, Linda took Twitter to tell other moms who may be going through something similar that their pain and struggle is valid. ... Read more »

Turkey's president appoints new head of statistics agency

ISTANBUL — Turkey’s president has fired the head of the Turkish Statistical Institute, which is responsible for posting official inflation statistics among other data. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s decisions were ... Read more »

Performance besser als Clubsport? - Hyundai i30 N Perf. gegen VW Golf GTI Clubsport 45

Es hat dem Golf GTI nicht an Konkurrenten gemangelt. Kaum einer kam ihm aber so nahe wie der Hyundai i30 N. Nun kommt der koreanische Hot Hatch frisch geliftet, verfügt ... Read more »

New Zealand PM Ardern is self isolating after exposure to COVID positive case

© Reuters/PRAVEEN MENON Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern addresses her supporters at a Labour Party event in Wellington WELLINGTON (Reuters) – New Zealand’s Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has gone into self-isolation ... Read more »

What next for world powers in war-torn Libya?

© Provided by Al Jazeera A member of the Libyan security forces holds a rifle in the city of Misrata in 2020 [File: Ayman al-Sahili/Reuters] At the start of this ... Read more »

Turkey's Erdogan threatens media with reprisals over 'harmful' content

© Reuters/FLORION GOGA FILE PHOTO: Turkish President Erdogan visits Albania ANKARA (Reuters) – President Tayyip Erdogan on Saturday threatened Turkish media with reprisals if they disseminated content that damaged the ... Read more »

DSSSB Recruitment 2022: Over 690 vacancies announced at dsssb.delhi.gov.in, know details

© Provided by Zee News DSSSB Recruitment 2022: The Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board has invited applications from interested candidates for over 690 vacancies it has announced on its official ... Read more »

Karnataka Covid Curbs: Bengaluru schools reopening Monday, night curfew to end; but here's what is restricted

© Provided by The Financial Express Karnataka Coronavirus Restrictions: Karnataka Chief Minister’s Office has announced that gym and exercise swimming pools in state can continue to operate with 50% capacity. ... Read more »

UP Assembly Polls 2022: PM Modi to hold first virtual rally on January 31

© Provided by DNA Prime Minister Narendra Modi will hit battleground Uttar Pradesh by holding a virtual rally on January 31, ahead of Assembly elections in the state. This virtual ... Read more »

Feiern ohne Maske? Warum Paxlovid ein Gamechanger ist – aber nicht das Ende der Pandemie

© keystone Teaserbild Die EU hat grünes Licht für das Corona-Medikament Paxlovid gegeben. Experten sehen einen Lichtblick – doch den Alltag von früher gibt uns das Medikament nicht zurück. Der ... Read more »

Orcas observed devouring the tongue of a blue whale just before it dies in first-ever documented hunt of the largest animal on the planet

© Elliott Hazen under NOAA/NMFS permit 16111 Approaching a blue whale to attach a suction – cup tag Elliott Hazen under NOAA/NMFS permit 16111 A study from Australia is the ... Read more »

Poland's Duda recommends Glapinski for second term as central bank governor -PAP

© Reuters/Agencja Gazeta FILE PHOTO: Poland’s central bank governor-designate Glapinski speaks during a hearing at a parliamentary panel at the Parliament in Warsaw WARSAW (Reuters) – Polish President Andrzej Duda ... Read more »

Apple Revenue, Profit, iPhone Sales, Services All Beat Forecasts In Key Quarter

Apple topped Wall Street forecasts on just about all metrics for its latest fiscal first quarter earnings, with revenue of $123 billion (up 11%, an all time record), EPS of ... Read more »

Patrick Shai described as a loving and resilient person

© Provided by SowetanLive Actor Patrick Shai was on Saturday described as a loving, caring and resilient person. Colleagues family and friends attended the stage and TV actor’s funeral service ... Read more »

SABC news chief's firing points to ANC interference, say editors

© Provided by Times Live Magopeni’s dismissal on Friday followed a disciplinary hearing which found her guilty of misconduct for failing to prevent the broadcast, airing and publication of an ... Read more »

Dyson Airwrap restock: now at Currys in time for Valentine's Day

Currys has gone live with a batch of Dyson AirWrap stock – one of the hardest to get beauty products in the UK. Head on over to the Currys website ... Read more »

Ivan Toney apologises for ‘unacceptable language' after video emerges of Brentford striker berating club

© Getty Images Ivan Toney jan 22 Ivan Toney has apologised after a video emerged online of him saying “f*** Brentford” while on holiday in Dubai. The Bees striker is ... Read more »

'Talks ongoing again' - Wolves receive blow as Fabrizio Romano provides key transfer update

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Donny van de Beek celebrates first Manchester United goal Rumoured Wolves transfer target Donny van de Beek is in talks with Crystal Palace over a ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic