COVID: will the UK vaccinate children under 12?


Some countries, such as the US and Israel, are now offering COVID vaccines to all children aged five and over. It’s a sign of how well vaccine rollout has gone in these places, but also that the pandemic is still raging on. Governments are going further and further to try to stay on top of the virus.

Could the UK follow suit? One group that will help decide is the Joint Committee on Vaccinations and Immunisations (JCVI), the government’s adviser on vaccines. It has “consistently maintained” that when considering COVID vaccines for children, the main focus should be “the benefits to children themselves, balanced against any potential harms to them from vaccination”, rather than any other factors.

When the JCVI weighed up vaccinating the next youngest age group – 12-to-15-year-olds – it found that the benefits were only “marginally greater than the potential known harms”. So marginal, in fact, that it advised against offering vaccines to this group.

So for the JCVI to give the green light to vaccinating over-fives, the health benefits will need to be more compelling than for 12-to-15-year-olds. But what does the evidence say?

Risk vs benefits

A trial of the Pfizer vaccine in children aged five to 11 found it to be both safe and effective. In particular, no cases of heart inflammation (myocarditis) were identified. This has been a rare but noted side-effect of the mRNA-based COVID vaccines in younger people.

However, fewer than 2,000 children were vaccinated in the trial, which is insufficient to accurately identify the risk of such a rare complication. More broadly, there doesn’t yet appear to be sufficient data to estimate the risk of myocarditis in this age group after they get vaccinated. This makes calculating overall risk difficult.

Then there’s the question of benefits. This begins with asking whether the risk from the thing you’re concerned about – in this case COVID – is small enough to forgo interventions to try to control it.

The risk of flu to healthy children is low enough for vaccination to be considered unnecessary. Aleksandra Suzi/Shutterstock

There’s no general consensus about what size a risk has to be to be worth responding to, though a lifetime risk of death of less than one in 100,000 is often considered “tolerable” and less than one in a million “acceptable”.

Researchers have reviewed all deaths in under-18s in England where the person tested positive for COVID shortly beforehand. Of the 61 positive young people who died, COVID contributed to death in only 41% of cases – and of this group, roughly three-quarters were children with chronic or life-limiting illnesses.

Among otherwise healthy children aged five to nine, COVID accounted for substantially less than one death per million each year. This could be deemed a tolerable risk, even though this elevated risk of death may last another year or two as the pandemic continues.

But what about ill health?

Healthy children who get COVID are also much less likely to be hospitalised than older people. Severe disease in the young is mainly seen in children with pre-existing illnesses. The risk of acute ill health for children also leans towards being acceptable.

However, one concern over the JCVI’s decision not to recommend vaccination for 12-to-15-year-olds was whether enough consideration had been given to long COVID. This would be a concern for under-12s, too.

While the JCVI noted that there did appear to be cases of long COVID among 12-to-15-year-olds, it concluded that the “signal” was small and that studies of the issue “had major subjective bias”. Indeed, recall bias and sampling bias are two common issues that can overestimate the prevalence of symptoms (and so the risk of long COVID) in studies like these that are based on self-reporting.

The JCVI didn’t think the evidence of long COVID in teenagers was strong enough to merit acting on. Julija Ogrodowski/Shutterstock

Better study design can reduce some of this bias. For instance, the Office for National Statistics ran a study that compared the prevalence of long COVID symptoms in people who had and had not had COVID. For the children aged two to 11, rates of these symptoms were no different across the two groups. So in this age group, much of what’s reported as long COVID may just be typical illness.

It’s also worth noting that many of the studies described so far involved children with little exposure to the virus. But in September 2021, England’s chief medical officer estimated that about 50% of British children had already caught the virus. That proportion will already be somewhat greater. The benefits of vaccination will be lower in young children if the majority are already immune.

JCVI doesn’t have the final say

Considering all the above, on health grounds the case for vaccinating British primary school children seems no stronger than the case for vaccinating 12-to-15-year-olds. Because these younger children are at even less risk of severe disease than teenagers, it’s unlikely the JCVI will recommend COVID vaccines for them (though it should offer vaccines to young children with prior health conditions that put them at greater risk).

Ultimately, though, the JCVI only advises. On teenagers, the UK’s chief medical officers didn’t take the committee’s advice and rolled vaccines out to them. Wider issues caused by leaving cases unchecked in this age group, such as disruption to education, informed that decision.

At the moment, around 40,000 new infections are being recorded in Britain each day, mainly in children too young to be vaccinated. Young people may now be driving the pandemic in the UK. It’s also feared that the new omicron variant may raise transmission, particularly among the unvaccinated.

So there are grounds on which vaccines could be rolled out to pre-adolescents – but a decision to do so would probably be based on a very broad assessment of the benefits that goes beyond just looking at young people’s health.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Paul Hunter consults for the World Health Organization (WHO). He receives funding from the UK National Institute for Health Research, the WHO and the European Regional Development Fund.

News Related


Dwayne Johnson is making a new video game movie – so what could it be?

Dwayne Johnson has revealed he’s developing a movie based on “one of the biggest, most badass games” of all time – and yes, we’re hoping it isn’t Doom II, too. ... Read more »

Female student ‘chased man across nightclub after he exposed himself on dancefloor'

Suranga Wijethunga, 36, outside Oxford Crown Court. (SWNS) A man exposed his privates and then pressed himself against a woman’s back on a nightclub dance floor, a court heard. Suranga ... Read more »

Girl named 'Ikea' after mum saw TV ad has to change name due to bullying

Jasmine said her mum Linda had agreed to the name change, despite benefiting from perks from the company after her birth. (SWNS) A teenager who was named 'Ikea' after her ... Read more »

Marilyn Manson responds to allegations he ‘raped' Evan Rachel Wood on music video set

Watch: Marilyn Manson denies sexually assaulting Evan Rachel Wood on music video set Marilyn Manson has denied “essentially raping” Evan Rachel Wood on camera while filming a music video in ... Read more »

Adele Did Not Postpone Concert Over COVID, Caesars Palace Sources Claim

Christopher Polk/Getty Images As Adele continues to issue refunds and FaceTime fans who’d shown up in Las Vegas for her abruptly postponed residency, it appears some insiders want to set ... Read more »

Yasmin Chkaifi: Woman stabbed to death in Maida Vale by ‘demon' ex-husband pictured

Yasmin Chkaifi, 43, has been named as the victim of a stabbing in Maida Vale, west London (Family handout/Metropolitan Police) A mother stabbed to death in broad daylight by her ... Read more »

Downing Street parties: The tweets coming back to haunt Boris Johnson

Boris Johnson has been hit by allegations of yet another party said to have taken place at Downing Street while social restrictions were in place to stop the spread of ... Read more »

PUBG going free-to-play has paid off tremendously

PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds has been free-to-play for almost two weeks now and the switch appears to have paid off in a big way. According to PUBG’s parent company Krafton (via GameSpot), ... Read more »

Mobvoi announces super-cheap wireless earbuds with active noise cancellation

Mobvoi has unveiled its new Earbuds ANC, wireless earbuds that boast active noise cancellation and up to 21 hours of battery life. If that wasn’t enticing enough, these lightweight earbuds ... Read more »

Home Depot Presidents' Day sale 2022: when it is and today's best deals

The Home Depot Presidents’ Day sale is always a highly anticipated shopping event with incredible bargains on everything from major appliances, furniture, tools, kitchen devices, and more. We’ve created this ... Read more »

IMF cuts world growth forecast due to omicron, other woes

The International Monetary Fund is downgrading its forecast for the world economy this year, citing the spread of COVID-19’s omicron variant, higher energy prices, an uptick in inflation and financial ... Read more »

Researchers Build AI That Builds AI

By using hypernetworks, researchers can now preemptively fine-tune artificial neural networks, saving some of the time and expense of training. Read more »

Save $150 on the MacBook Air with this deal exclusive to Amazon

Are you looking for a MacBook deal? Thanks to a new voucher, you can currently get the excellent 2020 MacBook Air M1 for its cheapest price so far this year. ... Read more »

Three new Star Wars games are on the way, including Jedi: Fallen Order follow-up

Respawn, the developer behind Jedi: Fallen Order and Apex Legends, is making three new video games set in the Star War universe. Alongside another entry in the Star Wars Jedi ... Read more »

Creating distinction b/w docs, paramedics for ex-gratia on death due to COVID-19 not justified: HC

The Delhi High Court Tuesday said the doctors and paramedic staff of small nursing homes have also provided treatment against COVID-19 to thousands of patients here during the first and ... Read more »

Dottir Freedom On-Grid review

One-minute review The Dottir Freedom On-Grid are sports-focused headphones that deliver rich audio and stay in place even during tough interval workouts. Dottir Audio takes its name from the Icelandic ... Read more »

Microsoft's Satya Nadella, and Google's Sundar Pichai get Padma Bhushan, India's third-highest civilian award

In a big honour for the top India-origin tech prowess that has virtually taken over the Silicon Valley in the US, the Indian government has awarded Padma Bhushan to Microsoft ... Read more »

Battlefield 2042 is losing popularity on Xbox while Steam reviews remain negative

Only two months since it launched, Battlefield 2042 appears to be waning in popularity on Xbox. Initially spotted by Theorry on ResetEra, both the Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S ... Read more »

The Ricoh Theta X is a pocket 360 camera for creating immersive virtual tours

It’s been almost a decade since Ricoh introduced one of the first 360-degree cameras, and now it’s made a new Theta model that brings a few useful, if not entirely ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution, GM to build $2.1 billion EV battery plant

South Korea’s LG Energy Solution (LGES) plans to spend $2.1 billion with General Motors to build a U.S. electric vehicle (EV) battery plant, parent firm LG Chem said on Tuesday. ... Read more »

Hyderabad-based tech startup Darwinbox turns unicorn

Hyderabad-based technology startup Darwinbox has turned unicorn with the raising of $72 million funding in the latest round for global expansion.With this round, the company’s valuation will cross the $1 ... Read more »

3 U.S. States, D.C. Sue Google for 'Deceptive' Location Tracking

Texas, Indiana, Washington State and the District of Columbia each filed suit against Google in their respective state courts on Monday, alleging that the company has implemented “dark patterns” and deceptive ... Read more »

Google Docs will now really let you stamp your mark on your work

Making sure your work gets the respect it deserves will soon be a lot easier in Google Docs thanks to a new privacy tool coming to the service. The word ... Read more »

LG's 65-inch C1 OLED TV drops to record-low price just ahead of the Super Bowl

The big game is just weeks away, and if you’re looking to snag an epic Super Bowl TV deal on a stunning display, then you’re in luck. We’ve just spotted ... Read more »

MWC 2022 cancellations: which brands will be at this year's show?

Mobile World Congress is the largest mobile technology show in the world, and its next iteration is set to take place in Barcelona at the end of February. That’s despite ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro vs Apple AirPods Pro: the noise-cancelling earbuds compared

The Samsung Galaxy Buds Pro arrived in January 2021, following months of leaks and rumors – and with active noise cancellation and 3D audio support, they’re a serious rival for ... Read more »

Norton antivirus features comparison: what you get with Norton plans

Norton has a range of products from basic antivirus to full-featured internet security suites, offering plenty of options for buyers to ensure they can get the right package for their ... Read more »

EU antitrust regulators set new date for decision on Nvidia's Arm deal

EU antitrust regulators have resumed investigation of Nvidia‘s deal for British chip designer ARM, setting a new deadline of May 25 for their decision, a European Commission filing showed. The ... Read more »

Opozycja po spotkaniu z premierem. "Zapowiadają 150 tys. zakażeń dziennie"

© Piotr Molecki/East News Opozycja po spotkaniu z premierem. “Zapowiadają 150 tys. zakażeń dziennie” Zakończyło się spotkanie przedstawicieli rządu z liderami partii opozycyjnych ws. walki z pandemią COVID-19. Lewica opuściła ... Read more »

New Pokémon Legends: Arceus trailer rounds up its original features

Nintendo released a new trailer for Pokémon Legends: Arceus ahead of the game’s launch later this week. The 6-minute ‘overview trailer’ gives a roundup of the game’s main features and ... Read more »

Twitter's Instagram-like feature ‘leaks' again, this is what the new details tell

Twitter has reportedly been working on a new feature that will allow users to create a list of people that can see their certain Tweets. This means that certain tweets ... Read more »

The cheapest Oculus Quest 2 price and deals in January 2022

It’s still tough to find any truly excellent Oculus Quest 2 deals over a year after launch. The VR headset has held firm with its $299/£299 price point over the ... Read more »

Twitter says record number of demands from governments to remove content, these two countries lead

Twitter said governments around the world made requests to remove content from a record number of user accounts between January and June last year, in data to be released by ... Read more »

Highams Park: Children among 19 injured in London bus crash

Five people were taken to hospital after a bus ploughed into a building in London on Tuesday. (PA) Three children and two adults were taken to hospital after a double ... Read more »

Tesla may be about to super-charge its EV Superchargers

Tesla’s Supercharger charging network is one of the automaker’s most visible products, and one of the key ways it differentiates its products while also making them easier to live with ... Read more »

Pfizer and BioNTech launch clinical trial for Omicron-specific vaccine

© AP pfizer omicron vaccine Pfizer Inc and BioNTech have announced the start a clinical trial to test a new version of their vaccine specifically designed to target the Omicron ... Read more »

Automation is bringing brick-and-mortar retail into the 21st century

It’s hard to overstate the value of data-driven solutions in the retail space, and even more so when it comes to the future of store automation. For retailers, in-store automation ... Read more »

Voices: So now a Tory MP is attacking a local newspaper – how low can they go?

Marson’s constituents are perfectly entitled to ask what she thinks about a scandal which has dominated the news for weeks now (UK Parliament) Is Tory MP Julie Marson’s venomous attack ... Read more »

Fight Club given a new ending in China where authorities win

Fight Club given a new ending in China where authorities win The ending of David Fincher’s 1999 film Fight Club has been changed in China. The film featuring Helena Bonham ... Read more »

Middlesex chairman facing backlash for 'outdated' claim 'black people don't like cricket, they like football'

Middlesex chairman Mike O’Farrell The racism furore in county cricket has reignited after the chairman of Middlesex expressed “outdated” stereotypes on why cricket is failing to nurture black and Asian ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic