Courts shouldn't be 'mere tape recorders': SC

courts shouldn't be 'mere tape recorders': sc

Courts shouldn’t be ‘mere tape recorders’: SC

Courts have to take a participatory role in a trial and not act as “mere tape recorders”, the Supreme Court said here and lamented that there is “practically no effective and meaningful cross-examination” by public prosecutors of any hostile witness during hearings of criminal appeals. The apex court said a judge has to monitor the proceedings in aid of justice and, even if the prosecutor is remiss or lethargic in some ways, the court should control the proceedings effectively so that the truth is arrived at.

Observing that relations between the public prosecution service and the judiciary are the very cornerstone of the criminal justice system, a bench headed by Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud said time and again, the top court has said that there should not be any element of political consideration in matters like appointment to post of public prosecutor etc.

The observations by the bench, also comprising Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, came in a judgement while upholding the conviction and life sentence awarded to a man for murdering his wife in 1995.

“It is the duty of the court to arrive at the truth and subserve the ends of justice. The courts have to take a participatory role in the trial and not act as mere tape recorders to record whatever is being stated by the witnesses,” the bench said in its verdict delivered on Friday.

It said the court must be conscious of serious pitfalls and dereliction of duty on the part of the prosecuting agency.

The bench said a judge is expected to actively participate in the trial, and elicit necessary materials from the witnesses in the appropriate context which he feels necessary for reaching the correct conclusion.

It said any crime committed against an individual is a crime against the entire society and in such circumstances, neither the public prosecutor nor the presiding officer of the trial court can afford to remain remiss or lackadaisical in any manner.

The apex court said while making appointments, like for the post of public prosecutor, the only consideration for the government should be the merit of the person.

“The person should be not only competent, but he should also be a man of impeccable character and integrity. He should be a person who should be able to work independently without any reservations, dictates or other constraints,” it said.

The bench noted that public prosecutors, who are responsible for conducting prosecutions and may appeal against the court decisions, are one of the judges’ natural counterparts in the trial proceedings and also in the broader context of management of the system of criminal law.

Observing that free and fair trial is the very foundation of criminal jurisprudence, the bench said, “There is a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the public at large that the criminal trial is neither free nor fair with the prosecutor appointed by the state government conducting the trial in a manner where frequently the prosecution witnesses turn hostile”.

It noted that over a period of time, the apex court has noticed while hearing criminal appeals that there is practically no effective and meaningful cross-examination by the public prosecutor of a hostile witness.

“The only thing that the public prosecutor would do is to bring the contradictions on record and thereafter prove such contradictions through the evidence of the investigating officer. This is not sufficient,” it said.

“What we are trying to convey is that it is the duty of the public prosecutor to cross-examine a hostile witness in detail and try to elucidate the truth and also establish that the witness is speaking a lie and has deliberately resiled from his police statement recorded under section 161 of the CrPC,” the bench said.

The top court was dealing with an appeal filed by the convict challenging the May 2014 judgement of the Delhi High Court which had affirmed his conviction and life term awarded to him by the trial court.

According to the prosecution, the appellant had married in 1982 and in December 1995, he murdered his wife due to their strained marital relationship.

The police had claimed that his minor daughter, who was five years old at the time of the incident, was the sole eye-witness to the incident.

The bench noted that during the trial, the minor failed to support the prosecution’s case and was declared a hostile witness.

While dismissing the appeal, the apex court noted it should not overlook the fact that the appellant had inflicted 12 blows with a knife on the deceased who was unarmed and helpless.

“For all the foregoing reasons, we have reached to the conclusion that the high court committed no error in affirming the judgment and order of conviction passed by the trial court, holding the appellant guilty of the offence of murder of his wife,” it said.

Noting that the appellant has undergone almost 11 years of imprisonment so far and is about 65 years old, the bench granted him liberty to prefer an appropriate representation addressed to the state government praying for remission of sentence.

It said if any such representation is filed by the appellant, the state shall look into it and take an appropriate decision in accordance with law within four weeks.

For more news like this visit The Economic Times.

OTHER NEWS

20 minutes ago

Billie Eilish Dances and Sings Along to Kendrick Lamar's ‘Not Like Us' Drake Diss

20 minutes ago

Girls Aloud kick off reunion tour with emotional tributes to late bandmate

20 minutes ago

Mother, 22, is killed after counterfeit airbag exploded during collision, spraying her face with shrapnel

20 minutes ago

Famed GOP advisor and political commentator Alice Stewart is found dead outside after 'medical emergency' aged 58

20 minutes ago

Revealed: Just ONE plane available for mass parachute drop commemorating 80th anniversary of D-Day landings in Normandy - with critics calling it 'an insult to those who made the ultimate sacrifice'

20 minutes ago

Dying Marine vet, 98, finally gets high school diploma while receiving hospice care after dropping out of school to fight in World War Two

22 minutes ago

Russian forces seize village in Kharkiv region amid major push into Ukraine

22 minutes ago

Roberto De Zerbi sees potential new role denied after Brighton exit announcement

23 minutes ago

Taiwan's FM: 'If Russia can do that to Ukraine, China might do the same to Taiwan'

23 minutes ago

Braves get Pierce Johnson back, Travis d’Arnaud injury update

27 minutes ago

PGA Championship: Shane Lowry ties the lowest score in major history

28 minutes ago

Eastern Conference Final Preview: Rangers vs. Panthers

28 minutes ago

Thousands of Brixham residents told they can safely drink tap water again

28 minutes ago

Zahawi: Tories should have held their nerve and stuck with Johnson

28 minutes ago

First look at Laiatu Latu in Indianapolis Colts uniform

28 minutes ago

Labor's housing plan to bring down prices

28 minutes ago

Britain ‘may not be fully prepared to fight full-scale war alone’

28 minutes ago

Seahawks finish final signings of rookie class

28 minutes ago

Buy 300 shares in this glorious ASX 200 dividend stock and create almost $2,000 in passive income

28 minutes ago

Chelsea contact Man Utd target about replacing Mauricio Pochettino

28 minutes ago

Alaalatoa mistake gifts Reece try

28 minutes ago

Renee Ballard Set To Appear In Bosch: Legacy Season 3 Ahead Of Her Own Spin Off

28 minutes ago

Formula One pays tribute to Senna, 30 years after tragic death

28 minutes ago

Pirates Fall to Cubs on Contreversial Call in 9th After Epic Pitchers’ Duel

28 minutes ago

Early retirement of old vehicles won't save the planet, says study

28 minutes ago

Irish media magnate Tony O'Reilly dies aged 88

30 minutes ago

Lowry shoots fifth 62 ever at major, climbs PGA leaderboard

30 minutes ago

Shane Lowry just misses record-breaking 61 en route to clubhouse lead at PGA Championship

30 minutes ago

Erik ten Hag says things are on the up at Manchester United

34 minutes ago

Zara McDermott sizzles in a sheer lace dress as she makes an unlikely presence amongst Hollywood stars at Emilia Perez's Cannes Film Festival premiere

34 minutes ago

Video: The stars are out in Riyadh! Cristiano Ronaldo, Anthony Joshua and Steven Gerrard arrive for Tyson Fury and Oleksandr Usyk's undisputed heavyweight title clash in Saudi Arabia

34 minutes ago

Pep's super six on the brink of history, writes JOE BERNSTEIN: Phil Foden and Kevin De Bruyne among half a dozen Man City stars who have won five titles so far with Guardiola

34 minutes ago

Fans BACK VAR in shock result of Mail on Sunday poll with over 1,000 canvassed… but what is the greatest technology bugbear for supporters?

35 minutes ago

Vanderpump Rules' Ariana Madix and Katie Maloney FINALLY open sandwich shop Something About Her with star- studded soft launch attended by Andy Cohen, Stassi Schroeder, and more

35 minutes ago

Hertz charging Tesla renters for not refilling gas tank

35 minutes ago

Vikings only favored in three games heading into the 2024 season

35 minutes ago

Madhubani Bihar Lok Sabha election 2024: Date of voting, result, candidates, main parties, schedule

36 minutes ago

'Can't believe this': Piastri stripped of front row start

36 minutes ago

Prince William to be an usher at Duke of Westminster’s wedding, without Harry

36 minutes ago

Golf-Schauffele in front at PGA Championship, Scheffler slips back

Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch