Coup anniversary fizzer Soldiers 'failed to deliver' on takeover promises, scholars say

Coup anniversary fizzer  Soldiers 'failed to deliver' on takeover promises, scholars say

Yuttaporn: Reform pledges broken

Thailand has endured two coups over the past 15 years and both revolve around former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra and his political network.

The 2014 power seizure led by then army chief Prayut Chan-o-cha followed months of street rallies triggered by the Yingluck government’s amnesty bill that could have led to Thaksin’s return.

Before that, the 2006 putsch led by then army chief Gen Sonthi Boonyaratglin put an end to street protests sparked by a conflict of interest over the controversial sale of Shin Corp shares by Shinawatra siblings to Singapore’s Temasek for 73 billion baht.

Marking the 15th anniversary of the Sept 19, 2006 coup, the Bangkok Post asked political scientists to share their views on the event and how it has reshaped the political landscape.

2014 takeover a watershed

Stithorn Thananithichote, director of the Office of Innovation for Democracy at King Prajadhipok’s Institute, said that to see the implications of the 2006 coup one should revisit the country’s political environment before the coup.

Thailand witnessed major democratic developments after implementation of the 1997 charter, known as a people-centred and progressive charter, he said.

The 2001 general election witnessed the rise of a major political party that won the polls with a clear mandate to form a stable government.

However, public optimism soon soured. The country’s leader was seen as having overwhelming power and the government was so stable that checks and balance mechanisms failed to work.

“We heard about a parliamentary dictatorship and how the country’s leader couldn’t be scrutinised.

“After the coup, the 1997 charter was seen by some as being ‘ahead of its time’. So the 2007 charter which was written after the coup was more like a compromise with half of the Senate being selected,” he said.

Mr Stithorn said the 2006 coup seems to have divided people into two camps. One believes the 1997 charter would have yielded political reforms by now had it not been superseded and the other predicts the country would have been dominated by a single party system had the coup not taken place.

He said the coupmakers behind in both events sought to meddle with the political system after stepping into power. This led to political conflicts and street rallies as people learned more about their rights and freedom.

In his view, the 2006 power seizure opened a window of opportunity for military intervention in politics, after soldiers stepped away following the 1992 popular uprising.

The coupmakers had also learned from the past and made adjustments as they went along, he said.

In the 2006 event, the political transition was quick and the armed forces quickly returned to barracks as they knew their status was not internationally acceptable.

However, after the latest coup in 2014, the coupmakers came to realise they could stay long in power by avoiding total control.

Even though they seized power and restricted political rights, they did not bluntly suppress freedom of speech, and the media was allowed some room to do its job.

Key independent agencies instrumental to performing checks and balances were also retained and much of national administration focused on social and economic development.

“The 2006 coup opened the door for the military to step back into politics after soldiers left the scene alone for 14 years following the 1992 uprising. They came back with better moves to stay in power.

“It is clear the 2006 coup was a watershed event for the 2014 coup and today’s coupmasters filled in the gaps seen in 2006 takeover,” he said.

No change for the better

Yutthaporn Issarachai, a political scientist at Sukhothai Thammathirat Open University, said no significant democratic development has taken place over the past 15 years despite expectations that coups would lead to something better.

Policy-oriented corruption, seen as rife under the Thaksin administration, has never been tackled while national reforms pledged by the National Council for Peace and Order (NCPO) have not materialised.

Instead, the political changes that followed the two military takeovers have resulted in guided or managed democracy and the 2014 coup is a form of democratic regression, he said.

“The clear change is the greater role played by the military for 15 years. The military has stepped back into the political realm.

“Nobody expected to see them back after the 1991 seizure, but we have seen two coups,” he said.

Mr Yutthaporn said the political environment has worsened with curbs on people’s rights and political divisions intensifying after the 2014 military takeover.

In the 2006 coup, society was divided between supporters and opponents of Thaksin while the current conflict has touched on political ideology and could be a tough challenge to overcome.

He said the young generation has grown up amid political rows and street protests. Their political views are diverse and differ from those of the youngsters who came before them.

However, the country’s political system has failed to keep up.

Political rallies have changed and they are not limited to street demonstrations. There are also social media platforms where young people air their opinions on social issues.

“It may be more difficult to find solutions because our social structure is unable to accommodate it.

“It is an important issue. If we do nothing, we may come to experience what is known as a failed state.”

Another coup is possible because the democratic system is not firmly established and military reforms have yet to take place.

“The biggest question is what they will do next after seizing power,” he said.

According to the academic, the way the military seized power has also changed.

In the 2006, flowers were presented to soldiers as a gesture of support while in the 2014 seizure, the military played the role of mediator between the pro- and anti-government camps and took control when talks failed.

“However, the next one may not be as easy as the previous ones. We’ve gone through major changes,” he said.

Car mob rally to mark anniversary

Nattawut Saikuar, a co-leader of the red-shirt United Front for Democracy against Dictatorship (UDD), will organise a car mob today to mark 15th anniversary of the 2006 coup.

He said the rally is a symbolic movement also intended to convey to the public that the Sept 19, 2006 and the May 22, 2014 coups, and Gen Prayut’s clinging to power are connected.

The rally will start at Asok intersection about 2pm with the procession of cars, taxis and motorcycles will head for the Democracy Monument on Ratchadamnoen Klang Avenue.

An online seminar also will be organised and key speakers will include prominent social critic Sulak Sivaraksa.

Seksakol Atthawong, an assistant minister at the Prime Minister’s Office, meanwhile, warned Mr Nattawut not to exploit the car rally as an attempt to stir up unrest.

Mr Seksakol accused Mr Nattawut of serving Thaksin who now aims to oust the government, not fighting for the public as claimed.

“Rallies led by Mr Nattawut are losing steam as more people know what is what,” he said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Pandemic leads to epidemic The Covid-19 crisis has led to a rapid rise in household trash, including problematic contaminated waste. How the city addresses this may determine Bangkok's future

Bangkok, as the city that generates the highest amount of waste per day in Thailand, saw over 2.2 million tonnes of trash in 2018, according to figures from the Department ... Read more »

A new generation slasher Netflix's There Is Someone Inside Your House is meant for Gen Z audiences but it suffers from a lack of originality and is too predictable

Théodore Pellerin as Oliver ‘Ollie’ Larsson in There’s Someone Inside Your House. DAVID BUKACH/NETFLIX Recycling stories isn't new but common practice in Hollywood. However, it seems to be the main ... Read more »

Time is not on anybody's side Making its Asian premiere in Busan, Jakrawal Nilthamrong's new film is a study of old age and the unstoppable march of time

A scene from Anatomy Of Time. There's the anatomy — the bone and the flesh, supple or flaccid. Then there's time, the cruellest judge of all. In Jakrawal Nilthamrong's Anatomy ... Read more »

Sühring makes World's 50 Best Restaurants list

Sühring restaurant in Bangkok has been named No.40 on the 2021 World's 50 Best Restaurants list, the highest entry from Thailand this year. Celebrated last week in Antwerp, Belgium, the ... Read more »

Double time Chopard's Alpine Eagle Cadence 8HF beats with a high-frequency heart

Alpine Eagle Cadence 8HF in titanium. In 2012 Chopard played a pioneering role in commercialising the world's first chronometer-certified timepiece oscillating at a frequency of 8Hz, for achieving a higher ... Read more »

Asean gets set for the digital era

Asean members are accelerating efforts to upgrade the digital economy within the bloc to brave digital challenges brought about by the pandemic. Trade Negotiations Department director-general Auramon Supthaweethum, who plans ... Read more »

Man offers family's organs to save home

A local government official has offered to sell his family's eyes and kidneys in a desperate bid to raise money after his house and land were seized because he was ... Read more »

Microsoft shuttering LinkedIn in China as rules tighten

LinkedIn is shuttering the Chinese version of its job-focused social network. NEW YORK: Microsoft on Thursday said it will shut down career-oriented social network LinkedIn in China, citing a “challenging ... Read more »

DoH to seek B9bn to fund Pathum Thani road project

The Department of Highways (DoH) is preparing to seek almost 9 billion baht to fund a 10-kilometre road project in Pathum Thani. Sarawut Songsivilai, chief of the department, said the ... Read more »

'Human trafficker' nabbed

A woman was arrested in Samut Prakan yesterday for allegedly luring Thai women into forced prostitution in Bahrain. Police from the Anti-Trafficking in Persons Division, led by its chief, Pol ... Read more »

Trans Netflix staff plan walkout over Chappelle special

Dave Chappelle, 48, has been accused of transphobia over Netflix specials including “The Closer”. LOS ANGELES: Transgender Netflix employees are planning a walkout to protest a Dave Chappelle comedy special ... Read more »

New cocoa fruit drink to make hot chocolate a has bean

Typically, 70 percent of the cacao fruit including the peel, pulp and juice are discarded, with just the beans used to make chocolate. THE HAGUE: Forget hot chocolate: a cold ... Read more »

10,486 new Covid cases, 94 more deaths

Buddhist monks chant prayers during the funeral of a dead Covid-19 patient at Wat Bang Phli Yai in Bang Phli district, Samut Prakan, on Thursday. (Photo: Somchai Poomlard) There were ... Read more »

Russia to lift Covid ban on flights to Thailand, other countries Country reports record daily virus cases, deaths

Planes of Aeroflot and Rossiya Airlines are seen parked at Sheremetyevo International Airport outside Moscow on April 8, 2020. (Reuters photo) MOSCOW: Russia will lift its Covid-19 ban on flights ... Read more »

Snack on the fiery flavours of Thailand Let your culinary imagination run wild with Ging Grai's gourmet popcorn

Popcorn has over the years evolved from a run-of-the-mill snack to gourmet delicacy. It is now offered with imaginative flavours — savoury and sweet. Fine restaurants in big cities wordwide ... Read more »

Zoho foresees hyper-personalisation focus Businesses to rethink sales post-pandemic

Gibu Mathew, vice-president and general manager for Asia Pacific of Zoho Corporation A surge in online engagement once the pandemic is controlled is expected to push various organisations to adopt ... Read more »

Competition office eyes level playing field Complaints have risen the past 4 years

Mr Santichai says as of September, the office has received 99 complaints about unfair trade competition. Complaints about unfair trade competition have risen the last four years since the Trade ... Read more »

PIER: Declining unity may hit growth

Anti-government protesters create flames by lighting up aerosol cans during a demonstration in support of the release of political prisoners outside Bangkok Remand Prison on Wednesday. AFP The Bank of Thailand's ... Read more »

IMF frets over supply-chain bottlenecks Disruptions hobble recovery momentum

Supply-chain bottlenecks may cause shortage of Halloween items. (AFP photo) WASHINGTON: Global finance officials gathered in Washington on Wednesday were focused on finding a way to alleviate supply-chain bottlenecks that are ... Read more »

Value of e-commerce forecast to hit B4tn DTC approach now a prevailing trend

The value of Thailand's e-commerce is expected to grow 6.1% to 4 trillion baht this year, crucially driven by businesses that are sharpening their focus on the business-to-customer (B2C) model ... Read more »

Extravaganza to cost up to B600m Concerts planned by Lisa, Andrea Bocelli

Fireworks light up the sky over the Grand Palace on New Year’s Eve in 2016. WICHAN CHAROENKIATPAKUL The Tourism and Sports Ministry expects to use a budget of 500-600 million baht ... Read more »

Most SMEs under digital attack over past year

Some 65% of Thai SMBs surveyed in the latest cybersecurity study by Cisco have suffered cyber incidents in the past 12 months, as opposed to 56% in Asia Pacific. (Reuters ... Read more »

Clubhouse grew 'way, way too fast', says CEO

The Clubhouse app is seen on a smartphone in this illustration taken on July 13, 2021. (Reuters photo) Clubhouse, the audio-only app designed to be a virtual conference hall, generated ... Read more »

No refunds over jab delivery

The Private Hospitals Association on Thursday said it has no refund policy for people who wish to cancel their Moderna vaccine preorders. However, they can postpone their vaccine appointment or ... Read more »

Chiang Mai battles clusters Minor outbreaks linked to market

Medical workers start Covid-19 vaccination for students at Yupparaj Wittayalai School in Muang district, Chiang Mai, on Oct 4. (Photo: Panumet Tanraksa) Chiang Mai is still experiencing more Covid-19 cases ... Read more »

Govt eyes purchasing Covid pills

The Centre for Covid-19 Situation Administration (CCSA) on Thursday approved a plan to buy 50,000 courses of molnupiravir pills — the world's first oral medication to treat Covid-19. The plan, ... Read more »

Kingdom 'ready' for reopening Curfew hours cut in some provinces

Air passengers check in at Suvarnabhumi airport in Samut Prakan province on Sept 22. (Photo: Varuth Hirunyatheb) Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha on Thursday urged the public, businesses and government to ... Read more »

Thailand Pass set to replace CoE

Immigration officers stand in front of an empty arrivals hall at Bangkok’s Suvarnabhumi International airport amid the spread of the coronavirus disease on June 3, 2020. (Reuters photo) The Ministry ... Read more »

Bangkok Post staff tested

Health personnel of Princ Hospital Suvarnabhumi conducts Covid-19 ATK rapid test for Bangkok Post staff free of charge. The results of all 101 Bangkok Post's workers who underwent testing were ... Read more »

Koh Tao, Phangan ease visitor entry rules

Koh Tao in Surat Thani. (Photo: Supapong Chaolan) SURAT THANI: Authorities have eased restrictions for people entering Koh Tao and Koh Phangan and they will take effect starting today, said ... Read more »

Four women held, 200kg of ganja seized in Hat Yai

Packs of compressed marijuana, weighing 200kg, are displayed during a media briefing in Hat Yai, Songkhla, on Thursday. (Photo: Assawin Pakkawan) SONGKHLA: Four women have been arrested and 200 kilogrammes ... Read more »

Distressed debt guarantor offers to sell family's eyes, kidneys Losing home because friend's wife reneged on tractor loan

Rakthewa Khapim-udomlarp, 48, of Ubon Ratchathani’s Khemarat district, his wife and their two sons, and the signs outside their home offering to sell their eyes and kidneys. (Photo: Good Governance ... Read more »

Why e-commerce in Southeast Asia will overtake the UK within 3 years Thailand is among the stars set to lead this growth across the region

The COVID-19 epidemic has made itself felt across the board. As we have changed our behaviour in accordance with the requirements of fighting the epidemic, it has affected all aspects ... Read more »

PTT and Krungsri in biggest THOR-based loan agreement

The Bank of Thailand (BOT) congratulated PTT Public Company Limited (PTT) in collaboration with Krungsri (Bank of Ayudhya PCL) on a successful THB 6-billion long-term loan facility using Thai Overnight ... Read more »

Lisa, Bocelli asked to join Thai countdowns B200m budget set aside for appearances at Phuket, Bangkok events

Thai-born rapper Lalisa Manoban (left) and Italian opera tenor Andrea Bocelli are being asked by the Tourism and Sports Ministry to join the New Year countdowns in Thailand, says minister ... Read more »

Dark-red zones cut, controls eased

CCSA spokesman Taweesilp Visanuyothin announces new Covid-19 zoning and further easing of disease controls, effective on Saturday, at Government House on Thursday. (Screenshot) On Saturday the number of dark-red provinces ... Read more »

Huawei partners with CSA to fortify cyberspace and promote Cybersecurity awareness among local enterprises

To help businesses, organisations, and enterprises in Singapore strengthen their cybersecurity posture, the Cyber Security Agency of Singapore (CSA) on 14 October 2021 launched its new SG Cyber Safe Partnership ... Read more »

Central Pattana wins ‘Top 10 Developers Award 2021' from BCI Asia Awards 2020/2021

Central Pattana Plc., operator of centralwOrld, CentralPlaza, CentralFestival, and Central Phuket and Thailand’s first luxury outlet Central Village, has won a Top 10 Developers Award 2021 from BCI Asia Awards ... Read more »

Quarantine being lifted, more provinces being opened

Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha confirms Thailand is ready to lift quarantine for fully vaccinated travellers from five countries from Nov 1, and open more provinces to visitors, after chairing a ... Read more »

Woman arrested for procuring for forced prostitution in Bahrain

Wassana Meechan, 54, centre right, is arrested in Phra Samut Chedi district on Thursday morning by plainclothes police. She was wanted on an arrest warrant for collusion in human trafficking ... Read more »