Coronavirus business loans: some directors may have defrauded billions from UK taxpayers

Rishi Sunak announced, the instruction, saw a total, estimates that, through disclosures, have been approximately, has been, relation to, committee stage

From pandemic to scamdemic. HM Treasury, CC BY-SA

In the early days of the pandemic, UK chancellor Rishi Sunak announced business-loan schemes as part of the government’s suite of measures to keep businesses on their feet. This offered businesses the chance to borrow tens and sometimes hundreds of thousands of pounds from participating banks, with relaxed lending criteria and nothing to pay for the first 12 months.

The schemes, which closed to new applicants on March 31 of this year, were part of the instruction from Alok Sharma, then business secretary, to “get the money out there”. This saw a total of £79 billion loaned to British businesses via about 1.7 million loans. Of that, 1.5 million loans amounting to £47 billion were through the bounce-back scheme directed at smaller businesses.

The big question is how much of this is going to be repaid. The House of Commons public accounts committee estimates that the bounce-back scheme alone will lose between £16 billion and £27 billion due to fraud and companies being unable to repay. This is a potential default rate of between 35% and 60% – with losses almost certainly higher once the loans to larger businesses are included. Since all these loans were state-backed, any failures to pay will be shouldered by the taxpayer.

PricewaterhouseCoopers is currently investigating the loan book to help the government to get a more accurate loss estimate and to determine the causes of this massive shortfall. The fact that there are likely to be losses from businesses failing is to be expected under the circumstances, given that so many have had to scrimp to get through the pandemic and may find life harder when the government furlough scheme ends in September.

But fraud also appears to have been a major issue – we are still to find out how much. Parliament is now hastily acting to close a loophole which may have helped unscrupulous directors to turn this taxpayer rescue into an opportunity. So what do we know so far, and what happens next?

The loophole

We already have limited evidence of fraud through disclosures from the Insolvency Service (IS) about a number of directors being disqualified for abusing the loan schemes. They did this, for example, by fraudulently persuading the lenders that their company was a going concern when it was not, and then pocketing the money or transferring it elsewhere.

But there are many directors that the IS can’t easily go after at present. This is where they borrowed under the scheme, took the money, then closed down their company through a dissolution. Directors can dissolve a company if it is solvent, and are supposed to notify creditors ahead of time. Otherwise, they are supposed to use a formal insolvency process such as liquidation, with all the scrutiny that this procedure brings. But the requirements are currently loose enough that a company can be dissolved without following the rules.

Rishi Sunak announced, the instruction, saw a total, estimates that, through disclosures, have been approximately, has been, relation to, committee stage

The law has made it easier for directors to get away with fraud. GaudiLab

Company dissolution certainly has its place in the process of ending companies. It is a normal part of the company life cycle that keeps the Companies House register tidy and up to date. Over the past six years, there have been approximately half a million dissolutions each year.

But it has also created a loophole that directors who dissolve a company will have been able to exploit in this instance. The IS can still go after such directors by restoring the company to the register, but that is a complex process. The police can also bring prosecutions under the criminal law of fraud, but the government wants another option.

The bill

Directors mis-using companies in these kinds of ways is hardly a new phenomenon. There has long been a phenomenon known as “phoenix-ism”, where a director closes down struggling company A, moves all the assets to company B, and leaves all the liabilities with company A. Some of the abuses around the coronavirus business loans fall into this category, as has been discussed in parliament in relation to the loan schemes.

The government is seeking to fix the dissolution loophole with the Rating (Coronavirus) and Directors Disqualification (Dissolved Companies) Bill. The bill will shortly have its third reading in the House of Commons, having recently gone through the committee stage. It is due to progress to the House of Lords after the summer recess.

Assuming the legislation passes, it will widen the net of the IS to seek to disqualify directors who have misappropriated money from the loan schemes using the dissolution loophole. This move is necessary to maintain public confidence, protect the public from unscrupulous directors, and to maintain the integrity of limited-liability companies.

Extending the rules will only work if the IS is given proper funding to pursue this extra class of directors, however. There are no signs that the government is going to do this, and it is vital that this is considered alongside the changes to the rules. The bigger the stick, the better the deterrent.

John Tribe does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Rishi Sunak announced, the instruction, saw a total, estimates that, through disclosures, have been approximately, has been, relation to, committee stage

News Related


Avigna Industrial & Logistics Park to invest Rs 500-600 crore to develop a warehousing project in Karnataka

Expanding its industrial warehouses in the country, Avigna Industrial and Logistics Park, has ventured into Hoskote in Karnataka, with a 4 million sq ft Grade A warehousing facility and will ... Read more »

Yamal's gas production capacity 25% above planned — governor

At the same time, Dmitry Artyukhov continued, it is not clear whether gas production will grow next year Read more »

Ahmedabad Airport to be closed for runway repairs from January - May 2022

Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport, Ahmedabad. Image source: ANI Sardar Vallabhai Patel International Airport could be closed from 3rd January 2022 till May 31, 2022, from 9 am to 6 ... Read more »

How Picnic wants to conquer France and Germany with Bill Gates' millions

Just under two years after the previous investment round, online supermarket Picnic has again raised capital to continue growing. A group of old and new investors is investing 600 million ... Read more »

Gas price surge blamed for UK fertiliser factory shutdowns

Just a day after steelmakers reported disruption to production from soaring energy costs, it emerges that work has been suspended at two UK fertiliser plants. Read more »

A new defence alliance, fast fashion and the future of AI technology

Listen to “A new defence alliance, fast fashion and the future of AI technology.”. A new defence alliance could be a big financial blow for France – as Britain, the ... Read more »

Tobacco giant Philip Morris clinches shareholder backing for inhaler maker Vectura

PMI says the takeover is part of its "beyond nicotine" strategy and aim to become a "wellness" company - but critics fear it could see big tobacco wielding influence over UK health policy. Read more »

ASOS boss sets out sustainability goals

Read more »

John Lewis charters ships to navigate Xmas supply disruption and warns on price pressures

The retailer is no stranger to the sector's supply chain and hiring challenges in the run-up to the crucial Christmas season that seems set to see consumers facing tough spending choices as prices rise. Read more »

Fossil fuel firms sue governments across the world for £13bn as climate policies threaten profits

The majority of the cases are being brought under the Energy Charter Treaty, and are being hosted within the International Centre for The Settlement of Investment Disputes, a branch of the World Bank. Read more »

Why investors in three FTSE 350 firms are cheering the AUKUS security pact

Sky's Ian King says shareholders of Rolls-Royce, BAE Systems and Babcock clearly see hope of lucrative work arising from the sharing of information and resources under the deal. Read more »

Expert: Second Arktika-M satellite launch to assure entire Northern Sea Route coverage

The first special Arktika-M satellite was launched in February 2020 and another such satellite will be launched in 2023 Read more »

Defence Ministry issues SOP for faster verification of bank guarantees during acquisition process

Defence Minister Rajnath Singh The Defence Ministry on Thursday issued a standard operating procedure (SOP) that induces clarity in the steps a buyer has to take to verify bank guarantees ... Read more »

US market will surpass India's in the near future: MPL's Sai Srinivas

Indians love playing games on mobile phones, and home confinement during the pandemic has accelerated the trend. This has triggered a boom that helped Mobile Premier League (MPL), India’s latest ... Read more »

Google, Apple fail to explain their position to Russian senators

According to Deputy Head of Roskomnadzor Vadim Subbotin, the Apple representative was unable to explain the motive of the company’s actions and the Google representative had no power of appointment, so he was not questioned Read more »

Primark vows to make all clothing from recycled or 'more sustainable' materials by 2030

The fast fashion giant also promised to halve emissions, but environmentalists fear the plans are too light on detail. Read more »

Energy watchdog warns on 'record' prices as two more household suppliers fail

Ofgem warns households that gas prices are likely to be "high for some time" as an energy crunch threatens to push up bills further for customers whose fixed tariff deals are expiring. Read more »

NARCL a game-changer for India's bad debt resolution

The banking sector in India has played a pivotal role in the growth and development of the economy. By mobilising deposits and facilitating seamless credit flows, the banking sector is ... Read more »

Damian Lewis recalls filming on the day of 9/11

The Billions star is raising money with BGC in remembrance of the colleagues who were killed during the 9/11 attacks. Read more »

UBS Principal Capital Asia sells IndusInd Bank's shares worth Rs 354 crore

(Image: PTI) UBS Principal Capital Asia Ltd on Thursday sold IndusInd Bank shares worth nearly Rs 354 crore through an open market transaction. Bulk deal data with the BSE showed ... Read more »

9/11 anniversary: City veteran reflects on loss of colleagues

Read more »

Why are there supply shortages in UK?

There is estimated to be a shortfall of around 100,000 lorry drivers - triggered by an exodus of foreign nationals during the pandemic and post-Brexit immigration rules, which is affecting stock levels in supermarkets and fast food chains. Read more »

'The upper reaches of society are going to have to pay' - Sorrell

Read more »

'You can't keep raising business taxes without consequences' - CBI

Read more »

'Inevitable' that prices will rise - Wagamama owner

Read more »

'Major job losses' on the way at travel firms

Read more »

Vacancies are at a record high: Which sectors have the biggest gaps to fill?

Official figures show which parts of the UK economy have the highest and lowest rate of vacancies across their workforces and where the gaps have opened up most quickly - with hospitality and transport among them. Read more »

Fears people will 'struggle to get Christmas presents for their children' amid supply chain woes

Sky's Paul Kelso writes that the government has delayed introducing Brexit customs checks to stop the current global supply chain squeeze becoming a crisis. Read more »

West Midlands 'developing a real cluster sector'

Read more »

M&S blames Brexit as it axes 11 French high street stores

The retailer said supply chain complexities under new trading rules now made it "near impossible" to serve fresh and chilled products to its customers in France to the expected standards. Read more »

Goldman boss credits Birmingham talent for investment

Read more »

Households urged to act on bills as fire adds to leap in power costs

As the £139 hike in the energy price cap prepares to take effect, families are being told time is running out to secure a fixed-price deal that will better protect them from what is likely to come. Read more »

Niti Aayog Vice Chairman emphasises need to reduce carbon footprint in urbanisation

Rajiv Kumar, Vice-Chairman of the NITI Aayog Niti Aayog Vice Chairman Rajiv Kumar on Thursday emphasised the need to reduce carbon footprint in urbanisation and said urban India will be ... Read more »

Sebi mulls carving out separate AIF category to buy distressed loans from banks

Sebi | PC-Shutterstock Markets regulator Sebi is planning to carve out a separate category in Alternative Investment Funds (AIF) whereby such entities can purchase distressed loans from banks and NBFCs. ... Read more »

12th Financial Markets Summit of CII | Focus on secondary market, says Sebi's Ajay Tyagi. Read full text

Ajay Tyagi, chairman of SEBI (Image: Reuters) Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) Chairman Ajay Tyagi on September 16 cautioned retail investors on IPO market frenzy. While speaking at the inaugural ... Read more »

Parle Products forays into cereals category

(Representative Image) Country’s leading biscuits, snacks and confectionery manufacturer Parle Products on Thursday announced its foray into the cereals category. The company has extended its popular brand ”Hide & Seek” ... Read more »