COP26 | If not net-zero, then what?

Asia's Tech News Daily

#climate change, #Conference of Parties (COP), #greenhouse gas emissions, #net zero emission, #opinion, only prospective technologies, ‘territorial, Yamin said in 2019., argued in April

(Image: Shutterstock)

On October 30, world leaders will gather at Glasgow, Scotland for the 26th UN Climate Change Conference of the Parties (COP26). The summit that was postponed last year due to COVID-19, a year that also saw some of the deadliest impacts of Climate Change yet, is expected to accelerate action towards the goals of the Paris Agreement and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). Or at least that is what the world is hoping for.

The science is clear, and emphatic, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in October 2018 concluded that the world needs to halve greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions over the next decade, and reach net-zero carbon emissions by the middle of the century if we are to limit global temperature rises to 1.5 degrees Celsius, and avert a full-blown climate crisis.

As part of the Paris Agreement, every country agreed to communicate or update their emissions reduction targets — their Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) — every five years to reflect their highest possible ambition, and a progression over time.

These targets set out how far countries plan to reduce emissions across their entire economy and/or in specific sectors. Last year, 2020, marked the end of the first five-year cycle. At Glasgow, countries are being asked to come forward with ambitious 2030 emissions reductions targets that align with reaching net-zero by the middle of the century.

Already more than 130 countries have set or are considering a target of reducing emissions to net-zero by mid-century. Businesses and investors have followed suit, with over 2,100 of the world’s largest corporations having set net-zero goals under the UN-backed ‘Race to Zero’ campaign, while asset managers have pledged to deliver net-zero emission portfolios by mid-century at the latest.

Some of India’s largest firms have announced net-zero goals. Mukesh Ambani’s oil-to-telecom conglomerate Reliance Industries Ltd said it will turn ‘net carbon zero’ by 2035. Private lender HDFC Bank Ltd has set 2031-32 target for being carbon neutral, while Tata Consultancy Services Ltd seeks to be there by 2030. Wipro Ltd, Infosys Ltd, Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd, JSW Energy Ltd, and even the Indian Railways have also announced similar plans.

Net-zero is not zero?

Even as the pressure for countries, and corporations, to commit to more ambitious net-zero targets builds up, there has been fierce criticism about the whole concept of the net-zero pledges. Critics point out that any commitment to net-zero emissions by 2050 are fraudulent if they allow expansion of coal, oil and gas, and do not include drastic, and immediate, cuts in current fossil fuel use.

In essence net-zero means achieving a balance between the greenhouse gases put into the atmosphere, and those taken out. The first is to stop releasing GHGs, by cutting emissions; and, second is to remove carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere using ‘negative emissions technologies’ (NETs). For example a country or company cuts most of its emissions through efficiency, and clean energy, then offsets the rest by removing CO2 from the atmosphere or eliminating emissions elsewhere using NETs.

But the main problem is that most NETs are still only prospective technologies — they do not exist as large-scale socio-technical systems ready for deployment.

Moreover, there is scepticism around how countries track, and report, their emissions in the absence of a Paris Rule Book to ensure transparency, and accountability. Currently emissions are tracked on a ‘territorial’ basis, meaning that net-zero targets are only concerned with emissions produced within a particular jurisdiction or territory, which leaves out all emissions arising from the products, and services, consumed in the territory but produced elsewhere. This also paves the way for cross-border carbon leakage, through which countries can simply relocate their polluting activities to other jurisdictions without having to take ownership for the resulting emissions.

It is obvious that net-zero pledges that use offsets simply cannot replace needed emissions reductions, and fossil fuel phase-outs. Also, nature-based offsetting that relies heavily on land use in the global south risks shifting responsibility for emissions made by wealthier nations to those already struggling with the impacts of the climate crisis.

Three of Europe’s leading environmental scientists, University of Exeter’s James Dyke, University of East Anglia’s Robert Watson, and University of Lund’s Wolfgang Knorr condemned the “fantasy of net zero”, and concluded “current net zero policies will not keep warming to within 1.5C because they were never intended to”. They allege that net-zero targets “were and still are driven by a need to protect business as usual, not the climate”.

Central to the race to net-zero debate is the question of equity. Under pressure to announce net-zero targets, India’s Environment Minister Bhupendra Yadav on August 8, said: “Developed countries have usurped far more than their fair share of the global carbon budget. Reaching net-zero alone is not enough, as it is the cumulative emissions up to net-zero that determine the temperature that is reached. India’s cumulative and per capita current emissions are significantly low and far less than its fair share of global carbon budget.”

The principle that rich nations should lead on Climate Change is enshrined in the UN climate convention that dates back to 1992, and was reconfirmed in the Paris Agreement. Therefore, if the science says ‘global net-zero by mid-century’, there is a strong moral case for developed countries adopting an earlier date based on their historical emissions, instead of expecting developing countries (such as India) to make deep carbon-cuts in the same time frame as it is still developing, and fighting poverty while having to rely on an energy-mix that largely relies on fossil fuels.

No alternatives

Unfortunately, there are no alternatives on the COP26 table right now. For all the valid criticism against it, net-zero is the only game in town that many believe can at least start the process of decarbnonisation, not on the scale required, but a start.

Also, no, it was not fossil fuel industries that lobbied for net-zero in the Paris Agreement, but Farhana Yamin, a British-Pakistani climate advocate. Taking inspiration from the success of Montreal Protocol, the treaty to phase out ozone-depleting CFCs, she settled for the simplicity, and universality of zero emissions, “Once people get their heads round this scary idea, they enjoy having this constraint and something to work towards,” Yamin said in 2019.

So what will make net-zero work?

To begin with, net-zero targets should cover all sectors, all GHGs, and all sources of emissions. These targets should in turn be made legally binding to ensure governments are held accountable, and also to ensure industry compliance.

The Paris rulebook should ensure ways of avoiding dodgy emissions accounting. One emissions accounting approach is ownership-based, recommended by researchers studying Chinese overseas coal finance, the principle behind such an approach is that emissions arising from all goods and services owned by a country should count towards its national emissions balance, irrespective of where these are located.

Most importantly, net-zero by 2050 target should have an immediate impact, with measurable, and verifiable, reduction in emissions right now, and not in the distant future. To quote climate activist Greta Thunberg, “Yes we need to balance out some emissions that can’t be eliminated (agriculture, etc.),” she argued in April. “But as it is now I dare to claim that these distant net-zero targets aren’t about that, rather they’re about communication tactics and making it seem like we’re acting without having to change.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Credit cards, personal loans lead debt types among Thais: poll

Credit cards are one of the leading types of debt for Thai people, and debt levels have increased since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic. (Photo: Varuth Hirunyatheb) Credit cards ... Read more »

Amazon India head summoned by ED over alleged Future Group deal irregularities

The Enforcement Directorate is the agency that investigates offenses related to money laundering. (Representative image) The Enforcement Directorate (ED) has summoned Amazon India head, Amit Agarwal, next week over alleged ... Read more »

China's ‘dual-credit' policy that spurred the EV sector will be revised in bid to ensure high quality growth

China’s decision to revise a “dual-credit” policy on carbon emissions that helped electric vehicle (EV) makers boost production is likely to hurt the industry leaders in a trade-off for long-term ... Read more »

Capitalism rethink: innovation needn't come at the expense of worker protection

The Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted major weaknesses in both the US and European capitalism models. In the United States, the crisis has shown the limits of an economic system that ... Read more »

Carmichael link: MSCI to drop Adani Ports from four climate indices

Gautam Adani | Representative image The MSCI Climate Change Index will drop Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone (APSEZ). This comes as the project had been termed ‘severe’. MSCI will ... Read more »

COVID-19: Compulsory PCR tests for UK arrivals are 'huge blow' to travel industry

It is hoped the measures will buy scientists time to learn more about the Omicron variant, but there are fears it will also affect the recovery of an industry hard hit by the pandemic. Read more »

China reportedly takes over Uganda's airport on account of loan default

In what is yet another move to acquire foreign assets on account of default of loans China allegedly has taken over the Ugandan Entebbe International Airport and other assets in ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency Prices Today on November 28: PNT biggest gainer while market remains in red

Most cryptocurrencies are mostly red on November 28. The global cryptocurrency market capitalisation is currently $2.44 trillion, down 1.22 percent in the past 24 hours. Siacoin (SC), the highest gainer on November 27, ... Read more »

Petrol, diesel prices on November 28: Fuel rates remain unchanged for 24 days in row

In Delhi, the petrol price remained unchanged and retailed at Rs 103.97 a litre. (Representative image) Petrol and diesel prices remained unchanged for the 24th consecutive day on November 28 ... Read more »

Cryptocurrency Prices Today on November 27: Bitcoin, LRC, CHR down; Siacoin rises high

Cryptocurrency (Representative image) Most cryptocurrencies are mostly red on November 27. The global cryptocurrency market capitalisation is currently $2.47 trillion, down 6.97 percent in the past 24 hours. Major coins like Loopring ... Read more »

Daily Voice | Don't expect massive listing gains in Star Health IPO, says Gaurav Garg of CapitalVia Global Research

Gaurav garg Gaurav Garg, Head of Research, CapitalVia Global Research is expecting further selling in the market led by FIIs due to rising dollar, and globally new variant of COVID-19 ... Read more »

Sir Ian Taylor - Nine questions for the Prime Minister about Covid tests in NZ

OPINION: I have to declare a potential conflict of interest. I voted for the current Government on the basis that I believed the Prime Minister when she said this would ... Read more »

First wahine Māori to head Pharmac advisory board

By Will Trafford of Maori Television The first wahine Māori will take over as chairwoman of Pharmac’s Advisory Committee, the group that recommends which pharmaceutical drugs should be funded by ... Read more »

Black Friday price hikes and fake sales on the rise, says PriceSpy

Black Friday has become one of the biggest sales days around the world but new research shows some discounts may be dud deals. Pricing and comparison service PriceSpy says nearly ... Read more »

Black Friday shopping in stores drops 28 percent from pre-pandemic levels

Shoppers shifted to buying online and started earlier in the year, according to preliminary data from Sensormatic Solutions. Read more »

Nike and G-Dragon collaborate on taekwondo-inspired sneakers

Nike is again collaborating with K-pop icon and rapper G-Dragon for a Taekwondo sneaker called Nike Kwondo1 to be released under the artist's streetwear line PEACEMINUSONE. The all-white shoe carries ... Read more »

Bayern Munich asked to end Qatar Airways $22.5 million per year sponsorship deal on human rights grounds

Bayern’s sponsorship deal with Qatar Airways is worth around $22.5 million annually, with the five-year term set to expire in 2023. Bundesliga champions Bayern Munich's recent annual general meeting saw ... Read more »

POSCO building hydrogen supply infrastructure in Pohang

According to the agreement, the POSCO group will establish a large diameter piping system to enable a massive hydrogen supply while keeping hydrogen prices competitive. POSCO would set up infrastructure ... Read more »

Watchdog assures clothing from recycled plastic bottles is safe

The consumer watchdog asked authorities to include recycled material garments among clothes subject to environment labeling certification, The Korea Consumer Agency concluded that clothes made with recycled plastic bottles generally ... Read more »

Black Friday shopping in stores drops 28% from pre-pandemic levels as shoppers spread spending throughout the season

Shoppers with bags from various stores stand next to each other as Black Friday sales begin at The Outlet Shoppes of the Bluegrass in Simpsonville, Kentucky, November 26, 2021.Jon Cherry ... Read more »

Police arrest at least 30 Extinction Rebellion activists over Amazon warehouse blockades

Police officers are pictured beside an Extinction Rebellion (XR) protest outside an Amazon warehouse in Tilbury, Essex, on 26 November, 2021. (AFP via Getty Images) At least 30 Extinction Rebellion ... Read more »

'Religious vandalism': Tripura CM asks DGP to review UAPA cases against social media users

Tripura Chief Minister Biplab Deb (Image: Twitter/@BjpBiplab) Tripura Chief Minister Biplab Kumar Deb on Saturday asked Director General of Police VS Yadav to “review” the cases against the 102 social ... Read more »

Tight regulations await top NBFCs looking for entry into banking

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on November 26 accepted 21 out of 33 recommendations of an internal working group on the ownership guidelines and corporate structure of private sector ... Read more »

Blockchain start-up Kingspin Technology Services starts operations in India

Representative image Kingspin Technology Services, a Keralite-driven UAE based blockchain start-up on Saturday launched its services in India with an aim to spread its wings in Kerala with Kochi as ... Read more »

‘Supermarkets massively sell bottles of soft drinks without a deposit', investigation inspection

Supermarkets sell bottles of soft drinks without a deposit, while they are legally obliged to ask for a deposit. It concerns a hundred liquor bottles, often of their own private ... Read more »

'I use it for life': Mike Tyson joins the list of celebrities launching a cannabis line

In this handout image Mike Tyson attends the Hublot x WBC “Night of Champions” Gala at the Encore Hotel on May 03, 2019 in Las Vegas, Nevada.Omar Vega | HUBLOT ... Read more »

Top 10 best read on DFT: energy and houses

The prediction by a leading energy expert that the oil price will fall next year attracted most readers. There was also a lot of reader interest for a tasty interview ... Read more »

COVID-19 update | Maharashtra minister asks Thane authorities to be prepared to tackle new variant scare

Image: Twitter Maharashtra Urban Development Minister Eknath Shinde on Saturday asked Thane district authorities and local civic officials to keep hospital facilities ready and ensure strict adherence among people to ... Read more »

Tata Steel focuses on increasing iron ore production to 45 mtpa in 5 years

File image Tata Steel will focus on augmenting iron ore production from 30 million tonne per annum to 45 mtpa in the next five years, a company official said on ... Read more »

Black Friday popular, Dutch bought for record

Payment service iDEAL recorded an “absolute” daily record on Friday, of 5.39 million payments, which accounted for approximately €430 million in turnover. About 70% more was bought online via iDEAL ... Read more »

Black Friday extremely popular, the Dutch bought for record

Payment service iDEAL recorded an “absolute” daily record on Friday, of 5.39 million payments, which accounted for approximately €430 million in turnover. About 70% more was bought online via iDEAL ... Read more »

Mauritius to stop flights from South Africa from November 28 over new coronavirus variant

(Representative image) Mauritius will suspend all commercial passenger flights from South Africa from Nov. 28 due to the new coronavirus variant Omicron, its foreign affairs ministry said on Saturday. A ... Read more »

Moneycontrol PRO presents Intrazon 2.0 on Sunday, 28th November, at 8 pm, with Dinesh Nagpal on ‘Harmonics & Ichimoku Trading (HIT) for intra day'

Dinesh Nagpal | PC-MoneyControl INTRAZON 2.0 is one of the largest retail Intraday Traders Online Conferences to be organised in India. Some of the best intraday traders in India will ... Read more »

‘Black Friday popular, sold a quarter more than last year'

According to Klarna, the Dutch have been interested in the offers from the first minute of Black Friday. In the first hour, the Swedish-based company noticed a 780% increase in ... Read more »

S. Korean scientists develop hydrogen fuel engines strong enough to power industrial drones

The engine supplies hydrogen fuel through the direct spray method while optimizing engine parameters, such as spray and ignition. The Korea Institute of Machinery and Materials has developed a 5-kilowatt ... Read more »

World on alert as UK reports cases of omicron COVID variant

The Associated PressA sign reading ‘Stay safe’ in Regent Street, in London, Friday, Nov. 26, 2021. A slew of nations moved to stop air travel from southern Africa on Friday, ... Read more »

Here are the 21 recommendations out of 33 accepted by RBI on ownership, corporate structure of private banks

Representative image The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has accepted 21 out of 33 recommendations made by an internal working group on the ownership and corporate structure of private sector ... Read more »

Small Business Saturday holiday shopping is back, and maybe changed forever

Sign on glass reading Thank You For Supporting This Local Business in a bakery in Walnut Creek, California, September 15, 2021. Photo courtesy Sftm. (Photo by Gado/Getty Images)Gado | Archive ... Read more »

Experts, activists say health equity needs more emphasis in fight against climate change

Nearly three decades after the world first came together to address climate change, its impact on human health was a focus of talks this month in Glasgow, Scotland. The 26th ... Read more »

Reusable gift wrap, homemade gifts: Sustainability is on the wish list this holiday season

SustainAble Home Goods sells a selection of eco-conscious products online and also offers cloth wrapping that can be reused.Source: SustainAble Home Goods Some children might be waking up on Christmas ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic