‘Controlling Britney Spears' Review: NYT Documentary Rehashes Trauma to Create Further Exploitation

© FX Network

Every time I think of Britney Spears I can’t help but think of Marilyn Monroe. Like Spears, Monroe was underestimated, abused, and her image remains so heavily exploited that her face is on everything from t-shirts to promoting rehab centers (which you, too, can see every time you travel down Hollywood Boulevard). And while Spears might be inching ever closer to winning the freedom that’s eluded her for the last 13 years, the amount of content that’s being created in her leadup to freedom still feels…scummy?

Case in point: The surprise release of the continuation of The New York Times Presents series, “Controlling Britney Spears” was announced early on Friday. The announcement came about as out of left field as the upcoming release of Netflix’s highly anticipated surprise documentary “Britney vs. Spears.” Where Netflix’s documentary is set to release just one day before Spears’ latest court hearing, this new NYT addendum to last year’s “Framing Britney Spears” feels like a desperate attempt to steal some of the wind from Netflix. This might work for something like the Fyre Festival or Tiger King, but here it feels like two media entities trying to compete for the juiciest reveal of a woman whose life has already been heavily exploited.

More from IndieWire

  • ‘Impeachment’ Star Annaleigh Ashford Wonders Whether We’d Treat Monica Lewinsky Differently Today
  • ‘Y: The Last Man’ Review: Diane Lane Capably Steers FX’s Clunky Comic Adaptation

In the rush to jockey with Netflix, it might have been better to question whether there was anything new to tell, as much of “Controlling Britney Spears” feels like leftover story angles that there weren’t time for in “Framing Britney Spears.” Clocking in at a little over an hour, “Controlling Britney Spears” lacks the urgency of its predecessor. Where that film served as a chink in the armor of Spears’ conservatorship, this documentary comes off as a series of Twitter “Top Trending” topics, detailing the levels of control that Britney Spears was under, from security bugging her phone and placing listening devices in her bedroom to controlling access to her friends.

The security bugging has been discussed in the shadows of the gossip world for a few years, and if The New York Times Presents wanted to truly blow Netflix out of the water, they shouldn’t have played things so safe. Onscreen text discusses 180 hours of audio from Spears, recorded presumably without her knowledge, with one talking head saying he allegedly kept a copy. This copy is never produced on the documentary, nor is there follow-up on what’s on it and why he decided to keep it. For someone who felt it was weird for them to record the audio at all, he didn’t seem equally weirded out keeping a copy. It’s later said much of this audio was taken from her bedroom, though the documentarians never go so far as to question whether her sexual activities were illegally obtained.

© Provided by IndieWire “Framing Britney Spears” – Credit: Courtesy of FX Courtesy of FX

There’s an odd level of respect (or maybe fear) to be too open about what is now presumably being secretly released from those inside the conservatorship, and yet where “Framing Britney Spears” felt like a way of telling Spears’ story, “Controlling Britney Spears” does not. Yes, there are moments that, in hindsight, we’re seeing reflected back in a disturbing way. The documentary includes large swaths of previous documentaries like “I Am Britney Spears” and “Britney Spears: For the Record” that show what we now could constitute as James Spears’ control over his daughter. But this is all a rehash of trauma we’ve heard from numerous sources, from Ronan Farrow to Spears herself.

When “Framing Britney Spears” came out I discussed how the documentary avoided looking at conservatorships as a disability rights issue. It’s something New York Times writer Liz Day said was eye-opening to her upon investigating Spears’ case. And yet it’s still never touched on with regards to Spears’ case. Talking heads discuss how they don’t understand how they missed things, just content to believe it was “part of the conservatorship” and for Spears’ own safety. A clip defining what a conservatorship is uses the elderly, while Day herself won’t say “disabled” but instead uses the word “vulnerable.” It’s hard not to say that people didn’t feel concerned for Spears because that’s so often what happens when the perception of disability is brought in.

It’s possible that Netflix’s documentary could be just as devoid of new material as this, but they both beg the question: When does the documenting of Spears’ trauma start to be its own form of exploitation? Based on what is delivered within the entire hour of “Controlling Britney Spears,” the hope is that just recycling what we missed on social media will be enough to stir the masses towards doing… something? It just doesn’t necessarily feel like caring.

Grade: C-

“Controlling Britney Spears” is now streaming on Hulu.

Best of IndieWire

  • Every IndieWire TV Review from 2021 So Far, Ranked by Best to Worst Grade
  • The Best Shows and Movies on Disney+
  • Every Episode of ‘Rick and Morty,’ Ranked

Click here to read the full article.


Video: New documentary claims Britney Spears was being recorded (NBC News)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Crew Members Injured After Prop Gun Misfires on Alec Baldwin Movie Set

Alec Baldwin has been involved in a shooting on the set of his next movie. The actor’s rep told E! News there was “an accident” involving “the misfire of a ... Read more »

Joel DELEŌN Goes Solo! Singer Talks Single 'La Culpa' and How His CNCO 'Brothers' Took His Exit

Zayn Malik left One Direction. Camila Cabello left Fifth Harmony. Jesy Nelson left Little Mix. And Joel DELEŌN left CNCO. As with most boy bands and girl groups, there seems ... Read more »

Siesta Key's Madisson Hausburg Marries Ish Soto in Romantic Sunset Ceremony

© Provided by People Michael Armstrong/mtv Siesta Key‘s Madisson Hausburg is married! Hausburg said “I do” to fiancé Ismael “Ish” Soto on Thursday — and PEOPLE has exclusive photos from ... Read more »

Whitney Mercilus: Coming to Packers “pumps new life” into me

© Provided by NBC Sports Whitney Mercilus spent his entire NFL career with one team before the Texans released him this week and he’s enjoying his first chance to spend ... Read more »

Watch 'Fantasy Football Live' for last-minute Week 7 news and sit-start advice

It’s Week 7 in the NFL and with SIX teams on bye, there’s no better place to prepare for your fantasy matchup than with the Yahoo “Fantasy Football Live” crew. ... Read more »

ABBA Voyage unbelievable new song Just A Notion is actually a long-lost classic

Last month, ABBA released their first new material for almost forty years. The two singles, I Still Have Faith In You and Don’t Shut Me Down, were the first preview ... Read more »

Here are seven movies to get you in the Halloween spirit

What better way to get in the spooky spirit than curl up and watch some scary flicks. From the creepy crawly to family classics, we’ve got you covered this Halloween. ... Read more »

Kate Beckinsale says her 'very high IQ' is a 'handicap' in Hollywood: 'Not helpful in my career'

Kate Beckinsale is more than just a pretty face. In a new interview this week on The Howard Stern Show, the actress revealed she has a “very high IQ”.  According ... Read more »

Rufus Du Sol's New Album 'Surrender' Has Changed The Iconic Australian Electronic Trio For Good

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd ELLE speaks to drummer James Hunt of renowned Australian electronic band RÜFÜS DU SOL about their new album, ‘Surrender’ and the trio’s epic ... Read more »

Last night on The Bachelorette, Holly showed Australia what consent actually looks like.

To catch up on all The Bachelorette Australia 2021 recaps and gossip, check out Mamamia’s recaps and visit our The Bachelorette hub page. © Getty Images Last night on The Bachelorette, Holly ... Read more »

How Belarus is helping ‘tourists' break into the EU

Belarus has been accused of taking revenge for EU sanctions by offering migrants tourist visas, and helping them across its border. The BBC has tracked one group trying to reach ... Read more »

Congress requests NFL documents on Washington Football Team investigation

The NFL is under fire from Congress over the league’s investigation into the Washington Football Team. Congress requested documents from the league, and questioned whether the NFL was impartial in ... Read more »

California sets new rules for mystery donations made on behalf of lawmakers

California regulators approved new transparency requirements Thursday for charitable contributions made on behalf of politicians with whom the donors may be trying to curry favor, an attempt to reveal wealthy ... Read more »

Supergirl Series Finale Synopsis Reveals Title, Teases a Wedding

© Courtesy of The CW As Supergirl speeds towards its series finale, we now have a title for the closing hour and at least one (romantic) hint at what to ... Read more »

Vanessa Hudgens Reprises All Three of Her Roles in Official Trailer for The Princess Switch 3

Vanessa Hudgens is once again portraying three characters with a royal link in the latest Princess Switch movie. The official trailer for the upcoming Netflix film, titled The Princess Switch ... Read more »

Alec Baldwin Involved in On Set Shooting After Prop Gun "Misfires"

Alec Baldwin has been involved in a shooting on the set of his next movie. The actor’s rep told E! News there was “an accident” involving “the misfire of a ... Read more »

Schumer endorses socialist for Buffalo mayor

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer has endorsed India Walton, a self described socialist, for mayor of Buffalo. “Today, I endorse @indiawaltonbflo, the Democratic nominee for Mayor of Buffalo,” the New ... Read more »

Watch a Marine end a convenience store robbery in a big hurry

A former Marine put a quick end to a 4:30 a.m. robbery attempt in southern Arizona Wednesday. © KNXV Marine stops robbery. Video obtained by ABC News shows an unidentified ... Read more »

DC rolls out old metro cars as derailment inspection and delays continue

Washington, D.C., is bringing old metro cars out of the mothballs as an investigation into a Blue Line derailment last week keeps most of the newer models off the tracks. ... Read more »

Six reasons why the Newcastle United takeover is controversial

The English Premier League football club Newcastle United has been bought by a group led by Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund. © Getty Images Many Newcastle fans have welcomed the ... Read more »

Orangeburg native writes a song to lift spirits over pandemic fatigue

Orangeburg native Tonya Ceasar hopes to lift people’s spirits with her new song called ‘So Worthy.’  The gospel singer-songwriter says she wrote the song during the pandemic last year. Ceasar says ... Read more »

Toby Keith Pays Tribute to John Prine on New Album

Legendary country folk singer-songwriter John Prine had a lot of fans. Bill Murray, Eric Church, Sturgill Simpson, and everyone who wrote him the postcards that were used in his final ... Read more »

Westerville ArtsLine: November brings eclectic mix of options

From autumn painting, teen mosaics and macramé knots to blues, jazz and percussion, the month of November is filled with a variety of art sessions and musical entertainment. Additionally, theatre ... Read more »

Review: Netflix's starry Black western 'The Harder They Fall' is both a dazzler and a muddle

The Times is committed to reviewing theatrical film releases during the COVID-19 pandemic. Because moviegoing carries risks during this time, we remind readers to follow health and safety guidelines as outlined by the ... Read more »

Harris stumps for McAuliffe in Virginia

© AP Photo/Steve Helber Harris stumps for McAuliffe in Virginia DUMFRIES, Va. – Vice President Harris campaigned with Democratic Virginia gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe on Thursday, urging voters to head ... Read more »

Vaccine rejection drives Russia's Covid nightmare

Near the darkened entrance of Hospital Number One in the city of Vologda in Russia’s north-west, an ambulance crew delivers yet another Covid patient, an elderly man struggling to breathe ... Read more »

Genshin Impact: Labyrinth Warriors “A Tricky Situation” Quest Guide

The Labyrinth Warriors event has started in Genshin Impact, which brings a unique roguelike element to the game. The event begins with a quest to introduce the event’s story, even ... Read more »

Young Thug reveals new song with Mac Miller was recorded a day before his death

Rapper Young Thug has revealed his song ‘Day Before’, a collaboration with Mac Miller that closes his new album Punk, was recorded just one day before MIller’s death in 2018. ... Read more »

Ozzy and Sharon Osbourne's love story getting a feature film at Sony Pictures

The lives and epic love story of rocker Ozzy Osbourne and manager and personality Sharon Osbourne will be the subject of an upcoming feature film. The untitled project comes from ... Read more »

Original Yellow Wiggle Greg Page meets new member Tsehay Hawkins

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Yellow Wiggle Emma Watkins announced earlier this week she was leaving the children’s band after 11 years. And The Wiggles have now released ... Read more »

Blake Lively calls out 'disturbing' Instagram post showing daughters' faces: 'You said you would stop'

Blake Lively has hit out at an Instagram account for posting photos of her three daughters with husband Ryan Reynolds. The Gossip Girl alum voiced her disapproval of the Instagram ... Read more »

New Zealand sets 90% vaccine target to end lockdown

New Zealand set a 90-percent vaccination target Friday for scrapping lockdowns as Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern unveiled a plan to open up despite the stubborn grip of the Delta variant. ... Read more »

Allen Robinson returns to limited practice, but Khalil Mack, Akiem Hicks remain out

© Provided by NBC Sports The Bears got receiver Allen Robinson (ankle) back to practice Thursday. He was limited after sitting out Wednesday. Robinson injured his ankle in Week 5 ... Read more »

Pandemic lessons learned must include prioritizing safe and equitable access to cancer screenings

© (Motortion/iStock) Pandemic lessons learned must include prioritizing safe and equitable access to cancer screenings When President Richard M. Nixon signed the National Cancer Act into law 50 years ago, ... Read more »

Novavax (NVAX) Outpaces Stock Market Gains: What You Should Know

Novavax (NVAX) closed at $138.79 in the latest trading session, marking a +1.41% move from the prior day. This move outpaced the S&P 500’s daily gain of 0.3%. Coming into ... Read more »

Notes: Lions defense offers peek into plan of attack against Matthew Stafford

This week, The Detroit Lions defense is tasked with thwarting a Matthew Stafford-led offense firing on all cylinders as Detroit heads to Los Angeles to take on the Rams. © ... Read more »

Murray out of European Open after straight sets loss to Schwartzmann

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Andy Murray ran out of gas at the European Open on Thursday night, going down in straight sets to Diego Schwartzman in the ... Read more »

Boyfriend of US roadtripper Gabby Petito found dead

Human remains found in a Florida nature reserve belong to the boyfriend of murdered road tripper Gabby Petito, US authorities said Thursday. © Handout In bodycam images from August 2021, ... Read more »

Kate Walsh Reflects on the 'Fever Dream' of Reuniting on 'Grey's Anatomy' With Ellen Pompeo

© Richard Cartwright/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images Kate Walsh‘s return to Grey’s Anatomy marked a blast to the past, reuniting her with Ellen Pompeo and reintroducing her beloved character, Addison ... Read more »

NBA's 75 Greatest Players: Kobe Bryant, Dominique Wilkins highlight full list of — yes — 76 players

The NBA tipped off its 75th anniversary season with its list of the top-75 greatest players in league history. However, because of a tie in the voting, 76 players made ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic