Concern over Mane’s motivation for Liverpool exit, and a view from Rwanda on Arsenal link…

The Mailbox discusses Sadio Mane’s reasons for leaving Liverpool. Also: questions for Chelsea over Lukaku; and how their Arsenal deal is viewed in Rwanda.

Get your mails in to theeditor@football365.com…

 

The view from Rwanda

As a Rwandan who has lived in the country for decades, I read Ian King’s article with interest. I would not dispute the fact that we have work to do regarding political space and human rights and I absolutely understand if people feel uncomfortable wearing the shirt with ‘Visit Rwanda’ if they don’t feel like it. However I feel like I need to give a different perspective.

Rwanda has made a remarkable transformation since the end of the Genocide against the Tutsi, but we are still one of the poorest Countries in the world and we desperately need tourists and investment to continue the transformation of the country as well as change the perception of it. The campaign is run and financed by the government because it has the resources but at the end of the day, you don’t need to support the government of Rwanda to visit Rwanda or invest in it. I understand the argument of sportswashing is that it’s hard to disentangle the two and governments benefit from that kind of PR but it’s difficult for me to see how else Rwanda can do this on such a large scale. For a lot of Rwandans, there is so much pride seeing our name on such an iconic shirt and a hope that it can translate into something tangible. There is no guarantee that the benefits will outweigh the costs of course, but that’s the risk you take.

I know the success or failure of Rwanda isn’t exactly high on the list of Arsenal fan’s priorities (which of course is understandable) but I thought you might want the perspective of a Rwandan. When you are a very tiny and poor country which is pretty much only known for war and genocide, your options kind of get narrowed down.

Turiyo Damascene

Kigali, Rwanda

Ian King: Arsenal exhortations to ‘Visit Rwanda’ strike an extremely unpleasant tone for just £10m a year

 

Mane’s motivation

Goodbye Sadio and thanks for the memories, no conversation about forward lines will be complete without the inclusion of SFM.

But Conor’s email got me thinking, just what are the real reasons for leaving?

One last big pay day? Surely you have enough money to see you through, even if you do contribute greatly to other people’s lives,

A new challenge? Surely the Bundesliga is not as challenging as the Premier League, it’s often a stroll for Bayern.

More interesting is his comment “I found myself in Bayern’s plans more than anyone else”. Is this a dig at Liverpool regarding the length of contract on offer? Was he given greater assurances regarding his place in the team.

More worryingly for me, does he feel he has a better chance of winning the Champions League at Bayern than at Liverpool?

I do think future comments will reveal more about his relationships within the team but if Lewandowski stays, he may be in the same situation again.

Playing football at this level shouldn’t be treated as a job (Danny Rose and Paul Pogba may argue differently) and the biggest satisfaction must come from winning, from being and feeling loved by the supporters/club, so to leave one huge club for another is a little baffling/concerning.

Howard (and thanks also Taki, you had moments) Jones

 

Liverpool already had Mane’s replacement

Interesting debate on the loss of Mane at Liverpool over the last couple of days. First of course, it is a loss – no doubt. He had a great end of season and is a special player. Though I also agree that Liverpool have definitely had his best years.

For me though I think one person being slightly overlooked in all this is Jota. One mail commented on the physicality of Mane, as well as his ahem, s-housery. Couldn’t agree more these aspects coupled with his immense skill on the ball made Mane the complete forward player. Jota has all this and still only 25 with plenty of room for improvement. Last season scored 20 goals, got 8 assists, and in some big games. He’s also, I would argue, better in the air than Mane – with only Bobby perhaps matching him.

He’s strong and has a delightful s-housery edge. Can play across the 3 – useful for when Nunez does come in. I wouldn’t be surprised if the starting 3 at the beginning of the season were Salah, Diaz, Jota.

The evolution is in full swing now as our squad ages and I’m excited for the new season.

In conclusion, Sadio is gone…..but Sadio mark II is already in place.

Cheers,

Marc

Can’t blame Lukaku for leaving

Kel asks a question about unsettled players, citing Romelu Lukaku as an example, because he wants to change where he plays football “every two years”. What I’d say in return is that outside of football, it’s perfectly normal to change jobs (or employers) every two or three years, or at least, it’s more frequent than people who have been in the same place forever – the primary evidence against jobs for life are people who have had the same job their entire life. It’s also a little bit unfair to criticise Lukaku for moving around when he was sent out on loan by Chelsea and subsequently sold to two clubs who broke their transfer record to acquire him (and he was Manchester United’s second most expensive signing at that point according to Transfermarkt).

Ex-F365 ace Daniel Storey has said repeatedly about one of his favourite players that Lukaku is at his best as a counter-attacking threat, not playing with his back to goal. While his isn’t the only valid opinion, it is surprising that a club with as many scouting resources as Chelsea would spend as much money as they did on a player who cannot do the job they want him to do very effectively. They could have had Christian Benteke for a fraction of the price. Or could they?

Kel also raises another example of how footballers cannot win, echoing a point made by the late Justin Edinburgh in one of the last interviews he gave to the Non-League Paper. Footballers want to play football, especially in Lukaku’s case with a World Cup imminent. If they aren’t selected and ask to leave, whether permanently or on loan, they are criticised by the likes of Kel and Edinburgh because they lack the desire to fight for a place (or, in real terms, sit on the bench watching others play); if they aren’t selected and don’t get upset about it, they are accused of being all too willing to collect a salary they aren’t seen to be earning (because they seem happy to sit on the bench watching others play while waiting for their opportunities).

There are things Lukaku can be criticised for, but wanting to play in a system that suits his strengths is not one of them, with his track record of thriving in the right environment.

Ed Quoththeraven (will F365 leave my mail intact for editorial integrity, or copy the NLP and edit it for epic banter)

 

Aaron in the middle

Has anyone thought of using Aaron Wan Bissaka at centre-back? Or one of three at the back? It’s obvious he doesn’t fit the modern definition of a full back. He’s not cut from the same cloth as Trent Alexander-Arnold. But I don’t see him being worse than Kyle Walker at CB.

OA

concern over mane’s motivation for liverpool exit, and a view from rwanda on arsenal link…
© Provided by Football365 Man Utd star Wan-Bissaka

Chelsea’s power

Your feature on Granovskaia’s Chelsea signings intrigued me. I think it serves to highlight the true advantage of the kind of wealth Chelsea, city, PSG and the like have. And it’s not simply the spending. Lots of teams spend money. Instead it’s the ability to make mistakes and it not really matter. Lumbered with the some of the big money signings on big money wages, other teams would suffer. They couldn’t move them on and it would impact their ability to buy and their wage bills. But not for Chelsea. Or City. Or PSG. Or, presumably, Newcastle. They can just brute force their way through the transfer market without any consequences. That was stark reading. Puts Liverpool’s success into a greater light.

Rob. (No. Not a Liverpool fan)

 

Books for the beach

Dave, South Wales — excellent question. I’m struggling to fill my non-football days too (Cricket? Golf? Family? – no ta) so I’ve been re-reading some classics. First up, I recommend The Miracle of Castel di Sangro – it’s the account of an American sportswriter Joe Mcginnis, living in this tiny mountain town that has just been promoted to Serie B for the first time. It’s funny, exciting and heart-warming.

Also — My Favourite Year – which is an anthology series including Roddy Doyle, Harry Pearson and Nick Hornby writing about their fave seasons at their clubs. It’s random and hilarious.

Enjoy!

Dan, London

 

…I thoroughly enjoy the idea of suggesting media for football fans to read in the season break.

Currently I’m reading Inverting the Pyramid and The Numbers Game. The former is an excellent book detailing the history of footballing formations and it’s changed and reformations over the years, the latter a look at statistics and their increasing (but still growing) use in football. I’ll admit alot of it goes over my head, and I’m still somewhat a believer of the “vibe” of a player over pure statistical output, but it’s certainly an excellent book

DaraghJohn, Wycombe fan

News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘I’m so anxious:’ Cameron Diaz has come out of acting retirement after eight years

Cameron Diaz is coming out of acting retirement after eight years. The Charlie’s Angels star hasn’t made a film since 2014, when she starred in an adaptation of the musical ... Read more »

Four signings Manchester United could make to avoid worrying Roy Keane prediction

Erik ten Hag’s summer rebuild at Manchester United looks as though it is finally kicking into action after a slow start. United are yet to secure their first signing of ... Read more »

'Ordered a second pair': These 'extremely comfortable' biker shorts will see you through all your summer workouts - and they're under £17

Products featured in this article are independently selected by our shopping writers. If you make a purchase using links on this page, MailOnline will earn an affiliate commission.  If you’re ... Read more »

Early Prime Day deal: This corded Shark vacuum cleaner with 'superb' suction is just £179 at Amazon right now (save £70.99)

Products featured in this article are independently selected by our shopping writers. If you make a purchase using links on this page, MailOnline will earn an affiliate commission. If you’re ... Read more »

COVID-19: Piers Corbyn fined for illegal gatherings held during lockdowns

"It was saddening to have to deal with these incidents where large numbers of people illegally gathered in breach of COVID regulations during a national emergency period," the Metropolitan Police said. Read more »

Prince Charles had ‘very emotional’ meeting with Harry and Meghan’s children, Lilibet and Archie

© Getty Images GettyImages-1402141402.jpg The Prince of Wales met his granddaughter Lilibet Diana Mountbatten-Windsor for the first time this year, as well as reuniting with his grandson Archie Harrison Mountbatten-Windsor ... Read more »

Courtney Lawes will captain England in first game against Australia despite Owen Farrell's return, while Harlequins duo Marcus Smith and Danny Care are also given the nod by Eddie Jones

England have named their squad for the first game against Australia on Saturday Northampton second row Courtney Lawes will be captaining the side  Uncapped Leicester Tigers pair Jack van Poortvliet and Guy Porter are on benchApprentice full-back Henry Arundell could make his debut as substitute Read more »

Jordana Brewster gives a glimpse at her cupping therapy marks as she heads out for breakfast with her sons Rowan and Julian

Jordana Brewster headed out for a family breakfast with her two sons, Rowan and Julian on Wednesday. Donning a cami top for the outing, marks from a recent cupping therapy ... Read more »

Video: Joe Wicks takes his exercise class to the stage as fitness fanatic trains a crowd of thousands in Hyde Park with the aim of beating the world record for a mass workout

Read more »

Video: Em Rusciano profusely apologises for not including transgender MEN while discussing abortion and vows to 'be better' after a fan called her out for using 'exclusionary language'

Read more »

Capitol riot hearings fuel the question: Did Trump commit a crime?

A US house committee has heard dramatic testimony from former White House aides and others about Donald Trump’s relentless efforts to overturn the 2020 election – and his encouragement of ... Read more »

I Went To A Sound Healing Class & Left With Mixed Feelings

© Provided by Refinery29 I have no idea what to expect when I sign up for my first sound healing class. I’m someone who is ‘wellness curious’ in the sense ... Read more »

Video: Furious local blasts motorcyclist and attacks his bike with threatening post-its and a promise to punch him in the face next time - but here's why their wild tirade was completely wrong

Read more »

Video: The Mountain vs Tyson Fury? Gypsy King calls out Icelandic strongman by asking if he can 'take a crushing right hand to the jaw', before Game of Thrones star hits back to confirm he is '100% ready for a war'

Read more »

San Antonio sheriff rips into Abbott for turning migrant trailer tragedy into ‘one big campaign stunt’

© Getty Images GettyImages-1399646444 (1) .jpg The sheriff of Bexar County, which contains San Antonio, has expressed his disappointment and anger at Texas governor Greg Abbott for turning the tractor-trailer ... Read more »

Wimbledon: Emma Raducanu and Andy Murray crash out in second-round

© Provided by The Independent jwplayer-thumbnail-2675111.jpg Emma Raducanu and Andy Murray crashed out of Wimbledon on Wednesday (30 June), losing their second-round matches. Having the Centre Court crowd behind them ... Read more »

Why are we feeding crops to our cars when people are starving?

What can you say about governments that, in the midst of a global food crisis, choose instead to feed machines? You might say they were crazy, uncaring or cruel. But ... Read more »

Michael Owen: The goal I scored against Argentina changed my life

Michael Owen’s career saw him represent clubs as illustrious as Liverpool, Real Madrid, Newcastle and Manchester United, but he is perhaps best remembered for his exploits with the England national team. ... Read more »

Carlton Palmer assesses EFL ace’s immediate future amidst Huddersfield, Luton and Sunderland interest

© Provided by Football League World Rudoni Huddersfield Town and Sunderland have seen bids rejected for AFC Wimbledon midfielder Jack Rudoni early on in this window, as per a report ... Read more »

Cricket-India, Pakistan players may line up together under Afro-Asia Cup revival plan

© Reuters/Andrew Couldridge Tour Match – Leicestershire v India By Amlan Chakraborty NEW DELHI (Reuters) – India’s Virat Kohli could line up beside Pakistan skipper Babar Azam in the same ... Read more »

Alexandro Bernabei Celtic transfer complete as Lanus wish him all the best of success

© Getty Images Alexandro Bernabei has had his transfer to Celtic confirmed by Lanus Lanus have confirmed that Alexandro Bernabei has joined Celtic. The 21-year-old left-back will become Ange Postecoglou’s ... Read more »

Football rumours: Borussia Dortmund set Jude Bellingham’s price at £103m

What the papers say Borussia Dortmund have finally settled on a minimum fee for Jude Bellingham. The Daily Mail, citing Bild, says the club have determined they will not offload ... Read more »

Lewis Bate’s Leeds United path is clearer than ever as he eyes breakthrough season

© Sebastian Frej/MB Media/Getty Images Lewis Bate’s path into first-team football has been made clearer by the arrival of a direct senior role model in Marc Roca. There will be ... Read more »

Cameron Norrie makes promise to Wimbledon fans after Raducanu and Murray defeats

© GETTY Cameron Norrie Cameron Norrie promised home fans “I’m in it to win it” with some of the big British hopes faltering at Wimbledon. The British no. 1 is ... Read more »

Report: Everton have made a ‘lucrative offer’ for an ‘excellent’ PL ace hailed by Van Dijk

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Everton have now made a ‘lucrative offer’ to sign Tottenham winger Steven Bergwijn, who is heavily linked with a move to Ajax, according to 90min ... Read more »

Richarlison fee deadline for Tottenham, Christian Eriksen decision and Clement Lenglet latest

© Photo by Emma Simpson – Everton FC/Everton FC via Getty Images Richarlison could be on his way to Tottenham Hotspur VENMFST: “Is the Lenglet deal as close as reported ... Read more »

Cindy Crawford opts for laid back look in navy top and matching skinny jeans as she steps out for a stroll in Malibu

Cindy Crawford cut a casual figure as she stepped out for a solo stroll in Malibu on Wednesday. The legendary model, 56, opted for a navy shirt for the day ... Read more »

Brooklyn Beckham can't keep his hands off his chic wife Nicola Peltz as the couple pack on the PDA during romantic dinner in St Tropez

They’re in the newlywed bubble after marrying in a lavish ceremony in April. And Brooklyn Beckham looked completely enamored with his wife Nicola Peltz during a romantic break in St ... Read more »

Kanye West threatens to SUE a small Melbourne burger joint – forcing the mega-fan owner to totally rebrand his business

Melbourne burger shop was threatened with legal action by Kanye West's teamCollege Dropout Burgers featured a mural of Kanye and is named after an album The popular burger joint even has dishes named in the American star's honour Shop owner says name will stay the same but Kanye references will be removed Read more »

Transfer news LIVE: Romelu Lukaku completes a sensational return to Inter Milan... while Manchester United edge closer to a Tyrell Malacia deal

Here is Sportsmail’s daily live blog for all the latest transfer news and rumours with a number of high-profile deals expected to be completed imminently.   Read more »

Top Australian professor says it's unlikely mask mandates work to stop the spread of the Omicron Covid variant - and explains how you can protect yourself from the virus

Professor Peter Collignon was skeptical about masks in the Omicron Covid eraHe said our eyes needed to be covered to prevent the spread of the virusProf. Collignon shared a comprehensive American discussion about masks  Read more »

Jack Wilshere 'holds talks' with Arsenal over U23 and U18 coaching roles... with academy manager - and his former team-mate - Per Mertesacker tasked with filling roles vacated by Kevin Betsy and Dan Micciche

Jack Wilshere has reportedly held talks with Arsenal about vacant coaching rolesThe ex-Arsenal and England midfielder is currently unattached and not playing The 30-year-old left Danish side Aarhus last month following a short spell abroadArsenal are looking to fill both their Under-23 and Under-18 coaching positions  Read more »

EXCLUSIVE: Camilla will have to suffer 'Airbnb tourists' making themselves at home next to her Wiltshire country pile after neighbours - whose renovations she's tried to thwart - receive permission to build a holiday let

EXCLUSIVE: Camilla's neighbours of country pile get permission for a holiday letGranted planning permission to build a holiday let accessed by her private roadDuchess of Cornwall previously tried to thwart Wiltshire neighbours' renovations Read more »

RL Today: Hughes exit, Cudjoe future, Ma’u blow & Hopoate return

© PA Images Jack-Hughes-Leroy-Cudjoe-and-Manu-Mau Hughes exit Warrington forward Jack Hughes is set to leave the club when his contract expires at the end of the season. (Yorkshire Live) Several clubs ... Read more »

Several flights cancelled from Heathrow due to 'high passenger numbers'

Several flights from Heathrow have been cancelled today due to passenger numbers exceeding the airport’s maximum capacity. A total of 30 flights have been removed from the morning schedule as ... Read more »

Diabetes: The golden drink that lowers blood sugar - drink 'immediately' after eating

Type 2 diabetes sends a clear signal that your body isn’t processing insulin properly. Insulin is a hormone that’s responsible for regulating blood sugar – the main type of sugar ... Read more »

Oil Down over Growing Concerns About Supply Tightness

© Reuters Oil Down over Growing Concerns About Supply Tightness By Zhang Mengying Investing.com – Oil was up on Thursday morning in Asia as concerns about global supply tightness outweighed ... Read more »

GSB could unearth dream Noble heir as West Ham plot bid for “fabulous” £15m talent - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Brownhill-Burnley-West-Ham-Moyes-Noble-Premier-League-GSB-transfer West Ham United are set to face stern competition in their pursuit of Burnley midfielder Josh Brownhill, according to the latest reports. What’s the ... Read more »

AVFC handed the chance to seal "underrated” £41m signing, it could be bye-bye Mings - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Ake-City-Villa-Gerrard-Mings-Premier-League-transfer Aston Villa are reportedly interested in a move for Manchester City defender Nathan Ake, with the Dutchman seemingly free to leave the Etihad this ... Read more »

Paris Hilton confirms canceling on President Joe Biden to attend wedding of friend Britney Spears

Paris Hilton confirmed that she had to cancel on President Biden to attend the wedding of her friend Britney Spears during a visit on Wednesday on a talk show. The ... Read more »