Companies Amendment Bill should unlock a new era of corporate transparency

Asia's Tech News Daily

The real owners of some companies hide their identities behind opaque legal mechanisms, which may mask political corruption, money laundering or terrorist financing. We should, therefore, welcome the newly published Companies Amendment Bill, which offers a game-changing overhaul of corporate ownership transparency.

Companies Amendment Bill should unlock a new era of corporate transparency
© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved

It was the 1976 film All the President’s Men that popularised the now ubiquitous phrase “follow the money”.

This pithy saying captures the idea that political and other forms of corruption can be revealed by chasing a trail of payments, transfers and donations that ultimately will lead to “an oak-paneled door and behind it will be Mr Big”.

This is indeed what investigative journalists spend many hours meticulously doing by poring through financial records.

But the Mr Bigs and their corporate cousins are often hidden behind a bewildering crowd of intermediaries and fronts, meaning that it is hard, sometimes nigh impossible, to find out who actually owns the shares or securities of a company.

The quest for ultimate beneficial ownership disclosure is one that seeks to pierce through various mechanisms that cloud who really controls and/or benefits from companies – in other words, those who hold beneficial interests.

These mechanisms include the use of shell or front companies to create layers of ownership, nominee shareholdings, the ability to control voting rights and more.

Though “follow the beneficial interest” is perhaps less Hollywood script-worthy, conducting this exercise has led to exposures of high-profile cases where political office bearers have unduly benefited from companies – a potential conduit for kickbacks.

In addition, concealment of beneficial interest holdings from the eyes of authorities and the public is straight out of the playbook for money laundering, as well as the funding of terrorism and other criminal activities.

South Africa’s 2008 Companies Act currently only assists in this exercise to an extent.

For instance, it only requires public (listed) companies to find out information about beneficial interest holders. For context: there are only about 315 companies listed on the JSE.

The Act is therefore severely limited in its scope to require companies to gather and verify information about those who own beneficial interests in them. More importantly, it does not provide means to make this information public.

Sourcing this information has required painstaking, skilled, time-consuming work – something amaBhungane’s investigators will attest to.

Hopefully, this state of affairs will soon change.

On the cusp of progress

The Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (DTIC) published the latest iteration of the Companies Amendment Bill on 1 October for public comment.

The Bill seeks to bring about a host of long-overdue changes to the Companies Act, which came into effect a decade ago.

The Bill includes a potentially game-changing set of amendments to corporate transparency regimes. These include wage gap disclosures and, most excitingly for anti-corruption interest groups such as civil society and investigative journalists, beneficial ownership disclosures.

If enacted in the current form, the amendments will make a number of company records available for public inspection, including memoranda of incorporation, share registers, annual financial statements (with exemptions for companies below a certain size) and registers of beneficial ownership disclosure.

The drafters have introduced the concept of a “true owner” so as to capture relevant information on the registers of beneficial ownership disclosure. The true owner is a natural person possessing one or more of a variety of characteristics in relation to a security, such as ownership, being able to direct the registered holder of the securities (whether directly or indirectly), or being the person in whose benefit the securities enure.

In essence, it is the person – the “warm body” at the end of the chain – who benefits from the security.

There is also a proposed amendment that would require companies to file a copy of their latest financial statements, securities register and register of beneficial ownership with the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission (CIPC) together with their annual return – and (with some exceptions) the public can view these documents on request to the CIPC.

An important proposed change is the extension of criminal liability to directors and prescribed officers of a company for failing to accommodate any reasonable request for access, though it will be a defence for such persons to show that they took all reasonable steps to ensure compliance. It is hoped that this will spur companies into better compliance with such information requests.

These suggested amendments are certainly a step in the right direction. 

However, the Bill contains some drafting errors and is in need of refinement. This includes ensuring that the definition of “true owner” captures the widest possible scope of beneficial ownership, ensuring that disclosure obligations extend to non-profit companies as well, and clarifying certain obligations.

In addition, it doesn’t consider alternative means of disclosure that could make access easier for requesters, and reduce burdens on companies, such as allowing those seeking updated information on shareholding to make requests to the central securities depository, known as Strate.

It’s time for business to get on board

There seems to be some initial indication that organised business will resist these changes. 

Business Leadership SA CEO Busi Mavuso publicly denounced two of the bill’s main concerns – wage gap disclosure and beneficial disclosure – as too onerous, going so far as to say that these changes would “diminish the attractiveness of South Africa as a place for companies to do business”.

This is, with respect, a short-sighted, blinkered approach, especially as it relates to beneficial ownership disclosure.

There is a global shift towards enacting beneficial ownership disclosure laws: Open Ownership reports that 110 countries have committed to beneficial ownership transparency, South Africa among them. 

A number of countries with advanced economies have already implemented disclosure mechanisms. In Africa, South Africa lags behind Nigeria and Ghana, both of whom have extractives industries registers of beneficial ownership online.

It’s no secret that South Africa has a corruption problem. A very big one. 

It certainly can’t help our attractiveness as an investment destination that public funds intended for development and infrastructure, the operation of state-owned companies, and the upliftment of the people whose labour sustains our economy are frequently siphoned away into companies, going up and down chains of subsidiaries, until they wind up in the hands of the corrupt – a process facilitated and shielded by beneficial ownership secrecy.

Of course, this is not to suggest that organised business should not raise concerns about the Bill operating as a sledgehammer rather than a chisel. 

There is scope through this comment period, and as the Bill eventually works its way through parliament, to propose changes that adjust egregiously burdensome obligations appropriately.

But there is no scope to renege on the essential commitment to beneficial ownership transparency contained in the Bill, whether to ease compliance burdens on business or for any other reason. The stakes are just too high.

Companies Amendment Bill should unlock a new era of corporate transparency
© Provided by Daily Maverick Business Leadership SA CEO Busi Mavuso. (Photo: Gallo Images / Masi Losi)

No place to hide

Out of context, the following statement may seem provocative: “The establishment of a company as a vehicle for conducting business on the basis of limited liability is not a private matter.”

But it is not. It is the first sentence of the oft-quoted paragraph 85 in Bernstein v Bester NO, a 1996 judgment of the Constitutional Court.

Ackermann J went on to explain that, when a company is formed, “it draws on a legal framework endorsed by the community and operates through the mobilisation of funds belonging to members of that community”.

The gist of the sentiment is that while companies may be formed to benefit certain individuals, they are a construct rooted in communities. They are imbued with limited legal liability, which gives people the freedom to use them as a means to test business ideas without necessarily risking personal ruin should they fail – risks that are, to some extent, borne by the community.

In exchange for this advantage, companies are not entitled to remain entirely private.

This important principle should not be forgotten when engaging with the Bill. While it may introduce new compliance burdens, these are necessary in service of a greater aim.

No time to lose

Earlier this month, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF, an intergovernmental organisation to combat money laundering) published the Mutual Evaluation Report in respect of South Africa’s anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financial measures. 

While its findings are orientated towards the impact on law enforcement, it made some concerning findings regarding beneficial ownership transparency.

South Africa was found to be “partially compliant” with the requirements for transparency and beneficial ownership of legal persons. The report stated that:

“South Africa meets some of the requirements but there are moderate deficiencies which remain … [Beneficial ownership] information is not always timely available to competent authorities and there is still limited access to such information … Some powers available to access BO information cannot obtain such information as the information is not required to be kept.”

This outcome would not have been wholly surprising to the DTIC. The push for the proposed changes to enhance beneficial ownership transparency was no doubt influenced by our previous, equally poor, assessment against FATF requirements.

This latest report underscores the need to keep up the fight to ensure that the necessary amendments are enacted into law without further delay. 

Transparency that delivers not just to law enforcement agencies, but to the public generally, enables scrutiny by diverse stakeholders, increasing the chances of exposing dodgy deals.

The beneficial ownership transparency changes to the Companies Act have been gestating over many years. AmaBhungane, together with other concerned civil society and private sector actors, have been engaging with the department since 2016 on this issue.

We have read widely, researched comparative laws, made written submissions, attended workshops, had discussions with officials from the Financial Intelligence Centre and CIPC, made presentations to business and industry stakeholders, and consulted with civil society.

In all of this work, we have seen many stakeholders endorse the principle of corporate transparency in recognition of its role in creating a climate in which clean, corruption-free business can thrive.

Will you? DM

Thakur is amaBhungane’s advocacy coordinator.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


New York City ranks 48th out of 57 cities for expats to live and work abroad

© Provided by CNBC New York City ranks 48th out of 57 global cities for expats to live and work abroad in 2021, according to the latest report from InterNations, ... Read more »

‘Top-up' immunity and get booster jab before Christmas parties, Brits urged

Brits are being urged to ‘top-up’ their immunity against Covid-19 by getting a booster vaccine before Christmas celebrations. © Sajid Javid has called on the public to get their booster ... Read more »

UK Omicron cases rise more than 50% in a day

A further 86 cases of the new Omicron COVID variant have been reported in the UK, taking the total to 246. © PA People queue to get their COVID-19 vaccinations ... Read more »

First case of Omicron in Lothian area as Scotland numbers soar

NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde had the largest rise, with 12 more cases, taking its total to 23. © The first case of Omicron in the Lothians has been identified ... Read more »

Gabriella Brooks gushes about BF Liam Hemsworth & his family in a rare interview: I'm very lucky to know them

© Provided by Pinkvilla Gabriella Brooks has a lot of good things to say about her boyfriend Liam Hemsworth and his family! During her interview with the Daily Telegraph‘s Stellar ... Read more »

Ralf Rangnick explains why Martial and Lingard missed his first Man Utd match in charge

© Provided by Metro Ralf Rangnick named an unchanged team for Man Utd v Crystal Palace (Picture: MUTV) Ralf Rangnick has explained why he named an unchanged team for his ... Read more »

Venezuela: Protest gegen Wahl-Wiederholung in Chávez-Bundesstaat

© Keystone/dpa/Jesus Vargas Anhänger der venezolanischen Opposition haben in dem bei den Regionalwahlen hart umkämpften Bundesstaat Barinas gegen die gerichtlich angeordnete Wahlwiederholung demonstriert. “Der heutige Tag in Barinas zeigt die ... Read more »

Russia media blast boss Ralf Rangnick as 'biggest fraud in country's football history'

Ralf Rangnick has faced a heavy backlash from Russian media after he left his role at Lokomotiv Moscow The German left the Russian club when Manchester United came calling as ... Read more »

Grant Shapps gets UK Covid-19 travel restrictions wrong amid fury over U-turn

The Tory Transport Secretary got his own Covid travel rules wrong for more than two hours as he announced new laws that have infuriated critics on both sides. Grant Shapps ... Read more »

Sheffield United duo win Paul Heckingbottom praise after win over ardiff

© Provided by Football League World Premier League – Sheffield United v Burnley Sheffield United ran out 3-2 winners against Cardiff City on Saturday with manager Paul Heckingbottom praising Billy ... Read more »

Dominic Raab admits ‘formal party' in No 10 last Christmas would have broken rules

© Sky News Raab.JPG A “formal party” in Downing Street last December would have been a clear breach of Covid guidelines, Deputy Prime Minister Dominic Raab has admitted. Boris Johnson ... Read more »

William ‘cringes' as he recalls following Taylor Swift on stage ‘like a puppy' to sing with Jon Bon Jovi

© Provided by The Independent Prince William has admitted he followed Taylor Swift “like a puppy” onto a stage to sing along with Jon Bon Jovi during a performance at ... Read more »

Liam Scales scores six minutes into league debut as Celtic beat Dundee Utd

© Alamy Stock Photo Liam Scales marked his Scottish Premiership debut with a goal. LIAM SCALES SCORED his first Celtic goal in an emphatic 3-0 victory over Dundee United. The ... Read more »

Saudi chicken brand Al Baik launches limited deliveries in Dubai

© Provided by The National Al Baik restaurant at Expo 2020 Dubai. Pawan Singh / The National It’s a brand that is as famous for its crispy broasted chicken – ... Read more »

Five stylish new gadgets to try, from coffee makers to robotic companions

© Provided by The National The Anaori kakugama brings centuries-old Japanese cooking techniques into the modern kitchen in a sleek and stylish way. Photo: Anaori Whether you are looking for ... Read more »

Lucas Moura has just scored a thunderbolt for Spurs vs Norwich after lovely team move

© GiveMeSport Lucas Moura scored a banger against Norwich Lucsa Moura scored a rocket in the opening 10 minutes of Tottenham’s Premier League clash against Norwich on Sunday afternoon. The ... Read more »

Final Fantasy XIV's Steam player base has nearly tripled since early 2021—and continues to rise

© Provided by Dot Esports Final Fantasy XIV is going strong this year, and it’s far from stopping with the early access release of its latest expansion Endwalker on Dec. ... Read more »

The Harry Potter actor who left his wife for an actress 18 years older

Finding out about the off-screen lives of your favourite childhood TV characters will never not be strange. Nobody was thinking about the Dark Lord’s love life while he was busy ... Read more »

All new weapons in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1

© Provided by GamePur A new Chapter in Fortnite normally means new weapons, and Chapter 3 is no different. There will be a range of new weapon types that players ... Read more »

J.X. Tiger win the Clash of Clans World Championship Finals 2021

© Provided by Dot Esports J.X. Tiger became the 2021 Clash of Clans world champions after a convincing victory over QueeN Walkers in the grand finals today. The team absolutely ... Read more »

All Aether currents locations in Labyrinthos on Final Fantasy XIV Endwalker

© Provided by Dot Esports New lands have been introduced with Final Fantasy XIV‘s latest expansion Endwalker, and Sharlayan is one of them. The region will be divided into two ... Read more »

Kate Garraway reveals Derek Draper can now say ‘I love you' amid Covid ordeal

© Provided by The Independent Kate Garraway has revealed that her husband, Derek Draper, can now speak a little to say words like “hello”, “thank you”, and “I love you”, ... Read more »

Third party to probe Oxford High's actions ahead of shooting

The latest on captured parents of school shooting suspect The duo is being held on $500,000 bail after allegedly attempting to flee law enforcement.Scott Olson/Getty Images PONTIAC, Mich. — A ... Read more »

Incredible moment great white shark lunges out of water at low flying seagull in narrow escape

DRAMATIC photos show the moment a seagull narrowly escaped death after a shark lunged out of the water trying to swallow him whole. Images show were captured of the attempted ... Read more »

Need for common platform for Public Accounts Committees, says LS Speaker Om Birla

© Provided by Hindustan Times Lok Sabha speaker Om Birla has stressed the need for a common platform for Public Accounts Committees (PAC), Parliament’s audit watchdogs. (ANI PHOTO.) Lok Sabha ... Read more »

Seven, Including 3 Minors, Test Positive for Omicron Variant in Maharashtra; State Tally Rises to 8

© Provided by News18 Seven, Including 3 Minors, Test Positive for Omicron Variant in Maharashtra; State Tally Rises to 8 Seven people have tested positive for the Omicron variant of ... Read more »

Actor Jacqueline Fernandez detained at Mumbai airport, stopped from leaving India

Actor Jacqueline Fernandez stopped by ED at Mumbai airport from leaving India Bollywood actor Jacqueline Fernandez was detained at the Mumbai International Airport by authorities based on a look-out circular ... Read more »

CBSE Class 12 Geography sample paper in MCQ format with solutions

CBSE Class 12 Geography sample paper in MCQ format with solutions The CBSE Class 12 Geography paper is one of the highest scoring papers and if you prepare well, it ... Read more »

Woman taken to hospital after falling on to the tracks at busy London tube station

Night Tube services face more disruption this weekend as drivers stage a second round of strikes in a row over rosters (Yui Mok/PA) (PA Wire) A woman has been taken ... Read more »

Israel's Bennett urges hard line against Iran at nuclear talks

© Provided by Al Jazeera Although Israel is not a party to the negotiations, it has kept up lines of communication with its American and European allies during the talks ... Read more »

N. Zealand convinced Ajaz would take all 20 v India: Ravindra

© Punit PARANJPE Ajaz moved to Auckland with his parents in 1996 and made his debut for New Zealand in 2018 aged 30 New Zealand’s Mumbai-born Ajaz Patel added two ... Read more »

Erik ten Hag blasts Manchester United for Donny van de Beek's lack of progress

Ajax manager Erik ten Hag has labelled Donny van de Beek’s lack of progress at Manchester United as a ‘mortal sin.’ Ten Hag nurtured Van de Beek as a youngster ... Read more »

Soccer-Terrier shines as Rennes demolish St Etienne

(Reuters) – Martin Terrier bagged a hat-trick as Stade Rennais moved into second place in Ligue 1 in style with a 5-0 away demolition of bottom side St Etienne on ... Read more »

Trainer-Knall in der Bundesliga: Leipzig schmeisst Jesse Marsch raus

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Leipzig schmeisst Jesse Marsch raus RB Leipzig reagiert auf den enttäuschenden Saisonverlaufund trennt sich von Trainer Jesse Marsch (48). Das verkünden die Bullen am Sonntagmorgen, zwei ... Read more »

The year 2021: A crisis of meaning

© Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved There is a proliferation of pop-psychology articles with headlines like: “From Shattered Goals to Meaning in Life”; “What is an existential ... Read more »

COVID-19: Gauteng Health vaccination teams robbed

© Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – The Gauteng Health department has condemned the attack on vaccination teams. This is after Vaccination teams in Soshanguve and Kagiso were robbed. Five gunmen ... Read more »

4 kematian akibat Covid-19 di Sabah hari ini, kata Masidi

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menteri Kerajaan Tempatan dan Perumahan Masidi Manjun berkata, empat kes kematian akibat Covid-19 dicatatkan di Sabah, hari ini. KOTA KINABALU: Menteri Kerajaan Tempatan dan ... Read more »

Operasi percubaan e-bus Kota Kinabalu di peringkat akhir, kata QSB

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Perkhidmatan e-bus sesuai dilaksanakan kerana mesra alam sekitar selain mengambil kira penggunaan kenderaan yang dipacu tenaga elektrik semakin mendapat tempat di seluruh dunia, kata ... Read more »

Ford Recalls 115,000 Bronco Sport, Escape SUVs over Brake Issue

© Ford A problem with the rear brake linings in 2021 and a few 2022 models can lead to reduced performance and a longer stopping distance. Some Ford Bronco Sport ... Read more »

4 dead after small plane crashes in California

All four people on board a small plane that crashed in California Saturday are dead, according to the Tulare County Sheriff’s Office. The identities of the victims have not been ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic