Commentary: Ending affirmative action won’t level the playing field. It took me over 30 years to do that for my family

Commentary: Ending affirmative action won’t level the playing field. It took me over 30 years to do that for my family

My son chose “Hispanic or Latino/a/x” in the demographics section of college applications he began filling out two months ago. It was an easy decision for him, though I have quietly agonized over this one box for years. I have encouraged him to excel academically so that no one could claim he had gotten into college because of his ancestry.

As someone who benefited from affirmative action to get into college, I have heard all the ugly insinuations from critics of the policy that considers race and ethnicity during the admissions process. How I didn’t deserve to take up the spot of someone with better academic qualifications. How life must be easy for me since I can check the “Latino” box and automatically get scholarships, awards, jobs, etc.

Opponents of affirmative action argue that simply by eliminating the “race/ethnicity” consideration, the college admission system will automatically convert into a level playing field for all students. Reality is far more complex, as I have discovered now that I’ve experienced the American college journey both as a low-income, first-generation student and, decades later, as a well-educated, middle-class mother shepherding my kids through the same process.

I never thought of myself as disadvantaged while learning English and living in an immigrant household in Santa Ana with few economic resources. It’s only now, as I help my son navigate the college application process, that I’m fully learning what an uphill climb I had throughout my educational path.

Affirmative action, which allows college admissions to take into consideration the race or ethnicity in ranking applicants, is a policy that engenders mixed feelings. Opponents say it bestows an unfair advantage. Supporters like me grudgingly accept it as a corrective measure that we wish was not necessary. Either way, affirmative action is on shaky ground in the Supreme Court.

Legal experts believe Supreme Court justices appear ready to strike down the policy after hearing oral arguments Oct. 31 in two lawsuits filed by Students for Fair Admissions against Harvard and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The group behind the lawsuits was formed by activist Edward Blum, whose failed 1992 congressional bid prompted him to file a successful lawsuit against redistricting that maximized Latino and Black political representation. If the court’s six-justice conservative majority favors the argument by the plaintiff that considering race as part of an evaluation of someone’s qualifications violates the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, it could have far-reaching implications at all higher education institutions and workplaces that consider diversity.

As Justice Sonia Sotomayor noted at the argument: “You’re assuming in your argument that race is the only factor that gets someone into a school.” She added, “sometimes race does correlate to some experiences and not others. If you’re Black, you’re more likely to be in an under resourced school. You’re more likely to be taught by teachers who are not as qualified as others. You’re more likely to be viewed as less academic — as having less academic potential.”

The fact remains that a majority of Native American, Latino, Pacific Islander and Black students suffer from disadvantaged socioeconomic conditions and other factors that affect their academics. Further, these conditions are often the result of policies that have hindered these communities, such as immigration policies that are discriminatory, racially restrictive covenants that spawned overcrowded housing, and disciplinary policies in schools that are unfairly applied to Black and Latino students. Affirmative action has been the imperfect answer to these systemic inequities.

Growing up, I was a bright student whose fondness for books helped me learn English quickly, but I navigated my educational career mostly on my own. My parents expected me to go to college, but their lack of familiarity with the U.S. educational system hampered their ability to help me. They never attended parent-teacher conferences because they didn’t speak English or school functions, such as my track meets in junior high, because of inflexible work schedules in the factories where they worked. Nevertheless, I felt their love and emotional support, which drove me to do my best in school.

Meanwhile, my son and daughter have relied wholeheartedly on my guidance and physical presence every step of the way. I have participated in everything from brainstorming science project ideas and being a room mom in their elementary school years to coaching my son through various drafts of his college essay. I attend all my kids’ cross-country races and track meets in high school. My kids’ bedrooms are filled with medals, plaques and trophies, each one earned in competitions, while I earned one gold medal in high school for language and literature in the Orange County Academic Decathlon.

My son is currently among the top 10 students in his senior class of nearly 750 kids, with an extensive list of extracurricular activities and honors related to his interest in a computer science career, including winning a national championship in cybersecurity. My younger daughter is equally driven, recently starting up a literary magazine by and for teens, in addition to publishing one of her short stories in a book. They have been enrolled in the academically rigorous International Baccalaureate program since middle school.

Being a college graduate has given me the advantage of knowing how best to support and guide my kids’ academic journeys. My kids will not need the special consideration provided by affirmative action during the college application process, though their diverse background is valuable nonetheless. Their dad is white, but they’ve grown up immersed in my Mexican culture. And whatever career field they eventually choose will also benefit from their Latino background. Society benefits from having diverse student bodies, particularly in top universities, to produce workers who can succeed in a diverse workplace.

The landmark Supreme Court case Grutter vs. Bollinger in 2003 reaffirmed affirmative action, allowing college admissions to consider race if other factors also are taken into account. In her majority decision, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote that “race-conscious admissions policies must be limited in time,” further suggesting that affirmative action would be unnecessary in 25 years.

Not surprisingly, conservative justices and the attorney arguing against affirmative action in the current Supreme Court cases have seized upon this time frame to criticize the policy. However, these benchmarks don’t work without systemic overhauls that eliminate all the inequality suffered by students who benefit from affirmative action. For example, increased parent outreach and free tutoring for kids living in disadvantaged areas, and massive expansion of programs such as the Educational Opportunity Program.

In an amicus brief in the Harvard case, the University of California notes that its efforts to create a diverse student body after Proposition 209 eliminated affirmative action in the state have not been entirely successful even 25 years later. It will be 34 years since I graduated high school when my son receives his high school diploma next June. That’s more than three decades of work in my household to try to create a level playing field for my own kids.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Israel's plastic tax repeal signals climate policy shift

Israel's plastic tax repeal signals climate policy shift Israel's new government is moving quickly to repeal a tax on single-use plastic goods like cups, plates and cutlery JERUSALEM — On ... Read more »

Bengals' Germaine Pratt Has NSFW Outburst Over Joseph Ossai's Costly Penalty Vs. Chiefs

Joseph Ossai committed an unnecessary roughness penalty on Patrick Mahomes that set up Kansas City's game-winning field goal in the AFC title game Read more »

Europe's Crackdown on Big Tech Omitted TikTok — But Now That's Set to Change

Unlike its larger American peers, TikTok hasn’t faced the kinds of mega fines or legal penalties that Google, Facebook-owner Meta or Amazon have in the EU over the years. TikTok ... Read more »

How Test cricketer Stuart MacGill allegedly screamed 'you're going down' at his best mate's ex-girlfriend extraordinary foul-mouthed spray: 'His face was red, his pupils were scary'

Former Australian cricketer Stuart MacGill fronted court He is charged with intimidation of his mate's former partner The 51-year-old allegedly yelled at her outside a Sydney pub   Read more »

Hundreds turn out to protest against UK move to block Scottish gender law

Hundreds of people in loud voice and good spirits packed St Peter’s Square this afternoon to protest against the UK Government’s decision to block Scotland’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill ... Read more »

Holly Newton: Boy, 16, to appear in court charged with murder of 15-year-old girl

The boy has also been charged with the attempted murder of another boy, also 16, and possession of an offensive weapon, following the incident in Hexham, Northumberland. Read more »

Video: Inside the 'ridiculously stupid' trend tourists are embracing in Bali to 'build immunity' to Bali Belly

Read more »

Video: Multiple Eagles fans 'suffer injuries' after climbing atop a glass bus stop that quickly collapses under their weight as Philadelphia mayor begs citizens to celebrate NFC title win 'joyously, safely, and respectfully'

Read more »

Madison Brooks news – live: Suspect in LSU student case arrested for alleged rape in 2020

LIVE – Updated at 04:19 One of the three suspects arrested for the alleged rape of Louisiana State University student Madison Brooks is facing a separate charge of first-degree rape ... Read more »

Struggling TransPennine train operator under pressure over £75m payouts

TransPennine Express train on a platform with a passenger boarding – Phil Oldham/PinPep A train operator that runs some of Britain’s worst-performing services is facing calls to halt a programme ... Read more »

Davina McCall tipped to host ITV's new ‘middle-aged Love Island' after talks with bosses

This month, ITV put an official call out that they were looking for single parents across the UK who are on the lookout for love. After admitting she pitched the ... Read more »

Karl Stefanovic takes a subtle dig at his ex Today show co-star Ally Langdon ahead of her debut on A Current Affair

Today show’s Karl Stefanovic took a cheeky dig at his former co-host Ally Langdon ahead of her debut on A Current Affair on Monday night. Karl and new co-host Sarah ... Read more »

Scotland to be hit with 'danger to life' 80mph winds next week as warning issued

Scots should brace themselves for blustery conditions as 80mph are set to blow across the country next week. The Met Office have issued a yellow wind warning for the whole ... Read more »

Seething Celtic punter claims proof over Rangers ref conspiracy triggered by Parkhead penalty – Hotline

Aberdeen pulled the trigger on Jim Goodwin after another humiliating 90 minutes against Hibs. And Willie Collum was in the firing line with Hotline callers for what they reckon was ... Read more »

Original Wednesday Addams Lisa Loring Taken Off Life Support, Dies at 64

ABC Photo Archives/Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images Lisa Loring, the original Wednesday Addams who played the spooky scion in the 1960s sitcom The Addams Family, has died at ... Read more »

Miley Cyrus’ ‘Flowers’ Stays at No. 1 In U.K.

Miley Cyrus’ ‘Flowers’ Stays at No. 1 In U.K. Miley Cyrus now has a bunch of U.K. No. 1s with “Flowers”. The post-disco hit blooms with upwards of 121,000 chart units, ... Read more »

Glasgow carer shared Snapchat picture of sleeping pensioner for a laugh with pals

Kathleen McDonald has been issued with a two year warning A Glasgow care worker took a picture of a sleeping resident and shared it on Snapchat for a laugh. Kathleen ... Read more »

Strike action likely to begin at Memorial University of Newfoundland: administration

Strike action likely to begin at Memorial University of Newfoundland: administration ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Memorial University says it is anticipating a strike to proceed by the union that represents ... Read more »

'Wealthy' Glasgow businessman bankrupt after failing to repay £400,00 loan from nephew

Retired bookie Hugh King A high profile Glasgow businessman has been made bankrupt by his bookmaker nephew over an unpaid £400,000 loan. Retired Hugh King failed to repay the money ... Read more »

Rio Tinto apologises for loss of tiny radioactive capsule in Australian outback

Search for a radioactive capsule that was lost in transit by a contractor hired by Rio Tinto MELBOURNE (Reuters) – Rio Tinto Ltd apologised on Monday for the loss of ... Read more »

Super Bowl halftime show: Rihanna performance details, date, time, location

1/29/2023 The available details of Rihanna’s return to the stage, including the Super Bowl 2023 date and the songs she may perform, are provided below. Recall that the NFL has ... Read more »

‘I assume I would be a chicken s***’: Nick Offerman on facing the apocalypse in The Last of Us

*Warning – Major spoilers ahead for The Last of Us episode three* Nick Offerman and Murray Bartlett’s episode of HBO’s hit video game adaptation The Last of Us has a ... Read more »

Welcome to Nollywood: The staggering true story of Crossroads queen Noele Gordon

Helena Bonham Carter in ‘Nolly’ and the real soap queen Noele Gordon (ITV) As the credits rolled on another episode of Crossroads on 4 November 1981, the switchboards at ITV ... Read more »

The Last of Us’s gay love story breaks new ground for an entire genre

Frank (Murray Bartlett) sits at the piano while Bill (Nick Offerman) watches, in a particularly heart-wrenching scene from ‘The Last of Us’ (HBO) Two men meet after the collapse of ... Read more »

Bengals' Joseph Ossai laments penalty that led to Chiefs' win

Bengals' Joseph Ossai laments penalty that led to Chiefs' win KANSAS CITY, Mo. — Cincinnati Bengals players and coaches gave defensive end Joseph Ossai words of solace and comfort following ... Read more »

Bengals' Germaine Pratt Has NSFW Outburst Over Joseph Ossai's Costly Penalty

Bengals’ Germaine Pratt has NSFW outburst over Joseph Ossai’s costly penalty originally appeared on NBC Sports Chicago Cincinnati Bengals linebacker Germaine Pratt didn’t hide his frustration with teammate Joseph Ossai’s ... Read more »

Major search for missing 45-year-old who vanished while walking her dog in Lancashire

Police dive teams, fire service drones, search dogs, helicopters and mountain rescue volunteers have been deployed to the Lancashire village of St Michael's on Wyre to find 45-year-old Nicola Bulley, who was last seen two days ago walking her dog on a footpath by the River Wyre. Read more »

WSU frat boy, 19, is found dead in his dorm just 10 miles from scene of Idaho quadruple murders, as online petition claims he died after extreme hazing

Luke Morgan Tyler, 19, was found dead in his WSU dorm room on January 22Police don't speculate foul play despite others warning he died due to hazingTyler was a member of the campus's Theta Chi fraternity  Read more »

Back to reality for Mr. BDE! Pete Davidson and girlfriend Chase Sui Wonders leave Hawaii together after their romantic PDA-packed week

Pete Davidson and Chase Sui Wonders’s romantic getaway has come to an end. The former SNL star, 29, and the actress, 26, who have been denying romance rumors for several ... Read more »

Council tax system in Scotland 'grossly unfair' as Green MSP calls for replacement

MSP Ross Greer A replacement for the “grossly unfair” council tax system should be agreed upon before the next Holyrood election in 2026, a Green MSP has insisted. Ross Greer ... Read more »

Eight shot dead at birthday party in South Africa - police

Breaking news Eight people were shot dead and another three injured in a mass shooting at a birthday party in South Africa’s Eastern Cape province on Sunday, police said on ... Read more »

Video: Karl Stefanovic takes a subtle dig at his ex Today show co-star Ally Langdon ahead of her debut on A Current Affair

Read more »

10 Older Sports Cars Far Superior To Their 2023 Models

10 Older Sports Cars Far Superior To Their 2023 Models When an automaker is updating a sports car model, they take a lot into consideration – reviews and opinions on ... Read more »

New ULEZ scheme launches today as drivers may get £5,000 to ditch petrol and diesel cars

The Ultra Low Emission Zone will expand once again on August 29, 2023, to include all 32 boroughs and the City of London. From today, January 30, Londoners receiving certain ... Read more »

Chester Zoo boss fears new law could be 'extremely damaging'

Chester Zoo has joined forces with a wildlife body to express ‘deep concern’ about a proposed new Bill that they say could be ‘devastating’ to wildlife in the UK. The ... Read more »

Old fashioned' eye makeup women over 40 need to avoid as it ‘ages you instantly'

makeup women over 40 Applying eyeshadow can seem daunting for older women, but makeup artist Bryony Blake has shared her top tips to ensure it is applied successfully and enhances ... Read more »

Property demand collapses as would-be buyers wait for house price falls

houses and for sale signs Home buyer demand has collapsed since last January as the effects of soaring mortgage rates bite and would-be purchasers wait for house price falls. Agreed ... Read more »

Jeremy Clarkson says Cotswolds neighbours 'divided' by his running of Diddly Squat Farm

Some residents remain frustrated by traffic congestion around the area, made popular by Amazon show ‘Clarkson’s Farm’ Jeremy Clarkson has admitted he is yet to win over a number of ... Read more »

Patrick Mahomes throws some shade at Joe Burrow in postgame interview

Jim Nantz presents the Lamar Hunt Trophy to Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15) after the AFC championship NFL game between the Cincinnati Bengals and the Kansas City Chiefs, ... Read more »

After less than half a year, Intel quietly kills RISC-V dev environment

After less than half a year, Intel quietly kills RISC-V dev environment Did Pathfinder get lost in Intel’s sea of red ink? Or is Chipzilla becoming RISC averse? Intel has ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự