COMMENTARY: Bloc leader's threat to unleash ‘fires of hell' over Quebec seat proposal might just backfire

Asia's Tech News Daily

A proposed rejigging of Canada’s electoral map could see Quebec lose one of its seats in the House of Commons by 2024 while Alberta gains three and Ontario and B.C. each gain one.

COMMENTARY: Bloc leader’s threat to unleash ‘fires of hell’ over Quebec seat proposal might just backfire
© Provided by Global News Bloc Quebecois leader Yves-Francois Blanchet speaks to supporters election night Tuesday, September 21, 2021 in Montreal.

The changes would increase the total number of federal ridings to 342 from 338.

There are reasonable arguments for and against implementing the exact changes recommended by Elections Canada. But Bloc Québécois leader Yves-François Blanchet’s opening salvo in the debate — that the BQ would “unleash the fires of hell” if his province’s seat count is dropped to 77 from 78 — is the wrong way to begin what needs to be a calm, cool conversation about updating the country’s political geography.

How are we supposed to respond to Blanchet’s Trumpian explosion of outrage? Can thoughtful discussion follow a toddler’s tantrum?

Injecting apocalyptic rhetoric into a decision-making process that must be driven by the fundamental democratic principle of representation by population — and basic math — is precisely how to inflame prejudices, fuel interprovincial pettiness and polarize the nation.

Blanchet, of course, knows this. Driving wedges wherever possible between Quebec and the rest of Canada is crucial, by definition, to the political project of any diehard separatist.

Video: Canada election: Blanchet vows to advocate for Quebec as election returns familiar result

So we shouldn’t be too surprised that Blanchet has zeroed in histrionically on the planned removal of a single Quebec seat from the Commons as if it were a sign of the End Times. Although Elections Canada proposed the change for the benign reason that Quebec’s population is not growing at the same pace as the populations in Alberta, Ontario or B.C. — and because Quebec is (relative to those other big provinces) already more fairly represented in the current parliamentary seat count — Blanchet is invoking biblical imagery of the final battle between Good and Evil.

Sonia LeBel, Quebec’s minister responsible for relations with the rest of Canada, has employed more moderate language — and advanced a more compelling rationale — in urging special considerations for the province in the latest redistribution of federal ridings.

“We are part of the founding peoples of Canada,” she said this week. “We have three seats guaranteed at the Supreme Court for judges. We have seats guaranteed in the Senate, a weight that is important and represents much more than just a simple calculation of population.”

All of this is why Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and other political leaders interested in preserving the peace in our mostly peaceable kingdom need to rise above Blanchet’s blatant bullying while finding a sensible solution to the seat-count conundrum — one that delicately balances numerical fairness with other considerations endemic in a land of complexity and compromise.

Remember: there’s no purely mathematical justification for granting a federal seat to each of Canada’s three territories — none of which has a population above 50,000 — when the average number of Canadians represented by each MP is more than 110,000. There’s no logical reason, either, for Prince Edward Island — with a mere 0.43 per cent of the national population of about 38 million — to have four seats representing 1.19 per cent of the elected positions in Parliament.

So there may well be legitimate reasons to avoid reducing Quebec’s seat count at this time.

In 2011, the Conservative government of Stephen Harper implemented legislation that increased the number of seats to 338 from 308 to reflect population changes. At the time, the Harper government — with much prodding from Quebec, the BQ and other opposition parties — chose to inflate the overall size of the House of the Commons so that the number of Quebec seats would increase (by three, to 78) instead of remaining static at 75 — as an earlier, hotly rejected, purely mathematical proposal had called for.

The government’s thinking at the time was that tweaking the formula for allocating seats in a way that would better recognize Quebec’s special status as a nation within the nation was politically prudent.

Video: Meet the new parliament, same as the old parliament

It also happened to keep the province’s seat total roughly proportional to its percentage of Canada’s population, even as those two numbers remained unfairly out of whack for faster-growing provinces.

The Quebec-friendly adjustment wasn’t immediately embraced by Harper’s own caucus. The additional Quebec seats, according to a Globe and Mail report at the time, “caused consternation among Conservative backbenchers, who were concerned that Canada’s French-speaking province was benefiting from a bill meant to address under-representation in the three large and fast-growing anglophone provinces” — Alberta, Ontario and B.C.

Sound familiar?

The Conservative caucus was ultimately convinced by Harper to accept the plan for the sake of national unity. But despite the Quebec-friendly compromise, the pre-Blanchet Bloc Québécois still slammed the 2011 reconfiguration of the House as falling short of true recognition of the province’s “unique status with regard to its political weight.”

You can’t please everyone. As then-B.C. premier Christy Clark, who supported the 2011 changes, said at the time: “Perfection in these things is impossible because it’s a big and complicated country.”

A decade later, the scenario confronting Elections Canada, the federal government and the provinces is much the same. And maybe a little massaging of the numbers to mollify Quebec is warranted yet again.

Would it be so bad if Quebec kept its 78 seats and we had 343 federal ridings instead of 342? That would represent about 22.7 per cent of the seats in the House for a province with about 22.6 per cent of Canada’s population. (Meanwhile, Ontario’s proposed 122 seats would then account for 35.6 per cent of 343 seats for a province with almost 39 per cent of the country’s population.)

But Blanchet’s bluster about unleashing the “fires of hell” risks torching the good will required for the rest of Canada to grant Quebec some latitude in its allotment of seats in the national legislature. It’s the kind of talk that’s more likely to unleash cynicism and stinginess.

And eventually, if population trends continue in the current direction, maintaining Quebec’s present share of federal seats as its population drifts towards one-fifth of Canada’s total will become untenable from a democratic point of view — Blanchet’s fires of hell notwithstanding.

Randy Boswell is a Carleton University journalism professor and former Postmedia News national writer.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Cowboys fans brawl with concession worker in stadium concourse

Cowboys players brawled with their opponents on Thanksgiving, and their fans brawled with a concession worker in the AT&T Stadium concourse. In what has seemingly become the weekly occurrence of ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity ‘fix' claim as viewers say Naughty Boy was given ‘easiest ever' Bushtucker trial to make him stay

I'M A Celebrity viewers furiously slammed the show as a “fix” after Naughty Boy was given the “easiest ever” Bushtucker trial to keep him from leaving. Fans are convinced the ... Read more »

Amanda Holden and Ashley Roberts share a cheeky Christmas smooch underneath the mistletoe

The Heart FM Breakfast duo wore matching elf outfits as they puckered up for the saucy snap.  RADIO presenters Amanda Holden and Ashley Roberts are both naughty and nice as ... Read more »

Macron throws strop over Channel crisis and bans Priti Patel from visiting for crunch talks

SULKY Emmanuel Macron threw a strop over the Channel crossings crisis last night — and banned Priti Patel from visiting for crunch talks. The French president fumed over a letter ... Read more »

Barbie Hsu latest celeb to split up with partner in recent years

© The Independent Singapore © The Independent Singapore Taiwan — While celebrities like Kim Lim and Rebecca Lim were getting engaged, Taiwanese actress Barbie Hsu is getting divorced from her ... Read more »

World Cup 2022 play-off draw: Scotland and Wales set for eliminator while Cristiano Ronaldo's Portugal face Italy clash

SCOTLAND and Wales are on course to face one another in a mouth-watering World Cup play-off final. The Home Nations were drawn in Path A in Friday night's draw in ... Read more »

Micah Parsons destroys officials from Cowboys-Raiders: ‘I'm not here to play tag'

Micah Parsons has every right to be upset. The star linebacker for the Dallas Cowboys was flagged for roughing the passer on a play where he made very light contact ... Read more »

EuroMillions results – Mega £137million jackpot scooped by a single ticket holder in France

THE results are out for the Euromillions – and it's good news for one lucky person as a single ticket holder in France has scooped up the whopping £137million. The ... Read more »

Dayton hits wild buzzer beater to upset No. 4 Kansas

Dayton guard Elijah Weaver celebrates the Flyers’ buzzer-beating upset win over No. 4 Kansas. AP Photo Black Friday produced a wild upset in college basketball season. Dayton had lost games ... Read more »

Jeremy Clarkson climbs on tractor & yells ‘have a drink, have a drive' at launch of new beer… but Kaleb went for a cider

SCRAMBLING atop his famous Lamborghini tractor, beer in hand, Jeremy Clarkson proclaimed: “Have a drink, have a drive, see what you can find!” The Clarkson’s Farm star had finally achieved ... Read more »

High school football team scores touchdown on ridiculous backflip trick play

No flipping way. Joe Accidardo, a wide receiver for Johnston High School Panthers in Rhode Island, did a series of backflips while running in motion to misdirect the defense. The ... Read more »

Motorists would save £150 a year if retailers passed on petrol price cuts

HARD-pressed drivers would save £150 a year at the pumps if “greedy” retailers pass on cheaper wholesale fuel prices, experts say. The RAC, AA and FairFuel UK have called for ... Read more »

Brooks Koepka fulfills quest to ‘spank' Bryson DeChambeau in ‘The Match'

Brooks Koepka wanted to “spank” Bryson DeChambeau in The Match. He succeeded. Koepka bested DeChambeau at “The Match” at the Wynn golf course in Las Vegas in a one-sided affair ... Read more »

Letters to the Editor — Nov. 27, 2021

New York Post readers sound off about Milwaukee County DA John Chisholm, who let Waukesha parade attack suspect Darrell Brooks out on a $1,000 bail for an earlier crime. YouTube ... Read more »

'All the boys in my class are doing it.' My daughter's school friends are vaping. They're in Year 4.

© Getty Images ‘All the boys in my class are doing it.’ My daughter’s school friends are vaping. They’re in Year 4. When I was in primary school, I dressed ... Read more »

Christmas lockdown fears grow as new super-mutant strain on brink of reaching the UK

FEARS of a second Christmas lockdown were growing last night with a new Covid variant on the brink of reaching the UK. Health Secretary Sajid Javid warned the super-mutant strain ... Read more »

Zion cleared for full team activities but still no timetable for return

© Provided by NEW ORLEANS — Pelicans forward Zion Williamson has been cleared to participate in full team activities, the club announced on Friday (Saturday, Manila time), but there ... Read more »

Iran, Kazakhstan score big wins in Fiba World Cup Asian qualifiers

© Provided by ARSALAN Kazemi was all over the floor for Iran as it blasted Bahrain, 82-66, to gain the early lead in the 2023 Fiba World Cup Asian ... Read more »

I romped naked in The Lovers' Guide and became a global star – then replaced sex with a £70k a year cocaine habit

WENDY-ANN PAIGE would be deciding what to buy for her dinner when she would notice a man at her shoulder. “My wife won’t wear heels in bed — is she ... Read more »

Chris Whitty concerned Brits will not follow new restrictions if needed

CHIEF Medical Officer Chris Whitty fears Brits will not obey new restrictions if they are needed. And he is more concerned about the Delta variant — which drove up cases ... Read more »

Nicola Roberts chic in a black maxi dress and Chanel pearls

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo She never fails to put on a stylish display when she steps out to socialise.  And Nicola Roberts looked effortlessly cool in a ... Read more »

West Side Story composer Leonard Bernstein 'wasn't crazy about film'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo The legendary composer behind West Side Story ended up resenting its success – and he wasn’t too keen on the Oscar-winning film adaptation ... Read more »

I started my business at 21 and now I'm 27 and have £12 million in assets – here's how YOU can do it too

ARE YOU fed up of working a boring 9-5 office job and barely having enough money once your bills are paid? Well, one woman has taken to TikTok to share ... Read more »

Gusts of almost 100mph as UK is battered by Storm Arwen

The UK felt the full force of Storm Arwen with gusts of almost 100 miles per hour battering some areas. One man died, buildings were damaged and trees blown down ... Read more »

Three wounded in shooting at mall in Durham, N.C.

Three people were wounded Friday in a shooting at The Streets at Southpoint Mall in Durham, North Carolina, and three others were injured, police said. The shooting victims included a ... Read more »

Calm returns to Solomons capital after deadly riots

A tense calm returned to the Solomon Islands’ capital Honiara Saturday, after days of rioting left at least three dead and reduced swathes of the city to smouldering ruins. © ... Read more »

BTS: Ahead of Jin's birthday, ARMYs plan a special surprise during the Permission To Dance on Stage in LA concert – deets inside

© Provided by Today, lucky BTS ARMYs would be getting to see the Bangtan Boys, the world K-pop sensations, BTS, live! It’s a big day for both BTS (RM, ... Read more »

Nikki Bella made one promise to Artem Chigvintsev that is preventing them from getting married

© Bang Showbiz Artem Chigvintsev and Nikki Bella at the Teen Choice Awards Nikki Bella keeps delaying her wedding because she “promised” Artem Chigvintsev that his parents would be able ... Read more »

Bryan Adams tests positive for Covid-19 for the second time in one month: ‘Off to the hospital'

Singer Bryan Adams tests positive for Covid-19 twice in one month (Instagram/@bryanadams) Bryan Adams has tested positive for Covid-19 twice in a month. The 62-year-old singer, who is currently in ... Read more »

Oubre, Hornets blister Timberwolves from long range, 133-115

CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) — Kelly Oubre Jr. matched a career high with seven 3-pointers and had 27 points off the bench, helping the surging Charlotte Hornets snap the Minnesota Timberwolves’ ... Read more »

Step in a new direction

© Provided by Mid-Day With Chhorii, director Vishal Furia has revisited a story he knows intimately. The Nushrratt Bharuccha-starrer, centred on a pregnant woman, is inspired by Furia’s 2017 movie, ... Read more »

Shahid Kapoor is lovestruck by wife Mira Rajput in her vibrant look in a new PIC; See how he reacted

Among the couples in Bollywood, Mira Rajput and Shahid Kapoor always manage to steal the limelight when they step out together. Not just this, often Shahid and Mira light up ... Read more »

Tebboune faces another test as Algerians vote

© RYAD KRAMDI It will be Algeria’s third national vote under President Abdelmadjid Tebboune, who has vowed to turn the page on the two-decade rule of late leader Abdelaziz Bouteflika ... Read more »

Tahira Kashyap Khurrana: Never thought of abandoning project

© Provided by Mid-Day Tahira Kashyap Khurrana believes she is a storyteller at heart, the medium does not matter. The writer-filmmaker, whose latest book The 7 Sins of Being A ... Read more »

Air Pollution Updates: AQI Worsens to 'Hazardous' Levels in Parts of Delhi; Winds to Bring Slight Respite in 2 Days

© Provided by News18 Air Pollution Updates: AQI Worsens to ‘Hazardous’ Levels in Parts of Delhi; Winds to Bring Slight Respite in 2 Days The air quality index in parts ... Read more »

‘He didn't like what I ate' at Thanksgiving: Marchand on Panarin's glove throw

Brad Marchand is among the league’s best at scoring goals and setting up teammates, but his ability to get under his opponent’s skin is unmatched. © Matt Slocum/AP artemi-panarin On ... Read more »

Hilaria Baldwin: I didn't think I'd make it through 2021

© Bang Showbiz Hilaria Baldwin at an Elton John AIDS Foundation event Hilaria Baldwin didn’t think she would “make it through” 2021. The 37-year-old health and wellbeing expert reflected on ... Read more »

Three bodies found after days of unrest in Solomon Islands

© Provided by Al Jazeera People walk through the Chinatown district of Honiara on the Solomon Islands on November 26, 2021, after a third day of violence that saw the ... Read more »

Australia starts 14-day quarantine for citizens travelling from southern Africa

© Reuters/JAIMI JOY FILE PHOTO: COVID-19 lockdown orders eased in Sydney MELBOURNE (Reuters) – Australia will introduce 14-day quarantine for citizens and their dependents travelling from nine countries in southern ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic