COMMENT: Illiterate? Singapore MPs need to be schooled on Parliament

Editor’s note: The opinions in this article are the author’s, as published by our content partner, and do not represent the views of MSN or Microsoft.

SINGAPORE — It was the gaffe that went viral and could have been heard around the world. Or at the very least, the vast echo chambers of Singapore’s online spaces.

At first, it could barely be heard during Tuesday’s (14 September) marathon 13.5-hour Parliament sitting. But then the video clip of someone remarking “He is illiterate”, followed by “Seriously, how did he get into RI?” and “Must have been a lousy school”, began circulating.

The gasps – and sniggers – could almost be heard across the island. Online wags quickly pointed to Non-Constituency Member of Parliament (MP) Leong Mun Wai as the target of the comments, while at least one minister was fingered as a culprit. But there was no smoking gun, particularly as the MPs pictured were all masked.

Then Foreign Minister Vivian Balakrishnan owned up to his “private comments to a colleague” in a Facebook post. “I should not have said what I said,” said the man who was once Minister-in-Charge of the Smart Nation Initiative, and who failed to notice the hot mic just metres away.

And just like that, the multiple talking points put forth by the government during the interminable debate on, among others, the Singapore-India Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA), have been practically forgotten.

Not to mention Leong’s hapless performance during the sitting – at one point, he even asked the Speaker for permission to let his party colleague Hazel Poa answer the relentless queries of Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam, a man whose style of questioning is reminiscent of the Spanish Inquisition.

Instead, all anyone can talk about is the sight of a Cabinet minister ceding the moral high ground to a man whom ministers had called a “race baiter” and “xenophobe”. Dr Balakrishnan’s comment also opened the door to age-old accusations of elitism, with netizens sarcastically quoting the government’s own oft-quoted claim that “every school is a good school”.

To be fair, politicians are only human. Indiscrete, even snide, comments in private are hardly new. Perhaps the minister’s real mistake was a lack of awareness of the recording devices around him.

Live streaming has changed the game

Dr Balakrishnan is certainly not the first, nor will he be the last, to slip up in the House. Back in 1996, the late Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) chair Ling How Doong was censured by Parliament for uttering the infamous line, “Don’t talk c**k”, to his SDP colleague Chiam See Tong.

Worse things have been said in the chamber. In 1992, the People’s Action Party’s (PAP) Choo Wee Khiang provoked an uproar when he spoke of driving to Little India one evening and finding it “pitch dark” because “there were too many Indians around”.

But now that the government has belatedly begun live-streaming Parliament proceedings, it is a whole new ball game. There is even less room for error now: every loose word and indiscretion is amplified, while the entirety of Parliamentary sittings, as opposed to just selected clips in the past, are now freely available online for anyone to peruse.

Among my peers, there were nervous jokes about the Ministry of Communications and Information shutting down the livestream. After all, former Leader of the House Grace Fu had claimed that live broadcasts risked turning the House into a “form of theatre”.

“Members need to… avoid playing to the gallery and striking poses for histrionic effect,” said Fu.

Eight months after live streaming began, this reporter, a regular observer of the House, has yet to see any noticeable increase in dramatic poses or histrionics. Proceedings remain largely sedate, with the odd fireworks.

Accountability and political theatre

At the risk of stating the obvious, Parliament’s principal purpose is still as a forum for the debate of ideas. While the PAP’s supermajority makes the passage of legislation a formality, it is still a means for the government of the day to convince citizens of the merits of its policies. The live aspect of the broadcast arguably enhances this.

But the PAP continuously makes the mistake of attempting to win an emotional argument with facts, and often comes across as bullies while doing so. This is exactly what it did again on Tuesday.

Consider this: Leong habitually looks unprepared in Parliament, stumbling over his own unsubstantiated arguments and getting easily caught out by PAP MPs. He has also advocated puzzling and impractical proposals such as a $10,000 qualifying salary for Employment Passes (EPs) for foreign professionals.

Dismantling Leong’s suggestions is not a difficult task. Ameliorating the optics of quite a few PAP MPs hammering away at him is far harder. To his credit, Leong did not back down, even if he desperately needs training in public speaking. Little wonder that some online celebrate him as an underdog, regardless of his simplistic, perhaps even dangerous, rhetoric.

Furthermore, the government wants to have it both ways – during Tuesday’s session, it stressed the importance of remaining open to foreign talent, even while providing limited data about the presence of foreigners in Singapore. This ultimately discredits its own arguments.

Leader of the Opposition Pritam Singh was right when he said, “The government needs to reflect on its own omissions and resistance when it comes to providing data and information, and how it ought to take some responsibility for the groundswell of misinformation about CECA.”

The PAP has the natural advantage in the House, but every MP – PAP or opposition – needs to up their game in Parliament. Otherwise, they may find themselves going viral for all the wrong reasons.

The views expressed are the writer’s own.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

On the Beach reports ‘suppressed trading' after suspending holiday sales

© Gareth Fuller On The Beach said sales are still below pre-pandemic levels (Gareth Fuller/PA) Travel retailer On The Beach said it saw “suppressed trading” in the last six months ... Read more »

‘Less than 20% chance' Boris Johnson will have to trigger Plan B Covid restrictions due to falling cases, insiders say

THERE'S now a “less than 20 per cent chance” Boris Johnson will need to trigger new Covid restrictions due to falling cases, insiders say. Whitehall officials are increasingly confident the ... Read more »

Usul jual aset Petronas di Azerbaijan dirunding di kamar khas, kata Azhar

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Anwar Ibrahim berkata, usul penjualan aset gas Petronas di Azerbaijan sepatutnya segera dibahaskan di Dewan Rakyat sebelum pembentangan Belanjawan 2022 pada Jumaat ini, bukannya ... Read more »

EVOS SG looking to the future after back-to-back MPL SG titles

It may be the last MPL SG trophy for EVOS SG captain Andrew “Potato” Lim, but he is already planning for the future. As a back-to-back champion for MPL SG, ... Read more »

Mana janji Muhyiddin naikkan bantuan JKM kepada RM1,000, soal ahli Parlimen Kulai

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Teo Nie Ching berkata, sempena Hari Orang Kurang Upaya Sedunia pada 3 Dis 2020, Muhyiddin Yassin berjanji bantuan JKM antara RM200 hingga RM300 akan ... Read more »

Bajet 2022: Kementerian tak perlu peruntukan banyak daripada kerajaan, kata Zuraida

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Zuraida Kamaruddin berkata fokus utama Kementerian Perusahaan Perladangan dan Komoditi ketika ini adalah meningkatkan kebolehan setiap agensi untuk mengukuhkan pendapatan melalui strategi pasaran lebih ... Read more »

Odisha Govt moves to ensure Olive turtles' safety ahead of mass nesting

© Provided by The Statesman Odisha Govt moves to ensure Olive turtles’ safety ahead of mass nesting The coastal State has contributed significantly towards preservation and growth of this endangered ... Read more »

NTA NEET 2021 entrance exam result: Kerala HC passes BIG order - Read here

© Provided by DNA As lakhs of medical aspirants across the country are waiting for the release of NEET 2021 entrance exam result, the Kerala High Court (HC) on Tuesday ... Read more »

'National Security Can't be Bugbear...' What SC Said on Pegasus Snooping Row | Top Quotes

© Provided by News18 ‘National Security Can’t be Bugbear…’ What SC Said on Pegasus Snooping Row | Top Quotes The Supreme Court on Wednesday appointed a committee of experts to ... Read more »

Gary Barlow and Sheridan Smith's bid for Christmas Number One

Gary Barlow and Sheridan Smith are reportedly collaborating on festive single ‘How Christmas Is Supposed To Be’. © Bang Showbiz Gary Barlow The Take That star – who teamed up ... Read more »

Cruise drugs case: Police appoint officer to probe allegations against NCB investigator Wankhede

© Provided by Hindustan Times NCB’s Mumbai zonal director Sameer Wankhede.  (ANI Photo) The Mumbai Police appointed an ACP-level officer to probe the allegations levelled against Narcotics Control Bureau’s zonal ... Read more »

IBPS Clerk Recruitment 2021: Last date to apply today for 7858 posts on ibps.in

Institute of Banking Personnel Selection will close down registration process for IBPS Clerk Recruitment 2021 on October 27, 2021. Candidates who have still not applied for Clerk posts through the ... Read more »

Chris Hughes hints at future I'm A Celeb stint and admits he'd be 'proud' to take part

Former Love Island star Chris Hughes says he’d be “proud of himself” if he went on I’m A Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here, but admits there’s “nothing in the pipeline” ... Read more »

Londoners to wear pollution monitors in toxic air study

© PA ulez0804c.jpg Londoners are trialling body-worn pollution monitors as part of a study to measure the amount of toxic air they are exposed to in their daily lives. The ... Read more »

Priti Patel pressed to explain award of spy agencies cloud contract to Amazon

Priti Patel is under pressure to disclose whether the UK’s most sensitive national security secrets could be at risk after the disclosure that its spy agencies signed a cloud contract ... Read more »

What the DA, ANC and EFF promise to voters who choose them to lead

© Provided by 702 What must be the most complex, uncertain local government elections in democratic South Africa’s history are mere days away. With an eye firmly on 1 November, ... Read more »

New housing estate planned on five-acres of football fields

A new 88-home estate could be built on football pitches in Breightmet. The estate would build over the current home of Bolton Wyresdale AFC off Inverbeg Drive. Plans submitted to ... Read more »

Andrea Torres shares sneak peek of press conference for Argentinian film

Andrea Torres IG Andrea Torres is making waves both locally and internationally as she stars in an Argentinian film! On Wednesday, the “Legal Wives” actress shared a sneak peek of ... Read more »

Fast-track route to renewables best option for European industry-research

FRANKFURT (Reuters) – Delaying the expansion of renewable energy in the European Union would drive up carbon emissions prices and result in higher electricity costs for industries while a fast ... Read more »

Stablecoins need to maintain reliable peg to promote industry's growth and acceptance

© Provided by The National Pablo Peillard, protocol lead developer and architect at Qidao, speaking at the Fantom Abu Dhabi Developer Conference on Tuesday. Khushnum Bhandari / The National The ... Read more »

Russia opens case against Apple over App Store payment restrictions

© Reuters/Mike Segar FILE PHOTO: An Apple logo hangs above the entrance to the Apple store on 5th Avenue in the Manhattan borough of New York City MOSCOW (Reuters) – ... Read more »

Elsa Hosk's Favourite Things

(Elsa Hosk) Elsa Hosk and Frozen’s Queen Elsa are not dissimilar. With their platinum blonde hair, piercing blue eyes and shared Scandinavian name, it’s not indisputable that the Disney monarch ... Read more »

Patience is running out: Seven in 10 back specific rules for the unvaccinated

Photo: Depositphotos.com Over seven in 10 people in the Netherlands think the government should bring in specific measures to deal with the number of people who have not been vaccinated ... Read more »

Xbox hardware sales increase substantially, steady Game Pass growth, says Microsoft Q1 2022 earnings report

© Provided by Dot Esports The Xbox seems to have continued its upwards trajectory since the launch of the new-generation Xbox Series X/S, recording a significant increase in sales. Microsoft ... Read more »

Amazon Web Services to help get the first billion users into blockchain game

© Provided by The National The four-day Fantom Abu Dhabi Developer Conference got under way on Monday. Khushnum Bhandari / The National Amazon Web Services (AWS) aims to onboard the ... Read more »

Scotland vs Namibia 2021: Probable XIs For ICC T20 World Cup 2021, Super-12, Match 21

© Provided by News18 Scotland vs Namibia 2021: Probable XIs For ICC T20 World Cup 2021, Super-12, Match 21 Scotland qualified for the main round after having won all their ... Read more »

Sean Abbott makes Test claim and Tanveer Sangha shines on debut

© Getty Images Sean Abbott made big inroads in the first session © Getty Images New South Wales 2 for 43 trail Victoria 199 (Maddinson 87, Abbott 6-38) by 156 ... Read more »

Bastian Schweinsteiger claims Guardiola relationship affected Man United spot under Mourinho

Bastian Schweinsteiger was never told why Jose Mourinho didn’t want to play him at Manchester United, but the former Germany international has an eye-catching theory. Having won every trophy imaginable ... Read more »

Hoarder's four bedroom home which is being 'sold as seen'

A property currently on the market has been causing a stir for its previous owner’s eccentric collecting habit. The three storey detached family home on Hartington Road in Toxteth had ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta in Arsenal transfer plea as Aston Villa link emerges

Arsenal boss Mikel Arteta wants to see Eddie Nketiah remain at the Emirates Stadium. Nketiah has been linked with a move to Aston Villa and their Premier League rivals Brentford ... Read more »

When does the minimum wage go up? National Living Wage increase explained before Budget 2021 announcement

A series of measures included in the 2021 Budget have been announced ahead of Rishi Sunak’s statement on Wednesday. Along with a public sector pay rise, which marks the end ... Read more »

Finnish scientists create 'sustainable' lab-grown coffee

Latte drinkers may in the future be sipping on java sourced from a petri dish rather than a plantation, say scientists behind a new technique to grow what they hope ... Read more »

Gardaí probe double stabbing in Dublin city centre

© Sam Boal via RollingNews.ie GARDAÍ HAVE LAUNCHED an investigation after two men were stabbed in two separate, but related incidents, in Dublin city centre.  The incidents happened on the ... Read more »

Bill Murray says he is joining the Marvel Cinematic Universe

© Getty Images for BFI GettyImages-1345880232.jpg Bill Murray has said that he is set to join the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). The actor hinted in an interview with German publication ... Read more »

Australian footballer widely praised after coming out as gay: ‘I know there are others living in silence'

© AAP Image Australia Soccer Cavallo Coming Out An Australian professional footballer has publicly said he is gay, adding he wanted to show “everyone is welcome in the game of ... Read more »

GMB's Richard Madeley asked 'are you stupid?' in row with Insulate Britain protester

Good Morning Britain presenter Richard Madeley was branded “stupid and heartless” during a heated row with Insulate protestor Tracey Mallaghan. She appeared on the talk show to defend the campaign ... Read more »

O'Shea Jackson Jr. landed Obi-Wan Kenobi role after 'crushing' Solo snub

© Bang Showbiz O’Shea Jackson Jr O’Shea Jackson Jr. landed a role in ‘Obi-Wan Kenobi’ after getting rejected for ‘Solo: A Star Wars Story’. The 30-year-old actor is set to ... Read more »

2021 Is Seeing The Coolest Innovations In Nails

© Provided by Refinery29 If you feel like you’re seeing more come out of the nail-art world than ever before, you’re probably spot-on. With visual platforms like Instagram and TikTok ... Read more »

The biggest nail colour trend for Christmas has total 90s vibes

© Provided by Evoke.ie Autumn marks a return to the darker tones of the season but the biggest nail colour trend for Christmas is anything but. What lies ahead for ... Read more »

Fox News's Neil Cavuto reveals his own viewers abused him in hate mail after he urged them to get vaccinated

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. File: Anchor Neil Cavuto is photographed during his ‘Cavuto: Coast to Coast’ program, on the Fox Business Network, in New York, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic