College Admissions Are Still Unfair

Asia's Tech News Daily

This week Amherst College announced that it was ending the use of legacy preferences in its admissions process. Its president, Biddy Martin, acknowledged that providing an advantage to applicants who are the children of alumni “inadvertently limits educational opportunity.” When incredibly wealthy, highly selective colleges such as Amherst (endowment: $3.7 billion; admission rate: 8 percent) make an announcement like this, it’s tempting to pour a bucket of cold water on the self-congratulatory fireworks they’re lighting for themselves. That should not happen this time.

College Admissions Are Still Unfair
© Ilana Panich-Linsman / The New York Times / Redux

Still, the temptation is real. Why congratulate a college for doing something it should have done a long time ago? Many large public universities, including the University of California, the University of Texas, and Texas A&M, dropped legacy preferences years ago, as did Johns Hopkins University two years ago and MIT and CalTech before it. Pomona College, a highly ranked liberal-arts college like Amherst, dropped legacy preference in 2017. What’s more, even at those places that give the offspring of alumni an edge, or what admissions offices call a “tip,” legacies usually account for a small share of the enrolled class, and many of those admits would likely have gotten in without the advantage, or so the admissions deans defending the practice of birthright advantage like to say.

Wouldn’t it be better to go after all those jocks on campus? Division III sports have been called “affirmative action for rich white students,” and almost a third of Amherst’s roughly 1,800 students play one of the college’s 27 varsity sports. That is nearly three times as many athletes as legacies. Amherst plays in the New England Small College Athletic Conference, of which 77 percent of athletes are white, while the college’s student body is only 43 percent white, which makes you wonder whether Amherst’s obsession with sports is also “inadvertently limit[ing] educational opportunity,” maybe even more so than legacy preferences were.

Within a few hours of Amherst sharing its news, Catharine B. Hill, the managing director of the nonprofit consulting and research firm Ithaka S+R, dumped out her bucket. In a piece entitled “Ending Legacy Admissions Won’t End Inequity,” Hill stated bluntly, “Legacy admissions are bad from a public-relations perspective, but ending them would do almost nothing to improve socioeconomic diversity at these institutions or increase lower-income students’ likelihood of being admitted.” Splash! So much for your fireworks, Amherst.

[Read: College sports are affirmative action for rich white students]

It’s important to say that Hill is not some internet troll or the kind of economist who thinks the market should decide who gets to go to college or drink clean water. She is the former president of Vassar College and a serious champion of college access. Under her leadership, Vassar reinstated its “need-blind” admissions policy and significantly raised its enrollment rate of students with Pell Grants. Hill’s absolutely accurate point is that increased institutional spending on grant aid—not loans—for students with economic need will do much more to increase the enrollment of working-class and low-income students at wealthy colleges than getting rid of legacy admissions will.

The problem with Hill’s argument is that Amherst did precisely what Hill recommended: It increased its financial-aid investment to make an education there more affordable. Her critique poses a false choice. Amherst showed that it’s possible to do two good things at the same time. There’s no need to decide between getting rid of the legacy tip and increasing need-based financial aid. Furthermore, no one who is fighting for legacy admissions thinks it will “end inequity,” as Hill claims. Straw men should be kept away from the fireworks.

Perhaps worst of all, arguing that legacy has no impact only gives further cover to the institutions that still think some children should inherit a leg up in the admissions process. This is also not true. Almost 400 University of Notre Dame freshmen, or 19 percent of the class, were legacies this year. At the University of Southern California, more than 500 freshmen legacies were enrolled last fall. Would they have gotten those spots without a legacy tip? Perhaps, but at Johns Hopkins, which is just as selective, the percentage of enrolled legacies declined from 12.5 to 3.5 percent, while Pell enrollment climbed from 9 to 19 percent.

[Ronald J. Daniels: Why we ended legacy admissions at Johns Hopkins]

There is also an important component of racial justice in dropping legacy preferences. The practice overwhelmingly benefits white applicants and harms first-generation, immigrant, low-income, and nonwhite students. A 2018 lawsuit against Harvard revealed that 77 percent of legacy admits were white, while just 5 percent were Black and 7 percent were Hispanic. At Notre Dame, the class of 2024 had five times as many legacies as Black students. The college-access advocate Akil Bello told me that “eliminating legacy preference at what I like to call highly rejective colleges matters because it ends the perpetuation of the generational head start and advantages that white people in this country have.” Colleges want to hold on to their institutional legacy, but discrimination is part of that legacy. And, looking at the legacy-enrollment rates of several highly ranked colleges versus their Black-enrollment rates in the chart below, the failure to serve all students remains a part of their present.

College Admissions Are Still Unfair
© Provided by The Atlantic ***Share includes legacies and donors, from data released according to CA legal requirements ****Data from trial documents and include Classes of 2015 to 2019

The fundamental reason to get rid of legacy preferences is that they are unethical; this led a group of young, first-generation students to create the “Leave Your Legacy” campaign, which helps alumni contact their alma mater to say they will not donate any money until the legacy preference is eliminated. This kind of pressure and the attention Amherst is rightly getting for dropping the tip for legacies could help persuade more colleges to give up an ugly and unfair practice.

Eliminating legacy preferences is not the end of the fight for fairness in college admissions; it’s the beginning. Elite colleges and universities have a long way to go in making a meaningful commitment to diversity, but Amherst took one step closer to it this week. And for that, I’m happy to light a sparkler.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Generation Start-up: MNT-Halan rides Egypt's FinTech wave

© Provided by The National MNT-Halan CTO Ahmed Mohsen and CEO Mounir Nakhla created the new financial services entity in June. Courtesy MNT-Halan In many ways, it is no surprise ... Read more »

Donohoe warned over ‘politically sensitive' zoned lands tax plan

© Getty Paschal Donohoe Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe was warned that any plan to tax land which was being used for farming even though it had been zoned for housing ... Read more »

Covid Q&A – Why are schools struggling and what are we doing to resolve the issue?

© Getty School children Why are things so bad in schools? That depends on who you are speaking to. But everyone acknowledges there is a challenge getting enough substitute teachers ... Read more »

10 Places to Stay Near Manila with Spectacular Views

© Provided by PHOTO BY L: Facebook/Twin Lakes Hotel; R: Facebook/Ocean and Mountain Breeze © Provided by PHOTO BY L: Facebook/Twin Lakes Hotel; R: Facebook/Ocean and Mountain Breeze ... Read more »

Spot Stays: Enjoy a Romantic Night at This Staycation Hotel in Manila

© Provided by PHOTO BY Christa I. De La Cruz © Provided by PHOTO BY Christa I. De La Cruz Hilton Manila1 Newport Boulevard, Newport City, Pasay City ... Read more »

Cinema in the Time of a Pandemic: What to Expect When You Watch a Movie

© Provided by PHOTO BY Ashley Martelino © Provided by PHOTO BY Ashley Martelino ( In mid-October, the Inter-Agency Task Force announced that indoor cinemas would be allowed ... Read more »

UP TET Exam 2021 Canceled After Question Paper Leak, To be Held After One Month

© Sumaila Zaman | Education Desk The Uttar Pradesh Basic Education Board (UPBEB) will hold the UPTET exam again after one month. UP TET Paper Leak: The Uttar Pradesh ... Read more »

Gold price surges amid uncertainty over new omicron outbreak

Gold futures on the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX) shot up by ₹219 per 10gm to reach ₹47,640 for 10gm in the closing session on Friday. The gold price rise sent ... Read more »

Petrol, Diesel Prices Today Remain Under Rs 100 in Several Cities. Check Fuel Rates

© Provided by News18 Petrol, Diesel Prices Today Remain Under Rs 100 in Several Cities. Check Fuel Rates On November 28, Sunday, petrol and diesel prices remained constant for more ... Read more »

Karnataka government takes BIG decisions amid 'Omicron' variant scare

© Provided by DNA Amid growing concern over new COVID-19 strain ‘Omicron’, the Karnataka government on Saturday (November 27) swung into action and decided to step up COVID-19 precautionary measures ... Read more »

REVEALED: Why is the Omicron variant of COVID-19 so deadly and scary?

© Provided by DNA The Omicron COVID-19 variant, which is described by many experts as the worst strain ever of the coronavirus, has several mutations from previous COVID-19 strains and ... Read more »

Switzerland to vote on whether to keep Covid restrictions as cases surge

People in Switzerland will vote on Sunday on the government’s health measures against Covid-19, in the wake of a large increase in new cases this month. © Fabrice Coffrini/AFP/Getty Images ... Read more »

Lithuanian villagers back tough line on Belarus migrants

From her green-painted homestead near the Belarusian border, Lithuanian pensioner Jadvyga Mackevic remembers the day she saw three migrants coming out of the forest and being detained. © PETRAS MALUKAS ... Read more »

Black Friday graphics card deals 2021 - sales still available right now

The best Black Friday graphics card deals are still trickling in even with the day proper long gone. The good news for latecoming shoppers is that the savings were few ... Read more »

Shark Black Friday deals 2021: Save 45% on this upright vacuum cleaner

This discount sucks… in a good way (iStock/The Independent) Black Friday has officially begun, and we’re well into the second day of the main event, with retailers offering great discounts ... Read more »

Arsenal transfer round-up: Nicolas Pepe sale considered as wonderkid bid launched

Arsenal’s season is going from strength to strength and the Gunners are hoping to translate their good work on the pitch to the transfer market. Manager Mikel Arteta and technical ... Read more »

Flights from HK still allowed, NTF clarifies

The National Task Force against Coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) clarified on Sunday that the decision to restrict arrivals from Hong Kong because of the Omicron variant is not yet final. ... Read more »

Barbados will spur others to ditch the Queen: experts

© JOE RAEDLE Ditching the British monarch is being seen as a final step on the long road to freedom after centuries of slavery and exploitation On a rainy night ... Read more »

Beverly Hills police and bomb squad in standoff with motorist on Wilshire Boulevard

Beverly Hills police and bomb squad were in a standoff with a motorist in a usually busy intersection of downtown Saturday night. Two police cruisers and the bomb squad's armored ... Read more »

The big picture: the decline and fall of a utopian social housing scheme

In 1934, the newly installed housing director of Leeds city council, RAH Livett, toured Europe inspecting the latest modernist housing blocks. Quarry Hill flats in Leeds city centre was subsequently ... Read more »

Kerajaan minta Gardenia tangguh naik harga roti

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Gardenia Bakeries dijangka memberi jawapan selewat-lewatnya esok sama ada bersetuju menangguhkan kenaikan harga atau sebaliknya, menurut Rosol Wahid. PETALING JAYA: Kementerian Dalam Negeri dan ... Read more »

Riot-hit Solomons begins clean up as more foreign troops arrive

© Provided by Al Jazeera The aftermath of a looted street in Honiara’s Chinatown, Solomon Islands,, November 27 [Piringi Charley/ AP] Clean-up operations have started in the riot-hit capital of ... Read more »

Chinese police capture North Korean convict on the run

Chinese police have captured a North Korean prisoner who staged a daring escape from jail in October and had been on the run for more than forty days, authorities said ... Read more »

Matthew Stafford adds new storyline to Rams-Packers playoff rematch

Where do we start with storylines for Sunday’s game between the Rams and Packers? Green Bay (8-3) is coming off a loss to Minnesota and hasn’t lost consecutive games since ... Read more »

Janhvi Kapoor recreates Bigg Boss Pooja Mishra's viral fight video. Arjun Kapoor reacts

Janhvi Kapoor is here to make our weekends a little more exciting. The actress shared a hilarious video, in which she can be seen recreating former Bigg Boss contestant, Pooja ... Read more »

Easy rider? We'll miss the roar, but electric motorbikes can't kill our road romance

For bikers, combustive power is one of the thrills of a long-haul trip. But flat batteries and charging points will just become part of exciting new journeys A full tank ... Read more »

BTS ARMYs Plan Jin's Advance Birthday Celebration, to Do This During Permission to Dance on Stage Concert

© Provided by News18 After a long wait, BTS ARMYs will finally get to see the septet perform live as the boys are back on stage with their Permission to ... Read more »

Shoojit Sircar reveals Varun Dhawan's October boomed on OTT: More people saw it there than when it released

© Provided by Pinkvilla Shoojit Sircar held our attention earlier this month when his film Sardar Udham starring Vicky Kaushal released. The film garnered praise and attention from all corners ... Read more »

Meet CCF, an Ayurvedic kadha for weight loss that also works as a complete detox

CCF… naam toh suna hi hoga! Nope! We promise you would be pleased to meet this one. Ladies say hello to CCF or the cumin-coriander-fennel kadha. Are you wondering why ... Read more »

Happy Birthday Yami Gautam: Top 5 Movies Of the Actress

© Provided by News18 Bollywood star Yami Gautam started her career in the Hindi film industry with Vicky Donor, starring alongside actor Ayushmann Khurrana. She’s known for her simple yet ... Read more »

When Aayush Sharma fell on Aamir Khan on his wedding day - Watch hilarious video!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Salman Khan’s brother-in-law and actor Aayush Sharma has been basking high after the release of his most-anticipated film ‘Antim: The Final Truth’. He ... Read more »

Soni Razdan pens sweet birthday note for daughter Shaheen Bhatt; Riddhima Kapoor Sahni sends wishes

© Provided by Pinkvilla Filmmaker Mahesh Bhatt and Soni Razdan’s younger daughter Shaheen Bhatt has turned a year older. She is celebrating her birthday today and there are wishes coming ... Read more »

IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st Test Match, Day 4: Tim Southee Strikes Twice as India Lose Half Their Side

© Provided by News18 IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st Test Match, Day 4: Tim Southee Strikes Twice as India Lose Half Their Side IND vs NZ, Live Score, 1st ... Read more »

Bangladesh vs Pakistan, 1st Test Day 3 from Chattogram: Live Cricket Score and Updates

2021-11-28 10:35:00 IST asdasdasds Read more »

Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson looked 'happy' together, claims fan who clicked selfies with the duo in LA

© Provided by Pinkvilla Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson are currently the talk of the town and a fan who ran into the duo at the Beverly Hills Hotel opened ... Read more »

Pengembara VTL darat wajib jalani ujian Covid-19 setiba di Singapura

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Semua pengembara dari Malaysia yang menyertai Laluan Perjalanan Lengkap Vaksin darat wajib menjalani ujian saringan Covid-19 setiba di Singapura. (Gambar Bernama) PETALING JAYA: Pengembara ... Read more »

Flight attendant's hack for 'less stressful and more enjoyable' flying - ‘get in the zone'

Laura Reynolds has been flying for two decades and there “isn’t many places in the world” she hasn’t been. With in-depth knowledge of most destinations and a love for travel, ... Read more »

Low expectations on nuclear talks as Iran creates facts on the grounds

© Reuters/Leonhard Foeger FILE PHOTO: The Iranian flag waves in front of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) headquarters in Vienna By John Irish, Francois Murphy and Parisa Hafezi PARIS ... Read more »

Dozens on S Africa flights test positive for COVID in Netherlands

© Provided by Al Jazeera People walk inside Schiphol Airport after Dutch health authorities said that 61 people who arrived in Amsterdam on flights from South Africa tested positive for ... Read more »

Around 30 People Loot a Best Buy Store in US' Minnesota on Black Friday

© Rajashree Seal | News Desk Black Friday shoppers leave a Best Buy store in Washington, DC, on November 26, 20221. Known as Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic