Coalition plans to scrap recovery plans for 200 endangered species and habitats

The Morrison government has proposed scrapping recovery plans for almost 200 endangered species and habitats including the Tasmanian devil, the whale shark and the endangered glossy-black cockatoo populations on Kangaroo Island, one of the worst-affected areas in the 2019-20 bushfires.

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Michal Čížek/AFP/Getty Images

Environment groups have decried the move as a backward step less than 12 months after a statutory review of Australia’s national environmental laws found successive governments had failed to protect the country’s unique wildlife.

Recovery plans are documents that set out actions needed to stop the extinction of species. Ministers are legally bound not to make decisions that are inconsistent with them.

Since changes were made to legislation in 2007 they have been increasingly replaced with what’s known as a conservation advice, a similar document but which does not have the same legal force under national law.

Related: Tasmanian devils wipe out thousands of penguins on tiny Australian island

Guardian Australia has previously reported that fewer than 40% of listed threatened species have a recovery plan. A further 10% of all those listed have been identified as requiring a recovery plan but those plans haven’t been developed or are unfinished. Even more plans are out of date.

© Photograph: Michal Čížek/AFP/Getty Images The Tasmanian devil is among 200 endangered species and habitats that would lose their recovery plan under Coalition proposal.

The federal environment department revealed last year it had not finalised a single recovery plan for threatened species in nearly 18 months and more than 170 were overdue. All listed species, including those requiring a recovery plan, have a conservation advice.

This year, the government asked the independent threatened species scientific committee (TSSC), which advises it on endangered wildlife, to review recovery plans for 914 threatened species and habitats to determine which should continue to have a recovery plan and which could just have a conservation advice.

The committee provided advice that 676 no longer required a recovery plan.

The government is responding to the committee’s recommendations in stages and on Friday published for public consultation the first tranche of 157 animals and plants and 28 ecological communities for which it proposes scrapping recovery plans.

They include the vulnerable green and golden bell frog and the spectacled flying-fox, which had its threat status upgraded to endangered after heatwaves in 2019.

Among the ecological communities is the critically endangered Cumberland plain woodland, one of the most under pressure woodlands in the country as a result of urban development in western Sydney.

It has been identified as requiring a recovery plan since 2009 but no plan has ever been finalised.

Labor’s environment spokeswoman, Terri Butler, said on Friday “Scott Morrison has given up on saving iconic Australian species.”

“The 2019-20 bushfires killed or displaced 3 billion animals and his response now is to cut 157 recovery plans.”

The Greens’ environment spokeswoman, Sarah Hanson-Young, said the government was seeking to rewrite its obligations and was “putting up the white flag on saving our wildlife and native plants”.

Related: New threatened species strategy won’t overcome Australia’s appalling record, campaigners say

“Downgrading the level of obligation on the minister is downgrading the protection of our native animals and species,” she said.

“This is all about letting the minister off the hook – the Morrison government has dropped the ball on protecting our environment and wildlife and now they want to change the rules and responsibilities.”

Helene Marsh, the chair of the threatened species scientific committee, told Guardian Australia that the species and habitats the committee had assessed were those for which recovery plans had expired, were due to expire or were overdue.

She said the committee had carefully considered every plant, animal and habitat and determined that overall about 13% of the country’s wildlife required a recovery plan.

Marsh said recovery planning had been ineffective, with plans often unfunded and actions not implemented.

She said a conservation advice could be as detailed and useful a tool, could be developed more quickly, and rapidly updated after an emergency such as the bushfire disaster.

“We’ve looked at whether a recovery plan will make a difference or not and we’ve looked at every single one in great detail,” she said. “A conservation advice can be updated and in these times of fires and climate change is a much more nimble instrument.”

Marsh told Guardian Australia that the most important reforms the government could make for Australia’s wildlife would be to implement legally binding and detailed national environmental standards that were recommended by the former competition watchdog head, Graeme Samuel, in his review of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act.

She said the committee’s recommendations on which species and habitats should not have recovery plans was based, in part, on whether they were regularly affected by development and therefore triggered the need for a development to be assessed under Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act.

She said the committee had recommended that species that regularly triggered the act retain a recovery plan.

However, the Cumberland Plain woodland, the golden sun moth and the striped legless lizard, which all regularly trigger the need for assessment under the act, all appear on the list of proposed habitats and animals that would no longer require a recovery plan.

Samantha Vine, of Birdlife Australia, said a conservation advice was a good foundational document but was not a robust plan to get species off the path to extinction.

The organisation is concerned about the 19 threatened birds that may no longer require a recovery plan, including the glossy black cockatoo populations of Kangaroo Island and South Australia, the northern masked owl and the Abbott’s Booby.

“We completely see where the threatened species scientific committee is coming from because they are overwhelmed,” Vine said. “But walking away from recovery plans because they’re not functioning as well as they should be is not the right approach in an extinction crisis.”

Brendan Sydes, a lawyer and policy adviser at the Australian Conservation Foundation, said recovery plans were not working as well as they should but the answer was not to abandon them all together.

“Conservation advices are not an adequate replacement for recovery plans, as they are much less rigorous in what they require and don’t have the same legal clout,” he said.

“To virtually give up on recovery planning would be a terrible admission that there is no political will to tackle Australia’s extinction crisis.”

A spokesperson for the environment department said the recommendations were based on “the best planning outcome for the individual threatened entity, and are subject to public consultation prior to any final decision being made”.

“This is the first tranche of public consultation which invites the public to provide feedback on proposed subsequent recovery plan decisions for 185 species and ecological communities,” the spokesperson said.

“Subsequent public consultation periods for lists of other species and ecological communities will be held.”

A spokesperson for the environment minister, Sussan Ley, said: “The proposed changes have been recommended by the independent Threatened Species Scientific Committee and are now available for public consultation.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Sydneysiders scramble to book flights before November 1 opening date

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Thousands of holiday-hungry Australians raced to book an overseas holiday after NSW announced it would reopen its international border on November 1.   Vaccinated ... Read more »

French ambassador returns to Australia after submarine snub

The French ambassador to Australia has arrived in Sydney, returning weeks after being called back to Paris. Jean-Pierre Thebault landed on Sunday afternoon saying he was “happy to be back” ... Read more »

Shirley Ballas books doctor's appointment after concerned Strictly Come Dancing viewers spot ‘lumps' in her armpit

Shirley Ballas has informed fans she has booked a doctor’s appointment after several Strictly Come Dancing viewers raised concern over “lumps” they’d noticed in her armpit. The head judge, 61, ... Read more »

Yeah Adam Peaty's Girlfriend Noticed Him ‘Almost Kissing' His Strictly Partner Katya Jones After Their Argentine Tango Too

Adam Peaty impressed with his Argentine Tango on Saturday night’s Strictly Come Dancing, but it was the very end of the dance that had everyone talking. As the Olympic swimmer ... Read more »

Matt Hancock loses UN job just four days after his appointment

Matt Hancock pictured in London earlier this year – Mega Matt Hancock has lost his new job at the United Nations just four days after being appointed, following outrage from ... Read more »

New partners and babies on the way. The Married at First Sight cast: Where are they now?

Married At First Sight had us glued to our TV screens for the better part of 2021. © Getty Images New partners and babies on the way. The Married at ... Read more »

Black Friday mattress deals 2021: early sales and our predictions

Black Friday is an excellent time of year to save money on a mattress. Big price drops, extra free gifts, and more offers to choose between than usual make November ... Read more »

Berejiklian ICAC hearings set to begin weeks after shock resignation

Two weeks since her sudden resignation as premier and a year after she first revealed her years-long secret relationship with a disgraced former MP, a corruption inquiry is this week ... Read more »

Joyce expects colleagues to reject deeper cuts to greenhouse gas emissions by 2030

Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce expects his colleagues to reject the idea of making deeper cuts to greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 despite support within the government for stronger action on ... Read more »

Shane Warne vows to make Melbourne 'great again'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Australian cricketing icon Shane Warne has vowed to make Melbourne ‘great again’ after months of harsh lockdowns. Taking to Twitter on Saturday, the ... Read more »

Australia to allows flights from New Zealand's South Island

Quarantine-free flights between Australia and New Zealand‘s South Island are set to resume from Tuesday. Meanwhile, Australians remain unable to freely travel to and from New Zealand‘s North Island. Australia’s ... Read more »

Maggie Gyllenhaal attends the Mill Valley Film Festival

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Maggie Gyllenhaal and Dakota Johnson were spotted posing for a few photos while attending a screening of The Lost Daughter at the Mill ... Read more »

Casualty wasn't on air this weekend, explained

Photo credit: BBC Casualty spoilers follow. Casualty did not air its latest episode as planned this weekend, as the BBC pulled Saturday's new episode from the schedules due to tragic ... Read more »

Daniel Craig appears as surprise guest alongside Rami Malek on SNL

Daniel Craig appears as surprise guest alongside Rami Malek on SNL Daniel Craig made a surprise appearance on Saturday Night Live tonight (October 17). Craig appeared alongside his No Time ... Read more »

Billy Connolly: ‘It might be lovely on the other side'

A fostered-off schoolboy going nowhere fast, turned apprentice welder on the Clyde. A welder turned regionally popular musician. A musician turned nationally popular comic. A comic turned Hollywood actor and ... Read more »

SAS Australia 'was The Sam Burgess Show from day one' sources claim

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A source exclusively revealed to Daily Mail Australia last week that one recruit on this year’s SAS Australia was given preferential treatment all ... Read more »

IRT Tarrawanna aged care centre COVID outbreak leads to death of vaccinated resident

A COVID-19 outbreak in an Illawarra aged care centre has claimed the life of a fully vaccinated man in his 90s. IRT chief executive Patrick Reid expressed his condolences to ... Read more »

Russian filmmakers land back on Earth after 12-day shoot on ISS

A Soyuz space capsule carrying a cosmonaut and two Russian filmmakers has landed after a 3 1/2-hour trip from the International Space Station. The capsule, descending under a red-and-white striped ... Read more »

Britney enjoys 'Saturday night rides' on motorcycle with Sam

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Britney Spears enjoyed some ‘Saturday night rides’ on motorcycles with her fiance Sam Asghari this weekend. The 39-year-old pop star could be spotted ... Read more »

Grant Gustin's The Flash gets new footwear for CW's season eight

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Grant Gustin’s The Flash costume is getting a facelift for season eight. The 31-year-old star of the smash CW series and DC Comics ... Read more »

Gabrielle Union opens up about adenomyosis and coping with the perimenopause

Gabrielle Union has candidly opened up her eventual adenomyosis diagnosis and the fury she felt at it having been missed by doctors for so long. © Bang Showbiz Gabrielle Union ... Read more »

Melbourne to ease world's longest COVID-19 lockdowns as vaccinations rise

By Lidia Kelly MELBOURNE, Oct 17 (Reuters) – Melbourne, which has spent more time under COVID-19 lockdowns than any other city in the world, is set to lift its stay-at-home ... Read more »

China could widen property tax trial, official media outlet reports

BEIJING (Reuters) – China could expand pilot testing of a property tax to Zhejiang province, a former government expert was quoted as saying in an official media outlet on Sunday, ... Read more »

Nicky Hilton and mom Kathy grab dinner in LA

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo They recently put on a glamorous display while attending The Fashion Group International’s ‘Night of Stars’ gala in New York City. But Nicky ... Read more »

Sally Carman: I make an effort for auditions but end up playing down-and-out crackheads

Sally Carman attends the British Soap Awards 2018 in London. (Photo by Tristan Fewings/Getty Images) Corrie and Shameless star Sally Carman says she always gets cast as the 'down-and-out crackhead' ... Read more »

'Strictly' judge Craig Revel Horwood compares Greg Wise to hip op patient

Greg Wise‘s Samba was heavily criticised by the ‘Strictly’ judges. (BBC) Strictly Come Dancing Craig Revel Horwood told actor Greg Wise he looked like he was recovering from hip surgery ... Read more »

Rebel Wilson cuts a very sporty figure on a solo stroll through LA

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Rebel Wilson was spotted going for a solo hike through the hills of Los Angeles on Saturday. The 41-year-old performer appeared to be ... Read more »

Julianne Hough and Malin Akerman lead stars at EMA awards gala in LA

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A handful of stars got all dressed up for a night of entertainment with a focus on environmental messaging, as they attended the ... Read more »

Nazeem Hussein breaks silence about father's death from Covid-19

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Nazeem Hussain has broken his silence about the tragic death of his father from Covid-19 and why he kept quiet about his personal ... Read more »

Suez taught us our future lay in Europe. So will Brexit

Many countries are experiencing economic problems associated with the pandemic and supply chain shortages, but none is in such a bad position as the UK. © Provided by The Guardian ... Read more »

Nationals not in a rush on climate deal

The Nationals won’t rush a decision on support for a new plan to reduce emissions, despite pressure to seal a deal with the Liberals before UN climate talks. © Mick ... Read more »

Inside the bitter feud that's torn Sam Newman's popular podcast apart

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Sam Newman’s podcast team is torn apart after a bitter behind-the-scenes dispute erupted with his executive producer. Football commentator Rod Law walked away ... Read more »

Gladys Berejiklian will be investigated by ICAC tomorrow. Here's everything you need to know.

Two weeks after stepping down as the NSW Premier, the time has come for Gladys Berejiklian to face an investigation by the state’s anti-corruption watchdog.  © Getty Images Gladys Berejiklian ... Read more »

Blake Lively takes a humorous jab at Ryan Reynolds' future plans

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Blake Lively poked fun at Ryan Reynolds’ announcement that he planned to take a brief hiatus from acting that was shared to his ... Read more »

Bangladeshi capital rocked by second day of protest as blasphemous footage sparks wave of anti-Hindu violence

Activists of Islami Andolan Bangladesh take part in a protest outside the National Mosque in Dhaka (Munir Uz Zaman/AFP via Getty Images) Thousands of protesters have taken to the streets ... Read more »

The murky past behind this breathtaking 'diamond lake'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo An abandoned coal mine is now one of Australia’s finest natural swimming holes – but it’s murky past means you dive in at ... Read more »

The bizarre secret ingredient behind Rachael Finch's chocolate cake

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Rachael Finch has shared her remarkably simple recipe for a frosted chocolate cake you ‘won’t feel guilty about’.  The former Miss Universe Australia, ... Read more »

Sydney is 'open for business'

Sydney is open for business and it is not looking back, says Sky News host James Morrow. “People are out, people are having a great time, the vibe and the ... Read more »

New COVID-19 exposure sites after truckie visit

South Australian health authorities have identified new COVID-19 exposure sites linked to a truck driver who entered the state while infectious with the virus. The driver entered South Australia from ... Read more »

New South Wales to no longer be classified as a national COVID-19 hotspot

New South Wales will have its status as a Commonwealth COVID-19 hotspot removed tonight after the state reached the 80 per cent fully vaccinated mark. The state has been a ... Read more »