Climate tribalism is pointless – we must reach across the political divide and work together

© Getty Images/iStockphoto

‘The successful climate movement won’t be radical or moderate – it will be both’

– Getty Images/iStockphoto

With each fresh environmental disaster, another cohort of society realises for the first time the trouble we’re in. Increasingly, they understand that nobody – least of all, the government – is coming to save us. Therefore we’re all responsible for humanity’s path through this deadly crisis.

Extinction Rebellion [XR] has done much to accelerate this awakening; legitimating the language of emergency, driving climate action up the agenda. But the scale of this realisation is not matched by an appetite for XRs tactics; the movements self-declared goal of mobilising 3.5 per cent of the population has not materialised. Nonetheless, a growing legion is newly aware of the crisis facing them.

Those who now understand the extent of the climate crisis want to know what they can do to prevent an imminent horror from unfolding.

Cop26 is firmly on course to fail us, governments may pretend otherwise, but it appears inevitable. If humanity is to escape unmitigated catastrophe, mass climate action is needed to force a course correction.

A mass movement is required to push for transformational, system-level change, and to act directly where needful change is opposed. Its aims may be no less radical than those of XR. But goals cannot be realised by radical tactics alone – the multitude primed to join the movement comprises mainstream elements of society with little interest in radical identity.

XR has shifted what’s considered politically possible. Within the space they have opened up, a mass ‘moderate flank’ can and must form.

In fact, we need a thousand moderate flowers to bloom in the fertile ground prepared by Greta Thunberg and XR. Several young organisations are showing the way, Parents For Future and Lawyers for Net Zero among them. The ‘Goldilocks zone’ they inhabit lies between conventional voting, lobbying and consumer action on one hand, and mass non-violent direct action on the other.

In particular, these pioneers of the new climate movement can highlight the vast resource that is our working life. Workers can create change entrepreneurially – pressing for rapid action from management and, where this is resisted, preparing to strike – a tactic modelled already by our children. If they can do it, surely we can?

Workplace-based action must be designed to limit the emerging spike in destructive economic activity. It can build on unforeseen gifts of the pandemic, such as the shift in perceptions around carbon-heavy commuting.

To make this happen, we must prepare the ground for converts with no prior enthusiasm for activism. Some will hold centrist views or incline towards the right. Many will not resonate with identity politics. That way of doing inclusion is not inclusive to them.

Securing their commitment will require a consciously variegated movement in which they feel welcome. We must consider the planet before polarisation.

The awakening that we seek to manifest is much broader than anything attracting a ‘woke’ label.

The successful climate movement won’t be radical or moderate – it will be both. It’s crucial that moderate flanks don’t call radical flanks out with harshness or negativity – and that radicals don’t characterise moderates with contempt or a sense of anticlimax.

Our great power lies in shared fundamental values. The will to protect what we love in the face of existential threat has to be enough. We don’t need to insist on a left, green or anarchist ideology – there isn’t time. Starting from genuinely common ground, such as the cause we share in parenting the future, is common sense.

Dr Rupert Read is an associate professor at the University of East Anglia, a former spokesperson for Extinction Rebellion, and the author of “Parents for a Future”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


State of Terror by Hillary Clinton and Louise Penny review: a topical, zippy read

© AFP via Getty Images hillaryclinton Ellen Adams is “medium height, trim with good dress sense” and secretary of state to the President she distrusts. A reckoning with the Trump ... Read more »

The cheeky reason the Queen turned down this award

Photo credit: Max Mumby/Indigo – Getty Images Being the nation's longest-reigning British monarch (having been on the throne for almost 70 years), it makes sense that the Queen would be ... Read more »

Uttarakhand floods: Dramatic video shows rescuers using digger to pull family car free from landslide in India

A dramatic video captured the moment a digger was used to rescue a family trapped inside a car that was being swept away in gushing floodwaters following a landslide in ... Read more »

Election truther Terry McAuliffe hosts election truther Stacey Abrams

Democratic Virginia gubernatorial candidate Terry McAuliffe has made former President Donald Trump’s 2020 election trutherism a chief focus of his campaign. © Provided by Washington Examiner Republican candidate Glenn Youngkin, ... Read more »

Watchdog investigates T-Mobile Polish unit over extra charges

© Reuters/Mike Blake T-Mobile logo is advertised on building sign in Los Angeles WARSAW (Reuters) – Polish consumer watchdog UOKiK has launched proceedings against the local unit of T-Mobile after ... Read more »

These Bake Off Memes Perfectly Portray The Stress Of Episode 5

The Great British Bake Off 2021 is in full swing and we are absolutely thrilled to be getting to know the contestants and snoop at them on social media. Speaking ... Read more »

Inside Steve Bruce's Newcastle reign: "Tactically inept cabbage head" to Rafa Benitez jibe

Steve Bruce’s exit from Newcastle United will be more dignified and gracious than his two turbulent years in charge. Social media death threats, chants for his sacking, an infamous bust ... Read more »

BARMM partners with UK, UNICEF to address COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among residents

© Bangsamoro Information Office BARMM partners with UK, UNICEF to address COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among residents The Bangsamoro government has collaborated with foreign partners to address COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in ... Read more »

Lloyds and Halifax to close 48 more branches across England and Wales - see full list

Lloyds Banking Group is to close 48 branches across England and Wales, including seven Halifax branches. The lender said the closures are linked to changing customer habits with 18 million ... Read more »

Blue Ivy Carter makes cameo in Beyonce and Jay-Z's bonus Tiffany's film

© Bang Showbiz Beyonce, Blue Ivy and Jay-Z Blue Ivy Carter makes a cameo appearance in Beyonce and Jay-Z’s bonus ‘Date Night’ ad for Tiffany & Co.’s About Love campaign. ... Read more »

SAD: Everything You Need to Know

It’s common to struggle with energy levels, mood and motivation during the winter months, but for 20% of the population, there’s more at play than simply winter blues. Spotting the ... Read more »

India vs Australia Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match: Glenn Maxwell Dismissed by Rahul Chahar, Stoinis Joins Smith in the Middle

© Provided by News18 India vs Australia Live Score, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match: Glenn Maxwell Dismissed by Rahul Chahar, Stoinis Joins Smith in the Middle India vs Australia, ... Read more »

Vera Wang reveals Jennifer Gates' second custom made gown for her wedding

© Provided by There was no messing around when it came to the wedding dress, or should we say dresses, of Bill Gates’ daughter Jennifer Gates on one of ... Read more »

Manager Spurs rejected emerges as favourite for Newcastle job

© PA Images Paulo Fonseca watches his team while at Roma Former Roma boss Paulo Fonseca is a target for managerless Premier League side Newcastle United, according to reports. Fonseca, ... Read more »

Jubilant FoodWorks' net profit up by 58% in Sep quarter on strong orders post COVID's second wave

© BCCL Jubilant FoodWorks’ net profit up by 58% in Sep quarter on strong orders post COVID’s second wave Shares of Jubilant FoodWorks fell more than 8% on lower than ... Read more »

Hearts manager Robbie Neilson hit with three-game SFA ban after Rangers red card

© Hearts manager Robbie Neilson is banned for three matches. He has accepted the Scottish Football Association’s punishment for misconduct and been given a one-game suspension. However, that has also ... Read more »

Dune review: Spectacular sci-fi adaptation is this generation's Lord of the Rings trilogy

© Warner Bros/Legendary Zendaya and Timothée Chalamet in ‘Dune’ – Warner Bros/Legendary Dir: Denis Villeneuve. Starring: Timothée Chalamet, Rebecca Ferguson, Oscar Isaac, Josh Brolin, Stellan Skarsgård, Dave Bautista, Zendaya. Cert ... Read more »

‘What Nonsense' Fans Slam ‘Mumbai Lobby' For Punishing Bhuvi For Hardik's Poor Form

© Provided by MensXP With not much time left in their opening encounter against Pakistan, everyone from fans to experts are  busy predicting what India’s Playing XI might look like ... Read more »

Bake Off in fix row as Freya sent home despite George serving up RAW dough in German week

THE Great British Bake Off surprised contestants and viewers with its first German-themed week – and fans were unhappy with the results. A staple of Tuesday night television, the Channel ... Read more »

Must-read of the week: the graveyard of gwenna luna

© Provided by The Scotsman Anthology The Graveyard of Gwenna Luna by Guenther Primig combines the best of classic and contemporary horror with a terror-bound coming-of-age saga dripping with atmosphere. ... Read more »

Coronavirus digest: Germany likely to miss vaccine donation target, says report

© Provided by A Health Ministry official said bureaucratic, logistical and legal problems keep Germany from reaching its donation target Germany could miss its goal to donate 100 million ... Read more »

Digital Vibes: Zweli Mkhize fights SIU report

© Provided by CapeTalk Disgraced former Health Minister Zweli Mkhize wants the SIU report into the Digital Vibes saga to be set aside Mkhize says he was ambushed during questioning, ... Read more »

Oil & gas giant Total downplayed climate threat: study

© Hector RETAMAL Oil and gas giants well aware of the dire risks posed by rising temperatures nonetheless undermining confidence in climate science French oil and gas major Total deliberately ... Read more »

Where to Reveal the Command Symbol in Fortnite

Here’s where you need to reveal the command symbol for Ariana Grande’s new Fortnite quest. Ariana Grande has returned to Fortnite, this time as the galaxy’s greatest monster hunter. Her ... Read more »

Netflix workers stage walk-out over Chappelle transgender comments

1 / 2Netflix workers stage walk-out over Chappelle transgender commentsFILE PHOTO: Comedian Dave Chappelle receives the Mark Twain Prize in Washington By Dawn Chmielewski (Reuters) – Netflix Inc employees are ... Read more »

UPSC launches helpline for govt job aspirants from economically weaker section, backward classes

The Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) on Wednesday launched a toll-free helpline to help government job aspirants from economically weaker sections and backward classes among others. The UPSC conducts civil ... Read more »

Pope praises freedom of children after boy gets a skullcap

1 / 7Vatican PopePope Francis talks with a 10-year-old boy Paolo Junior, family name not available, after he unexpectedly walked up to him at the beginning of a weekly general ... Read more »

U.S. highway expansions increase traffic and pollution, environmental groups say

Cars drive along Highway 50 in heavy smoke from Caldor Fire, in Sacramento By Tina Bellon AUSTIN, Texas (Reuters) – U.S. policies of expanding highways to ease congestion are misguided ... Read more »

Home Office intervenes over spate of alleged spikings on nights out

The home secretary has requested an urgent update from police on investigations into a spate of reports of women having their drink spiked or being drugged by injection on nights ... Read more »

Colwill starts: The predicted Cardiff City XI to face Fulham tonight

© Provided by Football League World Rubin Colwill n Many people expected to see Mick McCarthy given his marching orders after Cardiff City’s 3-0 defeat to Swansea City in the ... Read more »

Russian healthcare system feels the strain as daily COVID-19 deaths break record

Hospital for patients infected with the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in Moscow MOSCOW (Reuters) – Russia's healthcare system is operating under great strain, Health Minister Mikhail Murashko said on Wednesday, as ... Read more »

Eufy RoboVac 15C Max: Get £70 off this five-star robot vacuum

© Expert Reviews Eufy RoboVac 15C Max: Get £70 off this five-star robot vacuum Cleaning The Eufy RoboVac 15C Max was our best-value robot vacuum cleaner at £250, which makes this ... Read more »

The EVOKE team on the lash extension mascaras they can't live without

© Provided by Lash extension mascaras are everywhere right now, as are plenty of hacks to make them work harder. But which ones really deliver that long fluttery look ... Read more »

Queen Elizabeth II 'advised to rest' on medical grounds: palace

© Alastair Grant Queen Elizabeth II hosted international business leaders at Windsor Castle on Tuesday Queen Elizabeth II has cancelled a planned trip to Northern Ireland on medical grounds, Buckingham ... Read more »

Orionid meteor shower to light up night sky

The sky is set to be illuminated by shooting stars as the Earth passes through the debris left by Halley’s Comet. But stargazers may be denied the full sight as ... Read more »

Four new Covid-19 clusters, three in workplaces

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: The health ministry has detected four new Covid-19 clusters in the past 24 hours, health director-general Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah said today. ... Read more »

Forest Green Rovers' academy manager Hannah Dingley speaks on being a female football coach

© GiveMeSport Forest Green Rovers’ academy manager Hannah Dingley discusses being a female coach in the male-dominated world of football Rugby may often be seen as the most popular sport ... Read more »

Lebanon violence is a dangerous distraction from reform, experts say

© NABIL MOUNZER A protest on Tuesday against Hezbollah in front of the Justice Palace in Beirut. EPA One of Lebanon’s worst episodes of violence since the end of the ... Read more »

Jeddah's newest cafe is inspired by Japanese pop culture

© Motivate Publishing Geek Cafe Jeddah Anime-lovers, this one is for you.. Coffeehouses hold a treasured place in communities and fostering connection in addition to keeping customers caffeinated and full ... Read more »

N.B. city explores an overlooked heat source: its own industries

© Connell Smith/CBC The city is exploring how to use waste heat from the Irving pulp mill to heat nearby homes and businesses. The city of Saint John is exploring ... Read more »