Climate change misinformation fools too many people – but there are ways to combat it

Asia's Tech News Daily

Hadrian/Shutterstock

In recent decades, people in the UK have watched climate change shift from being an abstract threat discussed on the news to an increasingly common presence in everyday life. As the frequency and intensity of heatwaves, floods and other extreme weather events has risen, so has public concern about climate change. A 2019 poll found 80% of people were fairly or very worried, while a more recent survey ranked climate change as the most important issue.

People are more engaged with the climate crisis than ever before. But how well do they understand it? And which sources of information do they trust the most? We wanted to understand where the public gets much of its information on the topic and what the most effective ways of keeping people informed are.

We surveyed more than 1,700 adults living in the UK and found that almost half the sample were unable to correctly identify 50% of fake climate change news headlines, and almost half (44%) of all respondents were unaware of how often they encountered misinformation online. These numbers suggest that people need more guidance on how to effectively spot misinformation, and how to find reliable information about climate change.

What we found

Working with YouGov and The Conversation, we asked 1,722 people to read five real and four fake news headlines about climate change. Almost half (46%) mistakenly believed that “Scientists disagree on the cause of climate change” and 35% incorrectly thought that “Scientists believe the Sun has impacted the Earth’s rise in temperature”.

However, a majority of respondents also correctly identified fake headlines such as “Carbon dioxide levels are tiny. They can’t make a difference” (70%) and “Melting an ice cube in a measuring cup full of water doesn’t raise the water level, so melting icebergs cannot raise sea levels” (68%).

Over half of respondents correctly guessed the real headlines “More than one million species are at risk of extinction by climate change” (65%), “Earth had its second warmest year in recorded history in 2019” (62%), and “The worst impacts of climate change could be irreversible by 2030” (55%).

But only 15% knew that “Switching to jet fuel made from mustard plants would reduce carbon emissions by nearly 70%” was false, and only 34% were right in thinking that “Enough ice melted on a single day to cover Florida in two inches of water”.

We also asked people how much trust they had in certain sources of climate change information. While online influencers (6%), social media outlets (7%), tabloid newspapers (13%), politicians (20%), journalists (30%), broadsheet newspapers (37%), and broadcast media outlets (38%) were among the least trusted sources, the vast majority trusted academics (67%) and their own friends and family (59%) to convey information about climate change that was trustworthy.

Academic researchers were the most trusted source on climate change. Maridav/Shutterstock

A majority of those we surveyed thought accurate reporting was important, with 78% saying that climate change misinformation is very or fairly damaging to efforts to tackle the climate crisis.

When asked about media coverage of climate change, 39% claimed that media reporting overall was too abstract, with excessive focus on the future rather than the issues of today. Similarly, 29% thought media coverage was confusing, citing too many conflicting opinions (55%) and a distrust of politicians (55%) and news outlets (54%).

Finally, the majority of respondents (59%) were worried about climate change, with an even larger majority (80%) reporting a general willingness to make relevant lifestyle changes to stem the crisis.

What this means

Despite widespread awareness of the problems caused by fake news, many people we surveyed didn’t recognise their own role in this process. While large majorities worried about the effects of climate change misinformation and said that they didn’t share it themselves, 24% reported hardly ever fact-checking the information they read.

This could suggest the public aren’t sure which sources are reliable, making them more vulnerable to the very misinformation they see as damaging to the cause of tackling climate change.

Clearly, more can be done to educate people on how to distinguish real from fake climate change information. One way to do this is through a process called inoculation, or prebunking.

Just as vaccines train cells to detect foreign invaders, research has shown that stories which pre-emptively refute short extracts of misinformation can help readers develop mental antibodies that allow them to detect misinformation on their own in the future. Recent work has even used games to help people detect the larger strategies that are used to spread misinformation about climate change.

Although social media companies such as Facebook have started to debunk climate myths on their platform, politicians and social media outlets appear to have an untrustworthy reputation. This was not the case for sources with perceived expertise on the topic, such as scientists. We therefore recommend that the trust held towards experts should be harnessed, by more frequently disseminating their views on social media and in traditional media outlets.

In our survey, only 21% of people understood that between 90% and 100% of climate scientists have concluded that humans are causing climate change (99% according to a recent paper). Decades-long campaigns by fossil fuel companies have sought to cast doubt on the scientific consensus. Media messages should therefore continue to communicate the overwhelming scientific consensus on climate change.

Through years of research on the topic, we have identified several ingredients for trustworthy science communication. These include prebunking myths and falsehoods, reliably informing people (don’t persuade), offering balance but not false balance (highlight the weight of evidence or scientific consensus), verifying the quality of the underlying evidence, and explaining sources of uncertainty. If communicators want to earn people’s trust, they need to start by displaying trustworthy behaviour.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Mikey Biddlestone's research is funded by a Cabinet Office Infodemic Grant.

Sander van der Linden has consulted on this research for The Conversation and receives research funding on misinformation from the UK government, Google, and the EU Commission. He consults on climate misinformation for Facebook.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

WhatsApp may kick you out of linked devices for security reasons

The rollout of multi-device support has proved to be one of the most popular features of WhatsApp ever. While it’s still only possible to be logged into an account on ... Read more »

EU's 'roam like at home' system is extended for a decade

BRUSSELS (AP) — The European Union reached a political agreement Thursday to extend cuts to costly mobile-phone roaming costs in the bloc for another decade, affecting travel for tens of ... Read more »

Samsung's Lee returns from UAE amid expectation of 5G partnership

Lee Jae-yong (left), Vice Chairman of Samsung Electronics, and Kim Won-kyong, Samsung Electronics Executive Vice President in charge of global public affairs, arrive at Seoul Gimpo Business Avation Center at ... Read more »

Google Chrome gets support for Android 12's scrolling screenshots feature, here's how you can use it

A few months ago Google introduced the scrolling screenshot feature in Android 12. The feature allows users to capture a screenshot of content that is scrollable. With this feature, users ... Read more »

‘GTA Online': Franklin returns to help Dr. Dre retrieve his stolen phone containing unreleased music

From the ‘GTA Online – The Contract’ trailer | Photo credit: Rockstar Games / YouTube screenshot The next update to “GTA Online” is going to be star-studded. Rockstar Games announced ... Read more »

Christina Aguilera channeled the 'Dirrty' music video look 19 years later at the People's Choice Awards

Christina Aguilera at the People’s Choice Awards in 2021, and promoting her single “Dirrty” in 2002.Todd Williamson/E! Entertainment/NBCUniversal/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images, Theo Wargo/WireImage Christina Aguilera channeled her iconic ... Read more »

Vivo Y55s launched with 6,000 mAh battery, MediaTek Dimensity 700: All you need to know

The Vivo Y55s was recently unveiled in China. The Vivo Y55s debuts as a budget 5G smartphone. The Y55s 5G also has the biggest battery capacity of any smartphone in ... Read more »

Moto Edge X30 launch live blog: see the mysterious new Motorola phone unveiled

Refresh 2021-12-09T08:38:56.219Z Welcome to our Moto Edge X30 live blog – we’ve got a few hours to go until the event kicks off, but there’s some more information and insight ... Read more »

BTS lose out to Boris Johnson as UK's second most tweeted about people of 2021

Korean pop stars BTS were the second most tweeted about people of 2021, losing out only to Prime Minister Boris Johnson, according to the social media site’s annual UK data ... Read more »

Captain Sir Tom Moore memorial post leads Twitter's end-of-year report

The memorial message for Captain Sir Tom Moore was the most retweeted and liked post on Twitter in the UK this year, the platform has revealed. The tweet announcing the ... Read more »

What BMW's Concept XM says about luxury car brands in an electric world: the German company didn't learn from Tesla or Rivian, and Apple might be the winner …

This article is part of STYLE’s Luxury Column There was a time when luxury cars were head turners in a positive way. Sculptures on wheels. Objects of desire. Beautiful creations. ... Read more »

Didi's latest fines for unlicensed cars, drivers highlight compliance uncertainty ahead of Hong Kong listing

Didi Global, China’s leading ride-hailing company that will delist from the New York Stock Exchange due to Beijing’s data security concerns, has been fined by local authorities for operating with ... Read more »

Top Twitter moments of 2021: These tweets of PM Narendra Modi, Ratan Tata and Virat Kohli top the list

Microblogging site Twitter has released a list of top tweets of 2021. The list gives a recap of most-liked, most retweeted and others in different categories. It includes tweets shared ... Read more »

Oppo's first foldable smartphone Find N to debut on December 15

The Oppo Find N foldable smartphone will be revealed on the second day of INNO Day 2021, i.e., December 15. Oppo is gearing up to launch its first foldable smartphone ... Read more »

Skin N Skin to raise 5 bln won via stock sale

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Skin N Skin Co.on Thursday announced that it will sell stocks to raise 5 billion won (US$4.3 million). The proceeds from the stock offering will ... Read more »

Skin N Skin to raise 999 mln won via stock offering

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Skin N Skin Co.on Thursday announced that it will sell stocks to raise 999 million won (US$850,574). The proceeds from the stock sale will be ... Read more »

Skin N Skin to raise 3.8 bln won via stock sale

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Skin N Skin Co.on Thursday announced that it will sell stocks to raise 3.8 billion won (US$3.3 million). The proceeds from the stock offering will ... Read more »

Better.com CEO apologises for firing 900 employees on a Zoom call, read the full text of his letter

Vishal Garg, CEO, better.com, created quite a stir earlier this week when he fired 900 employees on a Zoom call. There has been backlash, memes, jokes and whatnot over his ... Read more »

Covid omicron news – live: Sajid Javid rules out mandatory vaccine in UK despite PM's call to consider it

Introducing mandatory coronavirus vaccines for the UK general public would be ethically wrong and impractical, Sajid Javid has said. The health secretary made the comments just hours after his boss, ... Read more »

‘Assassin's Creed Valhalla' updates to require players to re-download the game due to ‘data restructuring'

From the “Assassin’s Creed Valhalla” story trailer | Photo credit: Ubisoft / YouTube screenshot Ubisoft has confirmed for months now that it will support “Assassin’s Creed Valhalla” with new content ... Read more »

Soosung Innovation. to raise 1 bln won via stock offering

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — Soosung Innovation. Co.on Thursday announced that it will sell stocks to raise 1 billion won (US$851,425). The proceeds from the stock sale will be used ... Read more »

Xbox series X UK stock - live: Today's restock news from Argos, Currys, Smyths and Game

We’re expecting more restocks at major UK retailers this week (iStock/The Independent) The Xbox series X launched 12 months ago, but despite becoming Microsoft’s best-selling console is still difficult to ... Read more »

‘God of War' PC: Sony announces system requirements weeks ahead of launch

From the ‘God of War’ PC features trailer | Photo credit: PlayStation / YouTube screenshot With only weeks away from the “God of War” launch on PC, Sony has unveiled ... Read more »

Less than 2% of companies get A grade on climate crisis disclosures

(Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Archive) The number of companies considered leaders on climate crisis action and transparency has fallen sharply this year, according to a global study of more more than ... Read more »

You can now listen to recorded Twitter Spaces on iOS, Android and web

Twitter is also rolling out the ability to record a space on Android Twitter has updated its Clubhouse rival Spaces with an option to record them on Android, a facility ... Read more »

Hospital theatre nurse charged with voyeurism and sexual assaults against patients and staff

The accused theatre nurse worked at the Royal Hallamshire Hospital in Sheffield (Getty Images) An operating theatre nurse has been charged with a series of sexual offences against patients and ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial: Socialite pictured giving Jeffrey Epstein foot rub on private jet

Images of Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein together, including the socialite giving the disgraced financier a sensual foot rub aboard his private jet, have been released by prosecutors in a ... Read more »

S. Korea, France agree to boost ties in new industries, zero-emission policy

SEOUL, Dec. 9 (Yonhap) — South Korea and France on Thursday discussed ways to enhance cooperation on semiconductors, bio and other new industry sectors and their policy directions to achieve ... Read more »

New young leaders set to back Samsung's core strengths

Samsung Electronics Vice Chairman Lee Jae-yong speaks with reporters upon arriving at the Seoul Gimpo Business Aviation Center, after returning from meetings in the United Arab Emirates, Thursday. Yonhap By ... Read more »

Samsung names more young executives for generational shift

From left: Kim Chan-woo, Park Sung-beom, Yang Hye-soon, Jude Buckley. Kim, 45, is the youngest employee to be promoted to executive vice president at the company. He will head Samsung ... Read more »

SpaceX launches NASA X-ray telescope

Continuing an end-of-year launch surge, a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket boosted a NASA X-ray telescope into orbit early Thursday to study the processes at work near collapsed neutron stars, black ... Read more »

Japanese billionaire and his producer arrive at ISS as first self-funded space tourists in over a decade

Russian cosmonaut Alexander Misurkin (C) and space flight participants Japanese billionaire Yusaku Maezawa (L) and his assistant Yozo Hirano attend a training ahead of the expedition to the ISS (POOL/AFP ... Read more »

[Photo News] Self-drive for podium

(KAIST)A self-driving race car of the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology finishes fourth at the Indy Autonomous Challenge held in Indianapolis on Oct. 23.  KAIST said Thursday that ... Read more »

Kotra, foreign chambers to support expatriates on industrial trend

Kotra and 15 foreign chambers of commerce in Korea sign a memorandum of understanding to cooperate in providing educational programs for expatriates working in S. Korea. (Kotra)The state-run trade promotion ... Read more »

Instagram reveals plan to bring back chronological feed sometime in 2022 at US Senate hearing

Photo credit: Souvik Banerjee / Unsplash Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri appeared at the United States Senate on Wednesday to testify on the photo-sharing app's impact on teens. During the hearing, the top executive ... Read more »

Scientists find massive planet 10 times bigger than Jupiter that shouldn't exist

Image shows the largest planet-hosting star pair to date: b Centauri (top left), and its giant planet b Centauri b (lower right). The other bright dot in the image (top ... Read more »

Microsoft Defender review

Microsoft Defender Antivirus doesn’t get much security respect, but it’s been around for a long time. First released as Windows Defender in 2006, then rebranded as Microsoft Defender, it’s been ... Read more »

Meet the Man with a Plan to Bring Life to the Desert

Verticroft holdings is an innovator in the UAE for vertically integrated food security solutions, with a solid track record of producing some of the best lamb meat in the world, ... Read more »

Jungheung Construction to take over Daewoo E&C

Jungheung Group Chairman Jung Chang-sun, left, poses with KDB Investment CEO Lee Dae-hyun after signing a stock purchase agreement to take over 50.75 percent of Daewoo E&C’s shares, at a ... Read more »

France follows SpaceX by developing its own reusable rocket launchers

The French-European space agency Ariane Group is to develop its own reusable rocket launchers – following in the footsteps of Elon Musk's company SpaceX, which pioneered the technology. During a ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic