Claiming a monopoly on truth and decency is no way to win the assisted dying debate

Asia's Tech News Daily

Photograph: Bianca de Marchi/AAP

A man is standing on the parapet of a bridge. He is about to jump. What should you do? Most people would agree that the moral act would be to talk to him to try to persuade him not to. Most people would also agree that giving him a push because “that’s what he wanted” would be committing murder.

Your grandmother is dying. She is in great pain, has only a few days to live and wants you to end her life now. It’s unlikely that most people could bring themselves to do that. But most would probably understand if you did accede to her wishes, however tormented you felt. And even more were a doctor to give her sufficient painkillers to allow her to die in peace.

The debate about assisted dying is one in which there are no simple answers; a debate in which we need to acknowledge that truth and moral decency lie on both sides and in which context is particularly important in judging what is right and wrong. On Friday, the House of Lords debated Baroness Meacher’s assisted dying bill, which would allow terminally ill adults assistance to end their life. It’s unlikely to become law, but the debate will undoubtedly continue.

The Lords debate was respectful, often moving. Much of the wider discussion on the issue, however, is mired in bad faith assumptions: on the one side, the idea that opposition to assisted dying is driven primarily by religious obscurantism and on the other that supporters are tantamount to murderers and “not to be trusted”. Those are not good places from which to start a hugely significant yet highly sensitive public debate.

I am broadly in favour of decriminalising, in a limited fashion, acts of assisted dying but I also understand the force of the arguments from opponents and partly agree with them. This is a terrain to be carefully negotiated.

We can end up giving priority to the state of being alive over an individual’s moral sense of what life means to them

The first, critical argument is about the sanctity of life. This is more than a religious argument. Most of us, religious or irreligious, place special meaning on human life, recognising that we are not merely machines or slabs of meat, but persons, moral agents to whom we accord dignity and respect by virtue of being human.

Few, however, view the sanctity of life in absolute terms. Many who oppose assisted dying support the death penalty. Most would defend the taking of a life in self-defence or accept killing other humans in a war they think is just or necessary. Again, context matters.

The philosopher Ronald Dworkin observed that we value life through three lenses: subjectively (treasuring the inner life of the individual); intrinsically (insisting that a human life is valuable in and of itself); and instrumentally (gauging people through their usefulness for society and other individuals). Opponents of assisted dying rightly stress the intrinsic value of life and worry that in expanding the legal capacity to end life we may be drawn to viewing human worth in more instrumental ways. One of the ironies, though, is that in stressing the intrinsic, we may implicitly downgrade the subjective aspect of being human. We can end up giving priority to the state of being alive – of breathing or being conscious – over an individual’s moral sense of what life means to them. Yet it is that capacity for subjective evaluation that truly makes us human.

A second key argument is that of the “slippery slope” – the belief that one step towards any form of assisted dying would irrevocably lead to a world in which we accepted the culling of the old and the infirm.

There are few spheres of life in which slippery slope arguments have not been deployed. In the late 1960s, a Times leader warned that the new technique of IVF could lead to a race between nations, each “breeding a race of intellectual giants”. Any attempt to decriminalise marijuana becomes a downward path to smack being sold in the corner shop. And, for many, gay marriage is “a slippery slope to polygamy and bestiality”.

It’s a metaphor whose power derives from imagining social developments as though they were natural and inevitable, just as a ball rolls down a slope under gravity. What shapes human laws and conduct, however, are not invisible natural forces but political debate. There is nothing inevitable about social change and taking one step does not mean a slide all the way to the bottom.

Many critics point to developments in the Netherlands as an example of a slippery slope. In 2002, assisted dying was legalised for people with incurable illnesses facing “unbearable suffering”. Over the past decade, there has been a debate over extending the law to all those over 75 who feel they have “completed” their life. This, indeed, would be a calamitous move. The problem, though, is not the mythical slippery slope, but that critics have not yet convinced proponents that their proposals are dangerous and wrong. This, as much as any other contentious issues, from Brexit to immigration, should be worked out through public debate, not fear-mongering about slippery slopes.

Linked to slippery slope arguments are fears that assisted dying laws will devalue the lives of old or disabled people. Many might feel they are a burden on their families or on society and so feel a pressure to die. These are important issues and a primary reason the proposed expansion of the law in the Netherlands is so troubling. Society should view the elderly and the vulnerable as people to whom we have obligations, not as inconveniences weighing us down.

The real issue, though, is less the law than wider social attitudes towards elderly and disabled people. During the Covid pandemic, there have been abuses of “do not resuscitate” orders, apparently given to care home residents and those with learning difficulties without regard for their wishes or welfare. The stories are shocking, but few would argue that the solution lies in getting rid of DNR notices. The same logic should shape the assisted dying debate, too.

There are many other questions – from the need for improved palliative care to the relationship between individual choice and the common good – with which to wrestle in this debate. Too often, though, these get entangled in a common refusal to see the significance of the argument from the other side. Compassion and moral righteousness don’t belong in bunkers.

• Kenan Malik is an Observer columnist

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Roberto Mancini wasn't at Leicester long, but he left an indelible mark

Roberto Mancini only played five games in a Leicester City shirt, but the former Italy international certainly left his mark. © PA Images Roberto Mancini playing for Leicester at Filbert ... Read more »

BBC Strictly Come Dancing: Shirley Ballas shares huge health update as she thanks 'loving' fans

Strictly Come Dancing judge Shirley Ballas has shared a huge health update with fans as she revealed tests on her kidneys had come back showing no signs of cancer. The ... Read more »

'For Sunday' - Celtic receive big Aberdeen boost as Devlin issues update on 'extra special' star

Celtic’s Tom Rogic should be available for Sunday’s SPFL clash with Aberdeen, according to The Athletic’s Kieran Devlin.  © Provided by Transfer Tavern Celtic’s Tom Rogic The Lowdown Celtic will ... Read more »

Mikel Arteta sent warning amid rumours Arsene Wenger is returning to Arsenal

Tony Cascarino has questioned why Mikel Arteta opened the door for Arsene Wenger to return to Arsenal. Gunners boss Arteta strongly hinted Wenger could take up a role with the ... Read more »

Lando Norris makes Lewis Hamilton confession with perspective on fame

Lando Norris has admitted he’s “not Lewis Hamilton” when it comes to levels of popularity in F1. The McLaren driver is one of the sport’s rising stars, and currently occupies ... Read more »

Roberto Firmino, Naby Keita, Joe Gomez - Liverpool injury latest and expected return dates before Southampton

Liverpool are back in Premier League action this weekend as they prepare to face Southampton at Anfield. The Reds have returned after the international break with convincing wins over Arsenal ... Read more »

Furious Bayern Munich fans demand president resigns as AGM descends into chaos

© EPA FC Bayern Munich President Herbert Hainer was booed – EPA Bayern Munich’s annual general meeting ended in tumult with members yelling and booing the club’s directors for refusing ... Read more »

Ralf Rangnick's sent great Manchester United challenge as appointment looms

Andrei Kanchelskis believes the job on Ralf Rangnick’s hands ahead of his impending Manchester United arrival is a “great challenge”. The German has agreed to a six-month deal to manage ... Read more »

Tailor to the stars who took supermarket job to make ends meet

A tailor who swapped sharp suits for tins of baked beans during lockdown said he would do it all over again. Rich Gregson, 34, and business partner Rob Tattan, 35, ... Read more »

Video: Russia starts full-scale production of its 'unstoppable' 6,670mph Zircon hypersonic missile as Moscow boasts it has capability to evade all Western defences 

Read more »

Black Friday: Three's unlimited data deal is the best you'll find this year

© Expert Reviews three mobile sim only black friday deal lead image Mobile networks Three has a reputation for delivering delicious data deals and this SIM-only offer is a doozie: ... Read more »

Watch: Alison Hammond in stitches as comedian congratulates Dermot for ‘coming out'

© Provided by A comedian managed to get a big laugh out of Alison Hammond on This Morning — but it’s unknown whether or not he planned for the ... Read more »

The Democrats need to stop acting scared, stop scaling back the Build Back Better, and pass the bill right now

© Jose Luis Magana/AP Photo Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., accompanied by House Majority Whip James Clyburn, D-S.C., left and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer D-MD, speaks to ... Read more »

Alexandra Morgan: Second man, 53, arrested on suspicion of murder after mum-of-two vanishes nearly two weeks ago

A SECOND man has been arrested on suspicion of murder following the disappearance of a mum-of-two. Alexandra Morgan – who feared she was being stalked – was last seen on ... Read more »

David McWilliams: ‘Post-COVID boom will raise cost of living'

© Provided by David McWilliams says the economy will recover swiftly from the pandemic but warned of huge hikes in the cost of living, with inflation rates set to ... Read more »

Storm Arwen destroys Christmas attraction on ‘world's oldest railway'

© Provided by PA Media The team at Tanfield Railway said they were ‘devastated’ by the damage (Tanfield Railway/PA) Storm Arwen’s winds have destroyed a “magical” Christmas attraction on the ... Read more »

How Kevin Durant and James Harden are schooling breakout Nets rookie Cam Thomas

Corey Sipkin; Getty Images Bosses often demand the most of their best workers, and teachers are usually toughest on their brightest students. It says something about Cam Thomas that Kevin ... Read more »

Arsenal 0-0 Newcastle LIVE: Aubameyang misses SITTER from three yards in Premier League – Stream FREE, TV channel

ARSENAL are in action against Newcastle at the Emirates Stadium. Mikel Arteta's side were beaten 4-0 at Liverpool last time out, ending their 10-game unbeaten run. JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET ... Read more »

Susanna Reid shares terrifying near death experience after ‘young lad' tried to mug her with a knife and ‘slashed' her

GMB star Susanna Reid told of her terrifying near death experience when man attempted to mug her with a knife. The TV star revealed how she was close to being ... Read more »

‘Covid is no joke' — MMA legend Diego Sanchez hospitalised with ‘blood clots in both legs'

© Provided by MMA legend Diego Sanchez has revealed he has blood clots in both legs as he detailed his horrific battle with COVID-19. The former UFC star has ... Read more »

Dan Walker breaks down in tears during emotional tribute to late Gary Speed

Ten years on from Gary Speed’s death, the loss of the former footballer is still being felt keenly by those who knew him. The then-Wales manager, who also played more ... Read more »

Hasler erfüllt Olympia-Limite

© KEYSTONE/AP/Matthias Schrader Mit einem 8. Rang im Monobob-Rennen in Innsbruck sichert sich die Schweizerin Melanie Hasler frühzeitig das Olympia-Ticket. Nach den Plätzen 8 (Monobob) und 6 (Zweier) vor einer ... Read more »

Bund ruft Flugpassagiere aus Südafrika zu Corona-Test auf

© KEYSTONE/LAURENT GILLIERON Das Bundesamt für Gesundheit (BAG) hat wegen der neuen besorgniserregenden Virusvariante in Zürich ankommende Flugpassagiere aus Südafrika zu Tests aufgefordert. Die Leute sollten sich demnach umgehend auf ... Read more »

Frau ärgert sich über Gruppe ohne Maske im Zug – die Reaktion der SBB gibt zu reden

© sda Teaserbild © sda Nicht alle tragen im Zug die Maske so vorbildlich wie diese Frau. Nicht alle Passagiere halten sich an die Maskenpflicht im öffentlichen Verkehr. Einige schaffen ... Read more »

Omikron: Impfstoff-Experte geht nicht von Neustart der Pandemie aus

© Keystone/ZUMA Press Wire/Tayfun Salci Der Entwickler des Astrazeneca-Impfstoffs gegen Corona, Andrew Pollard, geht nicht von einem dramatischen Neuanfang der Pandemie durch die neue Variante Omikron aus. “Es ist sehr ... Read more »

Virusvariante: Bisher keine systematischen Kontrollen am Flughafen

© KEYSTONE/LAURENT GILLIERON Am Schweizer Landesflughafen Zürich sind am Samstag keine speziellen Kontrollen wegen der besorgniserregenden neuen Coronavirus-Variante Omikron durchgeführt worden. Am Morgen landete dort ein Swiss-Flieger aus dem südafrikanischen ... Read more »

Geisterspiel und volle Hütte: Bundesliga versinkt im Corona-Chaos

© Bereitgestellt von Blick Bundesliga versinkt im Corona-Chaos Die Bundesliga versinkt im Corona-Chaos! Nun hats den RB Leipzig erwischt. Nach Trainer Jesse Marsch und Goalie Peter Gulacsi sind sechs weitere ... Read more »

Shippers prepare for another pandemic crush of holiday gifts

1 / 5Holiday ShippingA worker carries a large parcel at the United States Postal Service sorting and processing facility, Thursday, Nov. 18, 2021, in Boston. Last year’s holiday season was ... Read more »

Ilhan Omar: Lauren Boebert's ‘Jihad Squad' bigotry is ‘no laughing matter'

Photograph: Allison Bailey/Rex/Shutterstock Colorado Republican apologises for remarks in home district Minnesota Democrat demands action from party leaders Islamophobic remarks by Lauren Boebert are “no laughing matter”, Ilhan Omar said, ... Read more »

How poorer citizens pay the price of economic change in the UK

In the 1970s, Britain briefly achieved peak equality. Jean Carlo Emer | Unsplash, FAL Despite the early claims of British prime minister Boris Johnson’s much vaunted plan to cap personal ... Read more »

Susanna Reid reveals she was the victim of a knife crime

© Bang Showbiz Susanna Reid reveals she was the victim of a knife crime Susanna Reid revealed she was attacked by a man with a knife during a terrifying ordeal. ... Read more »

Lacazette says he will leave Arsenal for a ‘beautiful project'

© PA Images Alexandre Lacazette celebrates scoring a goal at the Emirates Alexandre Lacazette admits his agents are looking at potential moves away from Arsenal but will only consider “beautiful ... Read more »

Naughty Boy's family blast trolls

© Bang Showbiz Naughty Boy’s family blast trolls Naughty Boy’s family have hit back at trolls. The 36-year-old music producer – whose real name is Shahid Khan – has been ... Read more »

'She was absolutely furious': Sheridan Smith 'had a backstage meltdown and threatened to SACK her team in row over misogyny following appearance on The Jonathan Ross Show'

Sheridan Smith reportedly had a backstage meltdown and threatened to sack her team in a shock row about misogyny amid her appearance on The Jonathan Ross Show. The entertainer, 40, ... Read more »

Delhi schools to reopen from November 29 for all classes

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia on Saturday (November 27, 2021) announced that schools in the national capital will reopen for all the ... Read more »

WC residents urged to vaccinate ahead of festive season

© Kaylynn Palm/Eyewitness News Jody Ziervogel gets his COVID-19 vaccine shot at the ATlone Stadium drive-through facility in Cape Town on 2 September 2021. CAPE TOWN – With the festive ... Read more »

Michael Vaughan breaks silence on Azeem Rafiq allegation in first BBC interview since axing

Michael Vaughan said he takes ‘some responsibility’ for what Azeem Rafiq went through at Yorkshire but continued to deny an allegation of making a racist remark to some of the ... Read more »

Iman, 66, Shares the Luxe ‘Really Hydrating' Under-Eye Patches She Loves—Here's Where to Find Them

© Gilbert Carrasquillo – Getty Images Supermodel Iman Abdulmajid, 66, shares where to find her top hydrating eye mask—the Peter Thomas Roth 24K Gold Pure Luxury Lift & Firm Hydra-Gel ... Read more »

Amitabh Bachchan remembers father Harivansh Rai on his 114th birth anniversary, shares unseen pic!

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Bollywood megastar marked his father and poet Harivansh Rai Bachchan‘s 114th birth anniversary on Saturday by writing an emotional note, sharing an unseen ... Read more »

About Last Night: Bargain bin performance by Habs on Black Friday

© Provided by The Gazette Buffalo Sabres center Cody Eakin (20) celebrates his goal with left wing Vinnie Hinostroza (29) during the second period against the Montreal Canadiens at KeyBank ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic