Citizens emerge from the slums

PhD student Ying Gao's research reveals that the urban poor in the developing world are politically engaged and capable of effecting change.

School of Humanities Arts and Social Sciences, Policial Science, Urban studies and planning, D-Lab, Poverty, Politics, Housing, Government, Research, Students, Graduate, postdoctoral, Profile, Democracy, Social sciences, Community, Developing countries, Ying Gao, MIT GOV/LAB, MIT D-Lab

The Kampung Lawas Maspati community, located in the city of Surabaya in the East Java province in Indonesia. Image: Ying Gao

Do the world’s nearly 1 billion urban poor, who subsist without legal housing, reliable water and sewer infrastructure, and predictable employment, lack political engagement as well?

Ying Gao does not buy the claim by many social scientists that social and economic marginalization necessarily means political marginalization.

“My results contradict the prevailing wisdom about slums and the political behaviors they are believed to foster,” says Gao, a doctoral student in political science. “I’m discovering that people do not participate less in politics (by voting), in labor markets (by getting jobs), or in social activities (by being active in community groups), just because they lack legal housing.”

Gao’s dissertation project focuses on Indonesia and plumbs a massive dataset tracking a representative sample of 30,000 individuals over 20 years. Her initial findings reveal “a kind of shared urban political culture that is more subtle and interesting than unconditional theories of marginalization would suggest.”

A politically active urban populace, previously unacknowledged and neglected, could prove consequential in the efforts of developing nations to improve the lives of the poor. This is an increasingly urgent matter, Gao says, as developing cities big and small swell with new residents and struggle to meet their needs.

With a background in urban studies and planning and international development, Gao hopes her continued analysis and research will point to public policy interventions that prove useful to governments and aid organizations.

Poverty, but not always a trap

At the heart of Gao’s dissertation research lies the question: In cities of the developing world, do citizens in informal (unregulated) housing or jobs participate in politics differently from those situated in legal housing or employment arrangements?

“The common narrative is that when you move to a slum, there is less access to good services, and it’s harder to get good jobs, which leads to even less social mobility,” says Gao. “This poverty trap story also suggests that under such conditions, where people don’t see much public service because the government is spending more time in places better off, marginalized citizens don’t have as much incentive to vote and demand better services.”

Gao set out to test the premise of these stories, drawing on fine-grained quantitative resources. She seized on the Indonesian Family Life Survey, conducted between 1993 and 2014. “These are high-quality, underutilized datasets that allow me to tease out housing conditions, connect them to social and political outcomes, and enable me to talk about slums and their effects on average people in a way that’s chronological and different from one-off qualitative studies,” says Gao.

Gao also relied on her own fieldwork involving informal workers in Jakarta — motorcycle delivery drivers — conducted in 2017 and funded by MIT GOV/LAB and MIT D-Lab. During this research, she explored the differences between areas of the sprawling megacity populated by informal workers residing in informal housing. Gao learned that many of these laborers grouped themselves into cooperative associations, where they could advocate for wages and project “a sense of influence beyond their members.”

Analyzing her varied datasets, a process still underway, Gao finds that Indonesian families move fluidly between formal and unregulated housing and “are not marginalized,” she says. “They are more ordinary than we might have thought, being active in labor markets, and are as socially engaged in their communities as people in good housing.” This is in contrast, Gao notes, “to what we know about people in poor housing and disadvantaged neighborhoods in rich countries, who on average have lower opportunities for social association.”

Her studies have yielded additional insights into what makes slums livable for people who experience them: residents form self-help social groups, including rotating savings and credit associations, “where people pool money and everyone draws on that pool once in a while.” At the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, Gao ran an original online survey of informal workers across different job sectors in Indonesia, and found that these small committee groups “had a big influence in encouraging people to comply with government lockdown policies.”

If the urban poor are indeed engaged citizens, with neighborhood and worker-based associations, and able to cooperate across ethnic or religious differences, can governments and aid agencies find productive measures for working together with them to improve their quality of life?

In the final phase of her dissertation, Gao will run surveys in Indonesia to examine if public policy interventions can make a positive impact on the lives of urban poor. She will be looking specifically at whether an Indonesian participatory slum-upgrading program leads to better infrastructure by enhancing the political capacity of community leaders in informal communities.

Place and political identity

The specific ways a place shapes identity has long fascinated Gao. Born in China but raised in Japan, her bicultural lens made her acutely aware of “how people develop a sense of belonging to a place and how that can have big political consequences.”

Gao studied international relations at Georgetown University. But her interest began turning toward international development after graduation, when she spent several years at financial firms in Japan, and later with the UN Human Settlements Programme, working on problems of sustainable urban development in low-income countries in Asia. “These regions were so dynamic because of all the people moving to cities,” she says. “Urbanization is one of the biggest trends of humanity, and presents enormous opportunity and risk.”

Intent on understanding how cities cater to the welfare of residents, Gao earned a master’s degree from MIT’s Department of Urban Studies and Planning in 2014. It was there that she homed in on unregulated housing and the informal economy as robust topics for academic exploration, and as potent targets for public policy that could change people’s lives.

Gao was drawn to MIT’s political science doctoral program by its tradition of “research that goes against the grain, which looks at how people actually live in developing societies and questions how things are done in the field of development.” She hopes to follow in the footsteps of a “long lineage of engaged women scholars” at the program and across the Institute, such as thesis committee member Lily Tsai, Ford Professor of Political Science.

“I want to move between research and policy contributions, continuing to work on questions that lie at the intersection of urbanization and development,” she says. “How can developing nations solve the physical problems of inadequate housing in a way that could improve relations between citizens and government, so that poor urban citizens can participate politically and lift themselves up?”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Giovanni Pernice denies ‘wrongdoing' after reported split from Maura Higgins

Strictly Come Dancing star Giovanni Pernice has denied that “wrongdoing” led to his recent breakup following his reported split from Maura Higgins. The professional dancer was reported to have split ... Read more »

Shiloh Jolie-Pitt's Yellow Leopard Sneakers Make Headlines - Here's Where They're From

Angelina Jolie may be dropping jaws left and right, wearing beautiful gowns by Atelier Versace, Balmain, and Ralph Lauren on the Eternals red carpets, but her daughters are making sustainable ... Read more »

Judi Love says 'Strictly' fitness is helping her cope with COVID

Judi Love says her Strictly fitness is helping her fight COVID. (BBC/Guy Levy) Judi Love has said she is thankful for having got fit through training for Strictly Come Dancing ... Read more »

Blue Origin unveils plans for commercial space station

Blue Origin and Sierra Space are leading development of a privately-funded space station known as “Orbital Reef” to provide a commercial destination in low-Earth orbit after the International Space Station ... Read more »

Legatum Center welcomes the inaugural Foundry Fellows

Thirteen entrepreneurs from eight countries across Africa join the first cohort of Legatum Foundry Fellows. Read more »

Ransomware cyber attacks double in a year, reveals spy chief

Increasing numbers of people are being held to ransom by cyber attackers – Peter Byrne/PA Wire Cyber attacks doubled in the last year, the chief of GCHQ has revealed – ... Read more »

Signs of first planet found outside our galaxy

The finding comes from observation of an X-ray binary – a neutron star or black hole pulling in gas from a companion star Astronomers have found hints of what could ... Read more »

Solid, liquid, or gas? Technique quickly identifies physical state of tissues and tumors

The method could be a route to quicker, less invasive cancer diagnoses. Read more »

Artificial intelligence sheds light on how the brain processes language

Neuroscientists find the internal workings of next-word prediction models resemble those of language-processing centers in the brain. Read more »

2 border agents are fired for offensive Facebook posts

Two Border Patrol agents were fired from among 60 found to have committed misconduct for participating in a private Facebook group that mocked migrants and lawmakers, investigators said Monday in ... Read more »

Speaker says ministers should resign for pre-Budget briefings on spending

(PA) Sir Lindsay Hoyle has suggested ministers should resign for pre-briefing details of the Budget, as he said it was unacceptable for the government to “try to run roughshod” over ... Read more »

Candace Owens slammed for calling accidental Alec Baldwin shooting ‘poetic justice'

Rightwing pundit Candace Owens provoked a furious response on social media for taking “perverse pleasure” in Alec Baldwin’s accidental shooting on the set of Rust. Ms Owens wrote in a ... Read more »

Princess Beatrice's Husband Edoardo Shares Photo with His Son (a New Big Brother!) in Greece

Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi/ instagram Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi and his son, Wolfie Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi made the most of his trip to Greece. Princess Beatrice's husband shared a ... Read more »

The Mystery Behind a Nearby Alien Beacon Is Solved

Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast/Getty Back in April 2019, an Australian telescope picked up a very tantalizing radio signal that seemed to emanate from our closest neighboring star. ... Read more »

Blue Origin teams up with Sierra Space, Boeing and others on ‘Orbital Reef' space station project

An artist’s conception shows a Boeing Starliner capsule at the Orbital Reef station. (Orbital Reef Illustration) Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin space venture is joining forces with Colorado-based Sierra Space and ... Read more »

Liberty University accused of punishing students who reported rape incidents

Liberty University received criticism following allegations that it punished students who claimed to be victims of rape. The Virginia university is accused of dismissing and discouraging students who alleged they ... Read more »

Facebook Q3 earnings: Investors eye fallout from whistleblower, Apple privacy changes

Facebook will report its third quarter earnings after the bell on Monday, as the company grapples with a new avalanche of stories resulting from a , and the ripple effect ... Read more »

NYT reporter says hackers used a 'zero-click' tool to get inside his phone: 'It's like being robbed by a ghost'

Getty Images Hackers targeted the iPhone of NYT reporter Ben Hubbard four times in three years. Cybersecurity researchers found that a government-surveillance software was likely used. Governments sometimes use anti-terrorism ... Read more »

Greenhouse gas levels hit a new record, cuts fall short, U.N. finds

The global average concentration of carbon dioxide, the main greenhouse gas, hit a new high of 413.2 parts per million last year, according to a World Meteorological Organization report. Read more »

Rising number of anti-vaxxers ‘willing to take direct action against schools'

“Substantial numbers” of people influenced by conspiracy theories were now willing to take direct action against schools administering vaccines, experts on online misinformation have warned, as Labour called for exclusion ... Read more »

Boris Johnson accused of ‘losing the plastic plot' after saying recycling doesn't work

© PA Wire Coronavirus – Fri Oct 22, 2021 Boris Johnson has been accused of having “completely lost the plastic plot” after telling schoolchildren that recycling “doesn’t work” as a ... Read more »

Rust Shooting Affidavit Reveals Heartbreaking New Details About Halyna Hutchins' Final Moments

A search warrant affidavit has revealed heartbreaking new details regarding the fatal shooting on the Rust movie set. On Thursday, authorities responded to an incident at the Bonanza Creek Ranch ... Read more »

Prince Charles was 'reduced to tears' over Prince William's Duchy of Cornwall plans

The Prince of Wales was deeply touched by Prince William's plan for his royal inheritance. Prince Charles said that he was “reduced to tears” after hearing about his son the ... Read more »

Prince William & Kate Middleton Break Royal Protocol During Surprise Trip

Prince William and Kate Middleton just broke a royal rule during their latest outing. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge recently embarked on a surprise vacation with their three children, ... Read more »

Fox News host Neil Cavuto tells viewers 'life is too short to be an ass' in urging them to get vaccinated

Fox News and Fox Business host Neil Cavuto. Steven Ferdman/Getty Images Returning to the air over the weekend, Fox News host Neil Cavuto urged viewers to get vaccinated. Cavuto, who ... Read more »

Alien false alarm: ‘Extraterrestrial' radio signals turn out to be human

Photograph: CSIRO/AAP Astronomers searching for alien life thought they’d spotted signs of intelligence beyond the solar system – but the signals turned out to be human. Parkes Observatory’s Murriyang radio ... Read more »

How to know if a country is serious about net zero: look at its plans for extracting fossil fuels

Fresh emissions targets from Saudi Arabia and Australia – two of the world’s largest fossil-fuel producers – are due to arrive just in time for global climate talks in Glasgow. ... Read more »

Millions of Venezuelan students return to school after COVID-19 closures

1 / 5Millions of Venezuelan students return to school after COVID-19 closuresVenezuelan students return to school after COVID-19 closures, in Caracas By Vivian Sequera CARACAS (Reuters) – Venezuela on Monday ... Read more »

What is Plan B for tackling Covid in the UK this winter?

Ministers have been told by their senior scientific advisers to start preparing for “rapid deployment” of basic Covid pandemic measures amid rising infections and hospitalisation rates. The Scientific Advisory Group ... Read more »

Nasa finds first possible planet outside our galaxy

A Nasa image showing the M51 galaxy, where the possible planet may reside (X-ray: NASA/CXC/SAO/R. DiStefano, et al.; Optical: NASA/ESA/STScI/Grendler) A Nasa telescope might have found the first ever planet ... Read more »

Pixel 6 and 6 pro review: Are the new Google phones worth buying?

The search giant seems to be finally taking its place in the hardware market seriously (The Independent) The Pixel 6 (from £599, and Pixel 6 pro (£849, have ... Read more »

Pixel 6 pro vs Pixel 6: Which of Google's new phones is best?

We’ve weighed them up in four critical areas (The Independent) Google launches two new phones on 28 October. The Pixel 6 and Pixel 6 pro are a couple of high-end ... Read more »

Apple third-gen AirPods review: The new go-to earbuds for iPhone fans

Apple‘s third-generation AirPods pack fantastic audio and many of the features found on the more expensive Pros, but they don’t offer active-noise cancelling. (Image: Howley) Apple (AAPL) has finally released ... Read more »

Google Pixel 6 Pro review: Google's first real premium smartphone is a total winner

The Pixel 6 Pro is Google‘s first true premium smartphone, and it easily stands toe-to-toe with the iPhone 13 and Samsung Galaxy S21. (Image: Howley) Google (GOOG, GOOGL) is finally ... Read more »

Has Oti Mabuse danced on 'Strictly' for the last time?

Has Oti Mabuse danced on Strictly for the last time? (BBC) Oti Mabuse and Ugo Monye were voted out of Strictly Come Dancing in week five – but have we ... Read more »

Ransomware attacks in the UK have doubled in a year, British spy chief warns

British spy chief sounded the alarm over the growing threat from <a href="/tag/criminal-gangs“>criminal gangs (PA Wire) Ransomware attacks in the UK have doubled in just a year as criminal gangs ... Read more »

Ransomware attacks have doubled in past year, GCHQ director warns

Ransomware attacks have doubled in the last year, the director of the Government’s intelligence agency has revealed. In an interview with The Cipher Brief, Sir Jeremy Fleming said more needs ... Read more »

Kristen Stewart on fame and why she's only made '5 really good films'

Kristen Stewart's latest cinematic turn, as Princess Diana in the upcoming Spencer, is generating plenty of Oscar buzz, but the actress says in a new interview that only a handful ... Read more »

Singing lemurs have rhythm just like humans, study finds

Black and white-coated Indri indri, also called the babakoto, are one of the largest living lemurs (Getty Images/iStockphoto) You might have heard a primate howl but have you heard one ... Read more »

Norfolk sand: Has a colossal experiment worked?

Two years ago, a stretch of coastline in North Norfolk underwent a radical transformation. Millions of tonnes of sand were shifted there to hold back the encroaching sea. It’s the ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic