Cities and climate change: why low-rise buildings are the future – not skyscrapers

Asia's Tech News Daily

Paris is an example of a densely built low-rise city. DaLiu/Shutterestock

More than half of the world’s 7.8 billion people live in cities and urban areas. By 2050, an additional 2.5 billion will be living there. As that figure continues to climb and ever more people flock to metropolitan areas in the hope of a better life, the big question is: how do we fit everyone in?

It is the job of city developers and urban planners to figure out how to build or adapt urban environments to accommodate the living and working needs of this rapidly expanding population. There is a popular belief that taller, more densely packed skyscrapers are the way forward, because they optimise the use of space and house more people per square metre and limit urban sprawl.

But given the global commitments to emissions-reduction targets and mitigating climate change, is this the most sustainable solution from a carbon-reduction perspective?

Our recent study, which examined whether building denser and taller is the right path to sustainability, busts this myth: we found that densely built, low-rise environments are more space and carbon efficient, while high-rise buildings have a drastically higher carbon impact.

Impact on the environment

We assessed the whole-life cycle of carbon emissions – meaning both operational and “embodied” carbon – of different buildings and urban environments. Operational carbon is generated while a building is in service. Embodied carbon is all the hidden, behind-the-scenes carbon produced during the extraction, production, transport and manufacture of raw materials used to construct a building, plus any produced during maintenance, refurbishment, demolition or replacement.

This aspect is often overlooked, especially in building design, where operational efficiency is always to the fore. The argument for cutting carbon at the design stage has been made by numerous researchers, and it is gaining traction with leading international organisations such as the World Green Building Council. But it’s still something that is largely disregarded, mainly because embodied impact assessment is voluntary, and there is no legislation concerning its inclusion. But it must be advocated for if we are to reach our 2050 emissions targets.

At a global scale, the construction sector is responsible for a significant impact on the environment, as is clear from the graph below. The largest contribution comes from its consumption of energy and resources, which boils down to the design stage – the part of the process that no one is looking at.

Construction sector’s contribution to environmental impacts. Edinburgh Napier University

Now that new buildings have to be more energy efficient and the energy grid is being decarbonised, this hidden embodied energy varies from 11%-33% for projects such as Passive House designs (a building standard that uses non-mechanical heating and cooling design techniques to lower energy use) to 74%-100% for near-zero energy builds (high performance buildings where the low amount of energy required comes mostly from renewable sources).

Given the focus on driving down the energy impact of day-to-day operations, the proportional share of embodied energy consumption has been driven up. So as energy demand becomes lower when the building is in use, the materials and activities required to build it in first place produce proportionally more impacts across the building’s lifespan. For example, low and near-zero energy buildings are made by improving insulation and using more materials and additional technologies, which greatly increases the hidden energy impact and carbon cost.

Moving to a smaller scale, the embodied carbon share across construction materials shows that minerals have the largest proportion by far, at 45%. The graph below shows the breakdown of materials, where concrete dominates in terms of hidden carbon contribution. This is important because skyscrapers rely heavily on concrete as a structural material. So the type of materials we use, how much we use, and how we use them is crucial.

The carbon contribution of different minerals used in construction. Edinburgh Napier University , Author provided

How we can fix it

We developed four different urban scenarios shown in the graph below, based on data from real buildings: high-density, high-rise (HDHR) which are tall and close together; low-density, high-rise (LDHR) which are tall but more spread out; high-density, low-rise (HDLR) which are low and close together; and low-density, low-rise (LDLR) which are low level and more spaced out.

To do this, we split the building stock into five main categories: non-domestic low-rise (NDLR); non-domestic high-rise (NDHR); domestic low-rise (DLR); domestic high-rise (DHR); and terraced/house. We gathered numerous data, including height, number of storeys, building footprint (the land area the building physically occupies), facade material and neighbouring constraints. This includes the number and area of blocks and green spaces within one square kilometre, average street width and average distance between buildings.

A graphic showing four different urban environments contained in the research study.

These parameters were all fed into a computer model to analyse the data looking at the following:

1. How whole life-cycle carbon changed based on the buildings and the number of people accommodated within an area of 1km².

2. How whole life-cycle carbon changed due to an increasing population based on four fixed population sizes – 20, 30, 40 and 50 thousand people – and the land use required to accommodate them under the four different urban scenarios.

Our findings show that high-density low-rise cities, such as Paris, are more environmentally friendly than high-density high-rise cities, such as New York. Looking at the fixed population scenarios, when moving from a high-density low-rise to a high-density high-rise urban environment, the average increase in whole life-cycle carbon emissions is 142%.

A panorama of New York’s iconic skyscrapers.

Equating this to the potential savings per person, based on the fixed population size, building high-density low-rise offers a saving of 365 tonnes of CO₂ equivalent per person compared with high-density high-rise.

It’s time for urban planners to start embedding this new understanding of the whole carbon life-cycle of a building, balancing the impact of urban density and height while accommodating expanding populations. To achieve urban sustainability the world will need more Parises and fewer Manhattans.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Francesco Pomponi receives funding from the EPSRC, the Royal Academy of Engineering, and Innovate UK.

Ruth Saint does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Has Microsoft gone too far with its latest Edge feature?

A new feature in Microsoft Edge that gives users the option to use a ‘buy now, pay later’ (BNPL) service called Zip, has begun appearing in the web browser for ... Read more »

Steam Deck's Nintendo Switch-like gyro controls could be a game-changer promises Valve

Valve is recommending future Steam Deck developers try out gyro controls for their games. In a Steam Deck FAQ post, the Half-Life publisher also said that “when combined with the ... Read more »

Here's how you can bring back dislikes count to Youtube Videos

A software developer named Dmitry Selivanov has developed an open-source browser extension for Chrome and Firefox that can bring back the dislike count to any video on YouTube. If you ... Read more »

Boat Rockerz 330 Pro Bluetooth earphones launched: Price and features

NEW DELHI: Boat is the leading brand in the earwear segment in India and the company is being aggressive in terms of new launches. The domestic wearable manufacturer has now ... Read more »

Visitors can take virtual tour of Skara Brae with new 3D model

Visitors can take a virtual tour of Skara Brae through a new digital 3D model of the Neolithic site. The Historic Environment Scotland (HES) model of the settlement in Orkney ... Read more »

Infinix Inbook X1, Inbook X1 Pro laptops to launch in India on December 8

NEW DELHI: After Xiaomi and Realme, now Infinix is also set to enter the laptop market in India. The company has confirmed that it will launch the Infinix Inbook X1 ... Read more »

Charlene White on the negative impact of 24 hour news consumption on our mental health

Charlene White speaks candidly about dangers of constant media consumption and how this can impact our mental health White Wine Question Time with Kate Thornton is the podcast that brings ... Read more »

Charlene White on becoming the first black woman to present the ITV News at 10, on keeping her identity in the media world, and her emotional journey to discover her Jamaican heritage

Journalist, newsreader and TV personality, Charlene White, speaks about the life-changing moment in which she made history, becoming the first black woman to ever present the ITV News at 10. ... Read more »

Rocket League mobile is now a thing, and we're not terribly impressed

Rocket League Sideswipe is now available on Android and iOS devices, offering a free-to-play mobile alternative to the online multiplayer phenomenon. Rocket League Sideswipe maintains the orange vs. blue head-to-head ... Read more »

IBM acquires hybrid cloud player in Australia

The acquisition will bring deeper experience to IBM on multicloud platforms. Read more »

Twitter bans sharing images of people without their consent

The move has prompted some criticism with the social media platform's users concerned that it could lead to censorship. Read more »

Tomb of horror: Mummy is found with hands bound and covering his face

Archaeologists Pieter Van Dalen Luna and Yomira Huaman beside the mummy which is estimated to be between 800 and 1,200 years old – AFP Discovering a mummy is always a ... Read more »

Elon Musk warns employees of potential SpaceX bankruptcy

San Francisco, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk in an email to his company’s employees asked them to work over the weekend on SpaceX’s Raptor engine as the company faces “genuine risk ... Read more »

Good Morning Britain: Robert Rinder in tears over anti-loneliness campaign

Robert Rinder became tearful on Good Morning Britain today (1 December) after watching the show’s anti-loneliness campaign video. The ITV programme is running its charitable campaign, 1 Million Minutes, for ... Read more »

Average traffic per smartphone in the India second-highest in the world: Ericsson

The average traffic per smartphone in the India region is the second-highest globally and is projected to grow to around 50GB per month in 2027. Total mobile data traffic in ... Read more »

Facebook, Instagram remove over 18.8 million content pieces in India in October

New Delhi: Meta, the newly-formed parent company of Facebook and its family of apps, on Wednesday said that it has removed over 18.8 million pieces of content in October on ... Read more »

Hawkeye episode 3 may have just confirmed the return of a fan-favorite character

Potentially major spoilers follow for Hawkeye episode 3. Hawkeye episode 3 has landed on Disney Plus – and it seems that the Marvel Phase 4 TV series may have already ... Read more »

Could Starfield surprise us twice over?

Bethesda’s space RPG Starfield is still a full year away, but a new teaser trailer has offered a key insight into the way the game might be structured. Game Director ... Read more »

This Italian-made e-bike could keep rolling for up to 200km

Italian company Noko has unveiled a trio of new e-bikes that it claims can keep running for up to 200km (or 124 miles). That’s not the greatest range of any ... Read more »

iPhone SE 3 rumored to launch before the end of March 2022

When is the iPhone SE 3 going to see the light of day? A new industry analyst report suggests it will be sometime during Q1 2022 – so January, February ... Read more »

The US government is trying to save Christmas from PS5 and RTX 3080 scalpers

A group of Democratic lawmakers introduced the Stopping Grinch Bots Act on Monday November 29 to try and prevent bots from buying up scarce, in-demand products like PlayStation 5 consoles ... Read more »

Why Britain needs to catch up on the new frontier of espionage

Just a few months ago, a group of hackers did something small, almost innocuous. They bought a stolen digital identity, known as a cookie, for £7.50. But that, by their ... Read more »

Still paying for antivirus software? Experts say you probably don't need it

Viruses are no longer the biggest threats for most users, particularly now that software updates itself automatically and so much personal computing happens over the internet. Read more »

EU to allow member states to detain migrants for 16 weeks in major weakening of asylum rights

Migrants are seen by the Bruzgi Transport and Logistics Centre, some 1.5 km northeast of Kuznica Bialostocka-Bruzgi border crossing on the Belarusian-Polish border. – Getty Images Brussels is set to ... Read more »

Zoom is bringing attendance status, chat flexibility and these new features

Ahead of the holiday season, video conferencing tool Zoom has updated its platform with a host of new features. These include enhanced slide control, ability to control polls, attendance status, ... Read more »

Razer's next gaming laptops will be pricier thanks to chip shortage

Razer has announced that its next-gen gaming laptops coming out in 2022 will be more expensive than current models. The bad news was delivered by the CEO of Razer, Min-Liang ... Read more »

Oppo's upcoming flagship smartphone to be powered by Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 chipset

NEW DELHI: Qualcomm finally unveiled its next-generation flagship chipset — Snapdragon 8 Gen 1. As promised the company has changed the naming scheme for the Snapdragon chipsets with the launch ... Read more »

Best text-to-speech software of 2021

The best text-to-speech apps make it simple and easy to reading documents aloud, on either your desktop, tablet, or phone. The best text-to-speech software Click the links below to go ... Read more »

Latest Oculus Quest 2 update lets you film yourself in VR – if you own an iPhone

The latest Oculus Quest 2 update brings mixed reality casting to the VR headset, effectively allowing you to film yourself in a virtual reality space. So far just six of ... Read more »

Apple AirPods prototype with transparent design surfaces on Twitter

Apple AirPods prototype with transparent design have surfaced on Twitter this week. The images of the prototype earbuds from Cupertino based tech giant has been shared by Giulio Zompetti who ... Read more »

Microsoft surface go 3 review: A light, portable and effective tablet

It has the same design, upgraded processor and software but a downgraded price – it’s £30 less than the surface go 2 (iStock/The Independent) Microsoft, of course, makes Windows, the ... Read more »

Which upcoming phones will use the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 1?

The new Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 is official, and it’s set to power some of the very best smartphones of 2022. Flights and accommodation for this launch event were ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S21 FE leak shows off all the phone's color options

The Samsung Galaxy S21 FE has traveled a long and winding road on its journey to being launched, but it seems that it’s now very close to being officially unveiled ... Read more »

Xbox series X stock – live: Argos restock now sold out – how to get a console

LIVE – Updated at 09:25 © iStock/The Independent XBOX LB1 INDYBEST.jpg Update: The Xbox series X is now sold out at Argos. Read on for more details. The Xbox series ... Read more »

‘Call of Duty: Warzone Pacific': New Caldera map goes live for everyone next week with 15 drop zones

Photo credit: Call of Duty / YouTube screenshot Next week is going to be huge for “Call of Duty: Vanguard” and “Warzone” players as it is when the integration of ... Read more »

What will happen when Elon Musk's Gigafactory faces the wurst?

News here in Germany is that Elon Musk’s Gigafactory in Brandenburg is about to start production.  As an Ausländer myself who has lived in East Germany (Berlin and Leipzig) for ... Read more »

Omicron: Experts fear new Covid variant will impact effectiveness of key drugs for vulnerable patients

(AFP via Getty Images) Scientists fear the omicron coronavirus variant will reduce the effectiveness of key drugs that are used to treat Covid-19 in vulnerable patients. As with the vaccines, ... Read more »

F1's Lando Norris on moving to Monaco: ‘People do many things in life for money'

Lando Norris drives for McLaren (Getty Images) F1 driver Lando Norris has revealed he will move to Monaco at the end of the season, saying: “People do many things in ... Read more »

Damning video of jury vehicle incident that got MSNBC banned from covering Rittenhouse trial released by police

Kenosha police in Wisconsin have released footage of an NBC journalist who allegedly followed a vehicle transporting jury members of the Kyle Rittenhouse trial. Judge Bruce Schroeder, who presided over ... Read more »

Steam Deck will not have exclusive games, Valve confirms

Steam Deck | Photo credit: Valve / YouTube screenshot Valve is the next video game company to release its gaming hardware, the Steam Deck. And Valve has already clarified it ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic