CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews last night's TV: Claudia's killer show murdered by a bunch of big-headed non-entities

The Traitors U.S. 

Rating **

Robson Green’s Weekend Escapes

Fluke or surefire formula? Claudia Winkleman’s reality format The Traitors, the mind game set in a Scottish castle, was the runaway surprise hit of last year.

The question is whether its sadistic, addictive effect on millions of viewers was an accident, the inadvertent result of its perfect cast of characters combined with Claudia’s previously unsuspected streak of cruelty.

The only way to answer that is to try it again. The Traitors U.S. (BBC3) does just that, in the same setting, with the same missions, even the same blacked-out limousines.

But there’s a crucial difference, one that betrays a lack of confidence in the format from its American producers. Instead of bringing together a group of unknowns with big personalities, half the players in this version are ‘celebrities’ from other reality shows.

Instead of bringing together a group of unknowns with big personalities, half the players in this version are ¿celebrities¿ from other reality shows

Instead of bringing together a group of unknowns with big personalities, half the players in this version are ‘celebrities’ from other reality shows

They were all so in love with themselves that there was no chance for those flirtations and crushes that made Claudia¿s clan of traitors and faithfuls so loveable

They were all so in love with themselves that there was no chance for those flirtations and crushes that made Claudia’s clan of traitors and faithfuls so loveable

For British viewers, at least, these are the most obscure celebs imaginable. Their fame is on the scale of subatomic particles.

It’s not just that nobody here has heard of Arie Luyendyk Jr, Kate Chastain or Reza Farahan — their shows also are meaningless to us. The Bachelor, Below Deck, Shahs Of Sunset . . . those titles sound like fakes generated by a sarcastic computer program.

And while you might know that Big Brother and The Real Housewives Of Beverly Hills are popular in the States, please don’t kid me that you have any clue who Cody Calafiore or Brandi Glanville are.

Their presence scuppers this remake, because half the first episode was devoted to deluded nonentities gloating about how overwhelmed the other players would be to encounter such stardom in their midst. ‘I’m kind of an icon,’ bragged Rachel Reilly, who won the U.S. edition of Big Brother in 2011. ‘This is my chance to use their fandom of me to my advantage.’

‘I love judging people,’ proclaimed Kate. ‘But I’m honest to a fault,’ she said, before adding that she’s a natural detective because Sherlock Holmes was related to her great-grandfather.

They were all so in love with themselves that there was no chance for those flirtations and crushes that made Claudia’s clan of traitors and faithfuls so loveable.

All 15 episodes of Robson Green¿s Weekend Escapes (BBC2) are on iPlayer, as the actor goes rambling round the North-East with friends

All 15 episodes of Robson Green’s Weekend Escapes (BBC2) are on iPlayer, as the actor goes rambling round the North-East with friends

Actor Alan Cumming is the new host, but the rules remain essentially unchanged. Three of the 20 players are secretly designated as ‘murderers’, eliminating one rival from the game each night.

The others have to guess who the killers are and can expel those they most suspect. The traitors lie to protect themselves . . . and the innocents turn on each other.

The Americans have introduced one good twist. The players now sleep in the castle itself, and Alan stalks the battlements by moonlight in electric blue tartan, like Banquo’s ghost on a modelling assignment in Macbeth.

This first show is repeated on BBC1 tonight — and the whole series is on iPlayer. So are all 15 episodes of Robson Green’s Weekend Escapes (BBC2), as the actor goes rambling round the North-East with friends.

This time, he was visiting the seaside with actor Mark Benton, not doing much more than eating ice cream on the beach with the donkeys at Saltburn, North Yorkshire, and sucking on a sour gobstopper in the sweetshop in Staithes.

The duo had an art lesson from local gallery owner and retired teacher Ian Burke. He told them he’d been the Drawing Master at Eton College — and they took the mickey.

That was a wasted opportunity. Mr Burke was the senior member of college staff cleared in 2006 of helping Prince Harry with his written exam work. Robson and Mark should have asked him what he thought of the reluctant royal’s current ghostwriter.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Ashworth could seal a "deadly" signing as Newcastle in talks for "breathless" £35m ace - opinion

Newcastle United are in talks regarding a deal to bring Denzel Dumfries to the Premier League in the January transfer window. What’s the talk? Transfer Focus That’s according to a ... Read more »

Mortgage clinic: ‘I’m self-employed and a first-time buyer. How much could I borrow to buy a rental property?’

Julie Ward Julie Ford, 46, is a consultant for the private rented sector who wants to invest in a buy-to-let property herself. She currently rents a three-bedroom house in Clifton, ... Read more »

Nadhim Zahawi - live: Former Tory chair calls on successor to ‘step aside’ in tax row

✕ Close Rishi Sunak says ‘no issues’ raised about Nadhim Zahawi tax affairs before cabinet appointment A former Conservative Party chairman has called on Nadhim Zahawi to “step aside” whilst ... Read more »

Andy Farrell: Six Nations pressure will be priceless for Ireland going forward

Andy Farrell’s Ireland were Triple Crown winners in 2022 (John Walton/PA) (PA Wire) Andy Farrell believes the pressure of being Guinness Six Nations title favourites can aid Ireland’s ultimate quest ... Read more »

BUSINESS LIVE: Direct Line CEO exits; Superdry losses widen; Wholesaler Bestway takes Sainsbury’s stake

The FTSE 100 will open at 8am. Among the companies with reports and trading updates today are Direct Line, Superdry, Sainsbury’s, YouGov, Mortorpoint and Amigo Holdings. Read the Friday 27 January ... Read more »

Shanina Shaik stuns in a daring black cut-out dress while Sara Sampaio sparkles in sequin frock as the models attend Cult Gaia opening in West Hollywood

Fellow supermodels and friends Shanina Shaik and Sara Sampaio stepped out for the opening of Cult Gaia in West Hollywood on Thursday. The gal pals, both 31, showed off their ... Read more »

Fans go wild as convicted drug smuggler Schapelle Corby reveals her stunning hair makeover - after urging tourists to be careful and lock their suitcases when traveling overseas

She’s found a career as an influencer after leaving prison. And Schapelle Corby showed off her social media credentials as posted photos of her hair makeover on Friday. The 45-year-old, ... Read more »

Manchester restaurant hits back after celeb haunt popular with Molly-Mae Hague and Ronaldo launch high court battle

An Italian restaurant chain with a vast celebrity client list has launched legal action against another Manchester eatery over a battle regarding their name. Cibo Hale and Cibo Wilmslow, which ... Read more »

Top Gear's Freddie Flintoff reportedly makes 'painful decision' to put TV career 'on hold' after horror crash

Freddie suffered facial injuries and broken ribs in the crash Freddie Flintoff is reportedly putting his TV career on hold following his horrific car crash on Top Gear. The former ... Read more »

Manchester United might have found their next captain with Erik ten Hag's £57m gamble

After Manchester United took a giant stride towards the Carabao Cup final on Wednesday evening, Lisandro Martinez might want to start thinking about investing in a bigger mantlepiece. Just three ... Read more »

Unai Emery has the keys to the Aston Villa castle, none of his predecessors have ever had this much control... the Spaniard is desperate to put his mark on the team this month with a European place in his mind

Unai Emery has had a significant impact since arriving as Villa boss in OctoberThe Spaniard has been given control to shape the squad and club as he wishesHe is desperate to sign players, with the possibility of European football still on  Read more »

Margot Robbie was offered Hooters job after filming advertisement for company

Margot Robbie Margot Robbie has revealed Hooters offered her a job after she filmed an ad for them. While speaking to New Music Express for an interview, the Barbie star ... Read more »

Sopranos star John Ventimiglia's daughter, 25, dies just months after giving birth

Sopranos star John Ventimiglia’s daughter has died aged 25, three months after giving birth. Odele died on 12 January, her family have heartbreakingly confirmed, but her cause of death is ... Read more »

Marvel fans think Tobey Maguire just dropped a big hint about Avengers: Secret Wars

Tobey Maguire has got Marvel fans excited with his latest admission about playing Spider-Man. The actor played Peter Parker (aka Spider-Man) in a trilogy of films from director Sam Raimi ... Read more »

Warren Gatland facing tall order to revitalise Wales but ‘anything is possible’ in Six Nations

Wales head coach Warren Gatland has returned for a second spell in the job (David Davies/PA) (PA Wire) Warren Gatland has adopted an “anything is possible” approach as he prepares ... Read more »

Boris Johnson reveals just how big his advance was for upcoming book

Boris Johnson is promising a political memoir ‘like no other’ (Geoffrey Swaine/Shutterstock) Boris Johnson has picked up an advance of more than £500,000 for his forthcoming memoir, as it emerged ... Read more »

Fast-food delivery courtside at Duquesne University basketball game was a planned PRANK as college reveals it's ramping up security to avoid future stunts

Delivery man appeared oblivious he was interrupting Duquesne University gameBizarre incident midgame has been found to be a planned prank by the collegeClick here for all your latest international sports news from DailyMail.com  Read more »

Salute Madonna: defying the odds at 64. But what are the work choices for other women her age?

The most shocking thing Madonna has ever done, as she once said herself, is just to keep on publicly being Madonna. She won’t give up. She won’t fade away. She ... Read more »

Mystery Channel ship wreck is 1600s Dutch warship Klein Hollandia, sunk by Royal Navy while full of valuables

Two guns found at the site of the wreck of the Klein Hollandia (Photo: Cathy de Lara/PA) When the Dutch warship Klein Hollandia sailed up the English Channel some 351 ... Read more »

'Lindsay's mental illness became overwhelming': Priest leads vigil for two children, 5 and 3, strangled to death by their midwife mother before she jumped out top window of Massachusetts home - as he pays tribute to 'happy and loving family'

Holy Family Church in Daxbury stood vigil for the family Thursday night The Very Rev. Fr. Robert Deehan said the family were 'happy and loving' Lindsay Clancy faces potential charges of homicide among several others Read more »

Woman fired for following 'transphobic' Twitter users accuses video game firm she worked for of caving to online mob: 'I follow accounts of every political affiliation!'

Kara Lynne spoke out after being fired by Limited Run Games last weekShe was the target of an online campaign led by trans activist 'Purple Tinker'Was fired after fury that she follows right-wing commentators on TwitterLynne says she follows a variety of accounts to see different views Read more »

These 5 animals from RSPCA Essex are looking for their forever homes

There are a few pets from the Essex RSPCA centres and Danaher Animal Home who are looking for new owners. (Image: RSPCA) Here is a selection of animals from the ... Read more »

Emily Ratajkowski accuses paparazzi of ‘screwing up’ her dating life

Emily Ratajkowski has spoken out about how media scrutiny around her love life has “screwed up” her ability to date casually. The model, who filed for divorce from her husband ... Read more »

When is the FA Cup fifth round draw?

The FA Cup continues this weekend with the fourth round of the competition. The third round saw nine Premier League teams eliminated, with Aston Villa’s home defeat to Stevenage among ... Read more »

Jamie Ritchie believes Scotland in a ‘good place’ ahead of Six Nations campaign

Gregor Townsend and Jamie Ritchie at the Six Nations launch (John Walton/PA) (PA Wire) Captain Jamie Ritchie has declared Scotland “in a good place” for the upcoming Six Nations after ... Read more »

Man City vs Arsenal predicted line-ups: Team news ahead of FA Cup fixture tonight

Manchester City host Arsenal in the FA Cup tonight as Pep Guardiola faces Mikel Arteta for the first time this season. A former assistant to Guardiola at City, Arteta has ... Read more »

Football rumours: Bournemouth interested in Roma forward Nicolo Zaniolo

Roma’s Nicolo Zaniolo (Mike Egerton/PA) (PA Archive) What the papers say Bournemouth are interested in Roma forward Nicolo Zaniolo, the Daily Mail reports. The 23-year-old is understood to be ready ... Read more »

Wout Weghorst determined to change Erik ten Hag's mind over Man Utd transfer plan

Wout Weghorst is adamant that he can persuade Erik ten Hag to shelve his search for a new striker in the summer and land a permanent deal at Manchester United. ... Read more »

Model Georgia Fowler stuns in a luxurious satin gown as she marries her Fishbowl founder fiancé Nathan Dalah in an idyllic countryside ceremony at 'exclusive' venue in the Southern Highlands

Georgia Fowler has walked down the aisle with her fiancé Nathan Dalah in a gorgeous countryside ceremony. The New Zealand born model and her Fishbowl founder love exchanged vows at Hopewood House ... Read more »

Average non-London asking rent rises to £1,172, up almost 10% in a year... while those in the capital face paying nearly 16% more for a property

Demand to supply is still high despite a rise in the number of properties to rentRightmove expects rents to increase by another 5% over 2023  Read more »

How much cash should investors hold? Emergencies, buying opportunities, loss avoidance... the best strategies in current markets revealed

Rookies are typically told to build an emergency fund of 3-6 months of salaryExperienced investors might want to hold an 'opportunities fund' in reserveInterest rates are up and markets are volatile - so how much cash do YOU need  Read more »

Emmy award-winning college basketball broadcaster Billy Packer - who covered 34 Final Fours for NBC and CBS from 1975 to 2008 - dies aged 82

Longtime Final Four broadcaster Billy Packer has passed away at the age of 82His son revealed he had been in hospital and succumbed to kidney failure Click here for all your latest international Sports news from DailyMail.com  Read more »

'You got your story wrong': Baltimore Ravens legend Ed Reed calls out Shannon Sharpe and exposes their Instagram DMs after Fox Sports host was left bemused as to why coach walked away from Bethune-Cookman

The HBCU fired Ed Reed after he initially agreed to be next football head coach Shannon Sharpe didn't understand Reed's expectations of under-funded school Click here for all your latest international Sports news from DailyMail.com Read more »

Video: Tensions rise in Gaza: Israel launches airstrikes in response to rocket fire from Hamas militants following deadliest army raid on the West Bank in years 

Read more »

Video: Oprah Winfrey and Tiffany Haddish at premiere of The 1619 Project in LA ... as show makes its debut on Hulu

Read more »

I’d buy 342 shares of this stock, for £70 in monthly passive income

Passive income text with pin graph chart on business table When it comes to harvesting passive income from dividend stocks, I prefer those backed by a defensive business. By that I mean ... Read more »

Man dies suddenly in Newquay after suffering 'serious burns'

The death of the man in Newquay is not being treated as suspicious A man has died suddenly in Cornwall after reports he had sustained serious burns. Police were called ... Read more »

6 easy ways to boost your mental health in 10 minutes

Sometimes, when a dark cloud descends on your day you need a quick fix to get your morale back on track. Whether it’s road rage, work stress, an argument with ... Read more »

Who will win the Six Nations? Six talking points ahead of the 2023 Championship

France are among the favourites for this season’s Six Nations (Adam Davy/PA) (PA Archive) The final Six Nations Championship before the Rugby World Cup begins in France later this year ... Read more »

Stefanos Tsitsipas beats Karen Khachanov to reach first Australian Open final

Stefanos Tsitsipas eased to victory over Karen Khachanov (Dita Alangkara/AP) (AP) Stefanos Tsitsipas overcame a third-set wobble to defeat Karen Khachanov and reach his first Australian Open final. The third ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự