China's ‘unfair trade practices' draw heavy fire at WTO trade review

Asia's Tech News Daily

China’s ‘unfair trade practices’ draw heavy fire at WTO trade review

China was accused of a laundry list of trade felonies and economic bullying during a series of attacks by other nations at the World Trade Organization (WTO) in Geneva on Wednesday, laying bare growing geopolitical rifts and widening schisms in the multilateral trading system.

The United States, European Union, Japan, Britain, Australia and Canada took part in the pile-on at China’s first WTO trade policy review since 2018, according to a well-placed source.

All WTO members must participate in trade policy reviews, essentially peer-group assessments, along with an in-depth analysis conducted by the WTO secretariat.

China’s commerce minister, Wang Wentao, led a team of 20 officials from seven Chinese agencies via video link, and used the occasion to promote Beijing’s achievements, including its poverty alleviation drive and economic recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic.

China’s ‘unfair trade practices’ draw heavy fire at WTO trade review

Wang Wentao, China’s commerce minister, led a delegation of officials participating via video link in the WTO trade policy review. Photo: Xinhua

China fielded more than 1,600 written questions from 40 WTO members, most of which were already answered in writing, and will have a chance to defend itself on Friday, during the second part of the review.

The session Wednesday clearly showed widespread dissatisfaction with China‘s trading behaviour, a dramatic change from China’s last review three years ago. Then, only Venezuela referred to “coercive measures”, when – in a thinly veiled swipe at the US – it said it stood with Beijing in “opposing any hegemonic pretensions” that undermine the world trading system.

But on Wednesday, several Western countries decried China’s perceived bullying – a marker of how the mood has soured in Geneva over recent years.

Australia, which has been involved in a trade and diplomatic spat with China since early last year, accused Beijing of “increasingly testing global trade rules and norms by engaging in practices that are inconsistent with WTO commitments”.

Australian businesses in sectors ranging from wine and barley to beef and lobster have seen shipments halted, taxed or banned by Chinese authorities, often for technical reasons. Many have linked the bans to Canberra’s call for an independent investigation into the origins of the coronavirus pandemic.

Australia’s envoy to the WTO, George Mina, cited “credible reports” that China had “instructed importers, not to purchase certain Australian products”.

He referred to a Chinese foreign ministry statement in July that Beijing would not permit “any country to reap benefits from doing business with China while groundlessly accusing and smearing China and undermining China’s core interests based on ideology”.

“WTO rules do not permit a member, however large, to impose conditions such as these on trade with another member,” Mina said, according to the source.

By contrast, at China’s 2018 review, Canberra praised Chinese leader Xi Jinping’s commitment to “ongoing trade and investment liberalisation, lower tariffs and expanding imports” and said it “looked forward to continuing to work with China to advance global trade liberalisation”.

Also in 2018, the Canadian delegation’s remarks were mostly positive about Beijing’s trade policy, thanking China “for its engagement and the hard work of its officials”.

On Wednesday, though, Canada’s envoy highlighted “the recent pattern regarding China‘s growing willingness to deploy economic coercive measures to block or otherwise hinder trade in response to political disagreements”.

Ottawa has linked bans of Canadian products, including beef and canola seed, to its detention of the Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou in Vancouver in 2018 on the request of the United States, which had indicted her of fraud charges. Two Canadians, Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, were subsequently arrested in China as the geopolitical feud escalated. Following Meng’s lengthy extradition battle, all three were released last month.

China’s ‘unfair trade practices’ draw heavy fire at WTO trade review

Huawei Technologies’ chief financial officer, Meng Wanzhou, arriving at Shenzhen Baoan International Airport in China on September 25 after her release. Photo: Xinhua via Reuters

For its part, the US delegation expressed regret that China had not reformed its economy in the manner expected when it acceded to the WTO in 2001.

“Members expected that the terms set forth in China‘s protocol of accession would permanently dismantle existing Chinese policies and practices that were incompatible with an international trading system expressly based on open market-oriented policies. But those expectations have not been realised, and it appears that China has no inclination to change,” according to the statement, attributed to David F. Bisbee, the US chargé d’Affaires at the WTO.

He accused Beijing of using the “imprimatur of WTO membership to become the WTO largest trader, while doubling down on its state-led, non-market approach to trade”.

The British delegation, referring to the UN’s International Labour Organization, called on China to “ratify and effectively implement the ILO forced labour convention”, saying that forced labour is “unacceptable wherever and whenever it occurs”.

This shows that there can be no business as usual

Bryan Mercurio, trade law professor at City University of Hong Kong

In 2018, the European Union “acknowledged the possible benefits that the Belt and Road Initiative may bring” and was “heartened to read how China considers itself as a firm defender of WTO values in its report”.

On Wednesday, however, Brussels criticised “China’s expansive use of an excessively broad concept of national security, negatively affecting foreign companies”.

“It has become increasingly clear that such distortions cannot be sufficiently addressed by current WTO rules,” the EU said in a statement following the forum.

Japan accused China of lacking transparency and of distorting global steel markets with overcapacity.

Bryan Mercurio, a professor of trade law at City University of Hong Kong, said the exchanges marked a “turning point” in WTO history.

“This shows that there can be no business as usual and that China can’t expect the return to the pre-Trump days, where the status quo ruled and China could hide in the shadows and almost get away with what it wanted to and not really have anyone care, “ he said.

However, Mercurio called out the US and other nations for a retrospective critique of China’s WTO accession 20 years ago.

“The great mistake was not holding China to account early on and giving it this five-year grace period, which really allowed China to cement its positions. It is a bit rich now to try to call out China for these policies when, in fact, the US and others have done nothing to hold China to account since 2001.”

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


New savings bonds in Q2 Issuance to offset budget deficit

Mrs Patricia says attractive interest rates made the first batch of savings bonds appeal to investors. Varuth Hirunyatheb The Public Debt Management Office (PDMO) is expected to issue another batch of ... Read more »

Government looking at more changes to KiwiSaver

Fresh off the back of a major shake-up to the default provider regime, Consumer Affairs Minister David Clark has signalled the Government is looking into more changes to KiwiSaver. Speaking ... Read more »

DTAC-True merger likely to pass muster Deal planned to clear regulatory hurdles

DTAC customers at a service centre in Bangkok.  Pornprom Satrabhaya The merger of Total Access Communication Plc (DTAC) and True Corporation is expected to survive regulatory challenges as the two ... Read more »

Hong Kong exchange to open New York office to bolster international presence

HONG KONG (BLOOMBERG) – Hong Kong Exchanges & Clearing (HKEX) plans to establish a representative office in New York to market its offerings in the United States amid increasing doubts ... Read more »

Vopak would like to put less in the oil

When you think of Vopak, you quickly think of oil. Is that right? Yes, the Rotterdam company, known for its imposing tank terminals in world ports, has been storing oil ... Read more »

Dealing with Omicron unease Business leaders believe Thailand has the tools to control the variant's spread, but they want more information

Syringes with needles are seen in front of a displayed stock graph and words “Omicron SARS-CoV-2” in this illustration taken on Nov 27, 2021. (Reuters photo) The emergence of the ... Read more »

Help your people grow their futures Leaders have a duty to show people how to take charge of developing their skills personally

Leaders growing their businesses and developing young people at the start of their careers today have an unprecedented opportunity. They also face some unexpected challenges. It is becoming more apparent ... Read more »

CCSA eyes border reopening Southern MPs lobby to open checkpoints

The Sadao checkpoint in Sadao district, Songkhla. The Centre for Covid-19 Situation Administration (CCSA)'s forward command dealing with Covid-19 in the deep South will this week consider whether to reopen ... Read more »

Hong Kong stocks' discount to book values ensnare Chinese funds betting on turnaround

Hong Kong stocks have become a valuation trap for mainland Chinese money managers. The Hang Seng Index’s bouts of dipping below book value this year have failed to fetch bottom-fishing ... Read more »

Foreign biz rules to ease

A rule requiring foreign nationals to secure permission before conducting half a dozen types of businesses could soon be lifted, says a source at the Commerce Ministry. The Department of ... Read more »

Is expensive perfume worth the money? What they have that cheaper ones may not, and how to choose the right scent for you

There are a number of decisions to make before choosing a perfume, from finding your preferred quality, intensity and longevity to the brands and notes you like the most. No ... Read more »

TikTok owner ByteDance ramps up e-commerce expansion with launch of Fanno shopping app in Europe

TikTok owner ByteDance has ramped up its expansion into e-commerce with the recent launch of shopping app “Fanno” in selected markets across Europe, as the world’s most valuable technology start-up ... Read more »

Vulcan heavily upgrades prospectus earnings forecasts

Newly-listed Australasian steel distributor Vulcan has heavily upgraded its earnings forecasts for the June 2022 year, following stronger-than-expected trading over October and November. The dual listed company now expects its ... Read more »

Black Sea - part cookbook, part travelogue of author Caroline Eden's journey from Odessa in Ukraine to Istanbul and Trabzon in Turkey – is a gem

After reviewing Caroline Eden’s wonderful Red Sands (2020), about the award-winning author and journalist’s travels through Central Asia, I immediately looked for more by her. In Black Sea (2018), Eden ... Read more »

As wildfires get hotter and more common, these start-ups are helping people protect their homes

In October 2017, Anil Arora sat helplessly in San Francisco as the Tubbs Fire approached his home in Calistoga, California. Arora watched through a Ring camera as the fire worked ... Read more »

Omicron scare: India's tally rises to 21 with 17 more testing positive for COVID variant

(Representative image: Reuters) India reported 17 more cases of the Omicron variant of COVID-19 on Sunday – nine persons in Rajasthan capital Jaipur, seven in Maharashtra’s Pune district and a ... Read more »

In Africa, waste often gets a second round

Mohamed Sissoko (50), a shoemaker in the city of Atar in Mauritania, uses a needle and thread to repair a pair of sandals. “I suspect that this footwear would have ... Read more »

How a little-known Kiwi ad agency landed the Allbirds account

New Zealand shoemaker Allbirds may have recently listed on the US-based NASDAQ with an IPO raising US$300 million ($445m), but the company hasn’t forgotten its roots. Despite having a market ... Read more »

COVID-19: Maharashtra logs 707 new cases, seven deaths

Representational image (Reuters) Maharashtra on Sunday reported 707 new coronavirus positive cases, taking the state’s infection tally to 66,38,778, while the death of seven patients took the toll to 1,41,170, ... Read more »

Omicron Covid variant in at least 15 states and cases are likely to rise, CDC chief says

Dr. Rochelle Walensky, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, testifies during the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing titled Next Steps: The Road Ahead for ... Read more »

Stock markets remain under the spell of Omikron variant

Photo: ANP Stock exchange trading will also be dominated this week by further developments surrounding the Omikron variant of the coronavirus. Last week, stock market indicators in Europe and New ... Read more »

Prashant Jain buys duplex apartment in Mumbai for Rs 45 crore

Several transactions worth Rs 25 crore to Rs 100 crore were registered in the Mumbai market this year. Prashant Jain, joint managing director and CEO and JSW Energy, has bought ... Read more »

The Latest Trends in the Hospitality Industry

Hospitality shift Firms like the Grand Cosmopolitan Hotel must keep up with the latest hospitality trends to avoid falling behind in the industry. Keeping up with the industry as a ... Read more »

Significantly more turnover for webshops during the Sinterklaas period

In the run-up to Sinterklaas, consumers bought considerably more from online stores than last year. The Dutch Payments Association estimates this on the basis of payment data from the past ... Read more »

How a Native American tribe on Long Island is losing its land to rising seas

Mila McKey, the Shinnecock aquaculture manager, farms oysters in Heady Creek, Southampton.Emma Newburger / CNBC SOUTHAMPTON, N.Y. — The Shinnecock Indian Nation once had seasonal villages that stretched across the ... Read more »

Vivendi ready to talk about state takeover Telecom Italia

Photo: ANP The French media group Vivendi, the major shareholder of telecom company Telecom Italia, is said to be willing to talk about a takeover by the Italian state of ... Read more »

NTAGI to consider administering 'additional' dose of COVID-19 vaccine to immunocompromised people

Representative image (Source: Reuters/Francis Mascarenhas) The issue of administering ‘additional’ dose of COVID-19 vaccine to immunocompromised individuals will be deliberated upon in the meeting of the National Technical Advisory Group ... Read more »

Market history says omicron volatility isn't a reason for investors to sell

As stock market investors have learned over the past week, it's tricky to time the next move in the Dow Jones Industrial Average after a big selloff. Buyers stepped in ... Read more »

How blockchain and smart tech can help green bonds and climate finance take off

While finance has long played a part in encouraging greener business practices, demand for investments addressing climate risks is growing exponentially. COP26 wrapped up in Glasgow earlier this month, where ... Read more »

China's regulator soothes nervous markets over Chinese stocks' delisting woes after global sell-off

China’s securities regulator said it maintains an open attitude to where companies seek to raise funds and respects their choices, denying reports of any imminent restrictions on overseas listings as ... Read more »

A fifth more turnover for webshops during the Sinterklaas period

Photo: ANP In the run-up to Sinterklaas, consumers bought much more from online stores than last year, the Dutch Payments Association estimates based on payment data from the past week. ... Read more »

Saudi Arabia to allow entry for people vaccinated with Sputnik V from January 1

Saudi Arabia joined 101 other countries approving entry of individuals vaccinated with the Sputnik V vaccine Read more »

Column: ECB does not play Sinterklaas for its own staff

Premium The best of De Telegraaf Through Teeuwe Mevissers 10 min ago in FINANCIAL There seems to be little in the bag for the staff of the ECB for next ... Read more »

Former TSB CEO Pester joins fintech frenzy with launch of money-sharing social network Loop

The Metro Bank and Atom Bank founder Anthony Thomson is one of the business heavyweights behind a new money-sharing social network that will launch next year, Sky News learns. Read more »

Memorial to Covid warriors to be constructed on Delhi Assembly premises

A health worker in personal protective equipment (PPE) takes a break while waiting for people to collect samples to conduct tests for the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), amid the spread of ... Read more »

Over 3 crore income tax returns for FY21 filed: Finance Ministry

Income Tax | PC-Shutterstock The finance ministry on Sunday said over three crore income tax returns have been filed for the financial year 2020-21 so far and advised taxpayers who ... Read more »

Corporations are turning to forest credits in the race to go 'carbon-neutral.' Advocates worry about 'greenwashing.'

Environmental groups warn the system doesn’t deliver the carbon reductions promised, but offers companies a way to avoid the tougher work of actually cutting emissions. Read more »

India to supply 20% more power to Bangladesh

Representational image India will supply 20 per cent more power to Bangladesh as the two countries renewed the contract for another five years, officials said on Sunday. Tripura State Electricity ... Read more »

LIC improves asset quality ahead of IPO, lowers net NPA to 0.05%

LIC | PC-Shutterstock Ahead of its proposed initial public offering (IPO), insurance behemoth LIC has improved its asset quality for the financial year ended March 2021. The non-performing assets (NPAs) ... Read more »

RBI Monetary Policy: Talks of reverse repo rate hike on December 8 may be premature, says SBI report

Representative image Amid the rising scare from the new coronavirus variant Omicron and ahead of the MPC meet, SBI house economists have urged the central bank to delay liquidity normalisation ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic