China's ban on private tutoring may create a black market as demand for education services remains high

private tutoring, high school and college entrance exams, Chengdu, prostitution, underground casinos, Ministry of Education, South Korea, have plunged

China’s ban on private tutoring for children has put an abrupt end to a once-bustling industry but may actually create a black market with significantly higher prices, according to industry insiders and parents.

Local authorities across the country have begun to enforce Beijing’s decision to ban off-campus classes and turn licensed institutions into non-profit organisations, but the pressure to perform on state exams, including high school and college entrance exams, will keep demand strong from the country’s middle-class families.

Mary Pan, the mother of a 10-year-old in the western city of Chengdu, enrolled her son in the last available maths tutoring class.

“Everybody else is still taking courses,” she said. “In the future, if the [state] rules are implemented but other families secretly hire private tutors, we will probably do the same.”

Even though one-on-one tutoring at home could cost 10 times more than institutional services, she said if other parents hire private tutors then she “had no other choice”.

Signs of a black market for tutoring are already visible in local Chinese media reports.

In Huangshan city of eastern Anhui province, police raided an underground tutoring centre where a local middle school teacher provided services to students.

A local newspaper has reported the crackdowns much like they would those targeting prostitution or underground casinos, both illegal in China and subject to regular raids by enforcement authorities.

A number of cities in the central Chinese province of Hubei, including Xiangyang and Huanggang, have tasked enforcement authorities responsible for cracking down on pornography and illegal publications to also police off-campus training, a move that treats private tutoring as a form of petty crime.

private tutoring, high school and college entrance exams, Chengdu, prostitution, underground casinos, Ministry of Education, South Korea, have plunged

Senior students study in a classroom at the No. 14 High School in Hengshui, north China's Hebei Province, June 18, 2020 ahead of China's national college entrance exam. Photo: Xinhua

China’s Ministry of Education issued a notice on Tuesday, strictly banning teachers at Chinese public schools from carrying out fee-based training services outside classrooms, already prevalent for many years.

The ministry pledged a “zero tolerance” attitude towards such activities and threatened to sack teachers who moonlight as private tutors.

But an investor in private tutoring in Beijing, who declined to be named due to his involvement in the sensitive industry, said tutors who are not officially employed by any public school can still find customers eager to pay for a boost to their child’s performance.

“The price [in Beijing] for one-on-one tutoring has surged to 3,000 yuan [about half the country’s average monthly salary] per hour,” they said.

private tutoring, high school and college entrance exams, Chengdu, prostitution, underground casinos, Ministry of Education, South Korea, have plunged

A student continues to review as he waits to enter the examination centre for the college entrance exam. Photo: Simon Song

The country’s ban on private tutoring mirrors a similar move by South Korea in 1980 when the new government, led by Chun Doo-hwan, banned almost all forms of private tutoring in an effort to ease pressure on students in the country’s highly competitive education system.

However, the efforts proved futile as underground private tutoring continued to flourish with Seoul gradually ending the ban.

Iris Zhang, who teaches English for a private education company, said many of her former colleagues who quit this year are mostly working at public schools now as the days of private education institutions are numbered under the new regulation.

The private institutions, which organise teaching resources to meet demand from parents and students, are bearing the brunt of the crackdown as the Chinese government has made it clear that they should not seek to make a profit from their K-12 services and can no longer pursue initial public offerings. They are also banned from scheduling courses on holidays or at weekends.

Delayed salary payments, lay-offs and outright closures are becoming more common.

Share prices of Chinese education stocks have plunged in both Hong Kong and New York. New Oriental, one of the country’s largest private tutoring companies, TAL Education and Gaotu dropped 70 per cent last week.

All are struggling to shift their business to new areas like adult education, graduate exam preparation and civil service employment certification.

For some, however, the ban will not kill their career as a private tutor.

A Beijing-based tutor working for New Oriental, who declined to be named since they are not authorised to speak with media, said they will keep teaching until the policy is fully implemented. Even then, the crackdown will not kill their career.

“As long as the college entrance exam exists, [tutors] can always make money,” they said.

Additional reporting by Che Pan.

News Related


Every Amazon device announced today, from Amazon Astro home robot to Echo Show 15

Quality over quantity seemed to be the mantra of today’s annual Amazon hardware showcase.  Where previous years have seen the retail and technology giant rattle off dozens of product announcements ... Read more »

Best Nokia phones 2021: find the right Nokia smartphone for you

The best Nokia phones are often affordable and mid-range options. That’s because those are the types of phones the company mostly makes. While the best Nokia phones don’t change as ... Read more »

Best Sony phones 2021: find the right Sony Xperia smartphone for you

Our ranking of the best Sony phones is easily topped by the Sony Xperia 1 III now. It’s very expensive so it won’t be for everyone, but that’s where the ... Read more »

Best LG phones 2021: finding the best LG phone for you

LG has quit the smartphone business so this guide to the best LG phones won’t be receiving any new additions or changes to its rankings. Despite that, there are still ... Read more »

Best Oppo phones of 2021: pick up the best Oppo handset for you

The best Oppo phones can seem a little confusing thanks to the company’s unconventional naming system. That’s why we’ve ranked all the best Oppo phones so you’ll know exactly what’s ... Read more »

Microsoft Store is finally allowing third party stores like Amazon and Epic Games Store

For years Microsoft has been running its own storefront for Windows 8 and 10 for different apps and games, but you were always restricted to the small variety of software ... Read more »

Citadel Securities denies involvement in 'meme stock' trading restrictions

© Reuters/Nick Zieminski FILE PHOTO: A GameStop store is seen in the Jackson Heights neighborhood of New York City (Reuters) – Citadel Securities did not ask Robinhood or any other ... Read more »

Microsoft Whiteboard receives new features and UI overhaul

© Windows Central Microsoft Whiteboard collaboration The new update brings a lot to the table. What you need to know Microsoft Whiteboard just got a big update that adds features ... Read more »

Vodafone to close all proprietary stores in Spain by March, union says

© Reuters/Toby Melville FILE PHOTO: Vodafone branding is seen outside a retail store in London MADRID (Reuters) – British mobile and broadband operator Vodafone will shut all 34 of its ... Read more »

There's a Horrible Bias That Makes Us Underestimate The Pain of Poorer People

© eric1513/Getty Images People from relatively low socioeconomic backgrounds are more likely to have their pain sensitivity dismissed by others, according to a new series of psychological experiments. Even medical ... Read more »

Huawei CFO's admissions won't help US in its case against the company: Experts

The admission by Huawei‘s chief financial officer that she misled a bank about the company’s business dealings in Iran likely won’t help the United States as it continues to prosecute ... Read more »

Meet Astro: Amazon just unveiled its own home robot that can follow you around

Amazon’s next big leap in hardware: a personal robot. On Tuesday, Amazon announced Astro, a home robot the company says can help owners keep up with tasks such as home ... Read more »

'Put bluntly, he would die': Carer with seriously ill husband pleads with petrol panic-buyers to stop

Watch: Carer describes life and death situation for husband caused by fuel shortages A carer struggling to get her seriously ill husband to critical hospital appointments has expressed her frustration ... Read more »

Some may have ‘protective version of gene which resists severe Covid-19' – study

Some people possess a version of a gene which can potentially restrain the virus which causes Covid-19, a study has indicated. The findings offer an explanation for why some people ... Read more »

No Time to Die: Prince Charles, the Duchess of Cornwall and the Cambridges arrive at James Bond premiere

The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, the Duchess of Cornwall and the Prince of Wales arrive at the world premiere of No Time to Die The Prince of Wales, the ... Read more »

Best iPhone SE 2020 cases: how to protect your iPhone

The new iPhone SE is a delight for many, striking the right balance of affordability with all the value that comes from Apple’s powerful processing and long-term software support (especially ... Read more »

Best iPhone 12 and iPhone 12 Pro cases to protect your new phone

If you’ve bought an iPhone 12, a case is a vital accessory that’ll help you protect your new iPhone from knocks, drops or falls. A small amount of money spent ... Read more »

Best wireless chargers 2021: how to charge up your iPhone or Android without wires

The best wireless chargers for 2021 are going to use the Qi standard compatible with any modern iPhone, Samsung phones, Google Pixel 5, OnePlus 9 Pro and every major smartphone ... Read more »

Amazon introduces home robot alongside new Echo devices

Amazon has unveiled an autonomous home robot designed to guard the house as well as help with caregiving, as the firm announced a range of new smart home devices. Called ... Read more »

Best tablet for kids 2021: the top picks for children

The best tablet for kids isn’t like finding the best one for adults. Generally, a dedicated kids tablet from Amazon or Samsung is a better option for young children than ... Read more »

Boy, 14, missing from home in Cumbria found safe and well

A 14-year-old boy missing from home in Cumbria since Saturday has been found safe and well, the Guardian understands. Leven Sopwith-Nicholson had not been seen since Saturday night when he ... Read more »

Melania Trump started showing up on the arm of a 'handsome military aide' after the Stormy Daniels allegations broke, former aide says in book

First lady Melania Trump departs The Capitol at the conclusion of President Donald J. Trump‘s State of the Union Address on Capitol Hill January 30, 2018 in Washington, DC. Chris ... Read more »

The best iPhone 8 cases and iPhone 8 Plus cases: protect your all-glass iPhone

The iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus are both well worth protecting, given that they have glass on both the front and back. That’s where this guide comes in, as ... Read more »

The best iPhone XR cases: our guide to protecting your phone

When the iPhone XR launched in 2018, its defining feature was that – despite a still quite hefty price – it was the ‘cheap’ iPhone. Since then, it has proved ... Read more »

3 astronauts move Soyuz to new space station dock ahead of film crew arrival

© Provided by Space The Soyuz MS-18 spacecraft during a relocation maneuver on Sept. 28, 2021. Three astronauts relocated a Russian Soyuz crew capsule to a new port on the ... Read more »

Best OnePlus phones of 2021: these are the top new or older OnePlus handsets

Our ranking of the best OnePlus phones has had a relatively recent and major update, as the OnePlus 9 and OnePlus 9 Pro have now launched and taken their places ... Read more »

Best phones for kids 2021: the top 10 phones designed for children

The best phones for kids aren’t like the best phones for adults. They’re more about having the bare essentials without overwhelming your child with options, compared to having the best ... Read more »

Dropbox is beginning to look more and more like a collaboration tool

The cloud storage provider Dropbox has announced three new products designed to make it easier for distributed teams to work together from anywhere. For many employees, working from home has ... Read more »

North Korea fires ‘short-range missile' in latest weapons test as Pyongyang hits out at ‘hostile' forces

© AP People at Seoul Railway Station on Tuesday watching a TV news report showing a file image of a North Korean missile launch – AP North Korea test fired ... Read more »

Apple Watch Black Friday deals 2021: what to expect this year

Black Friday Apple Watch deals are always popular, thanks to record-low prices on older models and first-time discounts on Apple’s latest releases. To help you score the best Black Friday ... Read more »

How to preorder Amazon's latest devices

Amazon announced a fleet of new products at its hardware event, including the Astro home robot, several Ring home security products, and other products like a bigger Echo Show 15 ... Read more »

Amazon launches its first wall-mounted speaker at unveiling event

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Tech giant Amazon has launched its first ever wall-mounted speaker, at its streamed launch event on Tuesday. The £240 ($250) Alexa-powered Echo Show ... Read more »

Alexa Together turns your loved one's Echo into an emergency support device

Last year, Amazon announced Alexa Care Hub, a free service that uses Alexa to let people check in on family members. The so-called “caregiver” can see notifications and alerts when ... Read more »

How to sign up for an Amazon Astro invite

Amazon announced a home robot called Astro during its fall hardware event today, September 28th, which is designed to serve as a helpful mobile assistant that can navigate around the ... Read more »

Black Friday came early for LG's C1 OLED TV - down to a record-low price at Amazon

Grab one of the best TVs of 2021 at a stunningly low price, thanks to this incredible Black Friday-like deal that we’ve spotted at Amazon. Right now, you can get ... Read more »

Amazon Echo Show 15: everything we know about the wall-mounted Alexa device

Picture this: The brand new Amazon Echo Show 15 is a wall-hung smart screen that’s as much a picture frame as it is a connected gadget — and yes, you ... Read more »

Best Pixel phones: we've ranked all the Google Pixel handsets worth buying

Pixel phones are known for having top-tier cameras, a clean ‘stock’ Android operating system, and also getting new Android updates as early as possible. If these traits sound like something ... Read more »

Best Xiaomi phones of 2021: these are the top Mi, Redmi, Poco and Black Shark devices

This list of the best Xiaomi phones has been selected from the company’s wide array of smartphones – the tech giant has several sub-brands, all with multiple lines of phones, ... Read more »

Amazon's little robot named Astro will keep a watchful eye on your home - and you

Amazon’s new Astro robot. Amazon Amazon unveiled its home robot, named Astro, at its product event Tuesday. Astro comes equipped with cameras, microphones, and a screen, and keeps an eye ... Read more »

Young children from England's poorest areas are shorter, study suggests

Young children from poorer areas in England tend to be shorter than their counterparts from richer areas, new research suggests. A new study found that primary school children from the ... Read more »