Child tax credit tussle reflects debate over work incentives

Asia's Tech News Daily

WASHINGTON (AP) — To supporters of the child tax credit, there has always been an “aha moment” — the recognition that as little as a few hundred dollars a month could be life-changing.

Child tax credit tussle reflects debate over work incentives
© Provided by Associated Press Child Tax Credit

For Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet, it was several years ago when he was working as Denver’s school superintendent. One high schooler kept falling asleep in morning classes. When Bennet asked why he was so exhausted, the student said he worked the midnight shift at McDonald’s so that his family had enough money.

For Connecticut Rep. Rosa DeLauro, it was the childhood memory of her parents being evicted and finding their furniture on the street.

Bennet and DeLauro are among the Democratic lawmakers who have pushed to make permanent an expanded child tax credit, which President Joe Biden’s coronavirus relief package transformed into a monthly payment that would be available to almost any child. But Biden could not convince even enough of his fellow Democrats that they should extend these payments through 2025, and in negotiations for his broader package of economic and social programs he appears to have settled for a one-year extension that runs through next year.

Despite the concession, the president is still fighting for a legacy-making policy that could become the equivalent of Social Security for children. Biden dubbed the start of payments in July as “historic,” saying that the reduction to child poverty would be transformative and that he intended to make the credit permanent.

The steady evolution of the child tax credit reflects a fundamental split on how lawmakers think about human nature. Do payments from the government make people lazier or give them the resources to become more responsible? Established with bipartisan support in 1997, the credit has changed in ways that challenge many of the assumptions of political identities, as Democrats would be the ones calling on Republicans to cut taxes.

Republican critics and West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin — the decisive Democratic vote — worry that the payments could discourage parents from working, while supporters say the money would make it easier to afford the child care and transportation needed to find jobs.

“It’s a flat-out tax cut for ordinary people,” Biden said in a Wednesday speech in Scranton. “That’s what it does. I make no apologies for it.”

The continuation of the payments of at least $300 a month per child is as much about a political transformation as an economic one.

For the purposes of the federal budget, it is a tax cut aimed squarely at the middle class as median family incomes are at $86,372. The credit’s evolution since being created in 1997 speaks to the power of using the tax code for social policy.

It allows Democrats to claim the mantle of middle-class tax cutters, while Republicans who oppose the idea could be criticized for favoring tax hikes on this key group of voters ahead of the 2022 elections. That is a sharp reversal from the Ronald Reagan-era identity of Republicans as committed to tax cuts for aiding growth.

“A lot of its initial success was that it did fit into the frame of tax relief,” said Gene Sperling, a Biden aide who worked on economic policy in both the Clinton and Obama White Houses. “This is one place where progressives have over a period of 30 years kind of won the conceptual war.”

The child tax credit was initially bipartisan, a unique policy overlap between former President Bill Clinton and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich.

Republicans made it part of their 1994 “Contract with America,” a list of polices that former Georgia Rep. Gingrich rode to the House speakership. Gingrich said in an interview that former Illinois Rep. Henry Hyde, a staunch abortion opponent, emphasized that the GOP needed to show that it cared about children after they were born, not just when they were in the womb. The tax credit was the chosen vehicle.

Clinton separately proposed it in December 1994 in his “middle class bill of rights” speech. The convergence ultimately led to the 1997 overhaul of welfare that established a $500 tax credit for children. Future administrations expanded the credit. But until this year the credit was not “fully refundable” — which meant that parents with low incomes might not earn enough to receive the full payment.

What Biden and Democratic lawmakers did with their coronavirus relief package was remove that limit, effectively turning the tax credit into a monthly child allowance. Their planned extension would make this change permanent.

Gingrich and Republicans say people would quit their jobs because they would be able to receive payments without working, depriving children of working parents who can serve as role models.

He calls that “an enormously dangerous thing for our culture.”

Backing that argument is a paper by University of Chicago economists that assumes the expanded tax credits would cause 1.5 million parents to ditch their jobs because the credits would no longer be tied to working.

“It’s a policy that’s been transformed from one that encourages self reliance and work to one that doesn’t,” said Bruce Meyer, the University of Chicago professor who co-wrote the analysis.

However, real world economic data shows no correlation between the payments and people leaving work so far. Researchers at Columbia University have found that the expanded child tax credit payments that began in July had no impact on labor and that models claiming otherwise are overly simplified. Workers often need to spend money in order to get a job, they reason.

“You have to make an investment in order to be able to work,” said Elizabeth Ananat, an economist at Barnard College who co-wrote the Columbia paper. “You do have to get your car fixed. You have to get your phone turned back on. You have to buy a month supply of diapers in order to secure your spot in the preschool.”

Democratic lawmakers believe the payments reduce poverty and improve educational outcomes, making it more likely that the children will hold steady jobs as adults.

Colorado Sen. Bennet backed the idea of a child tax credit after he found as a school administrator that more resources were needed to ensure kids had the stability to succeed.

“Most of the parents are working incredibly hard, some of them working two and three jobs. And no matter what they do, they couldn’t keep the kids out of poverty,” Bennet said.

DeLauro says the breakthrough on expanding the credit came as a result of the coronavirus showing how economically fragile many families are and Biden’s own choice as a presidential candidate to support the policy. She believes that beneficiaries will keep their jobs because work is part of who they are.

“People identify themselves by their work,” she said.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

P Pinang mungkin terus bangunkan LRT jika PSR tak dapat dijalankan

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Laluan LRT sepanjang 19km dengan 30 stesen yang bermula dari Bayan Lepas dianggarkan menelan belanja RM8.5 bilion. GEORGE TOWN: Pulau Pinang akan mempertimbangkan untuk ... Read more »

Ducks blow late 3-goal lead, beat Kings 5-4 in shootout

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Kevin Shattenkirk and Trevor Zegras scored in the shootout, and the Anaheim Ducks blew a three-goal lead in the third period before rallying for a 5-4 ... Read more »

Moore carries San Jose State over South Dakota 61-52

SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) — Omari Moore had 18 points and six rebounds as San Jose State beat South Dakota 61-52 on Tuesday night. Tibet Gorener had 14 points for ... Read more »

How Michelin star chefs tracked down long-lost seeds to give mother a taste of childhood

Despite having pioneered pig trotter carpaccio and ice-cream flavoured with cigar smoke, when the Michelin-starred Roca brother chefs were asked by their ageing mother to recreate the food of her ... Read more »

Wrexham 0-2 Yeovil Town: Parkinson furious with referee as Dragons surrender unbeaten home record

Wrexham AFC lost their first home game of the season as another 8,000 plus Racecourse crowd saw a largely disappointing Dragons display against Yeovil Town. However, the result owed largely ... Read more »

Bullies rely on power to protect them, not online anonymity

I’ve had more death threats than flat whites. But almost everyone who abused me did so using their real names The prime minister would have you believe that social media ... Read more »

Nigeria confirms first cases of Omicron among travellers from South Africa

ABUJA (Reuters) –Nigeria confirmed its first cases of the Omicron COVID-19 variant among two travellers who arrived from South Africa last week, the Nigeria Centre for Disease Control (NCDC) said ... Read more »

How uncertainty can impair our ability to make rational decisions – new research

When times are uncertain, we can fail to be flexible. jefftakespics2/Shutterstock We make decisions every day, many of which are so straightforward that we hardly notice we are making them. ... Read more »

Rakesh Jhunjhunwala's 3 latest picks are in sell mode. Worth a look?

NEW DELHI: Rakesh Jhunjhunwala‘s latest stock picks are having a rough ride in the market. These stocks are down up to 30 per cent from their 52-week highs, data suggest. ... Read more »

Abortion debate epicenter: Mississippi clinic stays open

© Provided by Associated Press Allen Siders, an anti-abortion activist, preaches outside of the Jackson Women’s Health Organization, a state-licensed abortion clinic in Jackson, Miss., Tuesday, Nov. 30, 2021. A ... Read more »

HYBE's new label launches online global auditions

hybe new label launches online global auditionsa This is your chance to be the next global idol! HYBE’s new independent label ADOR (All Doors One Room) just launched an online ... Read more »

'Miss Universe boycott is unconstitutional,' says civil organisation as it heads to court

© Provided by Times Live Citizens for Integrity cited a violation of several human rights and laws in its case against the government, the minister of justice and correctional services ... Read more »

New Zealand to send peacekeepers to crisis-hit Solomon Islands

© Charley PIRINGI The Solomon Islands crisis erupted last week when protests over government policies turned violent, fuelled by poverty, unemployment and inter-island rivalries New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern ... Read more »

In a new push for vaccine diplomacy, China's Xi Jinping has pledged to give Africa a billion vaccines

© Provided by Insider Asia Chinese leader Xi Jinping this week pledged to give Africa one billion vaccines. Xinhua/Rao Aimin via Getty Images Chinese leader Xi Jinping has made the ... Read more »

Prepare sanctions on Russia and ramp up military cooperation, Ukraine tells NATO

© Reuters/INTS KALNINS NATO Foreign Ministers summit in Riga RIGA (Reuters) – Ukraine urged NATO on Wednesday to boost military cooperation with Kyiv and prepare a package of measures, including ... Read more »

GrabFood rider punched & kicked multiple times by couple for cutting in between them, suffers bodily injuries & nose bleed

© The Independent Singapore Disclaimer: MSN advises its readers to use their discretion while reading this since the story’s details might be unsettling and can cause distress to some. Singapore ... Read more »

Man whose friend bought pistol and bullets for him jailed

SINGAPORE —A man who consorted with a friend who had bought pistols and bullets for him was jailed for five years and two weeks, and given six strokes of the ... Read more »

Petrol price in Delhi likely to come down

© Provided by Hindustan Times The petrol price in New Delhi is likely to come down on Wednesday. (REUTERS/File) The petrol price in the Capital is likely to come down ... Read more »

Vineet Kumar Singh ties the knot with girlfriend Ruchiraa Gormaray

© Provided by Radio City Bollywood actor Vineet Kumar Singh has married his long-time girlfriend Ruchiraa Gormaray in an intimate ceremony. The wedding date on the caption he shared on ... Read more »

Weather update: Mumbai sees December rainfall, netizens post happy pics and memes

© Provided by Zee News Mumbai, on Wednesday (December 1), saw rainfall in many parts. As a result the temperature is likely to go down and the city may officially ... Read more »

PM Modi holds high-level talks with senior Cabinet leaders ahead of Parliament session

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday held a meeting with senior Cabinet ministers to chalk out the government’s strategy before the start of the day’s Parliament session. Those who were ... Read more »

Former Japan PM tells China

Japan and the United States could not stand by if China attacked Taiwan, and Beijing needs to understand this, former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said on Wednesday. © STR/JIJI ... Read more »

BWF World Tour Finals: Kidambi Srikanth makes winning start, Ashwini Ponnappa-N Sikki Reddy pair loses

BWF World Tour Finals: Kidambi Srikanth makes winning start Indian shuttler Kidambi Srikanth made a winning start to his men’s singles campaign while the women’s doubles pair of Ashwini Ponnappa ... Read more »

Barbados Declares Rihanna a National Hero

Rihanna Barbados has a new queen. Sort of. On Monday (Nov. 29), the Caribbean nation formally cut political and ceremonial ties with the United Kingdom to become the world’s newest ... Read more »

Aneri Vajani to enter Anupamaa. Show gears up for major twist

Aneri Vajani’s entry will add an interesting twist to Anupamaa. Popular Star Plus show Anupama is gearing up for major twists, The makers are is set to introduce a new ... Read more »

Army decides on new digital pattern combat uniform, to be implemented in 2022

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: The Army has decided to introduce a new digital pattern combat uniform for officers and men from next year. The Army is also ... Read more »

IAF AFCAT 2022: Registration for 317 posts begins today; check details here

© Provided by Firstpost IAF AFCAT 2022: Registration for 317 posts begins today; check details here The registration process for Air Force Common Admission Test (AFCAT) 2022 has been started ... Read more »

RRB NTPC result, RRC group D exam: Candidates demand to expedite selection

Close to 5 months after the completion of the exam, RRB NTPC candidates have not been given any official word on the result declaration. Also, there is no update on ... Read more »

Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal wedding is turning out to be a nightmare for guests [Exclusive]

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com The big Bollywood wedding of the year Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif wedding is turning out to be a never seen or heard before affair. Oh ... Read more »

As Omicron variant spreads across the world, India's third dose policy may become reality in 14 days

© Provided by Firstpost As Omicron variant spreads across the world, India’s third dose policy may become reality in 14 days With the new Omicron variant of COVID-19 spreading fast ... Read more »

London rises up ranks of most expensive cities as Paris loses top spot

London has climbed the rankings of the world’s most expensive cities to hit its highest point in years as Paris is knocked off the top spot.  © Provided by The ... Read more »

Mourners pack church to grieve shooting victims

Mourners pack a Michigan church to grieve those killed and injured in a school shooting (Dec. 1) Read more »

1787 letter from Catherine the Great shows she backed inoculations: ‘They should be common everywhere'

Catherine the Great’s letter supporting vaccinations is displayed in Moscow on 18 November (AFP via Getty Images) A letter written by Russian empress Catherine the Great extolling the virtues of ... Read more »

Salman Khan warns against bursting crackers in theatres: People have lost their lives

© Provided by Radio City There’s Bhaigiri, and then there’s brashness. The latter was displayed over the weekend when Salman Khan’s fans burst crackers inside a theatre during the screening ... Read more »

Kapil Sharma asks John Abraham how to lose 10 kg weight in a month; here's how the Satyameva Jayate 2 actor responded

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Recently on The Kapil Sharma Show, John Abraham and Divya Khosla Kumar promoted their recent release Satyameva Jayate 2. The film’s director Milap Zaveri had also ... Read more »

Inside Ghum Hai Kisikey Pyaar Meiin stars Neil Bhatt and Aishwarya Sharma's vibrant wedding - Pics, Videos

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Popular television actors Neil Bhatt and Aishwarya Sharma got married on November 30 and fans can’t be happier. The internet is flooded with ... Read more »

Kareena Kapoor Khan adds a pop of colour to Wednesday morning in tangerine co ords; PHOTOS

Actress Kareena Kapoor Khan never fails to impress fans with her stylish looks. Be it her casual attire or her red carpet looks, each makes it to the headlines and ... Read more »

Elon Musk's $50 Tesla Cyberwhistle is sold out. He says 'don't buy silly Apple Cloth'

© Shylaja Varma Elon Musk’s $50 Tesla Cyberwhistle is sold out. He says ‘don’t buy silly Apple Cloth’ Billionaire Elon Musk has asked people to “blow the whistle on Tesla”, ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15: Karan Kundrra once again shows off his possessive side as Tejasswi Prakash discusses strategies with Nishant Bhat

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Karan Kundrra and Tejasswi Prakash’ relationship in Bigg Boss 15 has been discussed a lot. While their fans cannot stop rooting for #TejRan, there are a ... Read more »

Councilman Andre Dickens wins Atlanta mayor race

Atlanta mayoral runoff candidate Andre Dickens gives his victory speech Tuesday, Nov. 30, 2021, in Atlanta. AP City Council member Andre Dickens won a runoff election Tuesday to become Atlanta’s ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic