Channel boat push-backs are unlawful and will endanger lives, government told

Channel boat push-backs are unlawful and will endanger lives, government told
© Daniel Leal-Olivas/AFP

Committee says proposals backed by Priti Patel must be scrapped or changed

– Daniel Leal-Olivas/AFP

Government plans to push migrant boats back to France while effectively “criminalising the act of seeking asylum” are unlawful and will put lives at risk, a parliamentary report has found.

The Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) said pushbacks authorised by Priti Patel would “create a situation where state actors were actively placing individuals in situations that would increase the risk” of drowning.

“Under the current conditions, we cannot see how a policy of pushbacks can be implemented without risking lives, contrary to the UK’s obligations under the right to life and international maritime law,” said the report.

“Concerns about irregular migration cannot justify legislation that puts lives at risk.”

The JCHR, which contains MPs and peers from all main political parties, said the proposals must be scrapped or changed to comply with the law.

The home secretary has repeatedly insisted there is a “legal basis” for the pushback proposals, but officials have refused to give details or confirm whether any operations have yet taken place.

The report comes a week after at least 27 people drowned in the worst disaster of its kind in the English Channel, escalating political tensions with France following months of record crossings.

France’s interior minister has said it will not accept operations to force migrant boats back into its waters, and said thousands were boarding dinghies “they have no other way” of reaching Britain to seek asylum.

A union representing Border Force staff has joined one of at least three legal challenges being threatened over the policy.

The JCHR said the Nationality and Borders Bill, which would grant Border Force staff partial immunity from prosecution if migrants drown during pushbacks, contained several unlawful clauses and questioned their effectiveness.

It would mean “there is no way of holding the government, or their agents, to account for killing or injuring a person through negligence in criminal or civil law”, the report said, adding: “It is difficult to understand why there should be impunity in such circumstances.”

The committee warned that the bill “would effectively criminalise the act of seeking asylum in the UK” by making it a criminal offence to cross the Channel via small boat, or arrive by any other means without entry clearance.

“No visa for the purposes of claiming asylum exists and it is not possible to claim asylum without coming to the UK,” the JCHR said.

“Setting up a system whereby refugees are unable to travel to the UK to claim asylum without committing a criminal offence is inconsistent with the overall purpose of the UN Refugee Convention.”

The law would leave “extremely limited” resettlement schemes as the main legal route to claiming asylum in the UK.

Figures released last week showed only 1,171 refugees were resettled in the year to September and a promised scheme for Afghans has not yet started.

The law would also make it easier to jail asylum seekers who steer dinghies, and raise the possibility that the RNLI and charities could be prosecuted for “facilitating the arrival of an asylum seeker” by saving lives at sea.

The government has defended its plans by asserting that asylum seekers “should claim at the earliest opportunity in the first safe country they reach”, but the JCHR said its position had no basis in international law.

Harriet Harman, chair of the JCHR, said the bill was “littered with measures that are simply incompatible with human rights law and the UK’s obligations under international treaties”.

“The Channel is one of the busiest shipping lanes in the world and despite its short distance the cold and choppy waters make crossing perilous,” she added.

“The government is determined to prevent these crossings, but pushbacks are not the solution. They will not deter crossings, the seas will become even more dangerous and the people smugglers will continue to evade punishment.

“Current failures in the immigration and asylum system cannot be remedied by harsher penalties and more dangerous enforcement action.”

Ms Harman called for the government to set out how its proposals can comply with human rights laws, and remove any measures that do not.

The committee said ministers should prioritise saving lives at sea, while considering alternative means to deter people smugglers “such as creating more safe and legal routes for refugees or enabling asylum seekers to obtain visas to come to the UK from France to claim asylum”.

A Home Office spokesperson said: “As part of our ongoing operational response and to prevent further loss of life at sea, we continue to evaluate and test a range of safe and legal options to find ways of stopping small boats making this dangerous and unnecessary journey. These all comply and are delivered in accordance with both domestic and international law.

“Our New Plan for Immigration will also overhaul the broken asylum system and reduce many of the historic pull factors by making it firmer on those coming here through parallel illegal routes and fairer for those using our safe asylum schemes.”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Pro Kabaddi League 2021-22: Eight-point raid and mid-table shuffle highlight week 5

© Provided by Firstpost Pro Kabaddi League 2021-22: Eight-point raid and mid-table shuffle highlight week 5 For a man who had just earned eight points for his team, in a ... Read more »

How much will you need to retire?

© Provided by The Times of India Experts say retirement planning should start from the day you start earning. It’s sound advice that almost nobody follows. That’s why TOI is ... Read more »

UP Polls: BJP's Hindutva Poster Boys Sangeet Som, Suresh Rana are Keeping Kairana, 2013 Riots on Top of Recall

Sangeet Som and Suresh Rana, two of BJP’s Hindutva faces, are leading the campaign for the saffron party in the religiously divided region of western Uttar Pradesh ahead of Assembly ... Read more »

Paris Hilton found going to therapy with mother Kathy 'really healing'

© Provided by Cover Media Paris Hilton Paris Hilton found going to joint therapy with her mother Kathy to be “really healing” for them both. In her 2020 YouTube documentary ... Read more »

Australian Open to allow 'Where is Peng Shuai?' shirts after backlash

Fans at the Australian Open can wear “Where is Peng Shuai?” shirts as long as they are peaceful, tournament chief Craig Tiley told AFP Tuesday, after a backlash over the ... Read more »

Record fuel prices and cost of new homes push inflation to fastest pace since mid-2014

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAP Record fuel petrol prices and the highest cost of building new homes in two decades propelled consumer inflation at the end of ... Read more »

Andy Reid, Josh Allen give blunt assessment of NFL overtime rules after Chiefs' walk-off win over Bills

For however much of the discussion of the Chiefs-Bills playoff game centered around the play of quarterbacks Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes in the final minutes, as much, if not ... Read more »

Shriram Transport Fin jumps 4% as investors cheer 11% rise in Q3 net interest income

NEW DELHI – Shares of Shriram Transport Finance Company gained 4 per cent in early trade Tuesday even as the non-bank financing company reported a decline in standalone profit as ... Read more »

Zomato trading at heavy discount to listing price: Should you grab a bite?

NEW DELHI: Despite a 46 per cent drop over its peak, analysts largely have a mixed view on whether Zomato has entered into a ‘buy’ zone now. Foreign brokerage JPMorgan ... Read more »

New York state supreme court judge strikes down mask mandate

A state supreme court judge struck down New York state’s mask mandate Monday, ruling that the governor and NY State Department of Health did not have the authority to enact ... Read more »

Eva Longoria put on an effortlessly chic display in the French capital

Eva Longoria put on a very chic display as she stepped out in the French capital on Monday.  The 46-year-old actress, nailed Parisian style in a Navy wool coat and ... Read more »

Fall Guys Monopoly board game launches with real-life Big Yeetus

© Provided by GamesRadar Fall Guys monopoly Fall Guys monopoly is here to make your next family game night even more frenzied and chaotic – because that’s exactly what it ... Read more »

Can South Africans be the leaders to drive change for sustainable living?

© Provided by 702 To celebrate the future made possible today, thanks to BMW, Clement Manyathela is chatting to industry experts about innovative sustainable technologies and electric driving. In this ... Read more »

Opening Bell: Sensex, Nifty open lower amid mixed global cues; Axis Bank, Zomato in focus

© Provided by CNBCTV18 The Indian equity benchmark indices opened in the red on Tuesday, dragged lower by concerns about faster US rate hike, tensions over Ukraine, rising inflation and ... Read more »

How to make the best possible swords in Minecraft

Learning to make the best sword in Minecraft will give you a major advantage in any boss fight. When it comes to combat in Minecraft, the sword is any player’s ... Read more »

Can Coffee Consumption Improve Digestion? Study Answers

© KS Swati | India.com Lifestyle Staff Can Coffee Consumption Improve Digestion? Study Answers. Picture Credits: ANI According to a recent clinical study, coffee has positive effects on digestion and ... Read more »

Axis Bank shares rise after Q3 results. Should you buy, sell or hold the stock?

© Provided by CNBCTV18 id=”content” class=”jsx-1771851872 jsx-649666247 post_content”> Axis Bank shares were in focus on Tuesday, a day after the private sector lender reported its financial results for the December ... Read more »

South Korea's GDP growth hits 11-year high as exports boom

© Provided by Al Jazeera South Korea’s economy grew 4 percent last year despite the pandemic [File: Kim Hong-Ji/Reuters] South Korea’s economy expanded at the fastest pace in 11 years ... Read more »

Facebook Parent Meta Has Built The Fastest AI Supercomputer In The World

© Provided by News18 Facebook Parent Meta Has Built The Fastest AI Supercomputer In The World Meta (erstwhile Facebook) is the latest company to build an AI supercomputer. Meta’s AI ... Read more »

Babyleiche in Gefängnis-Müllcontainer gefunden

Das drei Monate alte Kind war den Ermittlungen zufolge auf einem Friedhof in Mexiko-Stadt ausgegraben und in das Gefängnis in der gut 100 Kilometer entfernten Stadt Puebla gebracht worden. Nun ... Read more »

Vodafone Idea gains 3% as management says may hike mobile services rates

NEW DELHI – Shares of Vodafone Idea added 2.7 per cent in early trade Tuesday after the beleaguered telecom operator said that it may raise mobile services rates this year ... Read more »

These Were the Most-Sold Skincare in K-Beauty Store Olive Young for 2021

© Provided by Preview.ph A trip to Korea wouldn’t be complete without a visit to the country’s biggest health and beauty store, Olive Young. It’s skincare and makeup paradise, with ... Read more »

Here's How This OFW Earns P120,000 from His Vegetable Garden in Italy

© Provided by Preview.ph Italy is one of Europe’s most popular tourist destinations, particularly among the wealthy and those interested in arts and culture. It is also, coincidentally, one of ... Read more »

Aditya Narayan on impending parenthood: 'I don't have it in me to be strict with my child'

© Provided by Firstpost Aditya Narayan on impending parenthood: ‘I don’t have it in me to be strict with my child’ Congratulations, when did you get to know the good ... Read more »

Hotlink Internet 365 dimansuhkan, Hotlink Pantas! menyusul

Saya sukakan prabayar Hotlink Internet 365 sebab ia adalah antara pelan yang berikan tempoh aktif paling lama pada kos paling rendah. Dengan hanya menambah nilai RM5, anda boleh nikmati tempoh ... Read more »

Not Only Patels, 3 Other Families Who Attempted To Enter US Found Missing: Report

© Provided by News18 Not Only Patels, 3 Other Families Who Attempted To Enter US Found Missing: Report The investigation into the death of the family of four across the ... Read more »

The Top 40 Highest-Rating Korean Dramas of All Time

© Provided by Preview.ph There’s no deterring our love affair with all things K-drama. This time, we give you the lowdown on the highest rating Korean dramas of all time ... Read more »

Tulare County Sheriff's Office nabs 14,763 marijuana plants in raid

Jan. 24—The Tulare County Sheriff's Office has conducted a successful raid of a local marijuana grow, according to authorities. In July of 2021, the Tulare County Sheriff's Office, Visalia Police ... Read more »

Bigg Boss 15 will see audience entering the house to evict a contestant. Watch promo

Bigg Boss 15 finale will take place on January 30. Ahead of that, the makers are doing the best they can to make the show interesting. And now, for the ... Read more »

As Mumbai Shivers Amid 'Coldest January in a Decade', What IMD Says; Cold Wave Warning for Guj

© Provided by News18 As Mumbai Shivers Amid ‘Coldest January in a Decade’, What IMD Says; Cold Wave Warning for Guj Mumbai has been witnessing cold weather, with the minimum ... Read more »

Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2: Release of Kartik Aaryan-Kiara Advani's film getting pushed? Here's an interesting update

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com When everyone in the film industry thought that the things were getting back on track, third wave of Coronavirus hit like a hurricane. After the theatres ... Read more »

Afghan girls must return to school: Former Prez Hamid Karzai

© Provided by The Statesman Afghan girls must return to school: Former Prez Hamid Karzai Afghan girls must be allowed to go to schools when they reopen in March, said ... Read more »

Did Ajay Devgn and Akshay Kumar turn down the Hindi remake of Ajith's Viswasam? Here's what we know

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com Pushpa star Allu Arjun has a huge fanbase in the Hindi belt. Yesterday, they got the sad news that the Hindi dubbed version of Allu Arjun’s ... Read more »

India logs less than 3 lakh daily Covid cases, positivity rate falls to 15.52%

India logs less than 3 lakh Covid cases, positivity rate falls to 15.52% India has registered 2,55,874 new Covid cases in the last 24 hours, a decline of 50,190 from ... Read more »

Republic Day: DD installs special cameras for 360-degree coverage

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Rajpath ahead of the Republic Day parade in New Delhi. (AFP) NEW DELHI: Public service broadcaster Doordarshan (DD) has installed dozens of cameras, including ... Read more »

Why German naval chief wanted West to respect Putin & what India-China have got to do with it

© Provided by The Print What does Russia really want? Is Russia really interested in having a small, tiny strip of Ukraine soil, to integrate into their country?… I think ... Read more »

Shraddha Kapoor soaks in Mumbai's cosy weather as she begins Tuesday morning with a cup of chai

© Provided by Pinkvilla The crisp winter air has taken over Mumbai and resulted in an unusually cold week. The coastal city which rarely witnesses winter has been experiencing light ... Read more »

Hielt sich für einen Übermenschen: Der Mann Pierin Vincenz

Wer ist Pierin Vincenz? Selber hielt er sich wohl für einen Übermenschen, der schliesslich an Geld, Gier und Grössenwahn scheiterte. © Bereitgestellt von Blick Der Mann Pierin Vincenz Pierin Vincenz ... Read more »

Assam and Nagaland opt for out-of-court settlement in decades-old border dispute

Nagaland Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio said that Assam and Nagaland are ready for out-of-court settlement for several decade old border dispute. Both the states have agreed to share royalty from ... Read more »

Active Covid-19 cases in India declines to 1,44,845; lowest in 260 days

India saw a single-day rise of 10,853 COVID-19 infections, which took the country’s total tally of cases to 3,43,55,536, while active cases have declined to 1,44,845, the lowest in 260 ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic