Caste bias lawsuit | Cisco files opening brief to compel arbitration in US Appeal Court

#Caste bias in Silicon Valley, #caste discrimination, #Cisco, #Cisco caste bias lawsuit, was stayed pending arbitration appeal, filed an amicus brief opposing

Cisco (Image: Reuters)

US tech major Cisco filed opening brief in the US Appeal Court to compel arbitration with John Doe, a Dalit employee who had filed caste-bias lawsuit against the company.

This comes after its petition for a private arbitration process was denied by the trial court in Santa Clara county early this year. Cisco filed the brief on September 7 in the Appeals Court in the State of California.

Moneycontrol has reviewed the copy of the brief.

This is one of the most closely watched cases in Silicon Valley. For, its outcome could force tech giants to take a relook at how they handle discrimination, especially one based on caste, in the workplace.

An email has been sent to Cisco for a comment on this development. The story will be updated with their response.

Cisco caste-bias lawsuit and arbitration

On June 30, 2020, a lawsuit alleging caste discrimination was filed against Cisco by the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) on behalf of Doe. The lawsuit accused two upper-caste Brahmins, Sundar Iyer and Ramana Kompella, of harassing the Dalit worker, referred to as John Doe to protect his identity, in their capacity as managers.

After the lawsuit, the company filed a petition to compel arbitration with Doe, which was denied. To compel arbitration is to make the plaintiff, here Doe, to submit to the arbitration process and take the dispute resolution out of court and to a third party.

This petition came up for hearing on January 26, 2021 in a trial court in the US. Judge Drew C Takaichi denied private arbitration in an order dated February 26 on the grounds that, “This claim and relief exceeds the scope of the private arbitration agreement.”

The order said the claims by the DFEH in Doe’s case on violations of California’s fair employment and housing act by Cisco, was in public interest that is broader than relief specific to Doe.

Cisco had appealed this verdict in the appellate court.

Appeal in the US court

Cisco in its opening brief contested the trial court’s order that the claims by DFEH that the lawsuit was in public interest and is broader than the relief specific to Doe. According to the filing, the agency does not have the legal statute to pursue its own interest, which is going beyond individual representation of Doe.

In its brief filed in the court, the company said that DFEH has no authority to pursue interests independent of Doe’s, when civil lawsuits can be subjected to private arbitration. It further said that the trial court reached the “wrong conclusion” by denying Cisco’s motion to compel arbitration.

“…the trial court erred in holding that the DFEH is pursuing independent interests. Because it cannot pursue such interests in a civil action on behalf of an individual employee, under the applicable test for arbitrability, the DFEH’s claims on behalf of the employee must be arbitrated,” the filing read.

Since DFEH is not bringing a class action suit, but is representing an individual, the agency cannot have independent interests to pursue the case. “It is acting solely as Doe’s proxy. The DFEH is bound by Doe’s arbitration agreement,” according to the filing

“For the foregoing reasons, the order denying the motions to compel arbitration should be reversed with directions to enter an order compelling arbitration of this case,” the report read.

Other petitions

In addition to the appeal, the company had filed Cisco filed ‘demurrer’ and ‘motion of strike’ petitions in the California court on October 26, 2020. The hearing scheduled for March 9, was stayed pending arbitration appeal.

The US-based Ambedkar International Center along with 19 organisations including Ambedkar King Study Circle, and Anti-caste Discrimination Alliance, filed an amicus brief opposing Cisco’s ‘demurrer’ and ‘motion to strike’ petitions, which challenges the legality of the caste bias lawsuit filed against it last year.

Ryan McCarl and John Rushing, founding partners, Rushing McCarl lawfirm in the US that filed the brief for Ambedkar International Centre, explained to Moneycontrol earlier that, both the motions are at the core of the caste discrimination and outcome could force other technology companies to look at caste discrimination as a more serious issue.

Why is this case important?

The outcome is important given the role of the Indian population in Silicon Valley, the tech capital of the US.

According to the 2019 report by the Strengthening South Asian Communities in America, there were about 5 lakh Indians in California, accounting for 1.3 percent of the state’s total population and home to 20 percent of the total Indian immigrant population.

There is no clear data on how many of these Indians are Dalits. But according to the lawsuit against Cisco, only 1.5 percent of the Indian immigrants were from the Dalit community as of 2003. This could have increased by now.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Southwest Airlines scraps plan to put unvaccinated employees on unpaid leave

If exemption requests have not been reviewed or approved by Dec. 8, employees will continue to work and get paid. They will have to follow mask and social distancing guidelines. Read more »

Tata Steel BSL posts over 5-fold jump in net profit to 1,837 crore for September quarter

Tata Steel BSL on Tuesday reported over a five-fold jump in its consolidated net profit to Rs 1,837.03 crore for the September 2021 quarter, mainly on account of higher income. ... Read more »

Climate change: Government sets out UK plans to reach net zero by 2050 - here are the key details

Boris Johnson says the plans are long-term and will benefit the UK and the world as he laid out several different areas that will be targeted. Read more »

Russia has nothing to do with EU's energy crisis — envoy

It was noted that Europe had made a gross miscalculation and now found itself in a situation where its underground gas storages were empty Read more »

More than a thousand children affected by the allowance affair have been removed from their homes

Between 2015 and 2020, 1115 children of victims of the childcare allowance scandal were removed from their homes. This is reported by the Central Bureau of Statistics. The childcare allowance ... Read more »

Badminton Association of India has to be like BCCI, says Prakash Padukone

Prakash Padukone and NSCI Secretary Atul Maru after the signing of the agreement. Mic in hand, Prakash Padukone gazed to his right at the new walnut-coloured courts at the National ... Read more »

$1bn Gorillas fundraising shows appetite for growth in rapid grocery delivery sector

The sector, which also includes the likes of Getir, Zapp and Jiffy, seems to have sprung up almost overnight - with expansion boosted by lockdowns and funded by billions of dollars from venture capital. Read more »

Stocks making the biggest moves midday: Ulta, ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF, ChargePoint and more

Fans gather at local Ulta Beauty in Houston to greet Kylie Jenner at the launch of her cosmetics line on November 18, 2018 in Houston, Texas.Rick Kern | Getty Images ... Read more »

Automakers are spending billions to produce battery cells for EVs in the U.S.

Dane Hardware (right), Ford design and release engineer, and Mary Fredrick, Ford battery validation engineer, measure the voltage of a battery using a digital multimeter at Ford's Battery Benchmarking and ... Read more »

Kerala IT park opens pavilion at GITEX Global 2021 in Dubai

Representative Imahe (Source: Reuters) The Kerala IT Park has opened its pavilion at the GITEX Global 2021 technology fest in Dubai showcasing the state’s IT infrastructure strengths and investment avenues ... Read more »

ICICI Pru Life posts 47% jump in net profit to Rs 445 crore for September quarter

ICICI Prudential Life Insurance Co Ltd on Tuesday reported nearly 47 per cent jump in its net profit to Rs 445 crore for the second quarter ended September 30. The ... Read more »

4 practical ways in which a personal loan can help in an emergency

Emergencies always arrive unannounced. And emergency funds are the financial safety net in such situations and have helped many safeguard their savings. Whether covering medical expenses or running the household ... Read more »

Gazprom can increase gas supplies to Europe after Nord Stream 2 approval — WoodMackenzie

The Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline operator reported the day before that the gas-in procedure for the first string of the gas pipeline was completed and it was ready to start deliveries Read more »

Dissatisfaction among academic hospital staff: ‘Largest action ever underway'

The activists will operate a Sunday shift, which means that all planable care will be canceled that day and only emergency care and treatments that cannot be interrupted will continue. ... Read more »

Draft Delhi Master Plan 2041: Second hearing of board of enquiry on October 20

Representative image The second meeting of a board of enquiry set up for hearing and considering objections and suggestions of the public on the draft Master Plan of Delhi 2041 ... Read more »

Armenia invites Russian companies to bid for construction of North-South highway to Iran

According to Minister of Territorial Development and Infrastructure of Armenia Gnel Sanosyan, the Iranian side is also interested in taking part Read more »

Iran becomes leading grain importer from Russia — experts

For the first three months of the new season 2021-2022, exports to Iran from Russia amounted to 3.697 mln tonnes of grain Read more »

Exercises within Runet stability law framework successful — official

The goal of exercises was to test readiness of communication networks or communication network segments for certain deviations in operations Read more »

Rains force auto companies to shut production at Uttarakhand plants

Production at most of the automotive and component manufacturing plants at Pantnagar in Uttarakhand has come to a standstill following incessant rain that has claimed at least 34 lives in the hilly ... Read more »

Surge in onion prices adds another layer of pain for India's consumers

Buying vegetables at a small market on the outskirts of Mumbai, Shubhangi Patil laments the recent rapid rise in the cost of everyday essentials, from cooking oil to sugar and ... Read more »

US futures ETF lists, Bitcoin nears all-time high

Representative image Bitcoin hit a six-month high and was within striking distance of its all-time peak on Tuesday as traders bet the listing of the first bitcoin futures-based U.S. exchange-traded ... Read more »

GlobalFoundries seeks $25 billion valuation in US IPO as chip demand soars

Chipmaker GlobalFoundries, owned by Abu Dhabi’s sovereign wealth fund Mubadala Investment Co, is aiming for a valuation of about $25 billion in its initial public offering in the United States. ... Read more »

Coal crisis: Number of power projects with less than 4-day coal stock dips to 58

The coal stock situation at thermal power projects has improved further as the number of non-pit head projects having less than four days of coal (supercritical stock) reduced to 58 ... Read more »

HGV driver crisis: 'Things are not visibly getting better at this stage'

Industry bosses told a select committee hearing that the crisis could last a year and that it was resulting in "terrifying" price rises for the hospitality sector. Read more »

The NBA arena that plans to end single-use plastic starting this season

Footprint Center exteriorSource: Suns Legacy Partners & Footprint When the Phoenix Suns open the 2021-2022 NBA season at home on Oct. 20, fans will likely notice the new banner hanging ... Read more »

ICICI Securities Q2 PAT up 26% to Rs 351-crore; announces interim dividend of Rs 11.25/share

ICICI Securities on Tuesday reported a 26 per cent jump in profit after tax to Rs 351 crore in the three months ended September 2021 on account of growth in ... Read more »

China's property and construction sectors contract in third quarter as Evergrande crisis and tougher regulation hit home

China’s property and construction sectors contracted in the third quarter for the first time since the start of the pandemic, hurt by a slump in real estate as the Evergrande ... Read more »

Apple is selling this piece of cloth for $19

Apple’s polishing cloth goes for $19. Apple At least it’s cheaper than an iPhone. Apple is now selling a “Polishing Cloth” for $19 — even though similar products go for ... Read more »

Inflation is not going away any time soon. Here's how top financial advisors are handling it

Shoppers at a New York supermarket on Aug. 11, 2021.Wang Ying | Xinhua News Agency | Getty Images One looming question for the U.S. economy is how long inflation is ... Read more »

STI up 0.79%, taking the cue from Wall Street rally

SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – Overnight Wall Street indexes rallied and gave the Straits Times Index (STI) and key regional barometers reasons to be bullish on Tuesday. The STI rose ... Read more »

Sembcorp Marine expects significant H2 loss with supply chain crunch

SINGAPORE (THE BUSINESS TIMES) – Sembcorp Marine (Sembmarine) expects to post “significant losses” in H2 ending Dec 31, 2021, potentially in the range of the S$647 million loss in the ... Read more »

Brussels kicks off debate on EU countries' budget rules: unity is hard to find

The fiscal rules, officially the Stability and Growth Pact (SGP), are mainly known for the limits on the national debt (maximum 60% of gross domestic product) and the budget deficit ... Read more »

Rallis India consolidated Q2 PAT down 32.53% at Rs 56 crore

Representative Image Rallis India, a Tata group company, on Tuesday reported a 32.53 per cent decline in consolidated profit after tax (after exceptional items) during the quarter ending September 30, ... Read more »

Wall Street start higher; J&J leads gains for health care sector

Source: Reuters Stocks are moving modestly higher on Wall Street in early trading Tuesday as corporate earnings reporting gets into full swing. The benchmark S&P 500 was up 0.3% in ... Read more »

Morgan Stanley says SpaceX's Starship may 'transform investor expectations' about space

Starship prototype 20 is stacked on top of Super Heavy Booster 4 on August 6, 2021.SpaceX Elon Musk's SpaceX has become one of the world's most valuable private companies, and ... Read more »

Gold prices climb above Rs 47,500/10 gm on positive global trend, weaker dollar

Gold prices soared above Rs 47,500 per 10 gram on October 19 tracking firm global trend and feeble dollar. The precious metal is trading above $1,780/oz levels breaching the intraday ... Read more »

Stock Blog: Higher Starts on Wall Street; AEX flirts with 800 points

Wall Street will start higher on Tuesday. Johnson & Johnson is in good shape, while Procter & Gabler has to give up ground. AEX is just below 800 points in ... Read more »

HUL's Q2 volume growth falls short of expectations, disappointing investors

Hindustan Unilever Ltd’s (HUL) September quarter results (Q2FY22) weren’t encouraging for investors, which is evident from the more than 3 percent drop in its share price on the National Stock ... Read more »

Alembic Pharma Q2 PAT may dip 49.2% YoY to Rs 169.4 cr: ICICI Direct

India business helped by COVID-19 and lower base of last year rose 57 percent to Rs 481 crore. ICICI Direct has come out with its second quarter (July-September’ 21) earnings ... Read more »

Axis AMC, Inversion to raise Rs 3,500 crore buyout fund to invest in underperforming companies

Representative image Axis Asset Management Company and Inversion Advisory Services on October 19 announced a partnership to invest in underperforming companies. The two entities plan to jointly raise up to Rs ... Read more »