Cash may not be the most effective way to motivate employees

Cash may not be the most effective way to motivate employees
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

Tangible rewards motivate employees when they’re easy to use, pleasurable, unexpected, and distinct from salary, a new study found.

A recent survey of firms in the United States revealed that 84 per cent spent more than $90 billion annually on tangible employee rewards, such as gift cards, recreation trips and merchandise in hopes of increasing productivity.

“We found that there is, at best, mixed evidence regarding the motivational efficacy of tangible rewards versus cash rewards,” said Adam Presslee, an associate professor at the University of Waterloo’s School of Accounting and Finance. “It is somewhat puzzling why so many companies go to the trouble of tangible rewards when cash rewards also lead to motivational differences.”

Presslee and his co-author, University of Wisconsin-Madison’s Willie Choi, used four experiments to investigate the factors driving the preference between cash and tangible rewards. The attributes examined include ease of use of the reward (fungibility), hedonic nature of the reward (want vs. need), the novelty of the reward, and how the reward is presented.

“Rewards are constellations of attributes, and firms should focus more on the motivational effects of the attributes associated with a reward rather than the reward type itself,” Presslee said. “Results confirmed that each of these attributes—individually and in combination—increases employee effort and performance.”

The researchers recommend managers interested in motivating employees using tangible rewards would be best served to offer tangible rewards that incorporate these four attributes.

“If for whatever reason tangible rewards are the only tool available, our results show compelling evidence that employees are motivated by rewards that are perceived as distinct from salary,” Presslee said. “Therefore, firms looking to get the most out of their reward programs should emphasize the distinctiveness of those rewards, and the attributes above are four ways firms can do that.”

The study, authored by Presslee and Choi, was recently published in the journal Accounting, Organizations, and Society. More information: Jongwoon (Willie) Choi et al, When and why tangible rewards can motivate greater effort than cash rewards: An analysis of four attribute differences, Accounting, Organizations and Society (2022). DOI: 10.1016/j.aos.2022.101389 Provided by University of Waterloo Citation: Cash may not be the most effective way to motivate employees (2022, August 15) retrieved 15 August 2022 from This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

News Related


3 Important Things to Think About When Starting a Business

Photo : DISRUPTIVO on Unsplash Deciding to start a business can be a very exciting chapter in your life, and it could be one of the absolute best moves you ... Read more »

The 'dense' potential of nanostructured superconductors

Scientists at SIT and University of Normandie developed bulk MgB2 with promising superconductivity. This picture shows unreacted magnesium oxide and boron in the matrix of MgB2, and the inset shows ... Read more »

Geneticists discover new wild goat subspecies via ancient DNA

Extended D calculation and application to Direkli4 specific allele sharing. (A) Extended D statistic. To control for gene flow with the Capra genus, we condition on variants derived in Direkli4 ... Read more »

Genomic research aids in the effort to understand how to treat deadly fungal infections

Screen for presence of the caspofungin paradoxical effect among mutant strains. Ten thousand conidia were inoculated into GMM containing 0, 0.125, or 4 μg/mL of caspofungin. The culture plates were incubated ... Read more »

Study: Farming community approves of crops and sustainable management practices chosen for diversifying European fields

Crop diversification in Italy. Credit: Diverfarming Agricultural intensification, characterized by the high use of external inputs such as energy and agrochemical products, negatively affects the environment, leading to soil degradation, ... Read more »

The battery that runs 630 km on a single charge

An electrode was manufactured by coating an ion conductive layer composed of polyethyleneimine polymer, silver, lithium salt, and carbon black on the surface of a copper current collector. The ion ... Read more »

Scientists discover why heroin is addictive

‘Greater impairment was correlated with earlier age of first drug use,’ study author adds Read more »

Apple wins discount in $1.1 billion French antitrust fine, but still wants more

In 2020, France’s antitrust watchdog fined Apple for “anti-competitive behavior towards its distribution and retail network.” Now, the Cupertino company has won a 2/3 cut in a 1.1 billion euro ... Read more »

Apple delays new external display with miniLED to early 2023

After introducing the Studio Display early this year, it seems Apple will wait a bit more to unveil a new 27-inch miniLED external display. DSCC analyst Ross Young says the ... Read more »

Apple wins 728-mn-euro cut to France antitrust fine

Apple plans to appeal the ruling to quash the entire 1.1-billion-euro fine. A French court on Thursday slashed more than 700 million euros from a record 1.1-billion-euro fine imposed on ... Read more »

Digital signal processing for high-capacity indoor optical wireless communication systems

Credit: Liuyan Chen With our increased use of smartphones and need for real-time video, future indoor networks are expected to provide seamless wireless coverage while at the same time supporting ... Read more »

Working towards less noise and better fuel efficiency during airport runway approach

Impact on people and the environment: Approach to runway 14 at Zurich Airport. Credit: Empa The approach to an airport runway is a real challenge for pilots: reducing speed, extending ... Read more »

Transition metal composite provides a cost-effective boost for lackluster zinc–air battery performance

Scientists from Beijing Institute of Technology, Tsinghua University and Harbin Normal University proposed a strategy of composing atomic transition metal sites to promote sluggish electrochemical reactions—oxygen evolution reaction (OER) and ... Read more »

Good planning gets the bike rolling: New approach to bicycle infrastructure planning

The route choice of cyclists is subject to various decision factors. For example, many prefer a separate bike lane (top left) instead of sharing space with dense car traffic (top ... Read more »

Body neutrality: What it is and how it can help lead to more positive body image

Body neutrality places an emphasis on what your body is capable of, not what it looks like. Credit: BearFotos/ Shutterstock Constantly “loving your body”—no matter what—can feel impossible at the ... Read more »

Boost Your Brain With Boredom

Summary: Boredom can stimulate creativity and improve problem-solving, all while giving the brain a much-needed rest. Source: Mayo Clinic “Mom, Dad, I’m bored.” How many parents have heard this from ... Read more »

Infinix Sets World Record With Zero Ultra

For some time now, Infinix has been well known as a manufacturer of entry level and midrange smartphones. They barely come out with any flagship level devices due to their ... Read more »

Laser engraver LONGER RAY5 10W can engrave more than 1000+ materials

We probably don’t need to introduce the LONGER brand to our readers, especially the laser engraving fans. The company managed to garner quite some solid reputation in their fairly short ... Read more »

Migraine linked to increased risk of dementia, study suggests

Scientists say further studies are needed to generalise findings and to uncover underlying mechanisms Read more »

Tiger Global targets $6 Billion for new venture capital fund

ETtechTiger Global Management is seeking $6 billion for its next venture fund, even after writing down the value of its private portfolio and as institutional investors pull back from the ... Read more »

Modern pesticide accelerates corrosion of ancient Roman bowl – study

The study highlights that soil polluted with chlorobenzenes may pose a continuing threat to the preservation of archaeological material. Read more »

Why Business Connectivity Is More Important than Ever

Business connectivity methods have had to adapt and re-evolve in today’s ever evolving digital climate. Following the arrival of COVID-19 in 2020, it is now more important than ever for ... Read more »

“Something Strange Is Going On” – Physicists Answer a Decades-Old Question

Physicists have answered a longstanding question concerning interacting quantum particles in a disordered system. A Different Type of Chaos Physicists from the University of California, Santa Barbara, the University of Maryland, ... Read more »

Shrine discovered in Egyptian temple with evidence of previously unknown rituals

Stele of the Falcon God and the Head; scale = 30 cm (K. Braulińska; drawing by O.E. Kaper). Credit: American Journal of Archaeology (2022). DOI: 10.1086/720806 The Sikait Project research ... Read more »

A big step toward treating tuberculosis without risking antibiotic resistance

The mechanism of selectivity of evybactin. Evybactin (EVY) is transported into the bacterial cell by BacA (M. tuberculosis) and SbmA (E. coli) transporters. However, in E. coli, evybactin is removed ... Read more »

Migration as morality politics

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain Migration often serves as an arena for conflicting values. In this context, religious groups, civil society organizations and local authorities often show a more liberal attitude ... Read more »

Land use matters as communities cut carbon emissions

This data visualization compares the land required for different kinds of power generation. Nuclear power, with its extremely energy-dense fuel, is the smallest by far. Credit: Good Energy Collective With ... Read more »

How we tracked one small seabird species' remarkable flight into a typhoon

Fluttering Shearwater. Credit: Francesco Veronesi from Italy/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA In 2018, 49,000 people in Japan were ordered to evacuate their homes as the strongest typhoon in 25 years, Typhoon ... Read more »

Martha Stewart Is Selling a Severed Hand Candle, Naturally

Don’t let the polished country-club persona fool you: Martha Stewart has always marched to the beat of her own drum. Need proof? The cooking and hosting mogul just launched a ... Read more »

Two winners of 2022 Nobel Prize in Chemistry share MIT roots

K. Barry Sharpless is a former member of the chemistry faculty, while Carolyn Bertozzi is the daughter of Physics Professor Emertius William Bertozzi and a Lemelson-MIT Prize winner. Read more »

Never Get Lost Again With Apple Watch's Backtrack Feature

If you ever get lost, you can use the redesigned Backtrack feature of the Compass app on the Apple Watch Ultra, Apple Watch SE, and Apple Watch Series 6, and ... Read more »

Apple Deals Weekly: Catch this iPad Mini 6 for $99 Off on Amazon

Today could be your lucky day if you have been saving for a new iPad for work or school. According to MacRumors, Amazon has reduced the price of the 64GB Wi-Fi ... Read more »

Expand Your Brand Seamlessly with Kadanza

Photo : Megan Rexazin from Pixabay With the internet’s large availability, startups from around the world now have a chance to showcase their products and flourish their business. However, this ... Read more »

Every new device Google announced at its Pixel 7 launch event

The latest Made by Google launch event took place on Thursday morning, and as expected, the Pixel 7 was the star of the show. But that wasn’t the only device ... Read more »

Twitter is finally rolling out the Edit Tweet feature we all want

Last month, Twitter announced the ability to edit tweets. At that time, the company only showed what it would look like. Then, by the end of September, the company published ... Read more »

Werewolf by Night review: Exploring darker corners of the MCU

Phase 4 has been a period of transition for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Iron Man is dead, the Avengers are in stasis, and new Disney Plus shows are launching as ... Read more »

NASA Astronaut Says They’re Living Albert Einstein’s Happiest Thought to Space

Astronauts on the Crew-5 mission of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and Space Exploration Technologies Corporation (SpaceX) paid tribute to the eminent theoretical scientist Albert Einstein on their ... Read more »

Google Officially Announces Pixel 7, Pixel 7 Pro, and Pixel Watch

This site may earn affiliate commissions from the links on this page. Terms of use. Google has finally unveiled its latest hardware products, including the Pixel 7, Pixel 7 Pro, ... Read more »

Windows 11 22H2 breaks provisioning with 0x800700b7 errors

Microsoft says the Windows 11 2022 Update is breaking provisioning, leaving Windows 11 enterprise endpoints partially configured and failing to finish installing. According to Microsoft, this known issue most likely ... Read more »

'Bio-batteries' enable us to store solar and wind energy

This is what happens to the molecules of a PCM material that is used in a heat storage system. Credit: Doghouse/Knut Gangåssæther Up until now it has been a challenge ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network