Carbon emitters 'failing to disclose climate risks'

Pollution from coal power station

A lack of detail in financial reporting will dramatically reduce firms' chances of meeting global emissions targets, researchers have warned.

There is no way of knowing if money is being put into sustainable activities, Carbon Tracker said.

Firms also need to be more transparent as to how they will hit sustainability targets, the think tank said.

But the International Energy Agency said firms should not have to focus on “ticking boxes for activists”.

Climate risk

In a study of 107 global businesses working in carbon-intensive sectors, researchers said there is a “glaring absence of climate risks in financial reporting”.

More than 70% of the companies studied fail to include their climate impact in their financial statements.

Plans for net zero targets and limiting climate risks were also omitted.

Eight out of 10 audits of these firms also showed no evidence of assessing climate risk.

Researchers assessed the 202 financial statements of 107 listed companies, from oil and gas firms to construction, car manufacturers and aviation businesses.

    The study, conducted by the independent charity group-funded Carbon Tracker and the Climate Accounting Project (CAP), said the lack of detail in their financial reporting will dramatically reduce the chances of meeting global emissions targets.

    “The fact that we don't have transparency means we have no idea if capital is being allocated to sustainable activities so we can actually transition to a greener future,” Barbara Davidson, analyst at Carbon Tracker and lead author of the report, told the BBC.

    Researchers also found that none of the accounts reflected aims set by the Paris Agreement – an international treaty on climate change which aims to limit global warming to no more than 1.5 degrees Celsius.

    The 2020 fire season ended as the most destructive season on record.

    “Lacking this information means we don't know if funds are being allocated to unsustainable businesses, which further reduces our chances to decarbonise in the short time remaining to achieve our Paris goals,” Ms Davidson added.

    The report identified inconsistencies across company reporting with firms announcing emission targets and climate strategies, but not indicating how these targets will effect their financial statements.

    “There's a level of disclosure that needs to be provided so we know how they are going to achieve these targets.

    “It's very important for companies to set these goals but without understanding the risks it's hard to know if they're greenwashing – so investors need to take the statements with a pinch of salt.”

    'Knock-on loss for ordinary pensioners'

    Ms Davidson said that the worst case scenario is that these companies will “go under because they can't continue to invest in polluting activities” and because pension funds have invested in these companies, that “will mean a knock-on loss for ordinary pensioners”.

    However, Andy Mayer, chief operating officer at the International Energy Agency (IEA) told the BBC he is “not surprised at all that this is information is being left out”.

    “UK companies are not required to report their perception of climate risks in their annual reports,” he said.

    “If investors genuinely want more climate risk information in reports they will disinvest and punish companies not providing it.”

    “Serious climate action involves taking risks and investing in new technologies, then seeing what the market will bear. Big companies, with their vast R&D budgets need to focus on that, not ticking boxes for activists,” he added.

    'Investors not given the data needed'

    Tracey Cameron, senior manager from the Corporate Climate Engagement at Ceres – a US organisation that works closely with investors – said: “Investors grappling with quantifying portfolio risks aren't given the data needed to make informed decisions.

    “In many cases, that data exists but it lives behind a locked door, and only companies and auditors have the key.”

    Auditors PwC, KPMG and EY did not immediately respond to the BBC's request for comment.

    A spokesperson from Deloitte said that under current accounting and auditing standards, companies and auditors are not required to issue the “kinds of information and opinions the PRI report calls for, and there may be cases where issuing such opinions would not be permissible under current rules and standards”.

    In 2019 and 2020 global accounting and auditing standard-setters said that climate-related risks should not be ignored in accounts, or audits.

    The International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) said: “If climate change impacts the entity, the auditor needs to consider whether the financial statements appropriately reflect this.”

    Internet Explorer Channel Network
    News Related


    Vikings were in America in 1021, well before Columbus, researchers say

    Vikings from Greenland — the first Europeans to arrive in the Americas — lived in a village in Canada’s Newfoundland exactly 1,000 years ago, according to research published Wednesday. Scientists ... Read more »

    Coronavirus press conference live: Government updates UK on COVID-19 pandemic

    Please wait a moment for the livestream to load Boris Johnson or one of his senior ministers are holding press conferences to update the public on the fight against the ... Read more »

    Yahoo news app, one of the last sources of Western news in China, is removed from Apple store amid censorship drive

    Yahoo news app, one of the last sources of Western news in China, is removed from Apple store amid censorship drive – JUSTIN LANE /EPA Chinese internet users have lost ... Read more »

    UK's Covid cases spike by another 15% in a week to brink of 50,000

    © Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Daily coronavirus cases have nearly hit 50,000 for the second time this week amid growing fears about the situation heading into winter, figures ... Read more »

    The term 'Anthropocene' isn't perfect - but it shows us the scale of the environmental crisis we've caused

    Humans are shaping the environment and geology of the planet for the first time in history. Xtrodinary/Pixabay Earlier this year, scientists identified early warning signs of the collapse of the ... Read more »

    Wills and Kate just shared a rare PDA pic and we're in love with them

    Photo credit: Max Mumby/Indigo – Getty Images With their busy schedules and all that royal protocol, it's not everyday that Prince William and Kate Middleton get to indulge in a ... Read more »

    Adele and Boyfriend Rich Paul Are All Smiles on Date Night at NBA Season Opener

    Adele and boyfriend Rich Paul were all smiles for date night. On Tuesday, the 33-year-old singer and the 39-year-old sports agent were spotted sitting courtside together at the Staples Center ... Read more »

    John Cleese under fire for joke about offensive Liverpool stereotype

    John Cleese made a joke about the sterotype of Liverpudlians being theives. (Getty Images) John Cleese has caused offence to the people of Liverpool by making a joke about the ... Read more »

    Tinie Tempah turns property guru for 'Extraordinary Extensions' - 9 other unusual celebrity career pivots

    Victoria Beckham, Tinie Tempah and Vinnie Jones all carved out successful second careers. (Getty/Channel 4/Getty) Property shows are not exactly unusual on Channel 4, but the newest version has a ... Read more »

    Egypt detains artist robot Ai-Da before historic pyramid show

    Photograph: David Parry/PA She’s been described as “a vision of the future” who is every bit as good as other abstract artists today, but Ai-Da – the world’s first ultra-realistic ... Read more »

    Vikings discovered America 500 years before Christopher Columbus, study claims

    A recreation of a sod-roofed Viking dwelling at L’Anse aux Meadows. Top right: Microscope image of a wood fragment from the Norse layers (Petra Doeve/SWNS/Alamy) The year 1021 AD is ... Read more »

    How many people have had a booster jab in England?

    The government has urged people to come forward for their COVID booster jabs. (PA) People are being urged to come forward for their COVID booster jabs as soon as they ... Read more »

    Kate Middleton and Prince William Backstage! Exclusive Photos of Candid Moments at the Earthshot Awards

    <img alt="<pJackson captured this intimate moment of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge hand in hand as they departed 1/19Kate Middleton and Prince William Backstage! Exclusive Photos of Candid Moments ... Read more »

    GPs complain they have no 'capacity' to accelerate booster drive

    © Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo GPs today complained they were too overworked to play a major role in accelerating the sluggish Covid booster drive as data showed only ... Read more »

    Governments set to increase fossil fuel production despite warnings

    Limiting global warming to 1.5°C is vital to reducing the risk of catastrophic natural disasters and weather events. Global leaders have spent months committing to make this happen, but on ... Read more »

    Social Mobility chief wants to see national campaign against phones for toddlers

    The newly-appointed head of the Government’s Social Mobility Commission has said she would like to introduce a national campaign urging parents against giving their toddlers mobile phones. Katharine Birbalsingh told ... Read more »

    Nadine Coyle claims she's had supernatural signs from late Sarah Harding

    Sarah Harding (left) and Nadine Coyle pictured together in their Girls Aloud days (PA) Girls Aloud singer Nadine Coyle has said she has received supernatural signs from her late bandmate ... Read more »

    Rylan 'broke down' at work after divorce - should we all get compassionate leave for break-ups?

    Watch: Rylan Clarke-Neal sparks marriage reconciliation rumours When a close family member or partner dies, it's acknowledged to be life changing. The bereaved are routinely offered time off work to ... Read more »

    Scientists find planet that had its atmosphere torn off in collision

    (Independent) Scientists have found a planet that appears to have had its atmosphere tornoff in a collision. The world is just 95 light years from Earth. It orbits around a ... Read more »

    Mom in UK drives her SUV into climate protesters blocking road

    The Insulate Britain protesters wants UK government to better insulate homes. Insulate Britain/Twitter A tense video has emerged appearing to show a British woman driving into a pair of climate protesters after ... Read more »

    China test fires 500-ton solid-fuel rocket engine

    File: Visitors view replica space launch rockets including the first generation rockets for manned launch produced by China Aerospace Science and Technology Corporation at an exhibition on 29 September in ... Read more »

    Amazon's big Samsung sale includes phones, earbuds, Chromebooks... and one deal you absolutely shouldn't miss

    We may receive commission from purchases made via links on this page. Pricing and availability are subject to change. You can sneaky save an extra 15% on the Galaxy Book ... Read more »

    Climate change, not humans, caused extinction of woolly mammoths – study

    After five million years roaming the Earth, woolly mammoths vanished from the planet nearly 4,000 years ago, and scientists say they have finally proved why. The cousins of today’s elephants ... Read more »

    In tree rings and radioactive carbon, signs of the Vikings in North America

    Wood at a settlement in Canada's Newfoundland that was cut with metal tools helped researchers pinpoint when the Norse first reached the continent — well before Columbus. Read more »

    How diet affects tumors

    A new study finds cutting off cells’ supplies of lipids can slow the growth of tumors in mice. Read more »

    Astronomers detect signs of an atmosphere stripped from a planet during giant impact

    Such planetary smashups are likely common in young solar systems, but they haven’t been directly observed. Read more »

    Pablo Escobar's 'cocaine hippos' are being sterilized because the population is out of control

    Wildlife officials in Colombia have begun sterilizing the so-called cocaine hippos that once belonged to the notorious drug lord Pablo Escobar. This measure will ensure that the hippo population doesn’t ... Read more »

    'Incredible performance for this price': This affordable smartphone is just $229 on Amazon

    Looking for more of the best deals, sales and product recommendations? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! Save 15% on the affordable UMIDIGI A9 Pro Unlocked Cell Phone. Images ... Read more »

    Alphabet's Wing is bringing its drone delivery service to Dallas-Fort Worth

    Drones will soon be buzzing overhead in Dallas-Fort Worth, bearing small containers filled with Tylenol and Band-Aids. Wing, a subsidiary of Google parent company Alphabet, is bringing its drone delivery ... Read more »

    Mother arrested over disappearance of 5-year old thought to have been missing for 6 months

    Missing boy Elijah Lewis (New Hampshire Department of Justice) The mother of a missing 5-year-old has been arrested along with a man and accused of covering up the boy’s disappearance. ... Read more »

    The Uselessness of Useful Knowledge

    Today’s powerful but little-understood artificial intelligence breakthroughs echo past examples of unexpected scientific progress. Read more »

    18,000 mobile SIMs sending scam texts blocked by EE since July

    Mobile network EE has blocked 18,000 SIM cards caught sending some 42 million scam text messages since July. Providers have been battling a wave of bogus SMS communications during the ... Read more »

    Heat and buildings strategy: the good, bad and ugly of the UK's plan to replace gas boilers

    chrisatpps/shutterstock The UK government has published its Heat and Buildings Strategy, a plan to replace fossil-fuelled heating like gas boilers with low-carbon technologies such as heat pumps. First the good ... Read more »

    Six popular beliefs about treating colds: our experts explain the facts

    Sticking garlic up your nose will not help you recover from a cold. Fizkes/Shutterstock As we start mixing again after lockdown, colds are starting to become all too common. A ... Read more »

    The left behind. Climate Fight podcast part 3 transcript

    This is a transcript of The left behind, part three of Climate Fight: the world’s biggest negotiation, a series from The Anthill podcast. In this episode, we talk to experts ... Read more »

    Environmental intelligence: using AI and data science to save the planet

    Our interaction with the natural environment plays a crucial role in all aspects of society: our health, wealth, safety and future prosperity. Climate breakdown and the transition to a net ... Read more »

    As Gwyneth goes TMI, here's how to talk to teens about sex

    Most teenagers are horrified at the very idea of discussing sexual matters with their parents. Equally, some parents are too embarrassed to bring it up, instead leaving informative books on ... Read more »

    Pakistani-American 'raped, beheaded' former ambassador's daughter

    1 / 2Pakistani-American ‘raped, beheaded’ former ambassador’s daughterPolicemen escort Zahir Jaffer, a Pakistani-American man who went on trial accused of raping and beheading his girlfriend, the daughter of a former ... Read more »

    Tilly Ramsay: Strictly star calls out LBC radio host Steve Allen for calling her a ‘chubby little thing' on air

    Tilly Ramsay has condemned LBC radio host Steve Allen for calling her “chubby” live on air. The Strictly Come Dancing star, 19, who is the daughter of chef Gordon Ramsay, ... Read more »

    COVID: new antibody treatment could offer up to 18 months' protection against severe disease

    Antibodies (light blue) binding to the spike proteins (dark purple) on the outside of the coronavirus. Design_Cells/Shutterstock A new treatment could soon help protect people from developing severe COVID. AstraZeneca ... Read more »