Carbon capture and storage: where should the world store CO₂? It's a moral dilemma

Asia's Tech News Daily

The recent Glasgow climate pact committed 197 countries to “phas[ing] down unabated coal”. Unabated coal refers to when power stations or factories burn coal without capturing and storing the carbon dioxide (CO₂) generated.

Because the world has made such little progress in eliminating coal, oil and fossil gas, climate modellers foresee some use of carbon capture and storage as necessary to reach zero emissions in enough time to avert catastrophic warming. The technology to capture carbon is in development, but one burning question remains: where on Earth should we store all that carbon?

Different methods of carbon capture will take place at different sites. Some involve absorbing emissions immediately after burning fossil fuels in chimneys and smokestacks where the CO₂ is highly concentrated. Other methods capture carbon directly from the air, either by using chemical reactions that bind the carbon using lots of energy or by growing carbon-hungry plants which can be burned for energy and the resulting emissions subsequently captured.

In new research, myself and environmental engineer Joe Lane at Princeton University in the US argued that, regardless of the method, leaving decisions about where to store carbon to commercial entities would mean avoiding an important moral dilemma.

Read more: We can't let markets decide the future of removing carbon from the atmosphere

Funding for carbon capture and storage is insufficient. At the current rate of deployment, 700 million tonnes of CO₂ storage capacity will be added by 2050 – 10% of what is required.

Countries would have to massively ramp up investment to be compliant with the Paris aqgreement’s target of limiting global warming to 1.5°C. Some of this money would be public funding, and people would reasonably expect it to fund projects which are morally sound.

On the one hand, it might be deemed important to develop storage sites with the best prospects for storing lots of greenhouse gas for the longest duration. This argument maintains that the most important consideration for deploying carbon capture and storage is making the largest possible contribution to arresting climate change.

To give carbon storage sites the greatest chance of success, it makes sense to develop them in places where the geology has been thoroughly explored and where there is lots of relevant expertise. This would imply pumping carbon into underground storage sites in northern Europe, the Middle East and the US, where companies have spent centuries looking for and extracting fossil fuels. Storing carbon is roughly the reverse of extracting it from the ground, and there is an opportunity for workers in the oil and gas industry to lend their skills and expertise to this endeavour.

Some US companies have been extracting oil for well over a century. Alizada Studios/Shutterstock

On the other hand, it might be important to develop storage sites in economies where the current and future demand for carbon capture and storage is greatest. These competing aims pull in different directions. The regions with the best prospects are not often those with the greatest expected need.

Developing storage sites in economies where expected demand for carbon capture is highest overwhelmingly favours developing regions of Asia. In India and China, for instance, coal power stations and cement plants are expensive to decommission and will need lots of carbon capture and storage capacity to decarbonise. If developing regions are expected to decarbonise without sufficient support to roll out carbon capture and storage, it could mean they have to throttle development to reduce emissions.

There are no easy answers in this debate. Increasing carbon capture and storage capacity as quickly as possible could benefit future generations by reducing the severity of climate change. So, you could argue that developing the most promising sites in Europe is the best way forward. But directing investment for storage facilities from wealthy countries to developing regions could help address the debt the former owes the latter for causing the brunt of the climate crisis.

World leaders should recognise this moral dilemma and consider the choices with urgency. The need to remove and safely store carbon becomes more severe by the day. Given the time and costs involved in developing storage sites, and the real possibility that the storage sites may not be sufficient for the carbon countries emit, this is a question which cannot be delayed.

Imagine weekly climate newsletter

Don’t have time to read about climate change as much as you’d like?
Get a weekly roundup in your inbox instead. Every Wednesday, The Conversation’s environment editor writes Imagine, a short email that goes a little deeper into just one climate issue. Join the 10,000+ readers who’ve subscribed so far.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Kian Mintz-Woo is a guest researcher at the Equity and Justice group at the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Type 1 diabetes: Artificial pancreas 'life-changing' for very young children, experts say

According to a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, the app-based system requires less input from parents and is more effective at managing blood sugar levels than current technology. Read more »

5G signals disrupt flights in the US

Flights in the US have been disrupted due to 5G signals impacting systems on board aircrafts. Read more »

January Jones stuns in knitted hat and nothing else in risqué new photo

January Jones stunned fans when she shared her most risqué photo yet on Thursday. READ: January Jones stuns in nude corset in poolside photo – but fans are divided The ... Read more »

US plans new effort to retain international engineering, science students

President Joe Biden has said he regards competition with China as the country's top national security challenge. The Biden administration plans to unveil new steps on Friday to retain international ... Read more »

Elon Musk calls Twitter's NFT profile pics 'annoying'

Soon after microblogging platform Twitter‘s subscription service Twitter Blue rolled out a new feature allowing users to show off their non-fungible token (NFT) on their profile picture, Tesla and SpaceX ... Read more »

World's first space-based movie and entertainment studio set to launch in 2024 - allowing actors and content creators to film above Earth

Sporting events, TV shows, films and influencer live streams are expected to be possible from the studio, which will orbit 250 miles above Earth. Read more »

Tinder charges more for young gays, lesbians and over-30s, claims Which?

Tinder tells Which? it was "categorically untrue that our pricing structure discriminates in any way by sexual preference". Read more »

PlayStation maker Sony in shares slump after Microsoft's Activision Blizzard swoop

The planned takeover of the Call of Duty developer by Xbox firm Microsoft represents a new challenge for the Japanese conglomerate in the battle for the console market. Read more »

Seeing into the future: Personalized cancer screening with artificial intelligence

Scientists demonstrate that AI-risk models, paired with AI-designed screening policies, can offer significant and equitable improvements to cancer screening. Read more »

Peloton shares fall 20% on report of temporary production halt

The company has seen its market value plummet sharply over the past year as people have returned to gyms and Peloton has faced greater competition for its connected exercise equipment. Read more »

'Bionic' gran is first in UK to use 'revolutionary' microchip that could help her see properly again

The octogenarian from Dagenham hopes the implant will allow her to do the things she loved again - like painting and gardening. Read more »

Where to buy the new PS5 console covers: release date, price and pre-order info

Sony finally announced official PS5 covers at the end of last year, giving you the opportunity to customise the color of your console’s faceplate. In a post on the official ... Read more »

Designers Have the Power to Shape the Metaverse. Here's How.

The world we live in is quickly changing. Technologies become an integral part of our environment, and boundaries between real and virtual worlds are blurred. Companies like Meta understand the ... Read more »

5 weird things people have transformed into crypto miners

When can something bad also be used for good? The answer is crypto mining!   Traditional crypto mining is notoriously resource-intensive with equivalent to that of countries like Argentina and ... Read more »

GM's betting its hydrogen fuel cells will revolutionize electric generators

While some automakers have bet on hydrogen to power up their transition to renewable energy, GM is following another approach: it’s going and it’s using its HYDROTEC fuel cell technology ... Read more »

Nuclear quantum computing: It's coming

A trio of separate research teams from three different continents published individual papers indicating similar quantum computing breakthroughs yesterday. All three were funded in part by the US Army and ... Read more »

Safari bug is leaking users' browsing history — but a fix is on the way (Updated)

(Update January 21, 2022, 10:15PM IST): Apple has released to fix the WebKit bug leaking your browsing history. This update will be rolled out to users soon after beta testing ... Read more »

A love letter to my lord and savior, the LaCie portable SSD

Love is unpredictable. You never know how it’s going to strike, so when it does, it’s often in the moments you least expect — and that’s precisely what happened when ... Read more »

Britishvolt gigafactory given £100m in taxpayer funding to help power electric car future

The battery factory is being built as the UK races to catch EU rivals in the battle to secure enough batteries ahead of the 2030 ban on the sale of new cars powered by petrol and diesel. Read more »

iPhone SE+ 5G to release in late April or early May, says analyst

(Image: iPhone SE 2020 model) Analyst Ross Young claims that Apple is going to release the rumoured third-generation iPhone SE in late April or early May. Apple 5G SE model ... Read more »

New Kakao CEO faces daunting tasks

Company has long way to go to restore public trust and investor confidence By Baek Byung-yeul NamKoong Whon, Kakao’s new CEO. Courtesy of Kakao Namkoong Whon, the newly appointed chief ... Read more »

Samsung hints at Note in new Galaxy S series

Roh Tae-moon, president and head of MX Business at Samsung Electronics / Courtesy of Samsung Electronics By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics’ Galaxy Note series, which skipped release in 2021, is ... Read more »

MS-Blizzard deal prompts Korean game firms to seek more metaverse M&As

By Baek Byung-yeul Nexon, NCSOFT, Netmarble and other Korean game companies are expected to seek more mergers and acquisitions (M&As) in metaverse- and non-fungible token (NFT)-related businesses, sparked by Microsoft’s ... Read more »

Storytelling baristas appointed as Starbucks ambassadors

2022 Starbucks Korea ambassadors Yang Jung-eun, left, and Seo U-ram hold cups of coffee at a Starbucks coffee shop in Seoul, on Tuesday. Courtesy of Starbucks Korea By Kim Jae-heun ... Read more »

Breonna Taylor's memory is being preserved in an augmented reality app

“People grieve in their way, and everyone needs a sacred space,” Taylor's sister, Ju’Niyah Palmer, said. Read more »

Chinese Olympic app has serious security flaws, report finds

The IOC issued a statement Tuesday saying the smartphone app was not compulsory and that cybersecurity testing organizations found no critical vulnerabilities with the app. Read more »

Gallery: new Nikon 400mm super-telephoto could be king of wildlife photography jungle

The camera phone wars may still be fierce, but an equally ferocious battle is brewing at the other end of the photographic spectrum – with the new Nikon Z 400mm ... Read more »

Leeds vs Newcastle live stream: how to watch Premier League online

There’s no rest for the wicked, as 19th-placed Newcastle, winless in seven weeks, now face a daunting trip to Elland Road to face one of the hardest-working teams in the ... Read more »

2FA compromise led to hack

More details have emerged about the recent hack that left almost 500 customers without their hard-earned cryptocurrencies. The company has published a post mortem on its website in which ... Read more »

Hong Kong-listed firm behind Yumy dating app is going to town with the metaverse

Newborn Town, a little-known mainland Chinese company focused on social apps for markets outside China, wants to help people hook up in the metaverse. After launching beta testing last November, ... Read more »

Apple patches Safari bug that leaked user data

Apple has pushed iOS 15.3 RC and macOS Monterey 12.2 RC to developers and beta users as part of a plan to fix a Safari flaw that leaked browsing history ... Read more »

Manchester United vs West Ham live stream: how to watch Premier League online from anywhere

West Ham travel to Old Trafford for the second time this season on Saturday afternoon as they look to get their push for a top four finish back on track. ... Read more »

40 amazing Valentine's Day gifts for him

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re shopping for Valentine’s Day gifts for him, you know ... Read more »

The holy grail of spaceflight: Aerospace firm reveals plans to build a spaceplane that can take off and land from a runway - and can be reflown within 48 HOURS

The spaceplane could cost well over $1 billion to develop, although the exact budget hasn't been revealedInvestors in the firm, Radian Aerospace, suggest it could trigger an orbital launch industry worth $200 billionThe concept is for a winged spaceplane that can take off from a runway, fly to orbit and land on a runwayIt would be fully reusable and able to operate in orbit for up to five days, including travelling to space stationsThe firm says it is in discussion with governments and a number of private space station developers  Read more »

F1 news: Kimi Raikkonen happy to be out of Formula 1 ‘bulls**t'

Raikkonen retired at the end of the last F1 season (Getty Images) Recently retired Formula 1 driver Kimi Raikkonen says he is happy to be out of the sport because ... Read more »

Ubuntu has a pretty serious security flaw, so patch now

Cybersecurity researchers have discovered a major flaw in one of Linux’s most popular distros – Ubuntu, and are urging all users to patch immediately. As reported on Ubuntu’s website, two ... Read more »

Xbox boss says Facebook and Amazon are its main gaming competitors

Head of Xbox Phil Spencer has said huge tech companies like Facebook, Amazon, and Google are the brand’s main competitors in the gaming industry, as opposed to its traditional rivals. ... Read more »

The N64's best Zelda game is finally coming to Nintendo Switch Online

The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask is finally coming to the Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack subscription tier, as part of its collection of N64 games. The classic Zelda title ... Read more »

Call of Duty developers considering moving away from yearly releases, says report

A new report has been published claiming that, in the wake of Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard, developers on Call of Duty are mulling over the possibility of slowing down ... Read more »

Climate change denial on Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and TikTok is ‘as bad as ever'

The climate is changing, but misinformation about it on the major social media platforms is not. Climate change falsehoods, hoaxes and conspiracy theories are still prevalent on Twitter, Facebook, TikTok ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic