'Can't Compete': Why Hiring for Child Care Is a Huge Struggle

‘Can’t Compete’: Why Hiring for Child Care Is a Huge Struggle

At a YMCA in San Antonio, 200 children are on wait lists for child care because of hiring problems. It raised average hourly pay for full-time workers to $12.50 from $10, but still can’t recruit enough teachers to meet the demand.

In Ann Arbor, Michigan, the school district had announced it was shutting down its after-school program. It managed to hire people to open at five of 20 elementary schools, those most in need, but that left out at least 1,000 children.

And in Portland, Oregon, preschool spots are few and far between, and elementary schools are running after-school care at limited capacity or have canceled programs altogether.

Schools have largely reopened this fall, but life is far from normal for parents of young children. One reason is that child care — for children too young for school, and for the hours before and after school — is operating at 88% of its prepandemic capacity. Even before the pandemic, child care did not cover everyone who needed it.

The shortage is partly because of the pandemic. Some centers went out of business after lockdowns early on. Because children under 12 are not yet eligible for vaccines, many programs are enrolling fewer children to limit potential exposure. But the biggest reason for the shortages, child care providers across the country said, is they can’t find people to hire.

Eight in 10 providers said they were experiencing a staffing problem, and half said hiring was harder than it had been before the pandemic, according to a survey over the summer of 7,500 of them by the National Association for the Education of Young Children. Half said they were serving fewer children as a result of hiring problems, and a quarter had reduced their hours. The lack of child care is also contributing to other labor shortages, because many parents who can’t find reliable child care can’t return to work.

“The only thing we haven’t done is sandwich boards and standing on the corner with a spinning sign, but I’m not eliminating that yet,” said Claire Miller, the director of children and youth services for Decatur, Georgia, which has raised wages by $2, asked parents for referrals and offered college students internship credits.

The city is offering 600 slots for children, down from 800. Miller said it was “an awful feeling, certainly, because we promised parents we had them covered.”

Child care providers face challenges like those in many other service industries that are unable to find enough workers — low pay and little job stability. The median hourly pay is $12, and 98% of occupations pay more, according to data from the Center for the Study of Child Care Employment at the University of California, Berkeley. Turnover is high in early childhood education, and jobs caring for school-aged children are only a few hours a day and often end in the summer.

Child care has additional challenges. Some people are hesitant to work with unvaccinated children. The job requires more qualifications, including background checks, certifications and even college degrees in some areas, than the stores and restaurants that are paying more.

Yet child care centers have not responded the way some other industries have — by significantly raising wages and expanding benefits. That’s because of a math problem with the business model.

In the United States, child care for children younger than 5 and before and after school is mostly financed by private tuition. Yet more than 60% of families are already paying more than they can afford, according to a report published Wednesday by the Treasury Department. (The Department of Health and Human Services considers child care affordable if it costs families no more than 7% of their income.)

Also, the cost of child care increased by half during the pandemic because of new health regulations, including additional staff to keep small groups of children in stable cohorts. States limit the number of children per teacher, so providers can’t bring in more tuition without hiring more workers.

“The free market works well in many different sectors, but child care is not one of them,” Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said Wednesday, speaking about the Biden administration’s spending proposals for education and child care.

“Those who provide child care aren’t paid well, and many who need it can’t afford it,” she said. The Biden plan would make preschool free starting at age 3, subsidize child care before then and raise the minimum wage for child care workers to $15 an hour.

In the national survey of 7,500 providers, 78% said low wages were their main recruitment challenge. Heather Mossefin, the owner of Heather’s Family Home Child Care in Clyde, Ohio, raised wages to $9 an hour, then $9.25, 45 cents above minimum wage.

“I can’t compete with sign-on bonuses and paying $20 an hour at the amusement park,” said Mossefin, who provides care for children from infancy through age 12. “Even fast-food places are hiring at $12 to $15 an hour here. I can’t because I can’t raise prices on my parents because we are all hurting.”

Last week, she lost an employee to an automotive factory. She has decreased the number of children she cares for by one-third, to 12, and says she’s working much more than full-time herself.

She took home $18,000 last year after paying her bills and employees’ wages. This year — with lower attendance, an additional $4,500 spent on cleaning supplies and the $1,000 she spent on Indeed trying to hire — she expects to earn $14,000. Full-time tuition for a toddler is $756 a month, and she recently raised it about $4 a week. But she knows her clients, who mostly work at the local Whirlpool plant or fast-food restaurants, can’t pay more than that.

“I get it, I was a single mom,” she said. “It’s just something that my town needed.”

The pandemic threatened to break an already fragile child care system. Centers that managed to reopen after lockdowns struggled at first with low enrollment — many parents weren’t comfortable sending children back. Workers have not always received masks and other protective gear, health care or hazard pay.

“You have a situation where workers were already struggling, and then they’re placed under just immense pressure to work, with not only a lack of resources but a lack of concern and respect people have for child care workers’ well-being,” said Lea J.E. Austin, executive director of the Center for the Study of Child Care Employment at the University of California, Berkeley.

Now that parents want to return to child care, they can’t find it, leaving some without full-time coverage for the third school year in a row.

When the Ann Arbor schools canceled after-school care over the summer, Alicia R. Ventresca Miller, an assistant professor of anthropology at Michigan, panicked. She had already delayed her tenure application a year when schools first closed, and was counting on having time to write a book this year. Her partner, a lecturer, had scheduled afternoon classes.

“I recognize I’m in a position of privilege and I have a schedule that could be forgiving, but I need this,” she said.

She found a few short-term after-school classes for their 6-year-old son, but most days she or her partner picks him up at 3:15 p.m. After that, the workday is over — he needs to be bathed, fed and supervised.

Child care providers say that when it comes to working with children, hiring standards can’t be lowered. So for some, the crisis is compelling them to improve child care jobs, at least temporarily — many have used the industry’s federal pandemic relief funds to do so.

“I do not want to just have a warm body in front of a child who needs that time and attention,” said Tony D’Agostino, who owns Inspire! Crayon Campus in the Rochester, New York, area. He raised the starting wage to $13.50 and added paid time off, health insurance and training for teachers to advance.

Still, he has 15 jobs open across three preschools.

© 2021 The New York Times Company

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


'I bought the same items from different supermarkets - there is a difference'

A shopper has conducted an investigation into supermarkets to find out once and for all which is the best value for money, and the results are quite surprising. Emma Gill, ... Read more »

Here's How My Unmanageable IBS as a Teen Led to My First Colonoscopy as an Adult

A team of doctors performs colonoscopy, diagnostics of the intestine. Bowel health. Medical concept with tiny people. Flat vector illustration. The word “colonoscopy” has always been one I have dreaded ... Read more »

Love eating rice? Know its health benefits from Rujuta Diwekar

If you are one of those who cannot do without your daily dose of rice and dal, here is some good news for you. According to celebrity nutritionist Rujuta Diwekar ... Read more »

What Is Wolfsbane Poison, As Seen In 'YOU' Season 3? Effects and Antidote Explained

The third season of hit Netflix drama YOU sees Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley) and Love Quinn (Victoria Pedretti) attempt to kill one other with wolfsbane. © Netflix The Love Quinn ... Read more »

What might be changing on aspirin guidance. An expert weighs in

Wait, are we taking a break from aspirin? © dszc/E+/Getty Images CNN Medical Analyst Dr. Leana Wen advises talking to your doctor before taking aspirin to protect heart health so ... Read more »

Dr. Francis Collins is retiring as director of the National Institutes of Health. What will be his legacy? What will he do next?

Dr. Francis Collins recently announced his retirement after the longest tenure of any director of the National Institutes of Health. The only presidentially appointed NIH director, Collins has served for ... Read more »

Do You Have Acne-Prone Skin? Follow These Key Makeup Tips for Better Results

© Provided by News18 Do You Have Acne-Prone Skin? Follow These Key Makeup Tips for Better Results Acne is a common skin problem in both men and women. Various reasons ... Read more »

World Food Day 2021 recipes: Motiyon wale gulgule, baked apples with singhada

One of the most celebrated days of the United Nation’s calendar, World Food Day is celebrated globally on October 16 to promote worldwide awareness and action for those who suffer ... Read more »

Incredible map lays bare staggering GP shortage in UK - with ONE doctor for 3,000 patients

Health Secretary Sajid Javid has announced changes to GP services as we reach the tail end of the coronavirus pandemic. The overhaul will focus on getting more patients in to ... Read more »

US coronavirus: J&J vaccine recipients should get their second dose as soon as it's available, experts say

As the greenlight looms for another dose of Johnson & Johnson’s Covid-19 vaccine, experts on Friday urged those who received it to get a booster shot as soon as it’s ... Read more »

More Covid-19 boosters are on the horizon. But not everyone will need one, experts say

Advisers from the US Food and Drug Administration voted unanimously to recommend emergency authorization of a booster dose of Moderna’s Covid-19 vaccine, and a day later did so again for ... Read more »

Tone your inner thighs with these 7 exercises, without leaving your bed!

When you think about working your inner thighs, you might believe it’s really hard. But NO, that’s not true! You don’t need to go to the gym or follow a ... Read more »

World Food Day 2021: 5 Food Items That You Can Eat Anytime of The Day Without Worrying About Calories or Indigestion

© KS Swati | India.com Lifestyle Staff World Food Day 2021: 5 Food Items That You Can Eat Anytime of The Day Without Worrying About Calories or Indigestion. Picture Credits: ... Read more »

World Food Day 2021: History, significance and theme this year

© Provided by The Indian Express World Food Day is celebrated every year on October 16 to commemorate the date of the founding of the United Nations Food and Agriculture ... Read more »

WC Health dept urges people to be cautious during snake season

© Pexels CAPE TOWN – The Western Cape Health Department is advising residents to be cautious while doing outdoor activities as its now snake season. October to April is snakebite ... Read more »

World Anaesthesia Day 2021: Here's How Surgeries Were Conducted Without Anaesthesia, and How it has Changed Now

© Provided by News18 World Anaesthesia Day 2021: Here’s How Surgeries Were Conducted Without Anaesthesia, and How it has Changed Now World Anesthesia Day is celebrated on October 16, all ... Read more »

Designs for dementia sufferers reinvent their world – a jacket that looks OK worn upside down, a way to tell time without numbers

Dementia is an incipient public health catastrophe. The World Health Organization estimates that 55 million people are afflicted, with some to be found among Hong Kong’s ageing citizens. Solutions offered ... Read more »

Health Department: More than 20 MILLION vaccine doses administered

© Provided by The South African In what can be described as a positive milestone in South Africa’s vaccination rollout, the number of jabs administered has breached the 20 million ... Read more »

South Africa surpasses milestone with 20 million jabbed against COVID

© Kaylynn Palm/Eyewitness News Jody Ziervogel gets his COVID-19 vaccine shot at the ATlone Stadium drive-through facility in Cape Town on 2 September 2021. JOHANNESBURG – South Africa has surpassed ... Read more »

Centennial makes it count against Norco with 48-24 victory

Six months of waiting. Six months of plotting. Six months of preparing to seek revenge. Corona Centennial players, coaches and fans just could not forget what happened on April 3, ... Read more »

Recipe: Celebrate World Food Day 2021 with a mouthwatering dish of Bean Foogath

Celebrated internationally to commemorate the date of the founding of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization in 1945, World Food Day is marked annually on 16 October. The food ... Read more »

NSW hits vaccine milestone faster than expected, new Premier declares

NSW has hit the sought-after 80 per cent vaccination rate it raced so swiftly towards, even earlier than expected on the first lockdown-free weekend in months. Newly installed Premier Dom ... Read more »

10 signs you may have celiac disease and when to see a doctor

© Cavan Images/Getty Images 10 signs you may have celiac disease and when to see a doctor Celiac disease symptoms include bloating, gas, constipation, and abdominal pain. A common, but ... Read more »

How to return to exercise after recovering from COVID-19

© Provided by 702 When a person recovers from the coronavirus, the body is in a state of severe inflammation and is often exhausted just from the recovery process even ... Read more »

Bring your tresses back to life with these 3 Ayurvedic ingredients

There is a wide variety of beauty and cosmetic products available to help achieve healthy and beautiful hair. However, there is nothing like natural ingredients, as they help promote hair ... Read more »

How to survive world's longest coronavirus quarantine without losing your mind

Do not take Hong Kong’s three-week hotel quarantine, the world’s longest, lightly – you’ve got to go in with a plan. I approached it much like I planned trips to ... Read more »

New gene-edited wheat which can be more heavily toasted could make for tastier breakfasts

Breakfasts could become that little bit tastier if trials of a new type of wheat that can be heavily toasted without becoming carcinogenic go according to plan. While many people ... Read more »

‘Fine doesn't fit the crime': Premier calls for harsher penalty for quarantine breacher who caused lockdown

The Tasmanian Premier has called for a harsher penalty for the NSW man who left hotel quarantine and forced part of the state into a snap three-day lockdown. Peter Gutwein ... Read more »

‘Tragic': Victorian teenager dies with Covid and ‘a number' of other conditions

A 15-year-old girl is among Victoria’s seven Covid-19 deaths overnight, while the number of cases in the state’s hospitals has surged. Covid testing commander Jeroen Weimar would not comment on ... Read more »

Nkengasong and Ihekweazu are leaving the continent. Is this a brain drain or gain for Africa?

Two of Africa’s Covid experts are clearing out their desks and counting the hours as they prepare to take up new roles offered to them overseas. © Provided by CNN ... Read more »

World Spine Day 2021: Theme, History and Significance

© Provided by News18 World Spine Day 2021: Theme, History and Significance World Spine Day is celebrated annually on October 16 to raise awareness about spinal health, spinal pain and ... Read more »

World Food Day 2021: High-protein Foods Vegetarians Should Add to Their Diet

© Provided by News18 World Food Day 2021: High-protein Foods Vegetarians Should Add to Their Diet Are you ensuring you are having enough protein in your diet? Protein is a ... Read more »

CDC releases updated holiday guidance: Have yourself a 'good, normal Christmas'

1 / 2CDC releases updated holiday guidance: Have yourself a ‘good, normal Christmas’ The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention urged Americans on Friday to celebrate upcoming holidays by taking ... Read more »

Fact check: Video on World Health Organization's VigiAccess tool lacks context

The claim: The World Health Organization's VigiAccess tool shows deaths, reactions from COVID-19 vaccine Amid the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines in different countries, health officials and scientists have utilized national ... Read more »

Gold Coast woman accused of handing out more than 600 fake Covid medical exemption certificates

A Gold Coast woman was allegedly pretending to be a doctor when she issued hundreds of fake Covid-related exemption certificates – and police are concerned she may have dished out ... Read more »

How to Diagnose Mitochondrial Disease

Mitochondrial diseases include a wide range of conditions that weaken a person’s neuromuscular system, such as Alpers disease, Leigh disease, or Luft disease. This is because the energy-producing parts of ... Read more »

World Anaesthesia Day 2021: History, Significance and Types of Anaesthesia

© Provided by News18 World Anaesthesia Day 2021: History, Significance and Types of Anaesthesia World Anaesthesia Day is observed to remember the “first successful use of diethyl ether anaesthesia” in ... Read more »

Double amputee beats breast cancer diagnosis

Even before her stage two breast cancer diagnosis in 2020, Yvonne Llanes knew her strength — and her community. Llanes, who was first introduced to “World News Tonight” in 2017, ... Read more »

US regulators weigh whether people can mix COVID booster shots

U.S. regulators are considering revising the rules for COVID-19 vaccines to allow people to opt for a different type of shot for their booster than what they originally received, a ... Read more »

Salmonella Outbreak With 'Unknown Food Source' Has Spread to 36 States

A U.S. salmonella outbreak that began in recent months has now expanded to 36 states and infected nearly 600 people, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). ... Read more »