Can governments stop being authoritarian?

Asia's Tech News Daily

For many Western observers, the Central Asian state of Uzbekistan has been a rare, positive example in the debate on whether authoritarian governments can change their ways. In this view, under a new president, Uzbekistan has since 2016 moved on from being a pariah state, infamous for torturing its political prisoners and forcing millions of its citizens to pick cotton. It has been toasted for economic liberalization and opening up to its regional neighbors, including Afghanistan.

Can governments stop being authoritarian?
© Getty Images Can governments stop being authoritarian?

Many governments have reactivated dormant diplomatic and trading ties. International investment and World Bank projects have increased, though accusations of links to global corruption remain constant. Uzbekistan even joined the United Nations’s top human rights body this year.

Given the significant number of brutal, oppressive rulers around the world, the debate on how to find ways out of authoritarian rule is crucial.

Uzbekistan is at a turning point. The government has introduced some important human rights reforms, but the country remains deeply authoritarian. Uzbekistan’s powerful security state operates unabated, courts and judges are not independent, police torture is common, and speaking your mind or criticizing the government can still land you in jail.

So, after five years of mixed messages, is the country really on track to break with its autocratic past or are the reforms so far a form of fool’s gold that anxious allies, in their desire for change, are willing to take for the real thing?

For the United States, the debacle of its troop withdrawal from Afghanistan has reinforced its focus on Uzbekistan as a potential ally in a volatile region. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said in July that America’s ties to Uzbekistan are “vital.” In October alone, his deputy, Wendy Sherman, and two congressional delegations visited the capital, Tashkent, to test the political temperature.

There is no doubt that President Shavkat Mirziyoyev will win re-election, the first since his election in late 2016. He took office soon after the death of Islam Karimov, his strongman predecessor, who had ruled over an isolated, increasingly impoverished surveillance state for 25 years.

Mirziyoyev has led the country on a different path. Uzbekistan is the largest country in Central Asia, with a relatively young population of 34 million. To avoid economic collapse and possible instability, his government has sought to tackle the country’s dire international image, begin economic reforms, and build bridges to its wary neighbors.

The strategy has worked in some ways. Uzbekistan is increasingly an economic and diplomatic pacesetter in the region, posing a challenge to more wealthy and worldly Kazakhstan. The economy and society are more dynamic, and its image has improved. Diplomats in September listened to, rather than dismissed, Mirziyoyev’s speech at the United Nations at the United Nations, where he talked of a “new Uzbekistan” and set the goal of becoming a per capita “above middle income” country by 2030 (predicted per capita income this year is a lowly $2,000).

Yet these reforms do little to alter the fundamentally authoritarian political system under which Uzbeks live, or to make the exercise and enjoyment of their rights any more real.

The immediate signs for the future are not encouraging. The election is an example. Credible international election observers have never declared an Uzbek election free and fair. Mirziyoyev’s government has, despite international advice, prevented opposition or independent candidates from running against him.

There has been a crackdown this year on independent bloggers, with one sentenced to a lengthy jail term and two others under arrest. And proposed improvements to laws harmful to human rights have stalled.

In optimistic moments, diplomats in Tashkent argue that, with the election all but over, Mirziyoyev will be emboldened – though probably not to throw off the authoritarian straitjacket, at least to loosen its ties.

To be credible, several steps would be needed. First, an overhaul of legislation, including a new criminal code, effective anti-torture legislation, and the lifting of heavy restrictions on independent media, civil society and public protests.

This would lay the basis for a more grounded respect for the rule of law. Second, and related, respect for everyone’s human rights, including religious and sexual minorities and people who have different views than the government’s. Moves toward more democracy also would be an important signal – within Uzbekistan and across a region dominated by the influence of Russia and China.

Third, Uzbekistan makes a great play of being ready for more international responsibility. Now is the time to show what this means. Afghanistan is a prime example. Tashkent wants friendly ties with the country’s new rulers, but says it expects the Taliban to create an inclusive government that respects the rights of women and minorities. Helping to persuade Kabul to deliver on these priorities would be an important step, as would being ready to receive Afghans fleeing the Taliban for their lives.

For their part, Uzbekistan’s international partners would be correct in this next crucial phase to offer critical support, but not at any price. Meaningful reforms that promote the interests and human rights of ordinary people in Uzbekistan should be priorities – for the country and as a sign that change can come, even in authoritarian states.

Hugh Williamson is Europe and Central Asia director for Human Rights Watch. Follow him on Twitter @HughAWilliamson.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Austria's stunned conservatives meet to pick leader for party and country

© Reuters/LISI NIESNER Former Austrian Chancellor Kurz resigns from all political duties, in Vienna By Francois Murphy VIENNA (Reuters) – Top officials of Austria’s ruling conservative party, reeling from their ... Read more »

Retailers make 'shocking' petrol profit says RAC

© Getty Images Retailers are continuing to put up fuel prices when they should reduce them in line with savings in wholesale oil prices, the RAC motoring services organisation has ... Read more »

Shutdown risk eases as Senate pushes toward funding vote

WASHINGTON (AP) — The risk of a short-term government shutdown appeared to be easing late Thursday as the Senate pushed toward final approval of a bill that would fund the ... Read more »

Worst of B.C. weather over; massive cleanup, rebuild ahead, says government

VICTORIA — The successive storms that brutalized southern British Columbia with floods and slides caused by record amounts of rainfall were declared over Thursday, but now the cleanup and costly ... Read more »

Bangkok now has a new night market near where Train Night Market Ratchada used to be

© Provided by Mothership Shopaholics and foodies who have plans to visit Thailand can check out this new outdoor market in Bangkok. Fans who were mourning the demise of the ... Read more »

Amazon Just Cut the Price of Several Instant Pot Appliances Up to 50% Off

© Amazon Here are the deals worth shopping. © Provided by Food & Wine Amazon It’s no mystery that we love to cook—that’s why we’re here, right? But there are ... Read more »

Here are 3 proofs of workplace gender inequality in SG

© Provided by Singapore Business Review Payroll solutions provider ADP released their annual study called People at Work 2021: A Global Workforce View. First, the study found 46% of women ... Read more »

China's Kaisa fails to get bondholders nod for extending maturity

© Reuters/TINGSHU WANG Sign of the Kaisa Plaza, a real estate property developed by Kaisa Group Holdings, is seen near its apartment building in Beijing By Sameer Manekar (Reuters) – ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Adequate supply of oxygen in city, says health secretary

© Provided by The Indian Express The emergence of Omicron (B.1.1.529), a new variant of concern of SARS-CoV-2, the possible threat of a third wave of Covid-19, has initiated several ... Read more »

First grant of post-matric SC scholarship from December 6

© Provided by The Indian Express The government will release the first allotment of post-matric scholarships for scheduled caste students on December 6, said Union Social Justice minister Dr Virendra ... Read more »

Where to find Sacks of Nuts in Final Fantasy XIV

© Provided by GamePur You’ll be hunting down multiple resources and items throughout your time in Final Fantasy XIV. You’ll need these items to exchange with vendors for their exclusive ... Read more »

Andhra CM Jagan Mohan Reddy knocks on NITI Aayog's door for special status

© Provided by The Indian Express Citing the state’s bifurcation in 2014, Chief Minister Y S Jagan Mohan Reddy has sought the NITI Aayog’s assistance in getting special status for ... Read more »

Kharar to get Rs 6.5 crore bus stand

© Provided by The Indian Express Punjab Transport Minister Amarinder Singh Raja Warring Thursday laid the foundation stone of the Modern Bus Stand in Kharar. The new bus stand will ... Read more »

Cardi B becomes first-ever creative director in residence for Playboy

© Bang Showbiz Cardi B at the F9 concert and trailer event in 2020 Cardi B has been named Playboy’s first-ever creative director in residence. The ‘WAP’ hitmaker took to ... Read more »

Reaktion auf Omikron-Variante: USA verschärfen Einreiseregeln – bleiben aber offen

Joe Biden äussert sich zum Plan für die USA, um die Corona-Wintermonate zu überstehen. Das hat auch Auswirkungen für Schweizer, die in die USA reisen wollen. © Bereitgestellt von Blick ... Read more »

Präsident El Salvadors kommentiert Merkel-Zapfenstreich: "Diktatur"

© Keystone/ZUMA Wire/Camilo Freedman Der autoritäre Präsident von El Salvador hat suggeriert, der Grosse Zapfenstreich zur Verabschiedung von Bundeskanzlerin Angela Merkel habe Merkmale einer Diktatur aufgewiesen. “Die Uniformen, die flammenden ... Read more »

7,500 patents & counting…How Samsung's Bengaluru centre fires up innovation

© Provided by The Financial Express When it comes to its own employees, the success rate has been much higher for obvious reasons. “If we look into last five years, ... Read more »

South Korea sees record Covid cases; imposes 10-day quarantine on all travellers amid Omicron scare

South Korea sees record Covid-19 cases; imposes 10-day quarantine on all travellers amid Omicron scare South Korea’s daily coronavirus case numbers rose to a new high on Thursday, as authorities ... Read more »

Last day to subscribe to Tega Industries' IPO — GMP at ₹410

© BCCL Last day to subscribe to Tega Industries’ IPO — GMP at ₹410 The IPO of Tega Industries was subscribed 13.8 times on the first two days of the ... Read more »

Omicron variant may become dominant in Europe in months: EU

Omicron variant may become dominant in Europe in months: EU The European Union’s public health agency said on Thursday that the Omicron variant could be responsible for more than half ... Read more »

Freshmen lead No. 24 Notre Dame women past Michigan St 76-71

EAST LANSING, Mich. (AP) — Freshman Sonia Citron scored a career-high 29 points, classmate Olivia Miles missed a triple-double by two assists and No. 24 Notre Dame edged Michigan State ... Read more »

12 woman candidates in Congress first list of 30

© Provided by The Indian Express The UT unit of the Congress on Thursday released a list of 30 candidates, including 12 women, for the 36 ward Chandigarh Municipality elections ... Read more »

Inflation outlook: Status quo from RBI on Omicron uncertainty

© Provided by The Financial Express On balance, we expect the CPI inflation to print at around 4.7% in November 2021. The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meets next week amidst ... Read more »

Watch: Cristiano Ronaldo passes 800-goal mark with double strike in Manchester United win over Arsenal

© Provided by Zee News Cristiano Ronaldo passed the 800-goal mark for club and country, scoring twice as Manchester United beat Arsenal 3-2 in an incident-packed Premier League match on ... Read more »

Where to find Ore Veins in Minecraft

© Provided by GamePur Ore Veins are long strains of resources that you may encounter when traveling underground in Minecraft. Depending on where you are in your world, you can ... Read more »

A ‘reluctant' CM-face, another propped-up

© Provided by The Indian Express Stating that he was never a CM candidate and that he doesn’t see himself as one for the 2022 Punjab polls, Chief Minister Charanjit ... Read more »

Facebook India gross ad revenue up 41% at Rs 9,326 crore

© Provided by The Indian Express Meta Platforms Inc-owned Facebook India Online Services on Thursday reported a 41 per cent year-on-year increase in gross advertisement revenue at Rs 9,326 crore ... Read more »

Mohali: Work to extend MC's jurisdiction to be expedited

© Provided by The Indian Express The Municipal Corporation (MC) started preparing for the next phase of the extension of jurisdiction on Thursday, and officials said that the process will ... Read more »

Mohali: Four oxygen plants set up in district for possible third wave

© Provided by The Indian Express The district health department Thursday claimed that it has set up four Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA) oxygen plants at various government hospitals to be ... Read more »

How to care for a potted Christmas tree, an eco-friendly alternative to cutting one down

© svetikd/Getty Images How to care for a potted Christmas tree, an eco-friendly alternative to cutting one down Typically, potted Christmas trees grow to be between 2 and 5 feet ... Read more »

Unite union to reduce donations to Labour Party

Undated handout photo issued by the Sharon Graham Campaign of Sharon Graham, an assistant general secretary of the Unite union, who is set to become its first female general secretary ... Read more »

Dutcher, Howard coaching matchup evokes Fab Five memories

SAN DIEGO (AP) — There’s a lot for Brian Dutcher to absorb when he thinks back to the key role he had in recruiting Juwan Howard and the rest of ... Read more »

US started inquiry into Cuomo sexual harassment claims

ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — The U.S. Department of Justice began a civil inquiry in August into sexual harassment claims made against former Gov. Andrew Cuomo, New York officials disclosed Thursday. ... Read more »

AP Top Stories December 2

Here’s the latest for Wednesday December 2nd: Blinken and Lavrov meet in Stockholm; Netherlands moves to tough lockdown amid omicron variant fears; Major railway between Laos and China to open ... Read more »

Broadway's Reneé Rapp makes TV debut

Reneé Rapp, former star in Broadway’s “Mean Girls” as Regina George, makes her TV debut in Mindy Kaling’s new series “The Sex Lives of College Girls” on HBO Max. Rapp ... Read more »

Kelsea Ballerini gets personal in new book, ‘Feel Your Way Through'

Country music star Kelsea Ballerini had no plans to become an author, but writing personal poetry during the pandemic turned into her new book, “Feel Your Way Through.” The Grammy ... Read more »

MLB owners lock out players, 1st time in 26 years

Major League Baseball plunged into its first work stoppage in a quarter-century when the sport’s collective bargaining agreement expired and owners immediately locked out players in a move that threatens ... Read more »

Ben Affleck calls Jennifer Lopez romance 'a great story': See their relationship timeline

Jennifer Lopez and Ben Affleck are back together after several public appearances The Hollywood power couple first together from 2002 to 2004. Affleck said in a recent interview he is ... Read more »

Meta brings new safety initiatives aimed at protecting women in India

Meta (formerly Facebook) announced on Thursday new safety initiatives targeted at protecting women in India, besides appointing two Indian members to a global group of outside experts that advises the ... Read more »

President Biden plans to fight winter COVID variants 'with science and speed'

President Biden laid out his plan for combating COVID-19 as the omicron variant is found in the U.S. and a poll shows rising frustration. Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic