Cambridge University ‘Terf-spotting' guide condemned as a ‘witch-finder's charter'

The guide was fronted by the Cambridge SU women’s officer, who uses he/him and they/them pronouns – iStockphoto

The women’s officer of Cambridge University’s Students Union has been condemned after issuing a guide on how to spot “Terfs”.

Students have been advised to “keep an eye out” for those who think biological sex is binary and that only women can experience misogyny.

“Terf”, which stands for trans exclusionary radical feminist, is generally used as a derogatory term for those who argue biological sex cannot be changed and that women-only spaces should not be opened to male-born trans women.

The document, published among resources on housing and exams advice, was drawn up by Milo Eyre-Morgan, the elected women’s officer, who goes by the pronouns he/him or they/them and vows to represent “marginalised genders”.

The new Cambridge guide, promoted by the women’s officer on Monday, lists several “signs of a Terf”.

The guide goes on to say that “some people who experience misogyny are not women”, and urges students to be “allies” by “keeping an eye out for this way of thinking” in any feminist works they study.

'Terf ideology is a specific form of transphobia'

It claims “Terf ideology is a specific form of transphobia” and gives tips for “talking to Terfs” in-person and online.

It adds: “The core characteristics of Terfs are a conservative, binary, essentialist conception of sex as the be-all-end-all, and a deep hatred for trans women, couched in the language of feminism and feminist theory.”

James Orr, assistant professor in philosophy of religion at Cambridge’s Faculty of Divinity, compared the document to a guide on “how to spot a witch”.

“It’s an attempt to set out a witch-finder's charter and it's driven by ideology not reason,” he said. “This is an extremely sinister development and is effectively incentivising behaviour among students that is wholly opposed to the flourishing of any serious intellectual culture.

“These are perfectly plausible and defensible positions to hold, not immoral and not even close to being unlawful, and should be able to be expressed freely – especially if you think they are wrong. How long before people wake up to this crisis?”

'Trans rights and women’s rights should both be protected'

A third-year Cambridge philosophy student at Clare College, who wished to stay anonymous, said: “There is not enough transparency from the SU; gender identity is grounded in biological sex.

“Trans rights and women’s rights and both should be protected. To ensure healthy discussion, you should have a separate elected women’s officer and an elected trans officer.”

The issue was further highlighted this week after anonymous trans activists at Sussex University launched a campaign to fire Professor Kathleen Stock.

Prof Stock, an expert in analytic philosophy, recently published a book questioning the idea that gender identity is more “socially significant” than biological sex.

She has also previously questioned the idea that men who feel like women should have automatic access to women-only facilities such as changing rooms, or be allowed to appear on women-only shortlists or sports teams.

Amid threats of violence and death, police advised Prof Stock to teach classes online and install CCTV outside her home, with possible bodyguards when she does return to campus.

'I do worry there are pressures towards restricting free speech'

Dr Arif Ahmed, a reader in philosophy at Cambridge, said: “The current persecution of Kathleen Stock has contributed to an atmosphere in higher education where one side of a very important public policy debate feels unable to speak out and in some cases probably is.

“I do worry that at Cambridge, as at any other university, there are pressures towards restricting free speech on this issue and my greatest fear is that these will be translated into disciplinary policy and official guidance from the top.

“Freedom is not a natural state of humanity, it is something we always have to protect.”

The Equalities and Human Rights Commission has made clear that gender-critical viewpoints on the trans debate are lawful and deserve to be heard.

On Wednesday night, Cambridge University insisted its students’ union was simply “contributing to an active social debate” and insisted it supports free speech and condemns harassment.

Cambridge SU was approached for comment.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Tube passengers step in as thug hurls abuse at young woman

Angry man confronts woman on Tube (CrimeLDN) A young woman confronted by an abusive male on the Tube had to be protected by fellow commuters. In a video posted on ... Read more »

Cardinals vs Browns live stream: how to watch NFL online from anywhere

The Browns pushed the Chiefs and the Chargers all the way but fell short both times, and now they face another powerhouse, the league’s only undefeated team, though Kyler Murray’s ... Read more »

Facebook claims hate speech visibility dropped 50 percent in nine months

Facebook is responding to whistleblower Frances Haugen’s testimony by attempting to shift the narrative on hate speech. Integrity VP Guy Rosen has posted a defense of the social network’s anti-hate ... Read more »

Facebook disputes report that its AI can't detect hate speech or violence consistently

Facebook vice president of integrity Guy Rosen wrote in blog post Sunday that the prevalence of hate speech on the platform had dropped by 50 percent over the past three ... Read more »

At least 13 auto safety rules are years overdue. Many of them could save lives

WASHINGTON (AP) — As traffic fatalities spike in the COVID-19 pandemic, the federal agency in charge of auto safety is struggling with a growing backlog of safety rules ordered by ... Read more »

Jabra's wireless earbuds are up to 40 percent off at Amazon for today only

Want some wireless earbuds to help you study or get in some cool-weather exercise? Here’s your chance to get some at a good price. Jabra’s earbuds are steeply discounted as ... Read more »

Daniel Craig Crashes Rami Malek's 'SNL' Episode For Prince Audition Sketch

Kenan Thompson, special guest Daniel Craig and host Rami Malek shared the screen during the No time to die, but plenty of time for sketch comedy, apparently: Daniel Craig made ... Read more »

Shocking moment woman falls down manhole with baby in arms

Shocking moment woman falls down manhole with baby in arms Read more »

10 Kate Spade Surprise purses you can buy for under $100 right now

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. If you’re planning on gifting a loved one a chic purse ... Read more »

Intel Alder Lake CPUs could fail to work with some DRM-toting games

Intel’s Alder Lake processors could have compatibility issues with older games that use DRM protection, according to a fresh report. The story here is that Intel has just released a ... Read more »

Going all-in on crypto mining? These are the best GPUs for you.

Cryptocurrency mining is a heavy process for the GPU, requiring the component (and your PC) to be running hard for prolonged periods of time. While it’s possible to choose the ... Read more »

Apple's new MacBook Pro chips may be called the M1 Pro and M1 Max

Leaks are still pouring in just a day before Apple’s “Unleashed” event kicks off. According to MacRumors, Bloomberg‘s Mark Gurman understands the chips for the widely expected 14- and 16-inch ... Read more »

Black Friday started early at Amazon: the 6 best deals you need to see

Black Friday still might be over a month away, but that doesn’t mean you can shop incredible deals at Amazon’s latest sale. The retailer is releasing “Black Friday-worthy” discounts throughout ... Read more »

Soldier who died in training accident on Salisbury Plain named

Jethro Watson-Pickering (Yorkshire Regiment/PA) A soldier who died during an Army training exercise on Salisbury Plain has been named. Private Jethro Watson-Pickering, 23, of the 1st Yorks Regiment, was part ... Read more »

Nintendo Switch Online N64 games: a brief introduction to every game

Nintendo Switch Online is a service that could be better. It’s Nintendo’s own version of PS Plus or Xbox Live, albeit with a less refined online play experience, a library ... Read more »

LG's 27-inch 1440p screen is great for gaming and down to its lowest price

LG’s 27GL850-B 27-inch Ultragear Nano IPS 1440p gaming monitor was going for as much as $500 in March and was still as high as $450 in July. Today’s drop to ... Read more »

Artists launch colorful 'jellyfish' balloon to the stratosphere in inaugural test flight

© Provided by Space Beyond Earth’s “Living Light” artwork. A group of artists has launched a colorful, jellyfish-looking craft into Earth’s stratosphere as part of a unique test flight.  This ... Read more »

Inspiration4 astronaut Sian Proctor reflects on historic SpaceX spaceflight experience

© Provided by Space Sian Proctor served as the pilot for the private SpaceX mission Inspiration4. CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — Sian Proctor, the pilot for SpaceX’s historic Inspiration4 mission, is ... Read more »

Chiefs vs Washington live stream: how to watch NFL online from anywhere

This clash of the teams with the two worst defenses in the NFL is a must-win for both franchises, which are matched at 2-3. Expect both quarterbacks to rack up ... Read more »

Python is now no. 1. This training can make sure you're a certified expert

TLDR: The Python Programming and Git Certification Bundle includes beginner and advanced training in how to use Python to code all your biggest programming projects. Well, it finally happened. After ... Read more »

Support scientific interest with a price drop on this comprehensive robot arm kit

The pursuit of scientific and technological understanding and innovation requires consistent dedication and a desire to learn. For many eventual individual successes in the industry, that journey starts at a ... Read more »

Apple's October ‘Unleashed' event: what to expect

Apple has announced an event for October 18th, with a video containing the title “Unleashed.” If you’ve been watching the rumor mill, it won’t come as a surprise — the ... Read more »

Packers vs Bears live stream: how to watch NFL online from anywhere

The Packers’ seemingly reluctant win over the Bengals last weekend was one of the strangest games in recent memory, so much so that a Bears triumph can’t be ruled out… ... Read more »

Chargers vs Ravens live stream: how to watch NFL online from anywhere

Two of the oustanding figures from the early weeks of the season, Justin Herbert and Lamar Jackson, go head-to-head in a game that’s got FUN written all over it. The ... Read more »

Russian crew returns from shooting the first feature film on the ISS

Shooting for the first feature-length movie in space has wrapped. Space.comreports Russian actress Yulia Pereslid, producer Klim Shipenko and cosmonaut Oleg Novitskiy have returned to Earth after the first two ... Read more »

How to watch the Apple October 2021 event: will new MacBooks get unleashed?

Apple has announced it is holding it’s ‘Unleashed’ event, where it’s expected to show off new MacBook Pros running on upgraded hardware, and we’ll show you how to watch the ... Read more »

Jabra's huge Epic Daily Deals sale includes $50 off the Elite 85t earbuds

One of Amazon’s Epic Daily Deals today is a gigantic sale on Jabra true wireless earbuds. The items available include multiple generations of Jabra’s true wireless earbuds going as far ... Read more »

NASA is studying how to build a Wi-Fi network on the moon in the hopes it could also solve Earth's digital divide

An artist’s concept of NASA astronauts returning to the surface of the moon via its Artemis program. NASA A new NASA study explores the possibility of building a Wi-Fi network ... Read more »

At Alaska's most popular national park, climate change threatens the only road in and out

1 / 3At Alaska’s most popular national park, climate change threatens the only road in and out DENALI NATIONAL PARK, Alaska – Denali National Park has just one road in ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy S22 leak reveals more about the smartphone's design

We’ve already heard plenty about the Samsung Galaxy S22 as its expected launch date gets closer and closer, but the leaks keep on coming – and the latest one gives ... Read more »

Daniel Craig's James Bond movies show where the Star Wars sequels went wrong

Big No Time To Die spoilers follow. Watch the film before reading this. They actually went and did it… For a franchise that’s spent most of its six decades adhering ... Read more »

7 reasons why programmers burn out — and 7 ways to prevent it

When Jerry started their job as a junior developer, they couldn’t wait to get to work each morning. And each evening, even after their 10-hour workdays, they’d still feel energized. ... Read more »

Best Buy's Black Friday plans: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

What do 10 million fewer iPhone 13 shipments mean?

While the iPhone 13 range seemingly launched without a hitch in September, a recent Bloomberg report claimed that Apple was expecting to ship 10 million fewer units of its newest ... Read more »

Russian spacecraft returns to Earth with movie crew aboard

A Russian actress and director-producer who spent 12 days aboard the International Space Station returned to Earth early Sunday along with cosmonaut Oleg Novitskiy who had been in space for ... Read more »

Three ways to add quicker access to the Windows 11 Task Manager

© Provided by Windows Central Here are three ways to create quick access to the Task Manager on Windows 11. On Windows 11, you can no longer right-click the Taskbar ... Read more »

HP Omen 15 (2021)

© Provided by TechRadar The HP Omen 15 from the front, displaying a vivd, colorful desktop background HP Omen 15 (2021): Two minute review If you’re looking for a powerful ... Read more »

Politicians and senior LGBT+ figures stand with Stonewall in wake of BBC attack

Politicians and senior LGBT+ figures have rushed to defend Stonewall in the wake of a BBC “investigation” into the charity. On Friday (15 October), the BBC published an article headlined ... Read more »

The pandemic laid bare the deep problems in America - from healthcare to housing. Now the question is: will we do anything about it?

Sophia Garcia, center, with Legacy LA in Boyle Heights joins housing advocates and tenants gathered against eviction of tenants from the 50 unit Tokio Hotel apartments n downtown Los Angeles. ... Read more »

The dark side of wellness: the overlap between spiritual thinking and far-right conspiracies

It was the afternoon of 4 July 2020, and Melissa Rein Lively’s video was about to go viral. A PR executive in Arizona, she already had the appearance of a ... Read more »