California now limits medical parole to those on ventilators

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A new California policy could send dozens of quadriplegic, paraplegic or otherwise permanently incapacitated inmates from nursing homes back to state prisons.

Prison officials say a change in federal rules led them to limit medical parole to inmates so ill they are hooked to ventilators to breathe, meaning their movement is so limited they are not a public danger. The state previously included a much broader range of permanent incapacities allowing inmates to be cared for in nursing homes outside prison walls.

Steve Fama, an attorney with the nonprofit Prison Law Office, said the court-appointed federal office that controls health care in California prisons told him the change could affect about 70 of the 210 inmates approved for medical parole under the current system, started in 2014.

“It’d be an awful shame if those people were returned to prison,” Fama said. “Those patients have been proven not to need a prison setting given their medical conditions.”

The policy shift comes as the state has been reducing its prison population due to the coronavirus pandemic, as well as a more general push from voters and legislators to free older and infirm inmates who are less likely to commit new crimes.

California officials say they have no choice under a new approach to the enforcement of federal licensing requirements for nursing homes by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. That’s a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services headed by former California Attorney General Xavier Becerra.

The federal agency has taken the position that parole officials can’t impose any conditions on inmates in community medical facilities, the state says. That includes a rule that inmates not leave except with permission from their parole agent — a restriction state officials said is necessary to ensure public safety.

In response, only those on ventilators are being placed in the community, corrections department spokeswoman Dana Simas said.

Federal officials disagree that revoking medical parole and putting incapacitated inmates back behind bars is the state’s only option.

They say California could leave the inmates in nursing homes with no prohibition on their leaving, or put them in facilities that aren’t regulated by the federal government — “assisted living or non-certified skilled facilities that a state may wish to license to serve parolees who have additional health care needs.”

Simas responded that sending offenders to such non-certified facilities “would require establishing an entirely new program to monitor and audit the care provided at these facilities.” Health care provided to offenders at the current facilities is checked by the federal receiver’s office and several outside agencies.

The state’s decision affects incapacitated inmates who are deemed to still need some sort of supervision, but it does not affect compassionate releases that are approved by a court and have no strings attached. Inmates can seek compassionate release if they are diagnosed with an illness that is deemed likely to cause their death in 12 months or less and is a medical condition they did not have when sentenced.

Several other states have had to address the same issue, though federal officials couldn’t immediately say which, when or how they complied.

Nearly every state allows prisoners with serious medical conditions to be released on what’s generally called medical parole, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. But the organization said in a 2018 review that such laws are rarely used.

Researchers from the Vera Institute of Justice, a national nonprofit research and advocacy group, said barriers include limited eligibility criteria and the difficulty in applying for release. Their 2017 report found that Alabama had released 39 people on medical parole over eight years, while Texas approved 86 out of more than 2,000 requests in 2016. The legislative organization said those states had some of the highest rates of release.

California eclipsed those releases by approving 210 medical paroles and denying 110 requests since 2014, though that is a tiny fraction of the nearly 100,000 inmates currently imprisoned in the most populous state.

California Assemblyman Phil Ting, who heads the powerful Assembly Budget Committee, is carrying a bill to expand the criteria and create an easier process for placing incapacitated inmates in community health care facilities.

“Limiting it to only those on ventilators is arbitrary and not based on medical science,” he said. “Public safety is not improved by taking such an unnecessarily narrow view of this policy.”

Ting’s bill would include those who qualify for hospice care or have debilitating pain or a debilitating disease. Instead of leaving the decision to the state parole board, which is composed largely of law enforcement officials, it would create a new medical parole panel at each prison made up of health care providers. It also would keep patients in outside facilities even if they no longer meet the criteria for medical parole.

It was originally carried by former Assemblyman Rob Bonta, now the state’s attorney general, and cleared the Assembly before stalling in the Senate last summer. Ting plans to try again next year.

Those sentenced to death, life without parole or for murdering police officers are not eligible under California law, and that would not change under Ting’s proposal.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

AQI of Delhi improved on Monday

© Provided by The Statesman AQI of Delhi improved on Monday Residents of Delhi and NCR woke up to improved air quality ‘moderate’ on Monday, after being ‘poor’ on Sunday ... Read more »

Waterloo Road: everything we know about show's return

The much-loved series Waterloo Road is heading back to our screens, with BBC announcing the exciting news that the show will return later in 2022. But who will be back ... Read more »

From Billy Elliot to Spider-Man: how Tom Holland won the world's heart

Tom Holland was obsessed with Spider-Man as a boy. Growing up in Kingston upon Thames, he came to own more than 30 Spider-Man costumes and cherished his Spider-Man bedsheets. And, ... Read more »

FF Plus wants Modise to be transparent about cause of Waterkloof Base fire

© Christa Van der Walt/Eyewitness News FILE: Waterkloof Air Force Base in Pretoria. CAPE TOWN – The Freedom Front Plus wants Defence Minister Thandi Modise to play open cards with ... Read more »

Iran talks: Will a deal be reached? Doubtful - INSS report

© (photo credit: EU DELEGATION IN VIENNA/HANDOUT VIA REUTERS) Deputy Secretary General of the European External Action Service (EEAS) Enrique Mora and Iran Iran and world powers are unlikely to ... Read more »

How to Pick the Right Rep Range for Your Workouts

This is Your Quick Training Tip, a chance to learn how to work smarter in just a few moments so you can get right to your workout. By far the ... Read more »

Shooting at AirB&B house party leaves one injured

Shooting at AirB&B house party leaves one injured Read more »

A Quiet Place spin-off release date delayed: The horror sequel suffers another blow

The original A Quiet Place was an immense success, taking home $341 million at the box office from a $17 million budget. The sequel was a hit as well, despite ... Read more »

Person robbed at gunpoint at Jefferson Twp. apartment complex

Jan. 24—A person was robbed at gunpoint Sunday afternoon in Jefferson Twp. with the suspect taking off with the person's cell phone and vehicle. The incident was reported around 1:49 ... Read more »

Inside the tragic death that sparked Rachel Stevens' split from Jeremy Edwards

Rachel Stevens is currently getting prepared for her first skate on Dancing On Ice, after joining the 2022 show. And the stunning singer will no doubt be cheered on by ... Read more »

Evan Rachel Wood claims Marilyn Manson 'essentially raped' her on music video set

© Provided by Cover Media Evan Rachel Wood Evan Rachel Wood has claimed Marilyn Manson “essentially raped” her on the set of his 2007 music video Heart-Shaped Glasses. Last February, ... Read more »

Which city is better: Delhi, Mumbai and Bengaluru flat rent debate goes viral

© Provided by Firstpost Which city is better: Delhi, Mumbai and Bengaluru flat rent debate goes viral Internet users are forever debating the pros and cons of living in various ... Read more »

Police: Gunmen kill Pakistani reporter working for local TV

On Location: January 24, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press LAHORE, Pakistan — Gunmen on a motorcycle shot and killed a Pakistani journalist in the ... Read more »

2 quakes shake southern Haiti; no damage reported

On Location: January 24, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.ABCNews.com PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti — Two moderate earthquakes shook southwest Haiti on Monday, creating panic and prompting schools to ... Read more »

Delhi govt slashes number of 'Dry Day' in state to 3, down from 21 earlier | Details here

© Provided by Jagran English New Delhi | Jagran News Desk: The Delhi government on Monday under its new excise policy has reduced the number of dry days to just ... Read more »

UK to lift travel test requirements for the vaccinated

The Associated PressWorkers walk over London Bridge towards the City of London financial district during the morning rush hour, in London, Monday, Jan. 24, 2022. The British government have asked ... Read more »

Manchester United show Arsenal what they are missing in top-four fight with new signings vital for Mikel Arteta

It was a weekend of contrasting emotions for Arsenal and Manchester United, and the manner in which their respective games finished was telling. The Gunners were desperately pushing for a ... Read more »

Inside Line: What England rookie Orlando Bailey will learn from Johnny Sexton masterclass

Johnny Sexton – Getty Images In the rubble of a record home defeat, Orlando Bailey’s performance on Saturday lunchtime offered some solace for Bath supporters. The 20-year-old produced a number ... Read more »

Aspiring cop, 7, says he wants to be a ‘hero' like slain NYPD officer

A pint-sized aspiring cop paid tribute Sunday to slain NYPD cop Jason Rivera – saying he wanted to be a “hero” just like the tragic rookie officer. Jason Rivera was ... Read more »

Stephen A. Smith loses it reacting to Bills-Chiefs game in viral video

If Stephen A. Smith doesn’t have a voice on Monday’s episode of “First Take” on ESPN, here’s why. The host took to social media on Sunday night to react to ... Read more »

Covid-19: Over 162 crore vaccine doses administered in India, says Centre

© Provided by The Financial Express Also 4,25,44,326 adolescents in the 15-18 years age group have received the first dose. (File) The cumulative COVID-19 vaccine doses administered in the country ... Read more »

Arsenal have ‘agreed terms' for midfielder as Edu ditches Vlahovic for late Calvert-Lewin bid

Welcome to our football.london The Arsenal Way daily news round-up. Maybe not the first, we’ve definitely done transfer round-ups before, and European round-ups, so I guess in some ways it’s ... Read more »

"I'm told": Source reveals major Claudio Ranieri future update this afternoon

© GiveMeSport p1fq68i9u5iat1v1b83g304vjlb.jpg Transfer insider Dean Jones has described Claudio Ranieri as a “dead man walking” at Watford. The Italian only replaced Xisco in early October, but his position as ... Read more »

Kohl's soars 36% as the department store chain receives 2nd takeover bid

© FREDERIC J. BROWN/AFP/Getty Images A woman shops for jewellery at a Kohl’s department store. FREDERIC J. BROWN/AFP/Getty Images Kohl’s shares jumped 36% on Monday following a report of interest ... Read more »

'Shouldn't even be in the squad', 'Leave the club' - Lots of Leeds fans blast 'shocking' ace

Leeds United fans have been reacting to the performance of Tyler Roberts during their recent game in the Premier League. Marcelo Bielsa’s men suffered a 1-0 defeat at Elland Road ... Read more »

Emma Raducanu earns ranking boost despite early Australian Open exit

Emma Raducanu will reach a new career-high in the WTA rankings next Monday despite an early exit at the Australian Open. The 19-year-old made her debut in Melbourne last week ... Read more »

Random diets and unplanned weight loss: 7 mistakes to avoid while managing PCOS

Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) is already surrounded by several myths and misconceptions which sometimes lead to women making mistakes. Only women with PCOS know how difficult and tricky it is ... Read more »

Lebanon's former PM Saad Hariri suspends political career

© Provided by Al Jazeera Lebanon’s leading Sunni Muslim politician and former Prime Minister Saad Hariri gestures during a speech in Beirut, Lebanon [Mohamed Azakir/Reuters] Beirut, Lebanon – Former Prime ... Read more »

Ireland's Jamie McGrath urged to focus on St Mirren amid speculation over future

ST MIRREN BOSS Jim Goodwin insists Jamie McGrath remains part of his plans and has told the midfielder he needs to focus on getting back to playing for the club. ... Read more »

Club reject AFC Bournemouth's transfer advances

© Provided by Football League World Championship – West Bromwich Albion v Peterborough United It could be a nervy end to the transfer window for Peterborough United with the news ... Read more »

Best Sink Unblocker

© Credits: Image by AndreyPopov on iStock Woman unblocking the sink There’s not much worse than a blocked sink, but before you call the plumber, you should try using one ... Read more »

Visitors to Colombian house find world turned upside down after pandemic

© Reuters/LUISA GONZALEZ People pose for a photo inside the upside down house, in Guatavita By Camilo Cohecha and Javier Andres Rojas GUATAVITA, Colombia (Reuters) – An upside down house ... Read more »

Daniil Medvedev survives but Aryna Sabalenka ousted on marathon Australian Open day

Contrary to what Daniil Medvedev may have suggested, day eight of the Australian Open was anything but boring. A slew of tense, torrid and at times exhausting fourth-round matches finally ... Read more »

A group of moms wanted to release some stress. So, they gathered in a field and screamed.

When you’re angry and stressed, what do you do? You scream at the top of your lungs in the middle of a football field. At least that’s what some Massachusetts ... Read more »

Trouble on the terraces: English football fan disorder ‘getting worse'

© Lindsey Parnaby/AFP via Getty Images Aston Villa’s Matty Cash and Lucas Digne were struck by a bottle at Goodison Park Lindsey Parnaby/AFP via Getty Images Arrests at matches in ... Read more »

Former Activision Blizzard developers form new development and publishing studio called New Tales

© Provided by GamePur A new studio going by the name of New Tales has just been formed, notably comprised of former Activision Blizzard developers. The Paris-based company doubles as ... Read more »

T1 Challengers coach Roach suspended for tampering, despite appeal to reconsider 4-game ban

© Provided by Dot Esports T1 Challengers coach Kim “Roach” Kang-hee has been suspended for four games in the 2022 LCK CK Spring Split and has received a fine of ... Read more »

Hitman 3's PC VR hotfix is out now but Game Pass crashes are still a problem

© Provided by GamePur IO Interactive has posted an update on the glitches and bugs in Hitman 3 Year Two that players found last week shortly after the update launched. ... Read more »

How to get a free extra day at Legoland Windsor theme park

FAMILIES wanting to spend even longer at Legoland can do so without having to pay for it, thanks to a new deal being offered by the theme park. From today, ... Read more »

Virginia school districts sue Gov. Youngkin over executive order making mask mandate optional

Seven school boards are challenging Virginia Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s executive order banning mask mandates. © Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images Gov. Glenn Youngkin speaks prior to signing executive actions ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic