By boosting flights in the UK, Rishi Sunak has revealed the Tories' true priorities

Asia's Tech News Daily

I don’t like to be constantly complaining about things, so let’s start with the good stuff from Wednesday’s budget announcement that air passenger duty (APD) is going to be halved on domestic flights. It won’t take long.

By boosting flights in the UK, Rishi Sunak has revealed the Tories’ true priorities
© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Chris J Ratcliffe/Getty Images

The best thing about it is that the cut in domestic APD will now apply only to those in the cheapest seats – “reduced rate” passengers. The Treasury had consulted on a change that would have cut £39 from the cost of an internal private jet flight, and £13 for a first-class traveller – but this didn’t happen, thankfully. It is also true that the overall direct impact on carbon emissions of this new tax incentive to domestic air travel is likely to be small; domestic flights account for just 4% of UK aviation emissions, and this cut in the tax rates won’t do much to change that.

And yet I am still banging my head on the table over this news. Why? First, it’s the symbolism of cutting taxes on the most environmentally damaging form of transport just as the UK hosts an existentially important international climate conference, Cop26. The government’s own figures show that travelling to Cop26 in Glasgow from London by plane would emit 154kg CO2e – five and a half times more than the same journey by train. The plane here isn’t even any faster than the train; colleagues from Campaign for Better Transport recently raced this route, arriving within two minutes of one another. Per passenger kilometre, domestic flights are substantially worse for the climate than long haul, as so much of the fuel burn takes place during takeoff and landing.

Our own research at Possible shows that most people would prefer to travel by climate-friendly train than polluting plane, but cost is the main barrier. Which? recently found that domestic flights to popular UK holiday destinations are on average 50% cheaper than the rail alternative. Making these flights even cheaper with yet more tax breaks seems deeply perverse – especially as British domestic flight passengers generally have income of around double the national average.

The Treasury shtick on the domestic APD cut is that it’s about “union connectivity” – the subject of a recent government commission that concluded that regions across the UK need help to establish better transport links. But that review specifically said that its key concerns included “the appropriate rate of air passenger duty for journeys not realistic by rail”. There is only one part of the UK that this really applies to: Northern Ireland (airports in Scotland’s Highlands and Islands are already exempt from APD; regular visitors to Jersey and Guernsey may not need any further help avoiding tax). By far the most popular domestic air route in the UK is London to Edinburgh, also served by 41 trains every day. People moaning about the schlep down to Cornwall would do better to ask the government what has happened to its Integrated Rail Plan, now around nine months late. Electrification of the Cornish main line up to London, as recommended over a year ago by Network Rail in its own decarbonisation plan, would improve reliability and slash journey times through increased speed and acceleration. What journeys are “realistic by rail” depends on investment in the British rail network, and the budget has done nothing to provide clarity on this.

By boosting flights in the UK, Rishi Sunak has revealed the Tories’ true priorities
© Photograph: Chris J Ratcliffe/Getty Images ‘Domestic flights in a small island nation such as Britain should be among the easiest of the things to give up as we rise to meet the challenge of the unfolding climate crisis.’

The real reason for the domestic APD cut is political: it is something the UK’s pandemic-struck aviation industry has been badgering the Treasury about for years, and the government wanted to be seen to throw it a bone at a difficult time for the sector. Everyone knows it won’t really do much to help. But the fact that the government ranks the symbolism of helping the aviation industry higher than the climate symbolism – incentivising people to travel short distances by the most climate-damaging mode available when the fate of the planet hangs in the balance at Cop26 – signals something disturbing about its priorities.

It also adds to the emerging picture around the troubling ideological limits to this government’s climate action. This is the thing that bothers me most about the APD tax cut. The transport decarbonisation plan published in the summer contained a foreword stressing that it was: “not about stopping people doing things: it’s about doing the same things differently. We will still fly on holiday, but in more efficient aircraft, using sustainable fuel.” But “sustainable aviation fuels” comprised less than 0.1% of jet fuel consumed in 2019, and no credible analysis expects all future jet fuel to come from sustainable sources by 2050, when the UK has committed to achieving “net zero” carbon emissions. The government’s grand net zero strategy published last week reiterated this magical thinking around aviation, and consequently its statutory advisers, the Climate Change Committee, have picked out the absence of any plan to manage growth in demand for air travel as one of the strategy’s key failings. It’s not just air travel; the UK’s climate plans have no targets for reducing fossil-fuelled vehicle miles driven on the UK’s roads either, and are perplexingly weak even on measures to reduce energy demand from buildings, despite both these things being central to any viable pathway to deep decarbonisation.

Fundamentally, the climate action challenge for government is straightforward: decarbonise everything we can, and do less of the things that we can’t. But the second half of this very basic and obvious formula is one Boris Johnson’s administration refuses to even talk about in public. Witness the farcical publication and immediate depublication of the research it commissioned on behavioural change initiatives to help people fly less and eat less meat – two insolubly high-carbon activities that meeting climate goals requires us to collectively do less of.

Domestic flights in a small island nation such as Britain should be among the easiest of the things to give up to meet the challenge of the unfolding climate crisis (indeed, France is already showing us how). But until the government has grown out of the pretence that this challenge can be met without anyone forgoing anything, we will remain locked on a course to catastrophe.

  • Leo Murray is co-founder and director of innovation at climate charity Possible

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Covid-19: Antibody drug works against Omicron, tests show

© Provided by Khaleej Times GlaxoSmithKline on Thursday said that a lab analysis of the antibody-based Covid-19 therapy it is developing with US partner Vir has shown the drug is ... Read more »

Omicron variant: Norway reports large outbreak of infections

© Provided by Khaleej Times Students from Norway who were on a field trip to South Africa wait to be tested for Covid-19 before boarding a flight to Amsterdam at ... Read more »

Measures against Delta work for Omicron variant too, WHO says

© Provided by Khaleej Times AP World Health Organisation officials in the Western Pacific say border closures adopted by some countries may buy time to deal with the omicron coronavirus ... Read more »

Covid-19 Omicron variant: Five virus cases confirmed in New York state

© Provided by Khaleej Times AFP The state of New York has confirmed five cases of the coronavirus Omicron variant, Governor Kathy Hochul said Thursday, bringing the total number of ... Read more »

Lizzo reveals special bond with Adele

© Bang Showbiz Lizzo reveals special bond with Adele Lizzo revealed Adele gave her “really good advice”, as she gushed about them both being “supreme divas”. The ‘Truth Hurts’ hitmaker ... Read more »

Implement orders of panel on air quality management to curb pollution, SC tells Centre, NCR states

The Supreme Court on Friday directed the Centre and the states in NCR to implement the orders of the panel on air quality management to curb air pollution while ruing ... Read more »

Aadhaar looking to go global

The Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) is looking to collaborate with foreign countries and international organisations to build digital identity systems across the world, a top official said on ... Read more »

12 Omicron suspects admitted to Delhi's LNJP hospital so far: Sources

As many as 12 patients suspected to be infected with the COVID-19 ‘Omicron‘ variant have been admitted to Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan (LNJP) hospital in Delhi so far, said ... Read more »

Bengal to soon conduct trials of COVID-19 booster shots

The West Bengal government is planning to soon conduct trials of COVID-19 booster shots in the metropolis, and has started feasibility tests at different medical establishments, a senior official of ... Read more »

Court 'should dismiss' Hungary-Poland bid to stop conditions being slapped on EU cash handouts

Hungary and Poland are trying to stop EU cash handouts from being conditional on respect for rule of law and other key values of the bloc. Read more »

EXPLAINER: Turkey's currency is crashing. What's the impact?

1 / 9Turkey Economy ExplainerA man sells Turkish flags in a commercial area in Kadikoy neighbourhood in Istanbul, Turkey, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021. Turkey’s beleaguered currency has been plunging to ... Read more »

Best fridge freezer deals in the sales for December 2021: Discounts at Currys, Very and more

It pays to keep an eye out for offers on large appliances (iStock/The Independent) Home appliances are a big investment, and they are often non-negotiable. Take for example a fridge ... Read more »

'No sad songs' at Kit Chan's new concert Reignite, which includes a Christmas segment

The warm, smooth and buttery voice that came from the phone was unmistakably Kit Chan’s. Even after back-to-back interviews (mine was the last), Kit sounded energised and fresh, raring to ... Read more »

Knicks' Julius Randle downplays squabble with Evan Fournier

At the conclusion of what clearly had been another frustrating first half for the Knicks, TV cameras caught Julius Randle and teammate Evan Fournier in a heated discussion on their ... Read more »

Cristiano Ronaldo showed Ralf Rangnick why Manchester United can't live without him

As Ralf Rangnick rose to his feet to give Cristiano Ronaldo yet another standing ovation he didn’t look like a man trying to find the best way of telling him ... Read more »

From Welcome to Earth to The Great: the seven best shows to stream this week

Pick of the week Welcome to Earth © Provided by The Guardian Will Smith inWelcome to Earth. Photograph: Disney Will Smith’s grandmother used to tell him: “All the best things ... Read more »

Dreamwork Makes Celine Work in New Mr Porter Capsule

© Courtesy Luxury’s gloomy little brother wakes up in a post-Covid Land of Nod for new exclusive collection Exclusive. Hey! Gloomy fashion boys have dreams too! Or at least they ... Read more »

Cameron Carter-Vickers: Why Celtic star missed Hearts clash as Ange Postecoglou gives reason for absence

Celtic were without Cameron Carter-Vickers for the 1 – 0 win over Hearts on Thursday night, a result which cut the gap to Rangers at the top of the Premiership ... Read more »

Thierry Henry points finger at Mikel Arteta over Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang treatment

Arsenal legend Thierry Henry has questioned Mikel Arteta ‘s decision to haul Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang off in Arsenal’s 3-2 defeat at Manchester United on Wednesday night. The Gunners took the led ... Read more »

UPL fire left Blackburn community with health issues, SAHRC told

© @SAHRCommission/Twitter. Witnesses from UPL Cornubia Fire Civil Society Action Group testifying at the National Investigative Hearing into the July 2021 Unrest. DURBAN – The community of Blackburn Village, in ... Read more »

Stellenbosch University adopts IsiXhosa as its third official language

© Provided by SowetanLive IsiXhosa will be part of teaching and learning at the Stellenbosch University (SU).  This comes after the university’s council approved the proposed new language policy for ... Read more »

Gauteng Health urges young people to get vaccinated

© Provided by 702 Gauteng will reach the peak of the Covid-19 fourth wave in the next two weeks, this is according to the Gauteng command council. The province is ... Read more »

Bedfordview & Nigel businesses say power outages hurting financial recovery

© Sethembiso Zulu/EWN Joburg business owners close up shop as Eskom implements load shedding. JOHANNESBURG – Businesses in Bedfordview and Nigel said that power outages had been a double blow ... Read more »

Female traffic officer in court for religious leader's kidnapping

© Provided by SowetanLive A female traffic police officer, 29, from Daveyton in Ekurhuleni was among the three people who appeared on Thursday at the Benoni magistrate’s court on charges ... Read more »

US steps up disclosure pressure on Chinese companies

The Associated PressFILE – The Wall St. street sign is framed by American flags flying outside the New York Stock Exchange in New York, Jan. 3, 2020. Chinese companies will ... Read more »

Now Google AXES plans for UK workers to be at their desks in January after cancelling face-to-face meetings and telling staff to postpone Christmas parties over Omicron warnings

Google has emailed UK staff urging them to move any social gatherings to 2022It reportedly also told staff face-to-face meetings must be approved by directorIt comes after Government's mudded messaging caused wave of cancellationsBut Boris Johnson insisted there is no reason for Britons to change their plans Read more »

Queensland records a new locally-acquired Covid-19 case as EIGHT locations including a Kmart and entire carpark are put on high alert

Queensland Health has raised the alarm after a seventh case of Covid-19 Contact tracing is underway at eight locations in south-east BrisbaneQueensland Health have yet to trace the source of a Gold Coast outbreak Infected person was in the community for two days before testing positive  Read more »

Newcastle outcast Dwight Gayle 'put on the loan list at St James' Park as Eddie Howe tries to offload striker to a Championship club in January... but his huge £40,000-a-week wages could prove to be a problem'

Dwight Gayle has fallen well down the pecking order at Newcastle UnitedReports claim Newcastle want him out in January, with Championship clubs keenBoth West Brom and Nottingham Forest are interested in taking striker on loanWages could be a sticking point with Gayle currently earning £40,000 a week  Read more »

'It's hard to put into words how much you have helped me': Scott McTominay leads the way as Manchester United stars pen emotional tributes to 'legend' Michael Carrick after his decision to leave the club

Michael Carrick has stepped down at Manchester United after his interim spellNew boss Ralf Rangnick will now take over but Carrick has left the club entirelyManchester United players were quick to praise the former Old Trafford playerScott McTominay said it was 'hard to put into words' how much he helped him  Read more »

Watford reveal fan who suffered cardiac arrest during game against Chelsea is in 'remarkably good form' and has accepted an invite to return to Vicarage Road as a guest of the club - as chairman Scott Duxbury praises 'decisive and essential' help from fans

Watford have named the fan who suffered a cardiac arrest during Chelsea game Larry Brooks required CPR but club say he is now in 'remarkably good form' Chairman Scott Duxbury has praised 'decisive and essential' help from the fans Brooks has also accepted an invite to return to Watford when he is recovered  Read more »

Giants' Nate Solder keeps starting role over Matt Peart: ‘The better player right now'

Maybe Nate Solder will be back with the Giants in the final year of his contract in 2022. Maybe he will sign a contract extension. Maybe he is a future ... Read more »

Kamala Harris staffers leave roles with admin as approval drops

Fox News White House correspondent Peter Doocy has the latest on the departure of the Vice President’s staffers Read more »

Omicron in India: Here's how genomic surveillance can help in tackling new COVID-19 variant

© Provided by Firstpost Omicron in India: Here’s how genomic surveillance can help in tackling new COVID-19 variant India has joined a growing list of countries where Omicron has arrived ... Read more »

Disha Patani is a vision in brown bodycon dress. Tiger Shroff reacts

Disha Patani’s new photos received a reaction from Tiger Shroff. Disha Patani is a glamorous diva who often sets social media on fire with her photos and videos. Recently, she ... Read more »

Sara Ali Khan Has One Condition For Marriage! Boys, Are You Listening?

© Provided by Lehren Sara Ali Khan Has One Condition For Marriage! Boys, Are You Listening? Sara Ali Khan is one of the most adorable and talented actresses in Bollywood ... Read more »

BSF Recruitment 2021: Apply for various vacancies at rectt.bsf.gov.in, check details here

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Directorate General Border Security Force (BSF) has issued notification for the recruitment of eligible and interested Indian citizens in various posts. BSF ... Read more »

Solar Eclipse 2021: Know the date, timing and duration of the last Surya Grahan of the year

As the year comes to an end, the world is all set to see the last total solar eclipse of 2021 on December 4. The eclipse is expected to last ... Read more »

From Total Solar Eclipse to comet Leonard's flyby: December is full of celestial events

As Venus, Saturn and Jupiter appear in the night sky, the month of December is full of celestial events one after another. From a Total Solar Eclipse to chances of ... Read more »

From The Apprentice house to the Love Island villa: The most expensive houses featured in reality TV shows

Reality TV fans across the UK will be aware of some of the amazing properties that are featured on their favourite shows. From modern open-plan living spaces and countless bedrooms ... Read more »

Octavia Spencer Dishes on Her 'Yellowstone' Obsession (Exclusive)

© Emma McIntyre/WireImage Octavia Spencer is a hardcore superfan. The celebrated actress isn’t shy about expressing her love for the outdoorsy dramaYellowstone. Spencer spoke with ET’s Matt Cohen on Tuesday, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic