Buyer tries to stop US billionaire Peter Thiel selling luxury Queenstown home to rival purchaser

Buyer tries to stop US billionaire Peter Thiel selling luxury Queenstown home to rival purchaser

A Queenstown resident has taken a caveat out against US billionaire Peter Thiel’s multi-million dollar clifftop home in a bid to stop it being sold to another buyer.

Brian McGee told the Herald he had taken issue with the sale process for the home, which boasts sweeping views over Queenstown’s Lake Wakatipu.

He said he registered the caveat to stop the house being sold until his dispute is resolved.

McGee claimed he had been told by an agent verbally his offer to buy the house had been accepted, before the house was sold to another buyer with a higher offer.

The real estate agent told the Herald he disputed McGee’s version of how sale negotiations took place.

The agent said he could not discuss the matter further because he was bound by confidentiality towards his client, the home’s seller.

Industry regulator the Real Estate Authority said all contracts to buy land in New Zealand must be in writing and that verbal agreements cannot be enforced.

Thiel bought the property – nicknamed the plasma house – in 2011, having secured New Zealand citizenship after spending just 12 days in the country.

Buyer tries to stop US billionaire Peter Thiel selling luxury Queenstown home to rival purchaser

Peter Thiel's Queenstown home, nicknamed the Plasma house, has gone on sale in the past week. Photo / ODT

He put it on the market just over a week ago, with the agent saying the Covid-19 pandemic had made it harder for the home’s overseas owner to visit New Zealand.

McGee said that led him to offer to buy the home last Tuesday for about $6 million.

He claims he was told his offer had been accepted. He and an agent toasted the sale with a drink on Wednesday evening as they looked over Lake Wakatipu from behind the home’s 15-metre wide landscape windows, McGee claimed.

But a purchase offer from another buyer, who flew into Queenstown last weekend to check out the home, was later accepted, McGee claimed.

“It is understood that Thiel subsequently accepted an offer from a third party at a considerably higher sum,” he said.

McGee acknowledged he had not received anything in writing confirming his offer had been accepted.

McGee also said he was contacted on August 7, three days after he claimed his offer was accepted, informing him that a prospective buyer had made a higher offer, it was now a “multi-offer” situation, and inviting him to make a higher offer to secure the home.

McGee said he refused because he was unhappy with the developments before lodging the caveat.

A Land Information NZ spokeswoman said the caveat had been “lodged by a purchaser to protect their interest in the property”.

Buyer tries to stop US billionaire Peter Thiel selling luxury Queenstown home to rival purchaser

Peter Thiel bought the luxury Queenstown home for $4.8 million 10 years ago. Photo / Supplied

Real Estate Authority (REA) chief executive Belinda Moffat could not comment on the specifics of the case.

But under New Zealand law, all property contracts must be in writing, she said.

“Verbal agreements to buy land cannot be enforced. Until the vendor has signed a written offer from a buyer, the vendor can negotiate with other buyers and accept a written offer from another buyer – even if they have verbally indicated they would accept an offer from another party.”

Moffat said it was important to remember selling agents were working for a home’s seller, not its buyer.

That meant their primary responsibility was to get the best sale price for the seller.

“In a multi-offer situation the licensee needs to be careful when communicating with potential buyers about the status of a verbal offer,” Moffat said.

“Even if the vendor has said they will accept the offer, the agent should explain to the buyer that a verbal acceptance is not binding, and there is always a risk something could change before the vendor signs the sale and purchase agreement.”

Moffat said it was important real estate agents dealt fairly with all parties, including buyers, and did not mislead them.

The five-bedroom home was sold to Thiel’s company, Second Star Ltd, 10 years ago for $4.8m.

Sitting on an outcrop, it offers stunning views from its lounge room and is noticeable around town for its line of gleaming windows fronting the lake.

Another agent reportedly raved about the view last week saying he thought it was “the best view I’ve ever seen from a house”.

He said while some homes in Queenstown had doubled in value over the past decade, that wasn’t necessarily the case with this home and the vendor expected “a little over $6m for it”.

“It comes down to [the vendor] being realistic, they’re not just trying to make a whole lot of money out of it.”

Thiel first visited New Zealand in 1995 when he was 28. Immigration documents show he first applied for an investor visa in March 2003, then again in 2005.

He was granted citizenship in 2011, despite having spent only 12 days in the country.

A venture capitalist, Thiel is reported to have made around US$2.3 billion from his early investments in Facebook and PayPal.

– additional reporting The Otago Daily Times

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Vaccination push in Ashburton this Saturday

Thousands throughout the mainland will be able to receive Covid jabs on Saturday as health leaders intensify the vaccine rollout. Community leaders are pushing for as many people to get ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Christchurch school board chair Trevor McIntyre resigns after jab made mandatory for education workers

An unvaccinated school board chairman resigned just moments after the Government made Covid-19 immunisation mandatory for education workers. Trevor McIntyre is remaining tight-lipped over his sudden decision to step down ... Read more »

Weather: Spring storm brings snow, gales across New Zealand

Another stormy day is on the cards for New Zealand today with strong winds, heavy gales and even snow on both islands. A cold front is making its way across ... Read more »

Reward brings no answers about missing toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank

Nicola Cruickshank thought her long nightmare might be coming to an end. Sunday will mark 29 years since her toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank went missing at a Cornwall St property in ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Possum trapper convicted over abusive messages to Chris Hipkins

A possum trapper unhappy with the Government’s Covid-19 response ended up in court after leaving several abusive messages for Minister Chris Hipkins. Wayne Andrew McIvor, 53, pleaded guilty to two ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Queenstown developer Min Yang denies lockdown breach

A Queenstown property developer has denied breaching lockdown restrictions by flying from Auckland to Christchurch before making his way to Otago, last month. Representing himself in the Queenstown District Court ... Read more »

George Tweedy avoids jail after violent home invasion in Greymouth

A Greymouth woman has told a court she thought she was going to die during a home invasion by retired soldier George Robert Tweedy in May. Reading her victim impact ... Read more »

Weather: Snow, thunderstorms and strong winds batter South Island

Snow has fallen in the South Island overnight with heavy rain and strong winds expected throughout the day. In Tekapo, snow has blanketed the town with temperatures dropping to just ... Read more »

Principal last stop for Ashburton teacher report findings

It’s unclear whether a report following multiple allegations of teacher bullying at Ashburton College will be shared with the community. An independent investigation in response to ongoing concerns around aspects ... Read more »

Former police officer tells of wild crowd at Dunedin Beatles concert

Dave Hughes well remembers the night he thought he might die. It was 1964. He was a rookie police constable at a Beatles concert in Dunedin Town Hall. Some never-before-seen ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: South Island frustrations grow as it remains at level 2 despite being coronavirus free

By Conan Young of RNZ As daily Covid-19 cases continue to climb in Auckland, there are rumblings of rebellion in the South Island and a call to break away from ... Read more »

Warnings in place as spring storm bears down on South Island

MetService has a range of weather alerts in place as a significant spring storm comes in for the first part of the week. Heavy rain, heavy snow and severe gales ... Read more »

'You left us doing what you loved' - friends remember man who died at Mt Hutt skifield

The man who died after he was found unresponsive on a Mid Canterbury skifield yesterday has been remembered by friends as an “inspiration” who will be “dearly missed”. Rupert Smith, ... Read more »

Covid-19 Delta outbreak: Dunedin man convicted over jet-boat lockdown breach

A Dunedin forest worker has been convicted for breaching August’s lockdown, after going jet-boating near Wanaka with a group of mates. Martin Karl Nolan, 30, admitted failing to comply with ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: South Island can stay free of virus if borders imposed say health experts

The South Island’s Covid-free status can be preserved with better regional border controls, top public health experts say. A University of Otago group has argued in a blog written by ... Read more »

Profile poles finally up for billionaire Peter Thiel's proposed Wanaka house

Profile poles have been put up at the site of Peter Thiel’s future Wanaka lakefront holiday home this week, after a complaint to the Queenstown Lakes District Council. Upper Clutha ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Mike Yardley - South Island Cup and Show Week casualty, close border to North Island

It’s a gut-punch for the South Island that looked ominously odds-on, the longer this week dragged on. The Government has failed to tighten up the ropey Auckland boundary and the ... Read more »

This young person will die: Judge, Children's Commissioner demand Oranga Tamariki 'do more' to keep young person safe, secure, alive

A Family Court judge and lawyer are gravely concerned a young person will die – either by their own hand or through their dangerous behaviour – because Oranga Tamariki cannot ... Read more »

Three Waters: Minister Nanaia Mahuta defends Māori involvement after councillors criticise 'asset grab'

By Matthew Rosenberg, Local Democracy Reporter Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta is stressing the importance of mana whenua involvement in Three Waters after a pair of southern councillors took shots ... Read more »

Ashburton College investigates teacher over long-term bullying allegations

By Adam Burns, Local Democracy Reporter An Ashburton high school is investigating long-term bullying allegations involving a teacher. Ashburton College confirmed on Thursday it had commissioned an investigative report in ... Read more »

Trees felled by out-of-town Dunedin firm

A Dunedin arborist firm has begun felling five eucalyptus trees in Queenstown’s town centre after local companies refused to give quotes for the work on ethical grounds. The trees, which ... Read more »

Three seriously injured after jet boat crash on Waimakariri River

Eight people were involved in a jet boat crash on the Waimakariri River which resulted in six being injured. Emergency services were called to the scene near Springfield just after ... Read more »

Person left trapped in vehicle after two-car crash in North Canterbury

A person was trapped in their vehicle after a two-car crash in North Canterbury this morning. Emergency services were called to the two-car crash at the intersection of Harmans Gorge ... Read more »

Two-car crash in North Canterbury

A person is trapped after a crash in North Canterbury this morning. Emergency services were called to the two-car crash at the intersection of Harmans-Gorge and Woodstock rds at about ... Read more »

John MacDonald: Sitting ducks in the South Island

OPINION I’m feeling for everyone in the South Island as we watch what’s happening in the North Island and hear the experts tell us it’s only a matter of time ... Read more »

Options being explored for future of Wellington landfill

By Hamish Cardwell of RNZ Wellington City Council is laying out its choices for getting rid of the city’s future rubbish. Consents for the city’s dump – the Southern Landfill ... Read more »

Mother wants answers after rare stroke takes three-year-old son's life

A grieving Christchurch mother is desperate for justice after claiming her three-year-old boy died needlessly because a fatal stroke was misdiagnosed. Ethan Tuo Brown, 3, died in Christchurch Hospital’s intensive ... Read more »

Dunedin man admits filming woman in toilet stall

A man who surreptitiously filmed a woman in a public toilet will likely be deported after being convicted, a court has heard. Kanava Galuega, a 32-year-old CCTV camera technician, appeared ... Read more »

Trio face weapons, drugs charges after Invercargill shooting

Three Southland people appeared in the Invercargill District Court today in relation to an incident in which a person received four gunshot wounds to their back. Whetu Taylor (36) and ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Kosher MIQ meals being flown frozen from Auckland to other facilities

A man staying in MIQ in Christchurch says the Kosher meals he is being sent frozen from Auckland are not “fit for human consumption”. Ilan Paz told the Herald he ... Read more »

Covid-19 coronavirus: Kosher MIQ meals being flown frozen from Auckland to other facilities

A man staying in MIQ in Christchurch says the Kosher meals he is being sent frozen from Auckland are not “fit for human consumption”. Ilan Paz told the Herald he ... Read more »

A Moment In Crime: The night stalker of Auckland - recidivist rapist Colin Jack Mitchell unmasked

In February 2017 the Herald first reported details of a shocking attack in Auckland. A 23-year-old woman walking home from annual Pride Parade celebrations in the central city suburb of ... Read more »

Invercargill shooting: Four people arrested after victim shot in back

Read more »

Covid-19 Delta outbreak: New Zealand A&P Show cancelled again

The New Zealand Agricultural Show has been cancelled for the second consecutive time. The organisers have decided not to go ahead with event planned to begin in Canterbury on November ... Read more »

Fire crews called to emergency at Christchurch Airport

Fire crews are on standby for an emergency at Christchurch Airport. A Fire and Emergency NZ spokesperson said they did not know what the emergency was yet. Flight ANZ771M has ... Read more »

Shopper's lucky escape - Dunedin woman almost crushed by toppled pole

A woman narrowly missed being crushed by a lamppost as she was loading shopping into her car at a Dunedin supermarket yesterday. The woman’s close call came when the pole ... Read more »

Power outage on West Coast caused by human error

An outage that left thousands of West Coast residents without power for several hours was caused by human error. The outage last Thursday began at about 9.20am and affected Westport, ... Read more »

Covid 19: Holiday parks discussing vaccine mandates for campers

One of New Zealand’s largest resort groups is considering options for how to accommodate unvaccinated campers in preparation for summer. TOP 10, which runs fifty campgrounds across the country, said ... Read more »

Driver who attacked police in Dunedin gets community detention

A drink-driver in an unsafe vehicle kicked and spat at officers then damaged a police car after being arrested, a court has heard. Robert William McRae, 29, appeared in the ... Read more »

Man charged in relation to shooting of 19-year-old in Invercargill

A man appeared in the Invercargill District Court yesterday afternoon in relation to the shooting of a 19-year-old man in the city on Saturday. A police spokeswoman said the 25-year-old ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic