Buttons beat touchscreens in cars, and now there’s data to prove it

Swedish publication Vi Bilägare quantified the problem with new tests.

Buttons beat touchscreens in cars, and now there’s data to prove it

/ Not all progress is good.Hispanolistic/Getty Images

It’s probably a little early to be warning of extinction, but in some new cars, buttons are becoming hard to find. Given that a screen has to go into the dashboard anyway (thanks to things like backup camera requirements) and the fact that people increasingly won’t consider a car without Android Auto or Apple CarPlay, touchscreens make life easier for automakers in terms of design and assembly.

It’s just that they don’t make life easier for drivers. Instead, we’re treated to bad interfaces that don’t create muscle memory but instead distract us while we should be driving. And now, Swedish car publication Vi Bilägare has the data to prove it.

VB tested 11 new cars alongside a 2005 Volvo C70, timing how long it took to perform a list of tasks in each car. These included turning on the seat heater, increasing the cabin temperature, turning on the defroster, adjusting the radio, resetting the trip computer, turning off the screen, and dimming the instruments.

The old Volvo was the clear winner. “The four tasks is handled within ten seconds flat, during which the car is driven 306 meters at 110 km/h [1,004 feet at 68 mph],” VB found. Most of the other cars required twice as long, or more, to complete the same tasks.

VB says that “one important aspect of this test is that the drivers had time to get to know the cars and their infotainment systems before the test started.” With my devil’s advocate hat on for a second, most drivers who drive regularly will regularly drive the same car, building more familiarity over months and years than a journalist will after even a week with a new model. But that kind of long-term adaptation is the user conforming to the vehicle’s wishes, and shouldn’t good design be the opposite of that?

Why they pushed the button on all-touch interfaces

VB lays the blame for the shift from bottons to screens with designers who “want a ‘clean’ interior with minimal switchgear.” That’s fair, but I don’t think we can count out the accountants either. If everything can be achieved by touching the screen, then the company doesn’t also have to pay for the plastic and wires that buttons are made from, nor the time it takes someone to make that into buttons or install them in a car.

Even with touchscreens, though, we can see in the spread of scores VB gave to different all-touch cars that design matters. You’ll find almost no buttons in a Tesla Model 3, and we called out the lack of buttons in the Subaru Outback in our review, but both performed quite well in VB’s tests. And VW’s use of capacitive touch (versus physical) for the controls on the center stack appears to be exactly the wrong decision in terms of usability, with the ID.3 right at the bottom of the pack in VB’s scores.

I’m not surprised that the BMW iX scored well; although it has a touchscreen, you’re not obligated to use it. BMW’s rotary iDrive controller falls naturally to hand, and there are permanent controls arrayed around it under a sliver of wood that both looks and feels interesting. It’s an early implementation of what the company calls shy tech, and it’s a design trend I am very much looking forward to seeing evolve in the future.

Again, there are examples of automakers doing this better than others. Over the past couple of weeks I’ve spent time in an Acura MDX and Mazda CX-50, neither of which uses a touchscreen infotainment system. Neither managed to do better than 19 mpg either, which is frankly appalling in 2022, but the CX-50 did at least distinguish itself for ease of use when it came to the infotainment system.

Mazda’s latest system has been criticized for being bare-bones, but odds are, a driver is using Apple CarPlay or Android Auto, and it’s actually quite easy to use with the rotary controller and its hard buttons, which, again, are right where your right hand expects them to be (or left hand, in a right-hand-drive car).

Managing Editor Eric Bangeman wished for actual physical climate controls when he tested the Subaru Outback, but it performed well in VB’s tests. Eric Bangeman

The Tesla Model 3 interior is the most extreme example of button-deletion, but it did not perform badly in VB’s tests. Jonathan Gitlin

The Volvo C40 has a few more buttons than a Model 3, but was edged in VB’s testing. Jonathan Gitlin

Volkswagen’s infotainment software in the ID.3 can be frustratingly laggy, and while there are permanent controls for the climate and audio, they’re capacitive touch, not real buttons or dials or knobs. Volkswagen

BMW’s rotary controller also integrates a trackpad and is a great way to interact with the iDrive system. It also features great voice recognition. BMW

Mazda’s infotainment controller is simple but highly functional and easy to use. Mazda

The True Touchpad in the Acura MDX might get easier to use with familiarity, but after a week I was still very frustrated with it. Acura

The more expensive Acura also places the infotainment screen far out of reach. It’s a much higher-resolution display befitting a much more expensive car, and the MDX’s infotainment system is much more capable than the CX-50’s in terms of apps and features. I also quite like the layout and fonts, although obviously that’s a pretty subjective thing.

I won’t subject you to the depth of my current feelings about Acura’s “true touchpad,” just a high-level, mostly polite version. It has a 1:1 relationship between the screen and the pad, so it doesn’t work at all like any other trackpad in any other car you might have driven. And that means it requires a lot of concentration to use, particularly if you’re trying to interact with CarPlay. And it doesn’t need saying that “requires concentration to use” is likely the last quality anyone wants in an infotainment system.

I’m not that surprised that the old Volvo won, dating from a time when most functions were controlled by individual buttons and when infotainment didn’t really yet exist. And in some ways, the tests played to its strengths—there’s no Android Auto or CarPlay, and the only safe way your phone is showing you directions is if you bring a suction mount. Do be careful what you press if anyone’s sitting in the back seat, though. In Volvos of that vintage, one of those buttons drops the rear headrests, which are rather heavy and very much wish to return to a horizontal orientation with absolute disregard for the skulls of anyone sitting in their way.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Voici l’Amazon Kindle Scribe : vous pouvez écrire sur cette liseuse

La Kindle Scribe est la nouvelle liseuse d’Amazon. Celle-ci se distingue en embarquant un stylet permettant d’écrire sur l’écran E-Ink. Comme promis, Amazon a tenu sa conférence annuelle pour présenter ... Read more »

¿Cómo debes actualizar WhatsApp en Android e iOS?

WhatsApp pide a sus usuarios que actualicen su app. Foto: Getty Images Recientemente WhatsApp reconoció tener una vulnerabilidad “crítica” por lo que exhortó a sus millones de usuarios a realizar ... Read more »

iCarData: The Best Time To Buy/Sell - Mercedes-Benz C200 Avantgarde (2017)

Between the big two German luxury automakers in Malaysia, there has always been a tug of war when it comes to the hearts of consumers, as well as a somewhat ... Read more »

Owner Review: The overengineered, high technology, underestimated oddball- My 2011 Toyota Prius 1.8

** This article is published on WapCar Community, representing the opinion of users. Click the link below to enter the community for car enthusiasts in Malaysiahttps://forum.wapcar.my/ Basic information of my ... Read more »

Motul Invites Partner Race Drivers To Talk All Things Motorsports Ahead Of Singapore Grand Prix!

With the Singapore Grand Prix and the supporting TSS The Super Series race around the corner, Motul invited drivers from its partner teams for a sharing session! The previous two ... Read more »

Jet Car Is A Floating Chevy Corvette C7 You Can Rent Or Buy

C7 Corvette If you have 50 grand lying around waiting to be spent, here’s an idea. If you happen to visit Miami and encounter a Chevy Corvette C7 floating on ... Read more »

ScamShield now available for Android users

ScamShield, an app developed by the National Crime Prevention Council (NCPC) and Open Government Products (OGP), is now available for Android users. The anti-scam app was launched almost two years ... Read more »

BMW lance une voiture électrifiée de 653 ch limitée à 140 km/h

BMW dévoile son nouveau XM, un grand SUV hybride rechargeable affichant une puissance démentielle, mais une autonomie un peu décevante en mode 100 % électrique. Si BMW avait jusqu’alors un ... Read more »

¿Un smartphone puede explotar si lo cargan con un cargador más potente?

Usuario de un teléfono Android. Desde el momento en que se popularizó el uso de los teléfonos celulares, todos usuarios desarrollaron una dependencia por la carga de batería de estos ... Read more »

El truco para evitar el bloqueo de Google que impide instalar la última versión de WhatsApp Plus

Meta, dueña de WhatsApp, no recomienda el uso de aplicaciones no oficiales como WhasApp Plus, que pueden poner en peligro la información de los usuarios. Pese a que WhatsApp continuamente ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Tab S8 FE emerges on Geekbench

Back in the last year, Samsung expanded the “FE” range to tablets. After the succesful Galaxy S20 FE, the company decided to launch the Galaxy Tab S7 FE tablet. The ... Read more »

2023 Tata Tiago EV: Price, variants, features explained

Tata Motors has launched the Tata Tiago EV at prices starting from Rs 8.49 lakh. This makes it the most affordable electric car in India in the private segment. The ... Read more »

Built-To-Order Explorer ST: Our Black-On-Black Performance SUV Progress

Medium After five months of waiting, we finally heard the news we’d been longing for: Ford Motor Company had scheduled our Explorer ST for production, along with issuing it a ... Read more »

Blown LSA-powered 1964 Chev C10

Steve Green grew up in the USA but has spent the past 31 years in Australia, so while the Noo Yawk accent has softened a fair bit, no amount of ... Read more »

Ce nouveau téléphone pensé en France protège vos données personnelles

Murena © Murena © Murena La marque française Murena dévoile un nouveau smartphone qui se veut respectueux de la vie privée des utilisateurs. Ce terminal sera proposé en France à ... Read more »

Tesla Megapacks arrive in Hawaii with the state’s last coal shipment

Tesla Megapacks arrive in Hawaii with the state’s last coal shipment as it shifts its grid to renewables supported by energy storage enabled by batteries like the Megapacks. In the ... Read more »

Doogee S96 GT, il primo smartphone con videocamera per la visione notturna torna sul mercato

Doogee S96 GT, il primo smartphone con videocamera per la visione notturna torna sul mercato (Adnkronos) – Il primo smartphone con telecamera per la visione notturna torna dopo due anni ... Read more »

Nueva interfaz de Meta permite cambiar entre los perfiles de Instagram y Facebook

Meta ha avanzado en la integración de sus redes sociales, Facebook e Instagram, a través del Centro de cuentas, que habilita una nueva interfaz para pasar de un perfil a ... Read more »

Meet The World's Most Sustainable Audio System From Warwick Acoustics

Warwick Acoustics says they’ve come up with the world’s most sustainable audio system. The ‘Clean Sound’ ElectroAcoustic Panels could shape the future of in-car audio systems, particular for carmakers who’re ... Read more »

This Cozy Farmhouse Rental Has Gorgeous Views of the Nasugbu Mountains

During the pandemic’s first onslaught, “cottagecore” trickled onto Pinterest boards everywhere. When the bustling, fast-paced ways of life seemed too much, people turned to daydream of pastoral landscapes and prairie ... Read more »

Potential Motors Adventure 1 Is A 600-HP EV ORV With A Sink And Bed

Potential Motors Adventure 1 It’s a mini-overlander that includes the kitchen sink, but it’s not street-legal. These days, it’s a rare occasion where we encounter something truly different in the ... Read more »

Ferrari's Latest One-Off, The SP51, Is Headed To A Taiwan-Based Collector

Ferrari revealed its latest one-off car: the Special Projects 51 or SP51. Considered as the most exclusive among Ferrari’s range, the SP51, like all other members of the SP range ... Read more »

Steelers: Spieler fordern wohl Rauswurf von OC Canada

Matt Canada (Pittsburgh Steelers) München – Drei Touchdowns in drei Spielen. Mehr haben die Pittsburgh Steelers nicht zustande gebracht. Und das trotz Spielern wie Running Back Najee Harris oder Wide ... Read more »

24 Kru Narasi Diretas, Rocky Gerung Menduga Terkait Kasus Ferdy Sambo

Rocky Gerung [YouTube] SuaraBatam.id – Pengamat politik dan akademisi Rocky Gerung menduga adanya hubungan pembungkaman Narasi dengan kritik pedas Najwa Shihab pada kepolisian. Untuk diketahui, aplikasi komunikasi hingga media sosial ... Read more »

Hyundai anuncia la preventa del nuevo HB20 2023

Llega a nuestro país el modelo HB20 2023. En una primera etapa llegará exclusivamente en versión hatchback y posteriormente el sedán. Podrá apartarse con $5,000 accediendo a la página de ... Read more »

Nintendo brings Splatoon 3 widgets to Android and iOS

A surprisingly smart and modern online feature from Nintendo Read more »

Google Needs To Fix These Android 12L Issues To Make It Even Better

Android as an operating system was first developed in 2003 to power digital cameras. But things changed swiftly in 2004 when the operating system changed from just camera software to ... Read more »

5 Cool Features of the New 2023 Ford F-250 Super Duty Truck

This week Ford announced its next generation of Super Duty pickups, or new 2023 F-250 and larger trucks. The Super Duty trucks are designed for hauling and towing heavy loads, ... Read more »

1 Key Reason Why Electric Convertible Cars Aren’t Available

The EV era is marching forward at a rapid pace. Many electric cars are now available, and more are on the way. You can find electric vehicles for nearly every ... Read more »

These Are the 5 Best Places to Get an Oil Change

Keeping up with routine oil changes is one of the most important things you can do for your car, truck, or SUV. In fact, according to iSeeCars, “Not only does ... Read more »

New Rendering Blends C3 Style With Modern Corvette Cues

New Rendering Blends C3 Style With Modern Corvette Cues What do you think about this modernized C3? Modern Vintage The internet has provided us with many things, some good, others, ... Read more »

Today’s Wordle Answer (September 29th, 2022): Puzzle 467 Hints, Clues, and Solution

If you’re not careful, the Wordle answer today for September 29th, 2022, will land you in hot water. The word featured in Puzzle 467 isn’t quite a homophone (a word ... Read more »

LDV eT60 to become Australia’s first electric ute

Snapshot eT60: Australia’s first electric ute LDV also bringing eDeliver 9 large electric van Completing trio will be Mifa 9 electric people-mover The 2023 LDV eT60 will from November become ... Read more »

Dua Celah Keamanan Ditemukan di WhatsApp, Pengguna Diminta Perbarui Aplikasi

Tim keamanan siber Singapura mendesak pengguna WhatsApp memperbaru aplikasi ke versi terbaru agar terhindar dari perampasan akun oleh peretas. Foto: Ilustrasi aplikasi Whatsapp. (Unsplash/Rachit Tank) Suara.com – Para pengguna WhatsApp ... Read more »

WhatsApp reconoce una vulnerabilidad “crítica” y hay que hacer actualización para protegerse

WhatsApp pide a sus usuarios hacer una actualización. Foto: Reuters WhatsApp, la aplicación de mensajería usada por millones de personas en todo el mundo, reconoció tener una vulnerabilidad “crítica” por ... Read more »

Porsche announces roof tent option for 911, available in Australia

Interested in going camping but prefer to take your Porsche 911 and not the family SUV? Well, the Porsche Tequipment department may have just come up with a solution for ... Read more »

Can You Drive a Ford Mustang in the Winter?

The Ford Mustang is America’s oldest pony car and one of the best-selling sports cars in history. However, for many owners across the globe, it’s also a daily driver. Still, ... Read more »

Bon Voyage: The Jeep Wrangler EcoDiesel Is Being Discontinued

We have bad news for diesel fans and Jeep Wrangler lovers. The 2023 Jeep Wrangler Rubicon will be the last model that features the EcoDiesel engine. The engine is being ... Read more »
Breaking thailand news, thai news, thailand news Verified News Story Network